Mad Dog Maddux
By CosmicConservativeI'm a huge baseball fan. I am also something of a traditionalist, meaning I still don't approve of the designated hitter rule the upstart "American League" uses to artificially generate offense to appeal to people who don't appreciate the nail-biting suspense of a 1-0 pitching masterpiece.
If you asked ten people who knew anything about sports who the greatest starting pitcher of the past 20 years is, 8 of them would probably say "Roger Clemens." And they'd have a good case, Roger has won six Cy Young awards in 22+ seasons and is up to #9 on the all time winning pitchers list with 341 wins.
My vote would go to Greg Maddux though. He's won 4 Cy Young awards and as of today has won 323 games in 20+ seasons.
The comparison of the two pitchers reveals two completely different temperaments, physical abilities, game philosophies and statistical results.
Roger is a "hurler", he throws hard, in the upper 90mph range, and he intimidates his opponents with his sheer physical size and velocity on the ball. He is a strike out pitcher and has struck out roughly 50% more batters than Greg has struck out in roughly equal careers. But he's also walked roughly 50% more batters than Greg has. Greg is a "pitcher" in the purest sense of the word. He is all about location and making batters make mistakes. He is finesse, Roger is power.
But the two most important pitching statistics, wins and ERA, they are remarkably similar. Both are right at the 3.00 ERA mark, with Roger's slightly higher ERA being explainable by his longer reign in the American League with it's ditzy designated hitter rule. Greg has averaged 15.9 wins per year (and holds the major league record for consecutive seasons of 15 wins or more, topping even Cy Young in that category) while Roger has averaged 15.5 wins per year, with a lot more big seasons and bust seasons.
Today Greg goes for his 324th win, which would tie him for career wins with Nolan Ryan, a pitcher much more like Roger Clemens in skills and temperament, but also one that most people will recognize.
Roger Clemens is currently the 9th winningest pitcher in major league history. Greg Maddux needs to get to 330 wins to become the 10th. I think it would be pretty cool to have two active pitchers (I know Roger is not active at the moment, but the rumors are that he is wanting to pitch at least one more year) in the top ten of all time.
So I'm rooting for Greg today.
Which is probably going to jinx him. Sorry Mad dog.
Comments (5)