Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On Morality

By CosmicConservative
As a rational, as opposed to a religious, conservative, I have some philosophical perspectives that surprise many people who make assumptions about my philosophy (not to mention my religion) because I am conservative on so many issues. One such issue is the concept of morality itself. One of the more common platitudes I hear from a certain smug religious type is this "Without God you can have no morality, therefore atheism is an immoral ideology." As an agnostic who is very skeptical about the existence of any sort of God, much less the "omipotent" and "omniscient" variety favored by the type of person who makes that sort of comment, let me state that such a statement is not only deeply offensive, it is an indication of a profound ignorance of philosophical thought that goes back thousands of years. Morality itself is the concept that there is such a thing as "good" at least, and "good and evil" in most philosophical systems, including religious ones. If morality exists, it is certainly fair to speculate on where it came from. To many people the answer is simplicity itself, morality must have come from the same place that everything else in existence came from, from an act of divine creation. But there are problems with this explanation of morality, both philosophical and practical. And neither of them are merely intellectual problems encountered in dry academic debates. The philosophical problem with this definition of morality is that it defines "good" as "that which God decides is good." Which means that morality is fundamentally arbitrary, and it also means that God cannot be described in moral terms. God cannot be "good" because there are no moral boundaries that apply to God, God only creates moral boundaries for others. There is no way to measure God's actions against any objective standard of behavior since morality for God is by definition subjective. And all God has to do to exempt himself from his own moral rules is to say "they do not apply to me." And by definition, that is "right." Taken to it's logical extreme, this means that morality is not fixed, it is modifiable at the whim of God. So what is "good" today could be "evil" tomorrow as God decides. For most philosophical thinkers this is a deeply disturbing concept of morality since it means that a lifetime of dedicated moral behavior can be wiped out and nullified by an arbitrary act of a being that is completely beyond our control. This sort of realization can lead one to conclude that the only reason to act in a "moral" manner is to ingratiate yourself with God by conforming to his arbitrary guidelines. Or it can lead one to conclude that since morality is an arbitrary construct of one being, however powerful, that there really is no such thing as morality at all, only a temporary set of rules that could change at any time. Neither of these views of morality give a powerful philosophical reason to act in a moral manner. But the practical implications of such a view are far more troubling. The belief that morality is defined by God provides powerful incentive for followers of a religion to act in accordance with whatever definition of morality they are taught. And since the vast bulk of humanity gets its religious information not directly from God, but through some intermediary, the opportunity to pervert the definition of morality is obvious. This is how religions convince otherwise decent, caring human beings that it is morally right to slaughter innocents who do not share their beliefs. This is how religious wars are justified and how mind-numbing acts of brutality are justified and even celebrated by those who believe that their God has told them that by committing such acts they are doing his divine will. This is how "jihad" is justified today, and how the inquisition was justified in the past. Although there is a clear culpability of those who pervert God's message, it is the fundamental belief that God defines morality that leads people to act on these "moral" guidelines. Without that fundamental belief, instead if morality were seen as a fundamental universal principle, it would be far more difficult to incent people, especially masses of people, to commit acts of barbarism and depravity under the name of God. So the belief in divinely created morality itself is dangerous, not merely philosophically questionable. This is why I believe that morality is a more fundamental concept than even the concept of divinity itself. This is also why I believe that morality is based on self-evident concepts such as the Golden Rule. And it is why I believe that any God that might exist can be judged against moral standards that transcend God himself. My life is guided by principles that transcend divinity, and that includes my moral compass. I don't know if there is a God or not, but I do believe that there are good and evil choices. I also believe that people who follow a moral guidance that is derived only from divine proclamation are not being moral because it is "right" they are being moral because it is what "God wants." And if God wants you to kill your neighbor, well, so be it. And that also means that I believe that if there is a God, then that God is also held to those fundamental moral standards. And any God worthy of respect, much less worship, would recognize those moral standards and do his best to follow them. This is why I find the concept of Hell that is held by so many religious types to be completely immoral. There is no crime a mortal human being could commit that deserves eternal punishment. None. It simply is not possible to do infinite harm, and so punishment should not be infinite. This is a fundamental moral principle called "reciprocity". The punishment should be proportionate to the crime, and if it is not, then it is cruel. And cruelty is immoral. Any God who is so cruel is too immoral for me to respect. At this point I usually hear "Who are you to judge God?" To which I reply, it is not my judgment, but the direct application of fundamental moral principles. It is self-evident.

Comments (15)

Dadman
You make a lot of assumptions about the nature of God that I don't believe are accurate. I would describe myself as a rational conservative who is also religious. But my view of God and morality are not precisely what you describe. I believe God operates within immutable laws of physics and morality, as opposed to manipulating such things in an arbitrary manner. I don't believe in a traditional 'Hell' held by the 'religious types' to which you refer. But, by and large, I agree with you. You've put your finger squarely on the problem of morality defined exclusively by religious philosophy . It is too often twisted, corrupted, and used to justify the most heinous kinds of behavior. This, of course, is not just a problem with religion. It is a human problem. Political and social ideologies have been used to inflict terrible pain and suffering as well. Atheism and humanism have also shown humanity a very ugly side. In the final analysis, I believe people look to religion as the source of their moral code because so much of that code in documented in their scriptures. It at least seems less arbitrary then the moral relativism they seem all around them. But, as you point out, it is not always what it seems. Religion needs to be applied with moderation and a healthy dose of skepticism. Otherwise, you might find yourself praising Allah at the moment of detonation or drinking poision Kool-Aid to expedite a rendezvous with the Mother Ship.
CosmicConservative
I wouldn't say I am making assumptions about "God" so much as I am reacting to the particular type of religious person who makes the statement that morality only comes from God because God created everything and is omnipotent and omniscient. There are other views of God, but people who hold other views don't tend to make the statement I was reacting to. And yes, I was reacting to an actual real statement from a real person in the real world when I posted this message.
JSullins
A question if I may: It is my understanding that you probably do not believe that God exists. Do you believe that human beings possess a soul? This is not a prelude to an argument, by the way. Simply curious.
CosmicConservative
"Believe" is a big word. Perhaps the biggest. I am skeptical about supernatural things, big and small. I am just as skeptical about the existence of a soul as I am about twins having telepathy. I don't "believe" in God or souls, that's what it is to be agnostic, I find it hard to believe in things period. That doesn't mean I don't consider the possibility that souls exist, but I don't have any compelling reason to suppose that they do. But I also do not "believe" that God or souls don't exist. I have no compelling reason to suppose that they do not. However, my rational side tends towards the conclusion that they do not, at least not in the form that most people think. There are lots of reasons that my rational side tends that way. A major reason is because the most common concepts of Gods and souls are tailor made to appeal to precisely the parts of the human psyche that most desperately need answers when no answers are clear in the physical world we can see and measure. Here's how it goes: "I don't want to die." We know that everyone does, so we believe in eternal souls that exist beyond the physical body. It makes us feel better. "People should pay for their evil acts." We know that many people are rewarded for their evil acts, so we believe in divine judgment that is infallible. It makes us feel better. "I want to be rewarded for acting good." We know that in life acting good is not always rewarded, so we believe in divine blessings that are handed out to the faithful. It makes us feel better. "There must be some purpose and meaning behind my life." We know that in general, most lives will be forgotten entirely within a few generations after our deaths, so we believe in divine intervention and a place where we will meet our ancestors and progeny in the afterlife where it is all made clear to us. There is no doubt that these concepts are powerful motivators for human beings, and no doubt that they provide great comfort to people who question the purpose of the universe and the role of humans in the universe. But the fact that these concepts are so powerful in the human mind has no bearing on whether they are factual. There is no compelling reason I have seen to believe that they are anything but wishful thinking. Now, I am just as susceptible to these desires, hopes and dreams as anyone else, and I just as desperately hope there is more to my life, and to life in general, than random molecular motions, but that only makes me more suspiscious of the likelihood of the existence of God or souls. It falls too close to the category of "too good to be true". But I lack the pure conviction of true atheists. I hold out hope that there is more and that there is justice and goodness behind all that I see. I just find myself doubting that things are that simple and that beneficial to human beings.
Dadman
My belief in a human soul or spirit has very little to do with my concerns of what occurs after death, whether it be some form of eternal life or divine justice. Instead, my conviction that we all possess a soul is derived from mundane observation: those that acknowledge the soul and seek to nourish it seem to flourish, while those who behave in ways that seem to deny or neglect the reality of a soul seem to suffer. I know this is all very unscientific, but those who practice love, charity, service, selflessness - all those things we are told are good for the soul - truly seem to be blessed. Those who take are more selfish path ultimately seem diminished. If life were truly just random molecular motion I'm not sure that would be the case.
CosmicConservative
I can't agree with you here. There are plenty of examples of atheistic ideologies (the most notable is probably the true Buddhist ideology) which is very much engaged in pursuing the value of selflessness, love, charity and service, and those who pursue that life are every bit as blessed as those who pursue those goals through a belief in divine purpose. What you are saying is that a life that does not center on ourselves, but instead is directed outwards towards others, is a more fulfilling life. That may be true, but it does not require supernatural explanations to explain why that would be so. There is a possibility that we do possess something that we could call a soul, but it is not supernatural. Perhaps it is just another aspect of our humanity, and if so it is nurtured by these selfless acts. I dunno, could be. But it is my opinion that the vast majority of people who believe in a soul do so for the reasons I've stated, not for the reasons of selflessness, charity and other altruistic motives. As Bill Cosby said when his children were surprised by his parents (their grandparents) and told him "they are nothing like you described them, they are nice, gentle people." To which Bill replied, "They are OLD people trying to get into heaven now." I think that may be a rather direct way of stating it, but I think it is by far more common than living a life of selflessness.
Dadman
I think you missed my point... I was trying to say that there is something within us - whether you believe in it or not - that responds positively to behavior that is often described as soul nourishing. The converse is also true. Those who become self-absorbed, indulgent, selfish, etc. are at the very least unhappy and at worst destructive to themselves and others. It's a matter of faith whether or not this attributable to the existence of an eternal human soul. I tend to believe that it is, but I certainly don't know that it is.
Aaron
If the soul does not exist in terms of matter (arrangements thereof, ect) (or any other physical quantity that we're familiar with), then what does it exist in terms of? And why does the soul existing in terms of this "different stuff" somehow elevate what it is capable of? This "random molecular motion" objection has always seemed strange to me. If it exists, it exists in terms of something. If it operates, it operates by a process. Why postulate that what it exists in terms of, or how it operates, is somehow beyond our knowledge or ability to know?
Aaron
BTW, nice article on morality. It addresses something that has concerned me for a while about the foundation for morality insisted on by the religious.
Dadman
Aaron: If a soul exists, I believe it is comprised of some kind of matter we don't yet understand. When you consider the strangeness of quantum physics or the bizarre ideas of string theory it seems plausible, even likely, that the fundamental nature of matter is still largely a mystery.
Aaron
I understand that there are probably many different types of matter, many different phenomena, forces, ect in the universe that we don't yet understand. However, I don't see why any of this necessarily has to do with human beings. Why does the functioning of our minds or souls necessarily [i]need[/i] to be embodied in something we don't understand? As far as "random" molecular motion goes - random would be a gas, ordered molecular motion is far more interesting, and as far as we can tell makes up all the other functions of our bodies and life in general. Since ordered matter can embody processes of arbitrary complexity already, why do we feel that it belittles us somehow to consider our souls as somehow derived from it? What is supposed to be missing if our minds as well as everything else about life are an epiphenomenon of matter, and why does that change if it's an epiphenomenon of some as-of-yet undiscovered system?
CosmicConservative
To play devil's advocate (or perhaps God's advocate in this case...) it isn't necessary that there is some other kind of matter involved. It could be hypothesized that the existing matter we are made of has dynamic properties we are currently unaware of in one of the eleven proposed superstring dimensions, and that the human soul is actually expressed through interactions in those (currently) invisible dimensions. I am no longer any sort of expert in physics, it's been way too long since my college days (and I was only an expert then in the "that was my major" sense, not in the "I chatted with Steven Hawkings" sense...) But.... There are still some very interesting unanswered questions about the nature of matter and the nature of space-time. I agree with Dadman that it is within the realm of possibility that the soul is real, but that we just don't have the means to explain it yet. However, even that takes it out of the realm of "supernatural" and brings it into the natural world, and even if we discover the nature of a soul and prove its existence, it remains to be seen if the soul is any more "divine" or "spiritual" than a piece of chert laying in a streambed in the mountains.
Dadman
Good point, Cosmic. I'm not sure I believe in the 'supernatural' as much as I believe that elements of our natural sphere remain hidden and, to date, unexplained.
MagikalOutkast
"...those who practice love, charity, service, selflessness - all those things we are told are good for the soul - truly seem to be blessed." I am new to blogging, but I've finally found a place with people like me. Not once have I ever been able to speak with someone upon religion like this. Now, back to the issue. I really like the point that Cosmic made on religion being used to explain the unknown. Some of the ideas used before are absolutely absurd, but to think otherwise was sacrilegious, and people risked being considered heretic (a.k.a. death wish). By such reactions such as war and bloodshed, one can derive just how much ideas scare them. The quote used at the top, I have somewhat an issue with. Dadman used it as an explanation on why people must have a soul, does that make the "law of morality" that many christians use prove that God does exist. Personally, I'm really tired of people saying, "Why else can we communicate to eachother, and think rationally? Since this planet is so perfect for us, does that not give us basic proof for God?" In my eyes, no...it really does not. Morality on the otherhand is based upon the eyes of the beholder. Something that you or I think is completely immoral could be the next best thing in another country; such an immoral practice as sacrifices is a prime example. Crap, I gotta go. I'll try finishing later.
Drax
I don't know if there's a "right" and a "wrong" which exists outside of ourselves. Historical evidence would seem to indicate that it does in some respects, i.e., throughout history, in great part, the same things are deemed to be "good" behavior or "bad" behavior...stealing, killing the innocent, etc. However, this could simply be explained as the rational response of the community to actions which are detrimental to the community, and are, therefore, deemed to be "evil." (Indeed, if we have something stolen from us or a loved one unjustifiably killed, we "feel bad" thus, whomever committed the act must have performed a "bad act.") As to the existence of a "soul," I find the question "Is there a "mind"?" a much more seductive question.