Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On bands and selling out

By CosmicConservative
I'm no great musical critic, but I do know what I like, and I have a decent feel for when a band loses its musical focus and becomes more a pop phenomenon than a musical endeavor. I felt that way when the Eagles released "Hotel California." There are a few good songs on that album, but when I heard "Hotel California" I realized that the Eagles were dead. I felt that way when Pink Floyd released "The Wall." The same thing, a few good songs, but the end of Pink Floyd as a musical force. This even happens with lesser musical talents. I was a huge Olivia Newton-John fan, until "Physical." Ug. Bye-bye ONJ. With the Beatles it was the "Let it Be" album, but the Beatles also recognized reality and saved me from further pain by breaking up. Good for the Liverpudlians. Are there other examples you can think of? UPDATE: Cullen at "Half a Pica Distance" has picked up on this theme too.

Comments (16)

Dadman
What? Hotel California is one of the best rock songs of all time! The Eagles did die with the release of Hotel California (the album or the song); they died with the release of The Long Run. That album sucked like a vacuum cleaner and paved the path to their demise as a serious band...imho...
CosmicConservative
My point is that I heard the death knell on Hotel California and was proven right, just as I heard the death knell of Pink Floyd on The Wall and was proven right there too. In fact there is a weird trend here, in most cases (not the Beatles, but all the rest) I heard the end of the band or artist on what was their most commercially successful album, but in spite of the overwhelming commercial success and the grammy awards and all of that, I heard a band dying, and they died, even if they actually seemed at their peak. But they were a dead band walking from the moment they went to the studio to work on Hotel California. That's what I'm trying to say.
Cullen
At what point did the Stones die? It happened before my birth, I'm sure. Paul Simon died with Graceland. Metallica died with ... And Justice For All. There are others I can't think of at the moment, but I know what you mean. What's cool though is that a band doesn't lose its ability to come back from the dead, though. Rush made a really good effort with Vapor Trails.
CosmicConservative
I wasn't a Stones fan when I was younger, so I can't pinpoint it, but my guess is that the Stones died with whatever album "Waiting on a Friend" was on. Bob Dylan died when he picked up the electric guitar. (Actually I'm kidding here, but it sounded hip..) Dire Straits died with "Money For Nothing." And that was a sad death indeed.
mark nelson
REM died with Green. Springsteen died with Born in the USA The Clash died with Combat Rock Queen died with Jazz On the subject of the Beatles...you ever notice that Beatles tribute bands always dress in either the "early Beatles" suits or the Sgt. Pepper's suits. Wouldn't it be cool if one of these bands dressed in the "Let it Be" style? All greasy 'n stuff.
CosmicConservative
Is that what they are called? Beatles "tribute bands?" Is Las Vegas filled with "Elvis tribute performers?" This is becoming a sort of "when did they jump the shark?" thread...
Dadman
In my previous post I meant to say that The Eagles DIDN'T die with the release of Hotel California, but rather with the release of The Long Run. You heard the death knell on Hotel California? Humbug. This is definitely a jump the shark thread... Fleetwood Mac jumped the shark with the release of Tusk, but their last album, Say You Will, was actually quite good. I was pleasantly surprised. Do you suppose American Idol will ever jump the shark? I'm waiting patiently...
CosmicConservative
I have never seen American Idol. I would say based on Internet buzz that it jumped the shark when Paula Abdul came to work zoned out on something, but apparently that had no negative impact on the show. I watch Jay Leno every now and then to see the "Headlines" segment and happened one night to catch Paula Abdul who seemed to have come on the Tonight Show to answer charges that she came to work on Idol stoned out of her gourd. If her goal was to convince America that it was all an act, she failed with me because she seemed to be pretty wigged out on Jay's show. If that was a "good" appearance for Paula, I have to wonder what her "normal" behavior is like. Back to the bands and why I heard the Eagles die on Hotel California. All of their previous work had been musically consistent, there was an "Eagles sound" and it was a vibrant rock-country mix with strong vocal harmonies, tight and clear instrumental work and in most cases the songs told a compelling story. I think of songs like "Lying Eyes" or "Witchy Woman" or "Already Gone" or "Take it Easy" or "Desperado..." etc... With Hotel California that legacy was dumped unceremoniously for Joe Walsh's screaming guitar and screaming vocals with a hard edge to it. In short, it wasn't the Eagles. I didn't buy an "Eagles" album when I bought "Hotel California" I bought a "Joe Walsh does the Eagles" album. And I didn't like that. The Wall is a similar situation. Up until The Wall Pink Floyd had been one of the most inventive, introspective and musically adventurous groups I had ever heard. Their albums went where their muses took them and many of their best songs (to me) had very little commercial appeal. When I heard "The Wall" all I could think of was "well, this band has decided to sell some records." Which is sort of ironic because I think over time "Dark Side of the Moon" ended up being one of the top selling albums of all time, but it took years for it to rack up those sales. But I defy anyone to say that "The Wall" has a more compelling timeless nature than "Dark Side of the Moon". I think you probably agree with me that ONJ went after the disco post-Grease market with "Physical" and lost track of her true talent. That's what I heard with "The Wall" and "Hotel California," a band that had lost track of its roots and its true purpose. After that it was no surprise to me that they fell apart. I would say the same thing about Fleetwood Mac, but I put their demise on "Rumours," not "Tusk." I had no desire to buy Tusk because by then Fleetwood Mac had become "Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks perform with the band once called Fleetwood Mac" and I just wasn't interested. Although I did like Stevie Nicks and thought on Rumours some of the best songs were the Stevie Nicks contributions. But it just wasn't Fleetwood Mac anymore.
Dadman
Well, if you're going to attribute the demise of Fleetwood Mac to Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham - which is the most absurd argument I have ever heard - you'd have to go back to the self-titled Fleetwood Mac album that was released just before Rumours. But the fact is Fleetwood Mac evolved into a much better band with the addition of Stevie and Lindsey. I have to ask you which version of Fleetwood Mac you prefer - the original lineup with Peter Green, Mick Fleetwood, John McVie and Jeremy Spencer, the lineup that added guitarist Danny Kirwan, or the lineup that included Bob Welch and the feminine influence of Christine Perfect (McVie)? The fact is that the sound of Fleetwood Mac changed and evolved significantly even before the inclusion of Nicks and Buckingham. Are you going to argue that Fleetwood Mac jumped the shark when Peter Green quit the band or when Spencer ran away with the Children of God? Rumours is considered one of the best rock albums ever produced. It's popularity does nothing to diminish its quality or legacy in rock history. And it certainly is not the album that killed Fleetwood Mac.
Cullen
First, manual trackback. Second, I can't talk about Fleetwood Mac, but I will tackle a little Eagles and Floyd. On Floyd: I agree with you that The Wall was the beginning of their shark jumpage. However, I still think it was a good concept album. Nowhere near as good as Dark Side of the Moon, but not a bad album. There next entries were horrible though. But, I think Floyd is one of those bands that was able to release another good album from beyond the grave. I loved Momentary Lapse of Reason -- On the Turning Away, Dogs of War, great tunes -- and the live Delicate Sound of Thunder was also great. But then they release Division Bell and it's right back to suck. All I can say about the Eagles is that I like Joe Walsh, but I see your correlation. That said, Wasted Time is the best Eagles song ever made.
CosmicConservative
I don't think Dadman is getting my point. My point isn't that the band was unable to make good music when they "jumped the shark" but that something in that album sounded a warning to me that the band had abandoned its roots and become something else, something worse, something more commercial and appealing, perhaps, but not the next natural step in the band's musical evolution. For comparison, when the Beatles did the "Revolver" album, that was a huge break with their previous work, but it was not "jumping the shark" because it was still the Beatles and was actually a growth moment for the band. It made me want MORE Beatles, not less. When the Eagles did "Hotel California" it had exactly the opposit effect on me, my reaction was "Oh fudge, there goes another of my favorite bands. Yes, this is a really cool album and has some really good songs, but I won't be buying their next one." Which is what I did with Rumours. But to be fair, I was a latecomer to Fleetwood Mac anyway, I just didn't like the direction they went after Rumours. I don't really care that much for the "original" Fleetwood Mac either, in fact Rumours is really the only album of theirs I really liked. So maybe they aren't a good example of the phenomenon I am describing. But the Eagles, the Beatles, Pink Floyd, Bruce Springsteen and others definitely had this phenomenon. The reason this whole thread started is because I read the interview of Roger Waters that I linked in the original post where he basically confirmed exactly what I was hearing on "The Wall." The band was losing its focus, losing its purpose and losing its artistic purity. That's what HE says. All I'm saying is that I heard that in The Wall when it came out, and that I have heard similar things with other groups who had similar "jumping the shark" moments. Cullen's point about returning from the grave is a good one. There are bands that I have wholly given up on who, against all odds and against all reason, somehow returned to their roots and released albums that defied all expectations. I would put the Beatles first and foremost in that list with the Abbey Road album, which is actually the album they completed last, although "Let It Be" was released after Abbey Road due to arguments about how to produce it. In Abbey Road the Beatles put aside their differences, returned to their musical roots and put one of the greatest rock and roll albums of all time out. Then they went their separate ways. But if you hear "Let It Be" and don't hear "End of the Beatles" then I don't know what to say. I would even say that Elvis did a bit of the "return from the grave" thing in 1968 when he gave his famous "comeback" appearance on TV and morphed from tired lounge singer back into rock and roll legend right in front of the cameras. But then he retired back to lounge singer again, but there for a moment he was the King all over again.
Dadman
I get your point, but it's a subjective one. After Rumours I personally wanted much MORE Fleetwood Mac, but was sorely disappointed in Buckingham's self-indulgent Tusk album. Same thing with Hotel California. I wanted more Eagles music that sounded like Hotel California, The Last Resort and New Kid In Town but got the insipid Heartache Tonight on The Long Run album. I will concede, however, that in the case of Hotel California evidence of shark jumping is clearly present in the Victim of Love and Life in the Fast Lane tracks. I think this was the Eagles attempt to be less country and more rock - a creative move that just didn't work for them.
CosmicConservative
Yes, that's my point exactly. I wonder if there are any current examples of jumping the shark. Mariah Carey? Madonna? Eminem? Snoop Dog? Green Wave?... I'm afraid I just don't listen to enough contemporary music to know....
Cullen
It's much easier to be less subjective with older music, I think. Just because we have kind of collective unconsciously decided what stands out from the bands of the past. I don't listen to much contemporary music ... that is, I don't listen to bands that get played on MTV (when they actually play music). But I do listen to bands that have only come into existence in the past 10 to 15 years or so. It's hard to say. Out of the bands I listen to, I probably haven't seen a jump the shark moment yet. But there are plenty of artists that I only listen to one or two songs from that I have no clue about the body of work.
Dean Esmay
Genesis ceased to be relevant or interesting when they came out with their second album with Phil Collins as lead singer. Not the first, the second. I can't name either one, mostly because, well, who cares?
cmh
Peter Gabriel is an interesting one. I thought SO was just so so, it was nowhere near as good as Security or PG3. However he redeemed himself with the Passion and then fell off my radar after US which was truly weak. Kate Bush never topped the Dreaming and Hounds of Love. The Red Shoes had some moments but it wasn't great. Sarah Mclachlan really only had Fumbling Toward Ecstasy. She will never top it and most everything else is just tepid. U2's last two albums although they have such a significant body of work with a fair amount of change that I haven't totally given up on them.