Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Tipping point

By CosmicConservative
Back a month or so ago, when Obama's strong negatives first rose above his strong positives, I asked if we had reached a tipping point in Obama's popularity. Events since then have, I think, vindicated that analysis and prediction. Obama is on his fifth day in double-digit negative indexes on his Rasmussen daily presidential approval poll. I expect that to continue to trend downwards as more idiot "Republicans" who voted for the man come to terms with what a monumentally naive, gullible fool they were. But we are seeing, I think, another tipping point, this is a cultural or societal one. There's lots of things going on, but the recent decision (which I predicted, of course) by "Eric Holder" (I put that in quotes because anyone who doesn't think this is Barack Obama's goal is a, well, gullible, naive fool) to go after the CIA for potential prosecution of "torture violations" is a major societal turning point that will, unfortunately, have serious consequences for years to come. First and foremost, we have just castrated our most potent defense against future terrorist attacks. You, your family, your friends, your co-workers, your grandchildren, your poker buddies, ANYONE who lives in any Western country, but primarily ANYONE who lives in the USA has just become much less safe. MUCH less safe. This is not merely going back to a "pre-9-11 mentality," this is going back to Carter era anti-CIA paranoia, which is what LED to the gutting of the department and making it a laughing stock of the world intelligence community. Reagan restored a lot of the CIA's power, but then Clinton and his team of anti-military zealots systematically dismantled the infrastructure and personnel of the CIA, which is what led directly to the complete lack of agents in the field who could have identified and perhaps prevented 9-11. To put this bluntly, Obama has just made another 9-11 orders of magnitude more likely to occur. Which is exactly what I predicted he would do. The only possible reaction the day-to-day CIA personnel can have to this witch hunt is to change their name from "CIA" to "CYA". It is not possible that this partisan scapegoat search will stop before the CIA is effectively dismantled. Executives and managers at Langley will become legal experts, lawyers will replace agents in the halls. Any agents who don't immediately flee to the private sector will not be allowed to take any risks whatsoever, to avoid having entire sections of the CIA being pulled into partisan hearings in front of cameras from every news organization on earth. No informant on earth will cooperate with the CIA in order to avoid having their name leaked to the press, or to the jihadists. Make no mistake about this. With this one decision Barack Obama has just made your life materially more dangerous than it was before. He has blindfolded our most effective guard against terrorism. He has gutted the talent of our most effective anti-terrorist forces. It is hard for me to even be critical of a move such as this without words like "treason" or "impeachment" tiptoeing on my tongue. I don't think I can possibly communicate how deeply and profoundly angry I am. If you thought I disliked Obama before, you have no idea how much more profound my disgust for that brainless ideologue has now become. He has put my children and family at personal risk of their lives in order to pursue a pointless vendetta against his predecessor. This is absolutely third-world banana republic stuff. I have rarely been as ashamed of my President in my life.

Comments (14)

Andy
Cosmic, why don't you tell us what you really think? ;) I know what you mean. "Tipping point" with this guy was reached with me the first time I heard him speak...seems like it was decades ago, but it was only about four or five years back. Keep an eye on what Leon does. If he flies the coop on BozObama, it will be a sure sign that Hillary will be next. They are birds of a feather. In fact, it is likely that Hillary has already written her letter of resignation, and will tell Leon when to turn his in. Hillary will challenge BozO in 2012. He will be so weakened by events by then that he may not even seek another term. Sadly, the rest of us will be greatly exposed to attack because of his "treason." It's "boiling" out there Cosmic. "Tipping point" is a good term. But I believe that "boiling point" more accurately describes it. I can read it in what you wrote. And I can identify it in myself...and millions of others. I think you wrote a good while back something like, "hang on...it's gonna be a wild ride." Yep!
Boyd
Let me play Devil's Advocate here, Cosmic. Isn't it reasonable to determine if any CIA employees broke the law, and if they did, to prosecute them for those acts? Even if the result is a weaker CIA, don't we want to ensure that CIA actors aren't above the law, and can be held accountable for their actions if they perform criminal acts? Even if they were ordered to perform such acts by their bosses, we hold military folks accountable for executing illegal orders. Why not the CIA?
CosmicConservative
Boyd: I suppose you may not be aware that Bush and Obama have already ordered investigations of the CIA. In fact the report that was just released was the result of one of those investigations. That report was forwarded to the US Department of Justice with orders (from Bush and obama) to identify any abuses and to prosecute anything prosecutable, to recommend any improvements in controls, and to determine if any non-prosecutable, but still unethical, acts had occurred. The result of that was a series of recommendations, which were implemented, to improve controls, a few resignations from CIA employees who had been identified as potential "bad apples" and the prosecution of one CIA contract employee who had beaten a prisoner to death. In other words, what you are asking for has already been done. Twice. And the prosecutors who decided who to prosecute and who not to prosecute were not political appointees of either Bush or Obama, but were career prosecutors who presumably do not have political axes to grind. However, all of that was done under the radar and outside of the glare of international press spotlights. By design. With Congress's approval. With Obama's approval. In fact, if you go back to February, Obama PROMISED that he would "move on" and not "rehash the policies of the past." He said this multiple times, including in a speech at Langley. The reason it was done quietly was to keep it from becoming a show trial with an "independent prosecutor" who would be pursuing political aspirations of his own, and the partisan political goals of his boss. Of course we know what a "promise" from Obama is worth, so I never for a minute believed he would overlook the opportunity to pander to his base the first time his base looked like they might be abandoning him. That's all this is Boyd. Obama is losing popularity. Polls show that he is losing his base. His health care reform is dying an agonizing and public death. People are starting to call him "incompetent" The New York Times and the Washington Post are starting to actually REPORT on him as if he were a man instead of a God. This is why Obama has had Eric Holder float the whole "well, Obama may not like it, but my core principles may require me to appoint a prosecutor into the CIA." That was pure political theater, like EVERYTHING with Obama is pure political theater. They were keeping this in their back pocket to throw red meat to the ravening Leftist pack of anti-military, anti-war, anti-CIA wolves from DAY ONE. Now they need it. So here it comes. It's that simple. This is pure grandstanding. It has to be obvious to anyone who understands that this has all been investigated before, that THIS prosecutor is going to have to FIND SOMETHING, and that means he will dig, dig, dig, exposing every single thing he can find, just to justify his job, and to justify his boss's appointment of him. This has nothing to do with finding out if interrogation practices were too harsh. This has now become a massive fishing expedition where Obama and Holder are hoping to find ANYTHING they can to maintain the focus of the public on the unpopular George W. Bush while Obama continues to try to dismantle the freedoms that made this country great.
Boyd
That's exactly my point in posing the wide-eyed, innocent questions, Cosmic. The general public does not know that the criminal investigations were already conducted, the results have been acted upon (and in very short order, when you think about it), and that's why the currently proposed probes are nothing but political posturing.
Drax
Boyd: I agree that, in theory, it can be important to determine whether an arm of the State is breaking the State's laws. But, that isn't the case here, is it? On any level? At the core of this "investigation," are lawyers who were tasked by the President (via subordinates) to determine how far interrogators could go in order to extract information from captured terrorists who would not willingly give up that information. In other words, the lawyers were asked: "How far can we go UNDER THE LAW to extract information which MIGHT save American lives?" So, the question posed to the lawyers was to determine WHAT WAS LAWFUL, i.e., SPECIFICALLY asking them what those tasked with gathering information could do to extract information WITHOUT "breaking the law." Nothing wrong with THAT question. In fact, isn't that an assiduous adherence to the law? Now those lawyers didn't mess around with their task. They tried to figure out what "torture" was and what it was not -- and give good legal advice. They, of course, were constrained by the reality that there IS no definition of "torture" which would survive examination IF the actual goal of the techniques being used were expected to have the actual effect of extracting information from those unwilling to give it. You see, if the RESULT of whatever techniques being used was to actually EXTRACT information from someone unwilling to give it freely, then that technique could almost certainly be termed "torture." What hardened terrorist on a mission from GOD would give up information which might lead to the failure of GOD'S mission, the death of his comrades, the imprisonment of his friends UNLESS he was, in fact, "tortured?" So, those lawyers were asked to give a guidance to interrogators on what was NOT "torture" which, if followed and the allowed techniques actually WORKED (and information was extracted), then that guidance could be defined as "torture." So, rock...meet hard place. Nonetheless, they did their level best to give good legal advice, nixing all kinds of things which, in their opinion, were "torture," but allowing other acts which were not. (Specifically "waterboarding" - a technique used on our own soldiers. How can it be "torture" if we do it to our own soldiers? But, of course, the reason we do it to our own soldiers, is to prepare them for the same to be done to them by enemies once captured, i.e., when they were "tortured." Apparently, the defining "torture" by the ACT was not effective, since the MOTIVE for the act apparently defined what was or was not "torture" relative to "waterboarding," at least.) But, they did their level best. The lawyers gave the requested legal advice. Nothing wrong with that, is there? Isn't that what they're paid to do? Certainly, that legal advice might be WRONG, but it is hardly CRIMINAL. Now those interrogators in the field, tasked with extracting information from those who are unwilling to give it, had some legal guidance as to what they could and could not do. If they followed that CONSIDERED legal advice, how are THEY doing anything CRIMINAL? They are tasked with gathering information. The techniques they used were in compliance with guidelines set out by their superiors as determined by some of the brightest legal minds in the country. Where, in this scenario, is there ANYONE who isn't doing their level best TO "follow the law?" This isn't a case of anyone being overzealous -- even in defense of freedom. It is a case of every single person, at every single step, doing EVERYTHING he could do to ADHERE to the law while still attempting to do their jobs, i.e., get information from those unwilling to freely give it. This is a distraction, nothing more. Obama needs to solidify his base; he hasn't delivered on a single thing he promised them. No gay marriage. No energy program. No health care. Nothing. But, he needs to do it without alienating the few remaining independents and conservative democrats who still support him, so he has to be "hands free" on this -- letting Holder be "independent." It's despicable. On every level.
CosmicConservative
Boyd: The problem here is that this is not "nothing but political posturing." Ask Bill Clinton or Ronald Reagan about the results of an Independent Prosecutor's "political posturing." He will have to dig, dig, dig, until he finds SOMETHING, even if he has to trump something up to be bigger than it really is. That will be dragged under the harsh spotlights of the press and the Congress. Congress will demand names, times, places. These are things that are dangerous to release. Congress will not be able to keep that from being leaked. People's careers and lives will be at risk. ANY NAME of ANY AGENT that is in ANY STORY will become a target of jihadists. In order to avoid that sort of exposure, agents are ALREADY BAILING out of the CIA, many are joining private "security firms" which are seeking contracts with the government to do intelligence gathering OUTSIDE of the controls of the CIA. This is just a few of the reasons this is an unmitigated disaster. Obama is either an idiot, or he is deliberately destroying the capacity of the CIA to do their job. I can't tell which it is.
Drax
CC: There is an argument to be made that many of Obama's actions are designed to weaken the country -- militarily, economically, socially. There is an argument to be made that he is doing this so to create an environment whereby a takeover by the executive branch of the government is not only possible but is welcomed by the majority of the populace. I'm not willing to make that argument YET, but I really couldn't construct a compelling argument AGAINST that theory.
CosmicConservative
I can believe that Obama is a naive Saul Alinski acolyte whose liberal ideology has blinded him to the natural consequences of his actions. I consider that to be a pretty harsh judgment of any human being by itself. To speculate that he is attempting to engineer an effective coup is something I'm not nearly far enough gone to suggest at this time. As they say, it is usually not necessary to speculate a malicious motivation when mere incompetence can explain things adequately. I'm still on the incompetence side of things.
Drax
CC: Yet, when one looks at who he has surrounded himself with, at who he has surrounded himself with over the course of his life, his admitted "mentors" whether live or through literature -- and what each of those people advocate and admire (communists, socialists, radicals, members of the Chicago political machine, etc.) -- THEN compare his actions against the theory that his actions are purposeful, it does make sense. For example: No one could imagine that his stimulus program would actually "stimulate" anything. It simply wasn't DESIGNED to. Around 1/7th of it has actually been spent with the remainder to be spent years out (when the economy would likely have repaired itself), and the "stimulative" aspects of what has been spent is only a tiny fraction of what has been spent. So, why the rush to spend us into bankruptcy? For example: Health care. While there's no question that there are problems with health care delivery and health care insurance costs, the actual bill is DESIGNED to eliminate the health care industry and push everyone into a "public option." There is no question that such an option would increase the debt of the U.S. at a time when such an increase (even by his OWN admission) would be adverse to the economic state of this country. Why the rush to not only attempt to "fix" health care, but to do so in such a way that it would destroy the health care insurance industry AND further weaken the economy AND wouldn't actually do what it was supposedly designed to do (cover the uninsured) according to the OMB? For example: Why push for cap & tax when, by his own admission, it would cause energy prices to skyrocket and destroy the coal industry -- at a time when the economy is significantly distressed anyway? For example: Why pressure for the firings of Inspector Generals? More and more every day? For example: Why did he support the attempted coup in Honduras? Why didn't he support the uprising in Iran? For example: Why is he pressuring for Israel to give up land for "peace?" Why is he currently supporting a "diplomatic path" which would isolate Israel? For example: Why does he have a communist for his "Green czar?" Why did one of his advisors laud the "great Vensuallian democracy?" For example: Cash for clunkers. Any 1st year economics major would cite the "Broken Window Fallacy" if this program were mentioned. (A kid throws a brick through a window. This creates jobs. Someone sells the glass; someone installs the glass; someone has to make more glass. Therefore, to stimulate the economy, every kid should throw bricks through every window.) This is a wasteful and destructive program on its face. Why do it? For example: Why the release of CIA documents? Why the CIA investigation? Every CIA director said "DON'T!" He did anyway. Why? Some of these actions (and so many, many more) could be attributed to incompetence. But, by everyone in the administration? Some could be attributed to political payoffs. Some could be attributed to politics to cater to his base. Some could be attributed to him being a "true believer." But, man, when you start looking at the LIST, it's getting harder and harder for me to attribute the results to "incidental" or "unforeseen" consequences.
CosmicConservative
Drax: It is hard for me to assign any responsibility for the actual contents of any of the bills Obama has been pushing since in my opinion he sees himself as "above" such petty concerns as actually WRITING policy. He farms that out to Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid and just signs what they bring back. So for me to put any weight behind this idea that things are "designed" to promote a systematic destruction of the economy until the President has to "save us" would require the complicity of several dozen Congressmen and Senators who actually WROTE the bills you are talking about. I just don't see that. Even if I thought Obama was attempting to implement such a plan, I simply don't think people like Chris Dodd, Barney Frank, Barbara Boxer, Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid, et. al. are CAPABLE of that sort of planning and execution. Nor do I believe all of them, for all their liberal lunacy, would buy into that. And they are the ones who actually WROTE the legislation.
CosmicConservative
... still, it is conceivable that if Obama was pursuing such a plan, the internal details of the bills really would not be that important. In fact he could probably count on Pelosi and Reid to produce a Leftist wet-dream of ineffective pandering to their base. But that would mean he's a whole lot smarter than I give him credit for... You are making me worry...
Drax
Again...not convinced of it myself. I can more likely envision the following: Obama is a true believer. He doesn't CARE about the effect on the economy -- the U.S. will eventually recover no matter how big the blow. He just cares about what he cares about, i.e., a re-distribution of the wealth and a more utopian society. So, he puts his agenda into play. As you say, he doesn't write the bills. He leaves that to others. But, those others are political hacks who do what political hacks do...they pay off their cronies and supporters. And, some of those "others" are pretty sharp. I can see THEM looking at the majority they currently have, recognizing where they got it from and how they can conceivably keep it in perpetuity -- by making the entire country dependent on the government for -- well, just about everything, starting with energy and health care -- automobiles and banking. Control that, you have serious control. So, the Czars. Executive power to expand Democratic power, power in perpetuity. Again, even those "others" are more concerned with their and their party's consolidating and growing power than they are about the state of the economy or our national defense -- after all, the U.S. will recover and we're so far superior to any other country militarily that there's no real danger to us in that regard. I can see this as the "why" for Emanuel & the Chicago pols and for Obama himself. It explains much of what is going on, including the individuals he's surrounded himself with. I don't think that they're attempting to destroy the country, but to TRANSFORM it -- just as he said that he would. And, the only way to KEEP it "transformed" is to fundamentally alter it so that it can't be "transformed" back or to ensure power in perpetuity for one party. What I don't think is that he's "incompetent." He's just "competent" at what he's attempting to do and that has little to do with what WE would consider to be in the country's best interests.
Andy
I am enjoying this discussion. So "How 'bout them Yankees?" I believe that BozO knows exactly what he wants to do. But he has misunderestimated the force of his personal aroma v. the 535 members of Congress that don't have Secret Service protection...and must face the prospect of "town hall meetings," and re-election, and going back to making an honest living if they are booted. BozO has over-reached. Too much, too fast, and too green to sell it. I could be wrong. It would not the first (or the last) time. The old "the bloom is off the rose" thing seems to apply. I'll go back to my belief that it will not be very long before Leon and Hillary (and probably many others) jump off the Amtrak before it collides with a semi.