Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The future of telescopes

By CosmicConservative
Telescopes will one day be virtually useless if based on earth. The combination of light pollution, atmospheric interference, and political turmoil over their placement and use will eventually turn earth telescopes into museums. There will also be a limit placed on how large you can build one, and with telescopes, size is everything, so that alone will eventually make earth-based telescopes obsolete. Astronomy, even optical astronomy will move into space. The Hubble Space telescope is a relatively small telescope by modern astronomical standards, roughly one-third the diameter of the Keck telescopes. Its amazing photos are more a result of the lack of atmosphere and the ability to keep the telescope pointed at the same spot in the sky for hours, even days. There is already talk of trying to put a larger telescope into space, but what we need to be doing is not thinking about how we get telescopes designed on earth into space, but instead we need to start thinking about how we design a space telescope to be MADE in space. I've had some really bizarre notions about how to build telescopes in space. One idea I've had is to blow a really, really big bubble in space. Now I'm not sure how you do that, but for the sake of argument, let's say that you can build a giant beach ball in space, say something on the order of ten kilometers in diameter. Then you spray the entire outside of the ball with a hard-setting resin that makes it a solid shell. Once it cures, you cut out circular pieces of the shell and paint the inside with reflective aluminum or something else. Do it right and you end up with several huge spherical mirrors. Spherical mirrors are not perfect telescopes, but if you build a much smaller (say something the size of the Hubble telescope) hyperbolid mirror as a secondary mirror, you can correct the spherical aberrations of the main mirror. One big beach ball in space could give you six or more giant reflecting telescopes in orbit. Arrange them properly and use interferometry, and bingo you have telescopes with resolution capable of spotting a planet like earth orbiting millions of stars in our galaxy. But say you want something truly gargantuan. A telescope the size the earth. Let's shoot for a 15,000 kilometer mirror. How would you build something like that? It's pretty clear you can't use the beach ball approach (or could you.... hmmm...) still, it seems unlikely. So what can you do? Well, you could build a lot of little mirrors and have them laser-ranged and self-adjusting in relation to a central platform. So, as with many of my far-future space-based schemes, let's say you start with an asteroid, one with a high silicon content. Then you build a self-replicating robot that builds two copies of itself, and then builds a small (say 1m diameter) mirror. For the sake of argument let's copy the Keck idea and have them make hexagonal mirrors. For the sake of simplicity, make the mirrors spherical with a focal radius of say, 15,000 kilometers. Then the mirror-robots launch themselves from the asteroid, and arrange themselves in the shape of a telescope. It would start small, but would grow rapidly. As each new mirror was completed and put in place, the final telescope would be just a bit bigger and better. Perhaps it would take a hundred years to complete the mirror, but I'm betting on the exponential nature of the robots making two copies of themselves getting the full mirror built pretty fast. Now, what if you wanted to build a telescope the size of earth's orbit?

Comments (4)

MagikalOutkast
That'd be one friggen huge telescope. "Look I can see the atoms 'vibrating' on Pluto." So why can't you just make multiple (like a few hundred, or thousand) spherical mirrors....and use your beach ball approach except have it designed more station style than....beach style? Couldn't you just extend them further for more power? I'm not real crazy into telescopes, but I for one, have other futuristic plans, such as the first station on the moon. If you look at it, it's possible physics-wise, and not possible money-wise. But if we could, you could have your impossibly large telescope stationed on the moon or something like that, or even a lauch pad for easy launches to Mars. It's a dream, but it would make a lot of things A LOT more accomplishable.
CosmicConservative
I'm not sure I understand your "station style" approach. But theoretically it doesn't matter if you create a single huge telescope with all the light focused on one real image ("real" in the optical sense), or if you create thousands, or even millions, of telescopes and combine their images through interferometry or through electronics. But the difference between theory and practice is that in theory there is no difference, but in practice there always is. Having a bunch of small telescopes combined into one composite image is just more complex than a single image, and I don't have the math skill anymore to prove it, but I am convinced that a single large telescope would have a much higher signal to noise ratio than a bunch of little ones all hooked together. Speaking of moon telescopes, I have long wondered if we can't drop a huge thermo-nuclear bomb in a suitably sized crater and essentially fuse the crater into a huge mirror, then grind and polish it. It would have a limited view of the sky, but in that limited range it would have incredible optical power. But after thinking about that for a while, I just figured the size limitations on the moon are in principal similar to earth, although much larger, there is still a practical limit to the size. So just build it in space where the practical limits are orders of magnitude larger, and the process is orders of magnitude easier. But there's no reason we can't do both if it is easier to do a moon telescope first.
MagikalOutkast
Well the huge moon crater would be interesting, but your asking for such a controlled blast it would give headaches. I mean the proportions have to be JUST right to land some thermo-nuke into a crater that has to be perfect. And wouldn't you have to time the blast just right so as not to produce an even larger crater? Also, if you have seen Contact, which is one of the greatest movies of all time, you see at the beginning of the movie in Texas that they have multiple (40 or so) satellite dishes which focus all on one point for more power. I don't know if the multiple satellite idea would work, but what if you made the satellite the length of about forty miles or so, and had them placed just right (reflector style), you could have your nuclear moon telescope in space. Look, there are many reflective materials, couldn't you just just use those materials, stretch them out to cover great distance, and use their reflection (parabaloidal of course) to achieve a great distance? It would enable you could enlarge even more, and make a greater distance to provide more power, am I correct? Or am I spouting on meaningless nonsense?
CosmicConservative
Magikal: If you could figure out how to use a nuke to fuse a crater into a paraboloid for later grinding, polishing and aluminizing to make a mirror, you wouldn't launch or drop the bomb, you'd build a tower, put it exactly where it needs to be, and detonate it remotely. Even so, such a plan is not likely to be feasible, it would be much more feasable to take an existing crater that is already roughly paraboloid and just build a framework to hold the parabolic mirror. That would be cheaper and more reliable than the nuke approach probably. I retract the nuke suggestion... Contact is not one of my favorite movies. It's not even one of my favorite science fiction movies. The linked radio dishes in Contact use interferometry to combine their signals, which can also be done optically, but since radio waves are much longer than light waves, radio interferometry has been practical for a longer time than optical interferometry. In fact there have been efforts to combine radio telescope signals across distances of several thousand miles. Usually the goals of interferometry are not to boost the signal, but to increase the resolution of the image. That's because of how light waves work (radio waves are light waves, just long wavelength ones). Essentially interferometry is way to try to reduce the effects of light wave diffraction. Diffraction effects limit the resolution of your telescope no matter how powerful the signal is. Signal boosting can be accomplished electronically, but you quicky reach signal to noise ratio limits which make further amplification pointless. I'm not sure what you mean by "reach a great distance" by stretching reflective materials. Telescopes (including radio, xray or microwave telescopes) essentially do two things. 1. They magnify the image. This is restricted by the diffraction effects which are directly related to the aperture of the telescope. There are only two ways to increase magnification once the diffraction limits are reached. Either make a bigger telescope with a larger aperture, or combine the signal of two or more telescopes together using interferometry. Using interferometry introduces more signal noise sources so has some practical limits of its own. 2. They gather more signal information from the source. This is restricted by the aperture of the telescope. There are three ways to increase the signal information. First you can make a bigger telescope. Second you can electronically amplify the signal, but this does not improve the signal to noise ratio, it just makes it louder. Third you can combine signals of multiple telescopes together, but this again has practical limitations due to the introduction of additional noise in the signal that offsets some of the gain of combining the signals. To build the most powerful telescope with the most practical approach scientists have always wanted to build the biggest main mirrors they can build. Nothing beats pure size for both resolution and signal reception. However there are probably practical limits to the size of an individual mirror, and there may be practical limits to the focal ratio. A one meter mirror with a focal ratio of 15,000 kilometers may be completely impractical, just because of the tolerances that would need to be achieved in creating the mirror. So there may be a "sweet spot" for optical mirrors which says it is impractical with current engineering techniques to build a mirror larger than 1 km in diameter and having a focal ratio less than 1 or greater than 100. If so then building hundreds of such telescopes and combining their signals through interferometry would be the only practical way to build a "super eye in the sky." I don't really care what the final design is, I just wish people would start thinking about building the things in space, instead of building them on the ground and then chunking them up into orbit.