Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NFL Week 10

By CosmicConservative
Other than New Orleans stretching their undefeated mark, it was pretty much a miserable NFL weekend, so I don't have much to say about it other than that I'm loopy from lack of sleep and not real happy about any of the outcomes. I can't even really be happy about Philly losing to San Diego since that puts the Chargers in a tie with the Broncos. So, pretty much a miserable sports weekend all around. Sigh.

Comments (32)

Interested
at work but watching the play by play on my NE / IND game.
Boyd
The Philly/SD game was the only outcome I liked, since it kept the Cowboys in 1st place in the NFC East. Luckily, I had to work and couldn't watch the Dallas/GB game and feel the pain in real-time. I recorded it on the DVR to watch tomorrow, but some hater gleefully mentioned the outcome, so I suppose I won't bother to watch it.
Interested
heh I gotta smack talk on some of my Dallas friends. Payback for their romping on me during the Jets / Pats game.
Drax
Heh. Not a bad week for me... Packers won. Dallas lost. A twofer. New Orleans won. Again, barely. Favre had another great day. Bengals won. Steelers lost. Another twofer. Warner had another great day. Arizona risin... Don't know if Ronnie Brown or Cedric Benson (my two main running backs) are injured or hurt. Could dull my rave... But, overall...a good day.
Interested
damn Indy rallied for 21 points in 4th. that's gonna improve their standing that they actually played someone.
Foobarista
9ers won, and still have a shot at a 500 season. Yeah, I suppose "conservatives" aren't supposed to root for SF, but I grew up watching freezing my butt and watching them lose in the late 1970s, and then lived the glory years, so they'll always be my team. Oh, and Dallas is ee-vile. And my alma mater Cal pulled off an upset of Arizona in the first game I've watched them win in person in about 20 years, setting up a huge Big Game next week against Leland Stanford Junior College, who stomped all over the University of Spoiled Children (USC) last week.
Drax
Heh. Colts won. Cheaters lost. A great last minute nail-biter that highlighted Manning's greatness coupled with an incomprehensible call by Cheater-in-chief Belichick. A Fourfer!
CosmicConservative
Ug, I went to bed before the Indy/Pats game. I'm a Brady fan so I tend to root for the Pats, but it's not a big deal for me. I like the whole "will they run the table" storyline for Indy so I'm not too upset, but I'd have preferred a Pats win. So another game that didn't go my way. Sigh.
Andy
Cosmic, I haven't watched much "pro" football this season. I've been watching The Cowboys. Man...that one left a mark...
Interested
whoa, you gotta be kidding me on two parts Drax. 1) Never met anyone with objective ability regarding football that put stock into the cheater bit. Most know that even now at least a third of the teams are doing it. Does it make it right? nope, is your team doing it? Good chance they have and are. 2) To call it an "incomprehensible" call is to limit these two teams histories and abilities. In essence, you're minimising Mannings and the Colt's accomplishments in that quarter.
Interested
and not to mention- no small surprise. Belicheck made the correct call to go for it. This dude did math on it. (advancednflstats.com) “With 2:08 left and the Colts with only one timeout, a successful 4th-and-2 conversion wins the game for all practical purposes. A conversion on 4th-and-2 would be successful 60 percent of the time. Historically, in a situation with 2:00 left and needing a TD to either win or tie, teams get the TD 53 percent of the time from that field position. The total win probability for the 4th-down conversion attempt would therefore be: “(0.60 * 1) + (0.40 * (1-0.53)) = 0.79 WP (WP stands for win probability) “A punt from the 28 typically nets 38 yards, starting the Colts at their 34. Teams historically get the TD 30 percent of the time in that situation. So the punt gives the Pats about a 0.70 WP.” You don’t need to know much math to know 79 percent is a greater likely win percentage than 70 percent.
Drax
Interested. As to the "cheater" part... Really. No one puts stock into it? He was fined $500,000.00. Personally. The Patriots were fined $250,000. They lost their first round draft pick. Because it wasn't "cheating." Just an incorrect "interpretation of the rules." Right. Goodell wanted to ensure a "fair" game by imposing these maximum fines, but it wasn't "cheating...." ESPN's Greg Easterbrook thinks otherwise: http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=easterbrook/070918 Joey Porter says an asterisk is appropriate. Ross Tucker (former Pat) confirmed that, in addition to the taping cheating, Belicheck routinely used players on injured reserved in practice. Bill Chaung (The Football Expert.com) thinks writes that Walsh was "instructed to use a cover story" if caught. Nah. Who needs a "cover story" when it's just an innocent misinterpretation of the rules? Boston Globe's Bob Ryan says: "The three Super Bowl championships are, and forever will be, under suspicion...The Patriots have been irrevocably stained. They will be, in the eyes of many, the reverse Black Sox. They will be the team that broke the rules. Their three Super Bowls will be regarded as ill-gotten gain." Matt Walsh (who participated in the cheating) acknowledges that it was cheating and said that the 3 superbowls were worth the $750,000 fine and draft pick. Yawn....and that's 10 minutes of searching for names one might recognize on something which happened (Didn't add George Bush or Hillary Clinton) four years ago or thereabouts... You can believe that it (secret videotaping of opponents' sidelines by an employee who was told to lie about what he was doing in the event he was caught) was an innocent misinterpretation of the rules when the person who innocently misinterpreted them was fined the maximum possible amount, the team was fined the maximum possible amount and lost a first round draft pick -- and then the evidence was DESTROYED -- all you wish. But to say that no one "with objective ability" believes it was cheating is just utter bullshit. As to the "incomprehensible call," you can do all the "math" you wish. Bottom line is that, it put the team in a position to fail, rather than a position to win. The possibility of giving MANNING the ball with a 28 yard field and 2 minutes to go was INSANE. What are the odds that MANNING with 2 minutes to go would score a TD on a 28 yard field? Well, from the results, I'd say SOMEWHERE AROUND 100%. It was a STUPID call. We are currently in day TWO of Sportscenter where this call is the lead on just about every segment. You can make an ARGUMENT that it wasn't insane, but you can make THAT argument if the ball was on the ONE YARD LINE. (In fact, there's a high school team who wins state championships with some regularity and goes for it on 4th down almost every time. But, this ain't high school. And, even in the Pros, there's only ONE MANNING. Against the Browns? Okay. Against the Raiders? Okay. AGAINST MANNING? INSANITY.)
Interested
Sorry man, gotta relegate you to the average weekend tailgate football fan. 1) no, most objective people know every team has done it in the past and a lot are today. Or did you just ignore the coaches who've said yeah - they did it when they were coaching? Cmon that's being wilfully blind to reality. Spend some more time searching. 2) If you knew these two teams, if you knew these two QB's, if you knew these two styles of systems, if you knew these two teams history. Heck if you knew anything about these two teams, it's a matter of who had the ball last - has been for the better part of 7 years. The one and only call Belicheck got wrong was he should have let them score faster and given the ball back to Brady with a minute half to spare. If you gave the ball to Manning or Brady on the opponents 30 yard play it's a score. If you gave the ball to Manning or Brady with 2:00 left on the clock at their own 1 yard line it's a score with zero time left on the clock. Farve probably couldn't do it, but Farve's no todays Manning and he's certainly no Brady.
Drax
Yeah. Everyone "cheats" so it's not "cheating." Yep. Gotcha. Just because there are rules against it, and you do it anyway, it ain't "cheating." Just because you tell your guy to lie about what you're doing if he gets caught, it's okay, because "everyone's doing it." Yep. That's what ALL cheaters say. "Everyone's doing it." Might be a good enough reason for you to ignore it, let him slide. Not me, nor many others. He's a cheater. He got caught. And like Bob Ryan (one of those with no knowledge of football) of the Boston Globe says, the Pats will wear this stain until the end of time. Just like Bonds and A-Rod. They cheated. They got caught. Doesn't matter if "everyone is doing it." They didn't get caught. So, maybe, just maybe....NOT EVERYONE IS DOING IT. Only the cheaters. Who whine "everyone's doing it." When they get caught. ---------------------- No. I's stupid. I don't know nuttin' 'bout no futbal, specially 'bout 'dem Patriots and 'dem Colts from that Baltimore city. The past is the past. The now is the now. If we only worried about the past in the present, then the Pats would have continued dominating the Colts instead of the Colts turning it around these past several years. There is a reason you don't give your opponent the chance to have the ball on the 28 yard line with 2 minutes to go. You might lose the game. Uh... I can buy the argument that cheater Bill felt that he had to take the chance because of his record versus the Colt's record. If he kept control of the ball, then he would likely win and the Colts would still be within reach for best record. He doesn't play for wild card, but for best record. I can understand that. But, not the 28 yard line. At least no coach (the likes of say...Walsch, Noll, pick your HOFers) of any repute has EVER made such a bone-headed call. Maybe they is as dum as I be..
CosmicConservative
Actually I have seen Landry make that call. Not exactly the same, but Danny White faked many punts in similar situations and ran or threw for a first down. I'd bet Knoll and Walsh have a couple of situations that are somewhat similar in their careers. I can see Belicheck making that call. I'm surprised it's not made more frequently. The only thing I would say is that he may have made the proper mathematical calculation, but he did not factor in the risk properly. The reward of success was a probable win, but the risk of failure was near certain loss. He shoulda punted. Those who are saying it showed confidence in hi offense are missing the equally likely possibility that he showed no confidence in his defense.
Drax
I've NEVER seen a head coach who is AHEAD with around 2 minutes to go and on his own 28 "go for it" on 4th down with 2 yards to go. Never. But, since Interested thinks that the last one to have the ball wins and he's an expert on this subject, let's examine it: 2008: Colts take a THREE POINT lead with 8 minutes to go. With 4 minutes to go, Cassell is intercepted. Colts with .29 left on NE 49 PUNTS on 4th and 2. Colts defense HOLDS and Colts WIN. 2007: NE takes FOUR POINT lead with 3 minutes to go. NE forces a fumble and recovers. Converts 3rd and 6 and kneels for win. 2006: Colts take lead with 1 minute to go. Brady intercepted on 1st and 10. Manning kneels for the win. (I guess you could call this one the "last team to have the ball wins" since Brady gave it to the Colts so Manning could kneel rather than win it when he had the chance...) 2005: We can forget this year. Colts win 40-21. 2004: We can forget this year. NE wins 20-3. 2003: We can forget this year. NE wins 24-14. 2002: Didn't play. 2001: We can forget this year. NE wins 44-13. So, let's see. Of the three games when it was close...we have...1) The Colts having the lead, giving the ball to NE then their defense holding for the WIN, 2) NE taking a late lead, kicking off to the Colts. The Colts having the ball with an opportunity for Manning to win the game, but he fumbles, the NE defense holds. The offense converts a 3rd down and kneels for the win. 3) Colts take lead with 1 minute to go, kick off. Brady has the ball and the opportunity to win but throws an interception. Manning kneels for the win. You know...this really doesn't sound anything like: "it’s a matter of who had the ball last - has been for the better part of 7 years." Or anything even close to that (for those three years...and of course, the other four years it wasn't even close. Sigh.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I don't even know how I'd go back and research plays when Danny White punted. I can't guarantee he ever faked a punt from his end of the field when they were ahead by less than a touchdown, but I would be surprised if he didn't. But I can't prove it. And as I've said, I rarely win a sports argument with you, so I'm not going to push it. I think Belicheck's decision was defensible, but I think it was the wrong one.
Drax
CC: There are hardly ANY decisions (sports or not) which aren't "defensible." And, I've seen a few talking heads defend this particular one. The vast majority not only panned it, but used language I have seldom heard used, such as "laughable" and "stupid" especially as applied to cheater Bill. Like I said, I can see both sides (you know what I used to do...hell, I got PAID to see the side you were paying me to see...) But, on your own 28? Two minutes to go? 2 yards? When you have the lead and could put them 70 or 80 yards away? Man, that takes SOME "defendin..." I mean the risk/reward here is HUGE. If Cheater Bill was of the mind that he COULDN'T stop the Colts (a thought which shouldn't go through his head with that team and on that night when they HAD repeatedly stopped them...) and that his SEASON WAS LOST if they didn't keep the ball, that certainly is a risk worth taking. And, frankly, that's the only thing I can think of which would make it a risk worth taking and, again, frankly, I believe that this is what he was think as he brought his kicking team back in (what was THAT?) and sending his offense back onto the field.
Interested
"Not me, nor many others." And yet at the same time you completely neglect to mention other Coaches who admitted to doing it. and you instead focus on the Patriots. Besides the point you failed to read what I put in it's entirety. What about GB former Coach's take on it. -- On Sunday NFL Countdown, Mike Holmgren and Sean Payton stated that many coaches steal opposing signals. -- Think that means that they didn't? But hey that's your flawed take on it. You're forgetting 2008, 2007, 2006 - Last team with the ball, Last team with the ball. Do you bother to read what you put or do you have such an incredibly biased opinion that any realities are dismissed? But if you want to claim that 2008 was different due to the 29 seconds I'll grant ya the 29 seconds. 2007 - had Colts gotten the ball they would have won (that's team with the ball last). --------- I’ve NEVER seen a head coach who is AHEAD with around 2 minutes to go and on his own 28 “go for it” on 4th down with 2 yards to go. _-------- Because again, you fail to realise the realities of these two teams. Once again, these two teams are so incredibly matched that if the Patriots punted and gave Manning 2 minutes on the clock, he would have eaten 1:52 seconds at least, and scored for the win. Once again, these two teams are so incredibly matched that if the Colts got the ball on the 28 which they did, they would have scored. Once again, these two teams are so incredibly matched that if the Patriots made the play (which they had the best probability of doing) the game was over. Once again, these two teams are so incredibly matched that failing to convert, if the Patriots opened up a hole, given themselves a minute 30 on the clock. they would have come back and won. Last team with the ball, it's the way it has and will be. Patriots made the right call at the time, and I would expect they would make the same call again. Monday morning quarterbacking is always 20-20. Search some more.
Interested
--- (a thought which shouldn’t go through his head with that team and on that night when they HAD repeatedly stopped them… ---- Really? Do you know how many points the Colts put up in the 4th Quarter? that's a whole lotta stopping. Geez man, this stuff is freaking transparent.
Drax
Yes. My how amazing it is that the winner of the game was the "last team with the ball." LOL. Cassel, behind, has the ball in the last minutes of the game with the opportunity to win it with a last minute drive and throws an interception. AMAZINGLY, the "last team with the ball" wins by taking a knee. Manning, behind, gets the ball with a couple of minutes to go, has the chance to win the game with a last minute drive, but fumbles. AMAZINGLY ENOUGH New England is able to convert one first down then take knees and is wins, being the "last person with the ball." Brady, behind, with 1/2 a minute to go with the ball in his hand, with the chance to win with a last minute drive, is intercepted, and OH MY GOD!!!! Manning, the "last one with the ball" takes a knee and wins. Amazing!!!!! When you have the ball, driving with almost no time left but with a chance to win the game -- and the DEFENSE HOLDS and you are intercepted or a forces a fumble and the ball is turned over to the WINNER whose DEFENSE HELD, by George! They were the "last one with the ball." I'm sorry, but that's laughable. In 2008 Cassell had the ball and a chance to win in the last minutes of the game. Colts defense HELD and Colts won. In 2007 Manning had the ball with a couple of minutes left with a chance to win, but the defense HELD forcing a fumble and NE won. In 2006 Brady had the ball with 1/2 a minute to go with a chance to win, but the defense HELD, snagging an interception. If THAT'S your notion of a 7 year history of the "last one with the ball wins" then, I don't know what to say. Kneeling, I guess is, in your mind, the "last one with the ball." Sheesh. Now...I just related to you the last three years. The ONLY three years in the last DECADE where the game was close enough for it to go down to the last possessions. In those three years, the "history" is that the ONE TIME when Manning had the ball with enough time to score, he DID -- BUT he left 30 seconds on the clock and gave Brady a chance to win the game. ONCE. ONCE. ONCE. ONCE. And, that ONCE, he left enough time on the clock for Brady to perform his OWN comeback. The OTHER time Manning had the opportunity to win, he FUMBLED, i.e., LOST. By my reckoning, out of the TWO TIMES that Manning has had the ball in his hands in the last three minutes, driving with a chance to win, he has: 1) Successfully driven once, but leaving 30 seconds on the clock for Brady, and 2) FUMBLED letting Brady kneel for the win. I can post helpful links to nfl.com so that you can dig into the play-by-play since your memory is so deficient. I agree that these two teams are relatively evenly matched, although NE outplayed the Colts on Sunday until the last minutes (10 minutes more possession, in the red zone 3 more times, more rushing yards, more passing yards). But, from your post(s), I see two things. 1) It ain't cheating to cheat if everyone else is cheating (even though there is NO proof that others are SECRETLY TAPING sideline signals to be studied later) 2) It's a good call to go for it on 4th and 2 with 2 minutes to go so long as the team you're playing against has one of the best quarterbacks in the history of the game who, according to you, can beat you from his own 1 yard line with 2 minutes to go every time he has the ball. 3) The "last one with the ball" includes being the "last one with the (intercepted) ball" and the "last one with the (fumbled) ball" and DOESN'T mean having the ball in your hands attempting to make a drive to win the game. Okay. Gotcha.
Interested
You also forgot 2009, and I'll give you a pass on it, I of course think 4 and 4 is better part of the years and I expect given your hatred not to see it the same way. btw - your two items, you listed three. And does bolding a word make it somehow correct? Lets summarise what you've stated here. 1) you feel that somehow a team that could not stop the opposition from scoring should again put the ball in the hands of that same offence with two minutes left top play rather than let the team score and get the ball back. High school teams understand this simple fact that if your offence is getting points and your defence is no longer preventing points. That sometimes the best way to win a game is to stop eating up the clock and let them score. But no, all football must follow conventional history - even if game facts show a different scenario. Tell me, how many times did you get this outrageous when Favre threw another game in one of his wild maverick I'm Brett Favre watch me throw another interception - games? 2) You couldn't care less about any game history between either team. 3) You either feel that A) It only matters if you get caught cheating. Coaches that confessed matter not at all. Not when it comes to the Patriots! or even worse, B) You really don't care about the cheating, you just like to bring it up against a team that wins - and wins a lot. And you attempt to climb up on some high horse and lecture me on what you think cheating is? That's certainly being less than truthful, don't you think? You sure somewhere deep inside is a nagging suspicion that Favre's one and only superbowl ring is tainted by cheating that was just not caught? But what's even more telling than all of that is that I, a Patriots fan, respect and admire the Colts for that comeback far more than you claim to. I see and respect the Colts for what they were able to do, and the momentum of the game. I put a lot more confidence in their offensive abilities at that point than in the defensive capabilities of our defence at that point. But I also place the equal amounts of confidence in our Offence with what - 13 seconds to make a play. You know Drax. If you claim you got paid to do this type of analysis, and I have to assume you did. One would hope you put more honesty and rationality into your analysis Your blind hatred more than tells me enough. Your just that kind of fan.
Drax
Interested, I never claimed to get paid for this type of analysis....just for the ability to see both sides of an argument and argue one side whether or not I agreed with it. Let's agree to disagree on the decision. At least there's an argument to be made that Cheater Bill (as Teddy said) thought so little of his defense that he would rather take the CHANCE of giving Manning the ball on his own 28 than the CERTAINTY of giving it to him on the Colt's 30 or so. Personally, I'm glad he made the call. I like to see the Patriots lose. (Of course, I like it when Brady and Moss perform well as they were my #1 and #2 picks in Fantasy Football since I had the last pick and all the best running backs were gone...) Your "last one with the ball wins" notion is nonsense. I ain't gonna pull you play-by-play again. If you want to live in a fantasy world of a seven-year "history" of the "last one with the ball wins" so Cheater Bill's decision to make a stupid decision to attempt to be the "last one with the ball," -- when the actual "history" of the past seven years doesn't show that at all -- but the OPPOSITE, I'm cool with that. (And...uh...no...I didn't include 2009 in Cheater Bill's 2009 decision because in 2009, when Cheater Bill was making the decision, the future history of 2009 had yet to occur....) You call it "blind hatred" to detest a cheat. Sorry. I detest cheats. In sports. In law. In life. You apparently not only tolerate them, but applaud them. Like most cheater apologists, you say "everyone does it," neither providing proof of "everyone doing it" nor adequately explaining what "it" is. In this case, the Cheaters were recording the practices of their opponents. This allowed them to capture the sideline signals (which are changed every week) of THAT week to be used in THEIR game...to capture the quarterback counts...the quarterback audibles and signals which would be used against them, the defense's signals and audibles to be used that week -- all to be carried back to the clubhouse to be studied in detail so to be able to affect the play-calling of his own staff. Name someone else who has done that. Who admits to having done that. Who was caught doing that. Name one coach (other than those who have worked for Cheater Bill since he began doing this in 2000) who has admitted (or has been caught) SECRETLY RECORDING the other team's practices and sidelines. NOT attempting to capture signals while PLAYING the game. This is as old as football and is something done in every sport. When the other guy is sending in signals, you try to figure out what he's doing, i.e., "steal" the signals. THIS ISN'T CHEATING...because, uh...IT'S NOT AGAINST THE RULES. If the signals were being TAPED -- THEN it would be "cheating" because (you guessed it) it would be against the rules. Not being against the rules, it's not cheating. Nice symmetry there. Before this degenerates further, let me sum up: 1) You applaud cheaters; I detest them. 2) You say "everyone does it," yet provide no proof that anyone "does it" when "it" is recording the signals the opposing team will use against you to be studied later to gain an advantage in violation of the rules, tossing out examples of "signal stealing" during the game which isn't against the rules. 3) You assert that Cheater Bill's decision was a good one under the circumstances. I assert it was a stupid decision ESPECIALLY under the circumstances. Let's just agree to disagree.
CosmicConservative
Drax, you don't need to say "Cheater Bill" every time. We get the point. From what I have seen and heard on the whole "cheating" incident, there do appear to be two sides to that story as well. I'm not prepared to turn Bill Belicheck into the NFL's version of Al Capone. He pushed the envelope and essentially gave the NFL the finger because he felt that the NFL had made a rule and allowed the Jets to violate it the previous year. So he blatantly stuck his cameraman right in the face of the Jets and dared them to do something about it. To claim that Bill Belicheck "cheats" more than other NFL coaches does seem to me to be either some deliberate ignorance on your part or else some level of disingenuity in your arguement. I'm not a huge fan of Bill Belicheck, but I don't have any major issues with him either. People who want to put some sort of asterisk on his Super Bowl victories seem to me to be ignoring a lot of readily available information about the activities of other teams during that same time. Up until Belicheck told the NFL to kiss his ass on the issue it's pretty clear to me that most NFL coaches were ignoring the year-old rule change on "stealing signals." It is my opinion that Belicheck got nailed more because he stuck his thumb in the NFL's eye than because he was doing anything that his peers weren't doing.
Drax
CC: Provide some proof that Cheater Bill (and I call him that so to leave a constant reminder of the "stain" he has left on the game) is not alone in his TAPING of other teams' practices. Proof. Not "stealing signals" during games which goes on in every sport and is NOT against the rules. It's up to YOU to protect your signal calling during the game. Cheater Bill was caught. He claimed he didn't understand the rule. The NFL sent out a MEMO clarifying the rule -- NO TAPING AT ANY TIME. Cheater Bill did it again. He got caught -- again. Sorry, unless and until the apologists PROVE that "everyone does it" rather than that just being what they SAY when they want to minimize the actions of the one who was CAUGHT, I'm going to continue with my belief that Cheater Bill DOES "cheat" more than other NFL Coaches. I DO have proof that Cheater Bill cheated. On multiple occasions. Do you have such proof of all the other NFL coaches cheating as you ASSERT they do?
CosmicConservative
You mean other than the admissions of people like Jimmy Johnson?
Drax
You really have to provide a link, so I can see what he said.
Drax
I have found references to his "admission," but nothing verbatim. Doesn't matter. Cheater Bill got caught doing it. He claimed that it was legal under his interpretation of league rules. There was no discipline. The NFL sent out a memo in response to this incident making it crystal clear that taping the sidelines of any team at any time was against the rules. He continued to do it. THAT is the point. He could no longer claim he didn't understand. He could no longer claim that it was legal under ANY interpretation of the rules since the memo was sent in RESPONSE to his being caught SPECIFICALLY to stop the practice by ANYONE. He didn't stop. Sure, I'm aware of the past cheaters cheating -- bugging locker rooms, taping practices, doing whatever they could to obtain an advantage. What sports fan isn't? THAT DOESN'T MAKE IT RIGHT. I'm TIRED of the notion that "if you ain't cheating, you ain't trying." I'm TIRED of people sticking up for people who are caught cheating instead of heaping approbation upon them as is what they deserve. Since that 2006 memo, ONLY Cheater Bill has been caught continuing to engage in this practice. Unless, of course, you have some evidence otherwise...which, of course, doesn't exist as anyone who was caught cheating in such a fashion would have been fined by the NFL -- as was Cheater Bill and the Patriots. I know the reverse of the truism: "Cheaters never prosper" is now the reality, but when cheaters not only prosper, but are APPLAUDED after they are CAUGHT -- it ticks me off.
CosmicConservative
Interview with Jimmy Johnson. Quotes: Q: How about the spying thing Jimmy. You’re a coach does that bother you what Belichick did? JJ: Oh please. I’ve said it on our show. Eighteen years ago a scout for the Chiefs told me what they did, and he said what you need to do is just take your camera and you go and zoom in on the signal caller and that way you can sync it up. The problem is that if they’re not on the press box side you can’t do it from the press box, you have to do it from the sideline. This was 18 years ago. Q: You think the NFL came down too hard on them? JJ: No, no, I said it on the show. He was wrong for doing it for the simple reason that the league knew this was going on not just in New England but around the league. And the league sent out the memorandum to all of the teams saying you cannot do this. And so that’s when Bill Belichick was wrong. After he got the memorandum saying don’t do it any more, he did it. Q: Did you ever steal signals? JJ: Oh in a heartbeat, yeah. Yes I did. In a nutshell Jimmy's interview supports the notion that it was common when Belichick was "caught." Belichick claims that the Jets violated the memo first and he complained to the NFL front office and nothing happened so he blatantly broke the rule himself. That's what he claims. You can believe what you like. Not really my deal, I agree with Jimmy, this is way overblown and has little impact on the actual games.
Drax
You apparently didn't read his transcript. First, it was what was going on during the game: "... just take your camera and you go and zoom in on the signal caller and that way you can sync it up. The problem is that if they’re not on the press box side you can’t do it from the press box, you have to do it from the sideline." That is "stealing signals" during the game. Common practice in every sport. (There's allegations of doing so as it relates to helmet communications being intercepted as well. Cheaters cheat...that's what they do.) Jimmy clarifies (making my point): "And so that’s when Bill Belichick was wrong. After he got the memorandum saying don’t do it any more, he did it." So...is there a point there?
CosmicConservative
I suppose we can each accuse the other of not paying attention to the facts. Not my deal really, I just think that your constant harping on Belichick with the "Cheater-Bill" stuff is sophomoric and doesn't really help your argument. If you really think Bill Belichick is somehow the poster child of NFL cheating, all I can say is that I've got some coast-front land in Colorado for sale if you are looking for a beach house.
Drax
He IS the "poster boy" for cheating. He got caught. Pretty simple. I like the sound of "Cheater Bill." Rolls off the tongue. Kind of like 'Roid Rod. Yet again, I have challenged you to provide proof of anyone who has "cheated" (as opposed to engaging in behavior that others engaged in which was NOT "against the rules") by flagrantly violating the rule against recording the sideline of the opposing teams. Doesn't exist. So...UNTIL such exists, then...yep..."poster boy for cheating." (Cheaters are going to cheat. Apparently your and Interested position is that, since others have done it in the past (when it was, at least arguably, NOT "cheating") then we shouldn't call down those who continue to do it today. Sorry, I don't adhere to that view. I adhere to the view that football, like all games, is a game of rules. If it ain't forbidden, it's allowed. But, if it's forbidden and you knowingly do it, you pay the price. The bigger the rule, the bigger the price. Acceptance of cheaters as "that's just the way it is" is unacceptable to me.)