Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Is Western Europe really not carrying its fair share?

By CosmicConservative
One of the most common claims made by conservatives when discussing Europe vs. the USA is that Europe depends on the USA for its self defense. I've made the same claim myself, and in spite of the below analysis, I'm still not convinced that Europe is doing its fair share. It's not all about comparing relative budgets and numbers of active military, there's also the much more important element of having the will to actually use the military. In the beginning phases of WWII France had a numerically impressive army, but when the Germans invaded it turned out that France was very much an army without the will, training, readiness or equipment to mount a significant defense. Still, the information from this website has made me revise my opinion of Western Europe a bit. It's worth reading. It has charts too.

But I did spot a couple Paul Krugman columns detailing his fight against the conservative thought that Western Europe is a crumbling old area, depending on the US for its protection. The idea is that Western Europe is no longer actively developing its military, where Krugman says:

“One of the responses I’m getting to my “Europe isn’t an economic hellhole” column is the claim, from conservatives, of course, that Europe is only able to prosper because we Americans are bearing the whole burden of defending freedom.”

Living in red state area, I hear this a lot.

Recently someone replied to me that it was true. Germany after WW2 handed over its protection to the US, and holds only a small force. I was quite croggled at the fact that a lot of Americans believe that all of Europe really doesn’t field many fighting men.

Being someone who is curious about the real data, I dug up some figures. I even made graphs.

When compared directly, Germany, France, Spain, Italy and the other countries of Western Europe obviously have a much smaller budget. But that is a comparison of differing scales. Germany has 80 million people to the US’s 304 million.

via That (not so much) crumbling core of Western Europe’s military might at Tobias Buckell Online.

You should read the whole thing.

Comments (5)

Drax
Nothing in those graphs and charts changed my mind about Europe's lackluster showing in their contribution to their defense. 1) Those are today's numbers and don't allow for the ENORMOUS amounts we spent from 1945 to date to ensure their existence while they built/re-built their military. 2) The amount of money we spend DWARFS the amount of money any individual country spends (and the European Union ain't no "union" in any sense of the word.) AND the amount of money we spend DWARFS the amount of money the EU spends AND the EU as an economic unit actually SURPASSES the U.S. in GDP which means that we spend FOUR HUNDRED PERCENT more as a percentage of our GDP over the ENTIRE EU. 3) Sheer dollars spent doesn't even come CLOSE to describing the relative POWER those dollars buy. Not only do we have MORE of everything, what we have is technologically superior and our troops are more highly trained. Sorry. That dog don't hunt...
Drax
Oh, and this conclusion: "As Krugman points out, Western Europe, on a GDP basis, sets aside a similarly large chunk of the budget for military defense, in the mid 2.5 to 2.7% compared to the US’s 3.3%." I don't get that conclusion. Maybe my math's wrong. I get a U.S. GDP of 14,441,425,000,000 with defense expenditures of over 600,000,000,000 compared to a EU GDP of 18,387,785,000,000 against defense outlays of less than 200,000,000,000. Dunno how that can be called "similar" or come anywhere near a 1/2 of a percentage point of each other.
CosmicConservative
Well, Krugman's never been known for his math skills...
pace
Regarding the GDP math discrepancy. The article throws around the term 'Western Europe' a lot. This is generally NOT used to refer to the entire EU. The term European Union does not appear anywhere in the article as far as I can see. Wikipedia calls out 17 or so nations as comprising 'Western Europe', and I think the EU is somewhere around 30 nations. That would quite possibly account for the difference in GDP calculation.
Drax
Pace: Maybe so. Dunno. If so, then there's even LESS reason to view them as a single political entity and compare those hand-selected countries to the U.S. which, of course, IS a single political entity.