Barry Bonds and Babe Ruth
By CosmicConservativeSo, somebody asked Barry Bonds if he was "greater" than Babe Ruth since he is closing in on the Babe's home run total of 714 career home runs. Barry answered "the numbers speak for themselves."
And indeed they do. Babe Ruth had a lifetime batting average of .342, #9 on the all time list. The Babe one year hit more home runs than every other TEAM in the American League. He led the American League in Home Runs eleven times, and led in RBIs six times and runs eight times.
Barry?
His lifetime batting average is right at .300, he has led the National League in home runs twice, and has never led his league in RBIs or runs.
When you factor in the possibility (probability?) that several years of Bonds' career were enhanced by steroids, while six years of Babe Ruth's career were devoted to pitching, and it is clear that had Babe focused on hitting his entire career, he would have ended with well more than Hank Aaron's 755 home runs. Based on the Babe's hitting years average of 40 home runs per year, he could have hit as many as 200 more home runs had he not been a pitcher for six years.
This is even more amazing when you consider that the Babe played many of his years in what is now known as the "dead ball" era, when home runs were so rare that Ty Cobb once led the league with eleven home runs (all inside the park, as I recall). It was because of the Babe that the ball was "livened up" in the first place.
When I was a kid I was a huge Ty Cobb fan. In fact when I was a kid Ty Cobb still held more than two dozen lifetime records, including hits, steals, runs, batting average, and a whole lot more. I believed Ty Cobb to be the greatest ballplayer of all time, but no matter how hard you make that argument, there can be no doubt that for all of Ty Cobb's greatness on the field (overlooking his shortcomings as a person) Ty Cobb adapted to the game of baseball as it was played at the time. Babe Ruth transformed the game into what it is today.
So for Barry Bonds, a career .300 hitter who is known as one of the most selfish and arrogant players in the game, to suggest that his numbers indicate he is a better ballplayer than Babe Ruth is simply laughable.
I am not one who believes in asterisks in record books. If Bonds eventually overtakes Hank Aaron, so be it. But I'll let the judge of who is the best ballplayer of all time be revealed just as Barry sneered it should be. Look at the numbers and judge for yourself.
Comments (2)