Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

"Tranquility Base here, the Eagle has landed."

By CosmicConservative
"Roger that, Tranquility. Copy you on the ground. You got a bunch of guys here about to turn blue, we can breathe again." I probably didn't get that quote perfectly, but it's close to that. It wasn't for years afterward that I learned the significance of those words. The whole "you got a bunch of guys down here about to turn blue" thing was not just clever repartee. Fuel monitoring of the Eagle lunar landing craft indicated that when they hit the ground, they had only a few seconds left of fuel, and if they had used it all up, they would have crashed into the lunar surface, most likely killing or at least stranding Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin. Why was that? Two things. First, while in their final descent to their planned landing spot, the computer which was supposed to handle the delicate landing process reported two errors indicating memory overloads. Armstrong asked mission control what to do and was told "that's OK" and to continue the landing. But that delay used up precious fuel. Then, the computer-selected location came into view and it was full of boulders. You can hear some of this on the audio recordings. At this point Neil Armstrong assumed manual control of the lunar lander, something that he was never supposed to do, although he trained for it. Balancing the lunar lander on its landing rocket, Neil then "flew" the lander forward, looking for a place to land. This continued for several seconds as the final fuel in the tank inched towards the "zero" mark. Finally, after a trip of a quarter of a million miles, Neil put the lander down with less than 30 seconds of fuel remaining. That's why mission control was full of blue-faced engineers. The engineer who reported "that's OK" on the computer glitch earned a congressional medal for doing so. At that moment, with a computer error on the computer screen, they were just seconds from scratching the landing and blasting back up to meet Michael Collins in the lunar orbiter and command module. Medical technicians monitoring Neil Armstrong's heart rate, respiration and blood pressure said all were "off the scale" as he landed the Eagle. But you can't hear the slightest unease in his voice. Neil Armstrong, to this day, says that his famous first words were corrupted by the radio connection. He intended to say, and believes he DID say "That's one small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind." Instead, whether due to his own error or due to an audio glitch, what it sounds like is "That's one small step for man, one giant leap for mankind." I tend to give him the benefit of the doubt and blame it on an audio glitch. Happy 40th anniversary of one of mankind's crowning achievements.

Comments (4)

Old Goat
It was certainly an exciting time. I remember looking up at the moon in amazement that man had walked up there. I agree that Armstrong's "version" is a lot better. Funny how "a" can make such a big difference in the meaning of a statement.
Andy
That's interesting Cosmic. I had never heard Armstrong's explanation. But it does make MUCH MORE SENSE. I mean "man" and "mankind" are pretty well the same thing...plural. "A man" would make much more sense. I mean, Armstrong was a sharp guy (obviously), and I am pretty sure he took English in school. Yep! That was an exciting evening. I remember right where I was, and even that I was laying on my tummy about 4 feet from the screen when Neil hit Moondust. Good memories...brilliant engineers...tough aviators...hearty souls one and all.
CosmicConservative
Because of the instrument panel built into the fronts of their spacesuits, Neil and Buzz could not even see their feet. Descending the stairs was done entirely by feel in 1/6 normal gravity wearing about 200 pounds of stuff. Both said it was extremely difficult to get down the ladder.
Old Goat
I had the good fortune to meet both Armstrong and Lovell. Hearing them speak about their experiences was priceless. During Armstrong's speech he talked about the comment made from the moon. When you think of the whole program and what it accomplished it really was an act of bravery.