Obama Birthers...
By CosmicConservativeI've commented a couple of times on the whole "Obama wasn't really born in Hawaii" thing. I commented on and linked to a story last week where a Major in the US Army had refused to deploy using the "Obama isn't an American Citizen" argument.
Well, that apparently generated a lot of commentary last week, including a statement from the White House yesterday which CNN is describing as the White House "shooting down" the theory. And if CNN says it is shot down, you know there's more to the story.
The fashionable thing to do on this story is to compare conservative "birthers" to moonbat "9/11 Truthers" or imbecilic "Moon Landing Hoaxers".
Now, I have two thoughts on this, so I want people to read this carefully.
1. I don't give a fig about Obama's birth. He was born to an American citizen who happened to be less than 18 years old. The whole "birther" argument is completely dependent on the "his mother was not 18 years old when Obama was born" because if she HAD been 18, then it wouldn't matter if Obama had been born in Antarctica. And I consider this technicality to be nothing but an oversight on the law. Why they put 18 as the arbitrary age in which a mother's child automatically becomes a citizen is beyond me, and I think it's a stupid thing to have done. If Obama's mother was a citizen, then Obama is a citizen as far as I'm concerned.
2. To compare those who question Obama's citizenship to fruitcakes who accuse the US of murdering 3,000 of its own citizens, or flat-earthers who believe the moon landings were faked is a disingenuous and unfair comparison. I've looked pretty hard at the "Obama isn't a citizen" arguement, and even though I think the whole thing is frivolous and pointless, I am quite convinced that there is in fact some legitimate question about where Obama was born. So if someone wants to make a technical argument about Obama's birth meeting the fine print of the citizenship law, that's a completely legitimate and defensible argument. It is also somewhat facilitated when we learn, as CNN's Lou Dobbs has reported, that Obama's "Long Form" birth certificate (which would be the only actual ORIGINAL document) was "destroyed" by the Hawaiian hospital in which he was supposedly born.
So even though I think the whole thing is a waste of time and hinges on a totally arbitrary legal technicality that nobody would care about if they SUPPORTED the guy as President, I think comparisons of "birthers" to true nutcases is unfair and unwarranted.
Comments (22)