Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Yet another reason "alternative energy" isn't the "answer"

By CosmicConservative
Geothermal energy plants shut down due to threat of earthquakes.
Two high-profile geothermal projects in the U.S. and Europe were both permanently halted late last week, after federal officials in both countries questioned their safety and propensity to cause earthquakes. Projects in Basel, Switzerland, and in northern California were both abandoned, raising questions about the danger of purposefully cracking open the Earth to extract its heat. The California project, operated by a firm called AltaRock, had been halted since September after the company ran into repeated snags with a drill. The project, about 100 miles north of San Francisco in an area called The Geysers, had also been under a U.S. Department of Energy review, according to the New York Times. The Swiss project had been on hold since late 2006, when it caused earthquakes in the city of Basel, doing about $9 million in mostly minor damage to homes and businesses. Both projects used an "enhanced geothermal" system, which works by fracturing bedrock and circulating water through the cracks to superheat it and produce steam. The steam would be used to spin turbines in a power plant.
This stuff is just plain obvious to me, and I've been pointing out for years. For us to replace the energy we produce from coal, oil and natural gas with "alternative" energy would have calamitous effects on the environment, no matter how you do it. To cover up tens of thousands of square miles of land with solar cells is a laughable notion. Even I would oppose that on environmental grounds. Wind farms are bird shredders, and the more you have of them, the more birds you'll shred. Plus if we are pulling enough energy out of the wind to power entire cities, if you think that won't have an impact on weather patterns, you're just an idiot. Trying to farm enough organic "bio fuel" would either deforest millions of acres or would reduce existing farmland increasing prices on food and decreasing crop yields so much that no surplus would be available to send to third world countries, resulting in mass starvation. Electricity as an "alternative energy" source is just laughable. Where do people think it comes from? You don't mine electricity out of the ground, you PRODUCE it using one of the above means. If we start pumping heat out of the mantle, we run a significant risk of earthquakes or other geological events (perhaps even volcanoes). Geothermal is worth pursuing where we already have heat escaping the earth's interior without any exploitation of it. Hot springs, geysers, even volcanoes are great candidates for geothermal. Minor geothermal which works from the minor differences in temperature between different ground depths is probably fine too, at least until EVERY HOUSE IN A CITY is doing it. But to suck heat wholesale out of the ground is to subject the area to potential geological instability. The only reasonably viable alternative energy sources are nuclear and high-orbit power plants. High-orbit plants can either be solar or nuclear. 99% of the world's population is too ignorant to trust with sharpened scissors.

Comments (1)

Old Goat
We will be going back to rubbing sticks together to supply our energy needs. This way we create the needed heat with our own sweat and only add to the greenhouse gases... at which point we can have heart attacks and be able to help contribute to the regeneration of the soil.