Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The fallout from Massachusetts

By CosmicConservative
OK, I'm going to delve into a little political punditry here. I don't do a lot of that, I mostly comment on my thoughts about things, but I usually don't make predictions or provide much actual analysis of things. And since as late as 6:30 pm mountain time last night I was still doubtful of a Brown victory, I think you can see why I avoid such analysis. But everyone else is doing it today, so here goes... I would say that Health Care is dead in the Senate. Harry Reid is seriously damaged goods, he is being challenged strongly behind the scenes as the Senat Majority Leader and he has been completely unable to sway a single Republican to his side in spite of months of wheedling, pleading and attempted bribery. In fact far from gaining any Republican support, he is steadily losing the support of his own caucus. Reid is a dead man walking and everyone in Washington knows it. So unless there is a major upheaval in Washington that I'm not aware of, I don't see the Senate taking up Health Care again. So that puts the onus completely on the House. Nancy Pelosi originally spoke out against the Senate version of the bill, but that was when she thought she could get some back-door deals done and another 60 vote win in the Senate for a "compromise" version of the bill. Now that it looks virtually impossible to take that approach, she will probably reverse course and proclaim the Senate bill to be the perfect bill and try to ram it through the House. But the House is not the same House that narrowly passed the current House version of Health Care, and the version that was passed in the House has several critical provisions that the Senate Bill lacks, most notably the Stupak abortion amendment which gathered 11 critical votes that Nancy needed to get the bill passed in the first place. Again, much like in Harry's case, Nancy's hand is greatly weakened since then, not strengthened. Her leverage is much less, and her caucus has just seen Massachusetts, the bluest of blue states, dramatically reject health care. There can't be more than a few dozen House members who now feel their seat is totally safe if they vote for Health Care. Certainly there are dozens who now view a vote for the Senate version of the bill as certain political suicide. Everyone is running the numbers now to see if Nancy can get to the magic number of 218 votes to pass the Senate bill. For the rest of this week and into next week Nancy will no doubt be trying to arm twist, threaten and bribe House members to put their own political future on the line to save face for Obama and Pelosi. She will be calling in every favor she can, and I have no doubt will be having conversations about potential Ethics committee investigations and leaks of damaging information to the press. Drax said that this would now become all out war. I am afraid he is right. If the House can't pass the Senate bill by, say, mid-February, when Congress takes a Presidents Day (ironic, eh?) break for a week, I can't imagine that they can pass it when they get back. So the next three to four weeks will probably be the final act on this particular piece of legislation. And on it's success or failure rests the political fortunes of Pelosi and Obama. If they can't get it passed, the only way to revisit health care is to do exactly what Obama promised in the first place, which is to have open, cooperative discussions leading to a workable compromise between Democrats and Republicans. Obama never once intended to do that and it's the last thing he wants. Pelosi will almost certainly receive a no-confidence vote from her own caucus if that happens since she has spent the last year making this version of Health Care her signature issue and she has made many, many enemies in the process. This will be very interesting to watch. In my mind's eye I see Pelosi as Khan from Star Trek IV saying "From hell's heart, I stab at thee. For hate's sake, I spit my last breath at thee!"

Comments (5)

Old Goat
The real problem with health care reform is that these people in congress are looking at it from entirely the wrong angle. They are looking to treat symptoms without addressing the disease. In order to change health care into a reform that will benefit people, have costs come down, tort reform is needed. That is the biggest stumbling block for the dems. They have a huge lawyer lobby group that contributes to them, and doing anything that hampers their ability to fleece the medical industry (and just about every other industry) would cut off that gravy train. Medical tests are driven in part to provide cover for future malpractice. Insurance for doctors is astronomical. I have a brother in law who is an oral surgeon. He pays over $300,000 a year for his malpractice insurance. Insurance companies don't fight cases if they can negotiate a settlement, even if there was no malpractice, because the legal fees make a win a loss. If congress wished to make real changes that helped health care they could do so by increments. Allowing for those reformed portions to show if they are effective or not, and if not either scrap them or put them into review for why they aren't helping. Sweeping changes usually aren't effective because of the law of unintended consequences. This bill is not about providing the poor peoples with coverage, its about control over a large portion of the population. I think the people of the US are finally waking up to that fact. This isn't about them getting a benefit, though there will be some thrown in there, its about creating a power structure for the Democrats to build on. They have angered the mob because they believe they have the right to tell us what we want and need. Honestly, even though this issue keeps coming up from the left side of the spectrum, I can't say why this health care issue is such an overwhelming and pressing one. Are people dying in the streets that I am unaware of? Are people who need urgent care turned away in huge numbers because of lack of insurance? If so, where are the TV and newspaper accounts of this? Yes, costs are high. Know who ends up paying for it? We do. Like everything else, we pay for our health care coverage. Our employers set what they are willing to pay us to work for them. Out of that amount is the additional costs of whatever benefits we receive. When the companies went to alternative health care measures, where we were charged as a reduction in our paychecks for the policies we wanted, it was really just a cost saving scheme by those companies so they wouldn't be paying any more out, and in most instances they are paying less. This election should put a halt to the government taking over the health care industry. I fear though that it won't kill it. Pelosi isn't going to lose her position in the House if this gets passed. Her people will still vote her in, she is the Ted Kennedy of San Fran. The job is hers for life because of the liberal bastion that city is, and liberalism being a mental disorder, it is the perfect fit. Pelosi will have no problem with pressing the House dems to agree to this mess. The big question will be how much those whose seats are up for election are willing to be out of power to give her that victory. I am sure there will be defectors, as they don't want to give up that heady power, and are smart enough to read the tea leaves that health care is a death knell to them. I think the US people bought Obama because of his race, and because they were able to project their own desires on that empty suit. They didn't think any President or Congress would be this far left. This is the pendulum swinging the opposite way. Big time. The US is more centrist than our Congress and President are. The only way to make a correction is to hand the leftists their walking papers. The rhetoric we are seeing now is how it was during the time leading to a Civil War. While I hope it never goes that far again, it feels like we are nearing closer to that edge. The political divide is becoming more pronounced, and the extremes are screaming the loudest. We have the extremists of one of the parties in a major position of power, in the House, Senate and the Presidency. Expect the swing to be dramatic, but there will be a war over it. It might not be the conventional type, but the left isn't giving up power easily. They won't go quietly as the Republicans did. Get yer popcorn ready.
CosmicConservative
Goat, you and Drax are singing the same song. And I agree that Democrats are drunk on power right now and the longer they remain that way, the harder it will be for them to kick the habit. I do have some faith that our system is robust enough to handle even this group of liberals' fascist ambitions without leading to violence in the streets. The Tort reform issue is the main reason the Dems didn't invite the Republicans to the table. That was clearly the Republicans' first compromise position, and as soon as Obama realized that, he just sneered and said "we don't need you." Well, now they do. Payback is a bitch. I have doubts that the current House is going to pass the Senate's version of Health Care, and if they can't then it's either dead, or it will have to essentially start over again with Republicans controlling at least a part of the agenda. It could well be another generation before Health Care is tackled, it's been almost 20 years since the last time. And like you, I'm certain that actual concern about health coverage is not remotely what is driving the Democrats, and never has been. It's about controlling the market and controlling the people. One of the things that continues to frustrate and anger me about the American people is their continued support for Obama. I can see how 30% or so of the population, made up mostly of the hard core leftists and the complete brain dead can still "approve" of this travesty of an administration, but for fully 50% of the nation to still be even "somewhat" approving of Obama is a blistering indictment of the average person's ability to observe reality and think critically. That's why more and more I am losing faith in this nation's ability to continue to be a "shining city on a hill".
Old Goat
I am puzzled as well to some of the numbers that the polls say about how people feel about Obama. I do see a number of different polls has him at significantly different numbers though, and that kind of disparity makes me think that it is either the pollsters or how the questions are interpreted. Obama never impressed me. Its rare when Politicians do impress me though. I really don't get it when people say he is such a great orator. I know I could give the same speech as him and have people crying in the aisles or eating out of my hand. Clinton was another that continually had good approval numbers and all I ever saw was a phoney. He was a "B" actor in my book, he knew enough to act a certain way, but it never was sincere. Back to Obama, it could be that people generally like him even if they aren't impressed with what he has accomplished. It could be that they aren't paying much attention, which I fear to be more of the issue. Far too many are influenced by the mass media who fawn all over him. It could also be influenced by how many african-american people are being asked in the polls, which would skew the numbers. (How is that not racist? Their adoration for the man knows no bounds, even from those who you would think would know better.) It seems far too many Americans who do go out and vote put politics aside once that vote is cast and start paying attention again when re-election time rolls around. News programs get generally low viewership. Fox gets the most by a large margin, and they are constantly ripped for not being legitimate. (Just ask Obermann.) I just don't put a lot of faith in the polls. They call 500 to 1000 or so people, and from that they can get a feel for how the nation as a whole is thinking? Seems unlikely to me.
CosmicConservative
Well, having taken some statistics classes and doing some polling of my own in college, I have a bit more faith in the accuracy of polls, but you are right, the polls only reflect the answers to the questions, and there are lots of ways to word questions to bias a poll, even unconsciously. But the 50% figure is too widespread, too consistent and too close to my own experience with people I work and interact with for me to challenge it. I think it's pretty accurate. And yes, it almost certainly includes 90% of the 20% of poll respondants who are black, so if you set that aside his approval rating among non-blacks is probably pretty close to 35% or so, which is getting Bushian... I have given up hope that the "black community" will ever educate themselves out of the thrall of the Democrats. Only a trickle ever seem to get out of that culture. In my mind that's sad. Any community that votes in lockstep like that should be doing some serious soul-searching imho.
Drax
Well, when you add together the following: 1) Blacks 2) True believers, leftists, statists -- hell, just call 'em commies. 3) Morons who continue to believe the words they think they hear coming out of the mouth of Obama, who continue to remember only the promise he represented in the glorious campaign and don't pay attention to what is actually going on (to the extent that they could actually understand what is going on....) You get a pretty good sized chunk of people, well over 50%.