On bands and selling out
By CosmicConservativeI'm no great musical critic, but I do know what I like, and I have a decent feel for when a band loses its musical focus and becomes more a pop phenomenon than a musical endeavor.
I felt that way when the Eagles released "Hotel California." There are a few good songs on that album, but when I heard "Hotel California" I realized that the Eagles were dead.
I felt that way when Pink Floyd released "The Wall." The same thing, a few good songs, but the end of Pink Floyd as a musical force.
This even happens with lesser musical talents. I was a huge Olivia Newton-John fan, until "Physical." Ug. Bye-bye ONJ.
With the Beatles it was the "Let it Be" album, but the Beatles also recognized reality and saved me from further pain by breaking up. Good for the Liverpudlians.
Are there other examples you can think of?
UPDATE: Cullen at "Half a Pica Distance" has picked up on this theme too.
Comments (16)