Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Barry Bonds and Babe Ruth

By CosmicConservative
So, somebody asked Barry Bonds if he was "greater" than Babe Ruth since he is closing in on the Babe's home run total of 714 career home runs. Barry answered "the numbers speak for themselves." And indeed they do. Babe Ruth had a lifetime batting average of .342, #9 on the all time list. The Babe one year hit more home runs than every other TEAM in the American League. He led the American League in Home Runs eleven times, and led in RBIs six times and runs eight times. Barry? His lifetime batting average is right at .300, he has led the National League in home runs twice, and has never led his league in RBIs or runs. When you factor in the possibility (probability?) that several years of Bonds' career were enhanced by steroids, while six years of Babe Ruth's career were devoted to pitching, and it is clear that had Babe focused on hitting his entire career, he would have ended with well more than Hank Aaron's 755 home runs. Based on the Babe's hitting years average of 40 home runs per year, he could have hit as many as 200 more home runs had he not been a pitcher for six years. This is even more amazing when you consider that the Babe played many of his years in what is now known as the "dead ball" era, when home runs were so rare that Ty Cobb once led the league with eleven home runs (all inside the park, as I recall). It was because of the Babe that the ball was "livened up" in the first place. When I was a kid I was a huge Ty Cobb fan. In fact when I was a kid Ty Cobb still held more than two dozen lifetime records, including hits, steals, runs, batting average, and a whole lot more. I believed Ty Cobb to be the greatest ballplayer of all time, but no matter how hard you make that argument, there can be no doubt that for all of Ty Cobb's greatness on the field (overlooking his shortcomings as a person) Ty Cobb adapted to the game of baseball as it was played at the time. Babe Ruth transformed the game into what it is today. So for Barry Bonds, a career .300 hitter who is known as one of the most selfish and arrogant players in the game, to suggest that his numbers indicate he is a better ballplayer than Babe Ruth is simply laughable. I am not one who believes in asterisks in record books. If Bonds eventually overtakes Hank Aaron, so be it. But I'll let the judge of who is the best ballplayer of all time be revealed just as Barry sneered it should be. Look at the numbers and judge for yourself.

Comments (2)

ira siegel
Bonds may not be the gratest player,or any where near Ruth, but if steroids produces long home runs,it has nothing to do with a 300 life time batting average.There has to be a lot of single and doubles in all those hits.Ruth may have hit in a dead ball era,but he never had to fly from coast to coast or play night games.Ruth saw one good pitcher a game , if that many and four times a game.Bond sees good starters,good set up pitchers and great closers in most games.Bond is a great ball player,never proof of taking steroids.He is just not a nice guy,remember Ty Cobb.
CosmicConservative
Steroids don't just produce long home runs. Steroids improve eye-hand coordination, which equates to more hits overall, and improves strength so that what would have been a broken bat pop-up to second becomes a bloop "Texas-leaguer" that falls just between outfield and infield. If there is a downside to steroid-induced performance that you could argue theoretically, you could probably argue that steroids induce more strike-outs, because of the increassed aggressiveness. Interestingly though, I have not seen that argument made. Regardless, steroid use impacts overall batting average as much as it does length of home runs. Let's look at Barry's stats as an example: Barry Bonds was a career .280 hitter until 2000, the year that is usually cited as the year he is thought to have begun using steroids regularly. That year he hit .308 and 47 home runs. The next year, 2001, when even casual sports reporters were stunned by his physical transformation at ag 35, he hit .328 and 73 home runs. The next year, 2002, he was back to 47 home runs but hit .370!! This, at age 36, was 80 points above his career average up to then. In 2003 he hit .341, in 2004 he hit .362. In fact his batting average numbers were affected much more than his home run numbers. This transformation from run-of-the-mill hitter, to league leader at age 36 is not merely unusual, it is in fact unprecedented. Ruth did not "fly from coast to coast" he rode buses that were less comfortable and were just as long as today's plane rides so there is no advantage to Bonds or Ruth in the area of travel time or inconvenience. I have never seen any baseball historian point to night games vs. day games as having any impact on player performance. This is a novel idea, I'd love to see some statistics to back it up. Your last point has some validity, but is offset by the much larger number of teams in the league. Ruth may have seen less of the "middle reliever" than Bonds sees today, but I have seen study after study of modern baseball that has concluded that the increase in the number of players (particularly pitchers) has greatly diluted the talent level in the game so that pitchers who would never have made the major leagues in Babe's day are now getting rich as middle relievers with an e.r.a in the 5.0 to 8.0 range. An e.r.a. that in Ruth's day would have sent you back to the minors in a heartbeat. Ty Cobb may have been a jerk and a racist, but nobody questions his baseball skills and he was never accused of taking unfair advantage, unless you call sharpening his spikes in the dugout before a game unfair advantage. I don't have any proof that Barry Bonds took steroids. But I am as sure that he did as I am sure that Pete Rose bet on baseball. I am also certain that he did it knowingly. Does that mean I would like to see an asterisk by his records in the books? No, I don't believe in asterisks. You missed the best argument for Barry to be listed among the all-time greats. That argument is that Barry was not the only man taking steroids during the 2000 - 2005 steroid explosion era. So were a lot of those pitchers who were trying to throw fastballs by him.