Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NFL roundup - Week 9

By CosmicConservative
OK, it's probably not fair to do this yet since Denver has not yet played the defending Super Bowl champ Steelers, but still, some interesting things today. Indy and the Saints both managed to scrape by and keep their perfect seasons intact. That's actually the mark of the teams with the chance to run the table, not how well they do in blowouts, but how they manage to win games they probably should have lost. These two teams seem to be the true elites in the league this year. Dallas seems to be back on track. Miles Austin has given Romo the deep threat he needed to open up both the underneath stuff and a viable running game. The 'boys ain't half bad on defense either. 6 - 2 and leading the NFC East after 8 games is nothing to sneeze at. The Giants seem to be in free fall. I assume they'll get their act together, but four losses in a row is a pretty big hole to dig out of. Brady looked merely human this week, but he also looks like he has shaken off the jitters from his injury last year. I expect the Patriots will just get better as the year goes on. If I had to pick a "surprise of the week" so far, it has to be the Titans whupping up on the 49ers. I thought the Niners had turned a corner. I guess not. And then there's the Bears. Oh my. And yes, I'm going to rag on Cutler again. I am so glad he's out of Denver. Today he actually had a decent day statistically, but the only real thing he should be happy about is that he managed to throw only one interception in a game where the Bears were throwing the ball on every down it seemed. I'll give him that. But what I can't help but point out is the same mental and attitudinal issues that I disliked in Denver. When he went to the Bears I said here to watch by mid-year to see if he's moping about on the sidelines alone when the defense is on the field. I also said that Cutler was locker room poison who created issues with team members. Well, today he didn't blame his problems on any specific player, but when asked if the Bears had any leadership on the team, he replied "I don't know. We'll see." Hey Jay, I think that just answered your question for you! Bears are 4 -4, Cutler is ranked 20th in QB rating and has 14 TDs and 12 INTs, pretty much identical numbers to when he was here in Denver. Yeah, I know, it has nothing to do with Jay. It's all coincidence. :) More tomorrow after the Denver game. I'm going to do my best to watch that one. I think it's going to be a hard-fought game and right now I'd say it's probably a toss-up who will win. Maybe home field will be what Denver needs to put the Steelers away.

Comments (12)

Drax
Heh. HE has a good game, and yet, it's still his fault. The BEARS, otherwise SUCKED, but it's Jay's fault. Ah, well. Course, the great leadership of Aaron Rodgers and (declining) QB Rating isn't much helping the lackluster Packers, is it? Damn team game.
CosmicConservative
LOL, I'm not drawing any conclusions, I'm just saying how remarkable it is that Jay's performance and the team's success in Chicago seems so eerily similar to Jay's performance and the team success in Denver. I mean it's eerily similar... :)
Drax
I know... But, the team in Chicago is eerily similar to the last year's team in Denver... Horrid defense, below average O-line, and what happened to their special teams? Sheesh. Denver, on the other hand, somehow grew a defense and an O-line who keeps Orton's uniform fairly clean. It is simply AMAZING how teams from one year to the next with only minor changes are INSANELY better or worse than the previous year.
CosmicConservative
I agree with that Drax. Or even in the same season. Look at the Giants and Cowboys this year. Four games ago the Cowboys looked done and the Giants looked like contenders. Four games later the 'Boys are looking like contenders and the Giants look done. I guess I should really stop ragging on Cutler. But I have to admit something about him just rankles and grates on my nerves. I am sure there are probably worse examples, but the disconnect between Cutler's hype and Cutler's results is just unbelievable. I just went to the ESPN NFC North blog and read a bunch of comments there, and I would have to say that the general commentary is quite similar to our discussions on Cutler, although the tone is quite a bit less civil. I actually am a little disappointed in myself because I actually get some satisfaction out of seeing Cutler suffer. That's not good for the karma I know. But I got so sick of his whining and finger-pointing while he was here, and I truly think he is locker room poison. I've said it before, and I think it is demonstrable, there are players who make their teams better and there are players who make their teams worse. I am pretty firmly convinced that Cutler belongs in that second group. He seems to breed dissension and dissatisfaction on a team. When his team wins, he basks publicly in the glory. When his team loses, he whines and points fingers at his teammates. He acts like a 12 year old. I met a guy who plays golf in some charity tournaments. Last year he played in the Cutler charity tournament and actually played with Cutler and another Bronco. According to him Cutler acted like a drunken frat boy at his own charity event. At the concluding dinner when Cutler was asked to make some comments, a visibly inebriated Cutler took the mike, looked out over the crowd of rich socialites who had poured a lot of money into Cutler's event, and said "Let's drink some beer!" That's Cutler in a nutshell.
Drax
Heh...I must admit that Cutler has always come off just as you describe in his public appearances, i.e., a spoiled frat boy. I know it's wrong to judge a book by its cover, but I could watch 15 minutes of him with the sound off and, just by his appearance, I would have judged him as such. He just looks the part. Dunno how much of that affects my opinion of him. But, he seems to be a vastly unlikeable person to me. But, what I find unlikeable and what other "drunken frat boys" find to be unlikeable may be miles and miles apart. He's young. It's possible he'll learn how to lead. That is a teachable ability if one is willing to do the work.
CosmicConservative
We'll see. After 9 weeks of the NFL season the Chicago Bears are in a desperate situation if they have any playoff aspirations whatsoever. At this point Minnesota will have to completely implode for the Bears to overtake them. That means the Bears most realistic shot to make the playoffs is as a wild card team. To get to the playoffs they will have to overtake the Eagles, Giants and Falcons, while also outpacing the Packers. Their 2-3 conference record essentially means they will likely lose a tie-breaker if they end up with the same record as one of those teams. Of course there's still a lot of football to go, but in the second half of the season every game is twice as critical as in the first half. Being 2 games behind with 10 games to play is not the same thing as being 2 games behind with 4 games to play. The Bears should win this Thursday, although the 49ers have shown moments of competence this season so it's no sure thing. If they lose to San Fran, it's hard to come up with a plausible playoff scenario for them that doesn't include two or three teams falling apart down the stretch. Just looking at things as they stand today, I would be surprised if Dallas, Philadelphia, New York and Atlanta don't all have at least 9 wins and a better conference record than Chicago as things stand right now. Unless Chicago goes 6-2 or 7-1 the rest of the way, I doubt they have a shot. And they just don't look like a 6-2 team to me.
Drax
No team with a defense that porous is a legitimate playoff team.
CosmicConservative
So, let's say Chicago goes 3-5 down the stretch and ends up 7-9. (I think this is very possible, in fact.) Last year the Bears were 9-7 and it was considered a disappointing year. Between the end of 2008 and the end of 2009 there were really two major events that probably registered on the average Bears fan. The first was the Orton-Cutler trade. The second was the Urlacher injury. Of course the Orton-Cutler trade wasn't just Cutler for Orton, it also included other players and draft choices. Also I believe Chicago traded away a second round choice to another team, so their draft options are looking pretty grim. The money spent on Cutler cuts into their free agency options. So basically the Bears are looking at pretty grim prospects for building their team in 2010. The question I have is what do you think the Bears fans will blame for their woes? If they end up 7-9 then there will be people saying "Hey, Kyle Orton was 11-7 as our starter, Cutler is 7-9! Who got the best of this deal?" There will be people saying "Hey, you can't blame Cutler, look at the injuries and defensive problems!" Which do you think will become the dominant narrative in Chicago? That Cutler is the victim of defensive injuries, or that Cutler is an over-hyped player and is Chicago's version of the Hershel Walker Minnesota trade?
Andy
I've enjoyed reading the comments. I have only one thing to add. Cutler went to Vanderbilt. Nothing against children of privilege...and I don't know if he was raised that way...but he likely caught the Commodore Fever while there.
Drax
In the end, blame the coach. That's the normal way things go.
CosmicConservative
I suppose you are right Drax, Cutler certainly cost Mike Shanahan his job. I suppose adding Lovey Smith would be a nice feather in his cap as well. ;)
Interested
disappointing butt week. Mainly because the only game I got to watch was Dallas / Philly game. I'd have preferred Philly win it, but what can ya do. My team won in division, we'll be playoff bound unless something serious happens.