The DaVinci Code
By CosmicConservativeNo, this is not a review of the movie, or the book.
If anything this is a rebuttal to an often quoted C.S. Lewis statement that is relevent to the DaVinci Code plotline. The basic plot of the DaVinci Code is that the Catholic Church was born when Roman Emperor Constantine led an effort to recast Jesus from a mortal prophet to a divine being. The supposed motivation to this effort to deify Jesus was, among other things, an effort to subjugate women from having equal value as men. As part of this effort, the role of Mary Magdalene was revised from beloved wife and first apostle to harlot. And Mary's bloodline and the children of Jesus were exiled from the church and expunged from history.
This story of Jesus having been deified centuries after his death has been told before. In fact C.S. Lewis tackled it head on in "Mere Christianity" where he says (paraphrased) that it is a "foolish thing" to describe Jesus as a mortal prophet whose teachings should be revered, but who should not be viewed as the divine Son of God. Lewis essentially says that Jesus's teachings include statements that either must be true, or reveal Jesus to be an imbecile or an agent of Satan. In Lewis's classic argument, you must either worship Jesus, or attack him as an agent of evil.
Of course there is a third and a fourth option that C.S. Lewis either intentionally overlooked, or else was not able to consider.
The third option is that Jesus never said the things that are attributed to him that are now used to "prove" his divinity. Those things were added on after the fact to support the story, but the basic teachings of Jesus could still be very much the same.
The fourth option is that Jesus was a mortal prophet who believed that he had been told by God to assume divinity in order to establish Christianity as the new religion that would save everyone on earth. Telling the world what you believe God told you to tell the world may be technically a lie, but is certainly within the normal behavior of prophets since they began spreading the word of whichever God they are aligned with.
Either of these options leaves open the possibility that Jesus could have been mortal and a great moral teacher whose lessons are valuable, without him being an imbecile or a demon.
The acceptance of Jesus as divine is the greatest leap of faith imaginable. Lewis is absolutely correct when he says that once you accept that, the rest of Christian theology is trivial by comparison.
I couldn't have said that better myself.
Comments (2)