Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Jay Cutler.... RIP?

By CosmicConservative
Wow, as much as I thought Jay Cutler was over-hyped, under-matured and under-performing, even my most pessimistic estimates would have had Jay performing far better then he actually did this year. With two meaningless games to go for his 5 - 9 Bears, Jay is mired in the bottom rung of quarterbacks by virtually every measure. His QB rating is a dismal 71 (tied, ironically enough, with Matt Cassell). He leads the league in interceptions with 25 (25!) has barely reached 3,000 yards and has a 6.4 yards per attempt average. Kyle Orton, the much-maligned "add-on" to the Cutler to Chicago trade, has the following numbers: QB rating of 89, has thrown only 8 interceptions and has slightly more overall yards than Cutler (in an offense that is primarily short pass or run oriented). The most surprising stat is that Orton's 7.2 yards per attempt is significantly better than Cutler's. Orton's rating puts him in the middle tier of QBs, ranked at #15 out of 33 QBs ranked. Tony Romo's numbers are very similar to the numbers he's posted for the past four years. He is the 8th ranked QB (just ahead of Eli Manning in fact) with a QB rating of 98, 7 interceptions (vs. 23 TDs) almost 4,000 yards and an 8.1 yards per attempt average. These are really stellar numbers for a QB, a 3 to 1 TD to int rating, a QB rating of nearly 100 and 8+ yards per attempt are numbers that would normally put a QB in "elite" status if it weren't for the existence of Drew Brees, Peyton Manning and Brett Favre. In fact the ony real significant difference between Romo and those guys STATISTICALLY is wins and completion percentage. Sometime between the end of last season and the beginning of this season, during one of my "How in the name of all that is holy is Jay Cutler a 'pro-bowl' quarterback?!" rants, I predicted that by the end of 2009 Tony Romo and Ben Roethlesberger would be in the top ten QB by QB rating, touchdowns, yards, etc., and that Jay Cutler would be in the mid-tier where he has always been. If you look at where things are now, you'll see that Tony and Ben are right where I predicted they would be, but Jay is significantly worse. Maybe next year we'll see a Jay Cutler revival, but for the third year in a row I feel pretty vindicated by calling Jay Cutler the most over-hyped, under-performing QB in a decade. Had Jay Cutler ever posted numbers remotely comparable to Tony Romo's, based on the massive hype thrown his way, he would no doubt by now be getting Hall of Fame buzz. It will be interesting to see if ESPN goes on another Jay Cutler love-fest in 2010 as they have for the past four years. Very interesting indeed. Oh, and the reason for the title of this post? After watching Jay's collapse these last six games or so, I'm really starting to wonder if he's really lost his swagger and may not be able to get it back. It's happened before. In fact, Jay has fallen so low this year that I'm actually starting to root for him a bit. I would have loved to keep flogging him for years if he continued to be an over-hyped but mediocre quarterback. But now he's a sort of forlorn sad sack and I just don't like beating people when they are down. Maybe this season will be a badly needed lesson for him. I certainly hope so.

Comments (3)

Drax
The difference between a good quarterback and a great one (all other things being equal) is mental toughness. Dunno if Cutler has it or not. But, I'm not going to give up on Cutler (as if that decision has any effect on anyone other than myself...) He has all the tools (with the possible/likely exception of mental toughness). He needs a good coach. A good defense would help. O-line. Running game. Receivers. But, most of all, he needs a good coach who puts into place an offensive scheme which is conducive to his style of play and stays there, system intact, for many years so that Cutler can learn the offense, the same offense with the same players (for the most part) for a long time. This is what you see with the most successful QB's in the greatest part. Manning had one coach until this year. Favre had the same coach and/or scheme for going on two decades (absent 1 year with the Jets). Elway. Marino. Montana. Kelly. Aikman. Etc. Being in the same system, with the same coach (and/or offensive co-ordinator) or, at the very least, in the same scheme gives a QB the opportunity to learn and grow within that system. We'll see. He may be a Culpepper or he may grow up and become a good QB. He sure ain't one right now. And, worse, if he ever had them, he has lost the team.
CosmicConservative
Well, just to recap a bit, my consistent complaint with Cutler has been his lack of mental maturity. I'll put "mental toughness" in that same category. He whines, he blames, he pouts... it's downright embarrassing. I think from my first posts I pointed out that Cutler had been a poison in the locker room. I predicted that by mid-season this year he'd be sitting alone on the bench during the Bears' defensive series with his head in his hands, morosely looking around while his teammates ignored him. And that was when I thought he'd at least be competitive. I don't think he ever had the team. He never had the Broncos.
Drax
What many people don't understand is that on most teams, the QB isn't the "leader" of the team. He is on some teams, but not most. On at least 1/2 the teams, he's in constant competition for his job (if not that year then the next). 1/2 the other 1/2 aren't the "leaders" of the team, being, at best one of the leaders. We have Palmer (maybe #85?), Favre (Peterson?), Manning, Brady, McNabb (Maybe...hard to be the "leader" when every year there's a question as to whether he'll be there the following year), Brees, maybe a couple of others. The rest are just doing their jobs... Cutler just needs to do his job. He doesn't need to carry the team -- even if he could. Run the plays the coach calls and don't turn the ball over. Don't try to win every game with every throw and don't give up when things go badly. You know...be a fricking professional football player.