Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On Black Holes

By CosmicConservative
I am a physics heretic. I don't believe in singularities. They may well exist, but I cannot wrap my brain around them, they violate everything I seem to know about reality and so I simply don't believe in them. I'm not sure I believe in black holes or not, but I definitely don't believe there is some infinite density dimensionless point that sucks time and space into another dimension. That just seems crazy to me. Now, it is not impossible that there are objects so dense that they are "black holes" in the classical sense, meaning that they are objects from which no light (and therefore no matter) can escape, except through Hawking radiation (which is sort of like magic too, but I actually do understand it and "believe" in it). But "dense enough to be a black hole" and "infinitely dense" are not the same thing. So I guess what I believe is that matter has some basic degenerate state that is incompressible, and when it reaches that state, it can compress no further. Why this is so may not be due to some inherent strength of matter, but could be due to something more akin to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. It is conceivable to me that matter may reach a point inside a black hole that if you try to pack it any more tightly, it simply gets "fuzzy" in the same sense that Heisenberg talks about fuzziness. It doesn't compress any further, because nothing can force it any closer, it simply reappears outside of the boundaries that would make it collapse to nothingness. Sigh, that doesn't sound very convincing. But I don't know how else to put it. What it boils down to is just my belief that infinite density and zero dimensions are meaningless statements in reality. As I said, I just can't wrap my brain around it.

Comments (5)

Aaron
Yeah. I'm a physics heretic too. There usually is some nonlinearity, or some other force that comes into play to prevent physical quantities from becoming infinite anything. We probably just model them as mass points because we don't know what sort of force would come into play to prop it up. As far as black holes are concerned, I'm a physics heretic in more ways than one. Do you know that from the perspective of a remote observer, it takes mass an infinite amount of time to cross the event horizon?
CosmicConservative
Yes, I did know that the theory of black holes results in mass appearing to stack up on the event horizon. This is another area that I find not to be plausible. But I guess the only way to be sure is to build one of those earth-sized telescopes I posted about and actually go look at some black holes and see what we see.
MagikalOutkast
Is it not possible for a blackhole to create so much pressure that in a sense it does form a hole? I've always seen black holes depicted as a whirlpool almost, the way I see it is literally a big black ball. Out of curiosity, do you think a black hole has a weight and continues to grow either in density or size as it pulls things inside? Or, do you think that it retains one weight and size and literally does somehow wormhole it someplace else? Also food for thought, might black holes have something to do with the big bang effect?
CosmicConservative
Magikal: I'm not sure that our current understanding of physics at the extremes of nature are adequate to tell us what is "possible" or not, but is it plausible that a black hole creates so much pressure that it forms a hole? I dunno, I guess I need to understand into what the hole is forming. I guess I am trying to use Occam's Razor here and ask myself, what is more plausible, that a black hole opens some sort of rip in spacetime into another dimension where all the matter and energy falls leaving a dimensionless singularity, or that within a black hole matter eventually reaches an incompressible point due to quantum fluctuations in spacetime? Well, it is more plausible to me that the matter stays in our universe in a form that avoids the practical paradoxes that singularities imply. I'm not sure what the "big bang effect" is. If you mean is there some connection with black holes and the big bang, then yes I do believe that black holes recreate some of the density conditions of the Big Bang. But I believe that actually supports my contention that the matter never became a singularity and popped into some other dimension, because it's all still here. I'm basing this whole premise on the notion that at the quantum level you cannot identify the position of anything with perfect precision, and a singularity essentially does exactly that, you know exactly where it is, and how fast its moving. This violates what I know about quantum physics. So my contention is that as the density increases, so does the quantum uncertainty, so that the center of a black hole is essentially a quantum particle field with no perfect boundary. It's sort of a surging ball of quantum foam seething back and forth as particles tunnel to and fro. Of course black holes grow in mass and size as they pull things into the event horizon, that's perfectly acceptable within the bounds of physics as I understand it. What I don't buy is the singularity, wormhole, mass falls into another dimension explanation of black holes.
Avery
Allow me to dispel a bit of the mystery regarding black holes: 1) They aren't black! This is a myth propagated by ignorance and popular science fiction. Just like the Earth, the Sun, and any other massive body, "black" holes warp space causing light to appear to bend. The difference here with "black" holes, is that they warp space so completely that light from a source behind them will be bent completely around the black hole making them in fact invisible (except for the accreation disk if they're active). The apperance of an actual black hole would be a shifting/shimmering star field ... not unlike a Romulan cloaking device from Star Trek. 2) There is no singularity. The singularity is an artifact of the limits of General Relativity. Like any mathamatical model, if you feed it data beyond the problem domain it was ment to solve you get garbage. Most likely if you were to have the misfortune to travel across an event horizon you'd find a rapidly spinning sphere made of degenerate condensed matter (see neutron star). Inside said sphere you would find a quark/gluon soup not unlike the material that comprised the entire universe moments after the big bang ... proto-matter if you will. You see physic and quantum theory give us all the tools we need to understand the dynamics of a "black" hole without meta-physics or multidimensional speculation. I hope this helps! Avery Davis