Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Writer's Crisis!

By CosmicConservative
Yeah, me. Here's the deal. I started working on this book about two and a half years ago. I tried to do the whole thing "right", meaning I bought some books on how to write and did some research and sat down and planned out the whole thing. That means I started out with a central story summary in one sentence, then expanded that into a paragraph, then expanded that yet again so that each sentence in the original paragraph became a paragraph. That gave me a several paragraph guide for the story. Then I created a cast of characters, starting with the protagonist and then working my way through his immediate friends and family and then adding the antagonist. I tried to come up with descriptions, motivations and relationships for each one. I took that guide and those characters and laid out about 25 scenes that I thought would be memorable and listed each scene in a spreadsheet. Then I started to write. And I wrote a lot. I've got over 81,000 words of this thing written now. At first I just wrote, letting the story flow. I didnt' worry overly much about grammar, tense, voice, etc. I thought it would be valuable just to get the story down on paper, fleshed out as much as possible. I figured I would be able to come back and "polish" the rough edges off of that draft manuscript and voila! Instant novel! Well, not quite instant, but doable anyway. I've already recounted how that effort was put aside after my father passed away, and how I've picked it back up again. I've written two of the final five or six chapters in the past week, so I intially thought that I was back on the horse and moving forward. That is, until I actually started doing the copy editing work. Basically I wanted to get some feedback about what I've written already, and I didn't want to send off rough drafts, so I decided to start copy editing the first chapters while I was still writing the final chapters. I've completed a first cut at copy editing for about ten chapters now. And I am not real thrilled with the result. Basically I have three major problems with the book. 1. Many parts of it are just plain boring as I try to get introspective with the main character. My intentions are good, but the result is page after page of boring, expository text. 2. I haven't been able to make some of the fundamental conflicts come to life. It's one thing to have a descriptive blurb in your character definition that says character 1 has a rivalry with character 2. Actually demonstrating that rivalry in a compelling way is something else again. 3. Somehow I managed to lose track of the original central concept of the book. Instead of driving towards that concept the story sort of wanders around, sometimes hot on the trail of the concept and other times moseying over the horizon a bit in search of some other supposedly interesting tidbit. I gotta do something. Somehow I have to tighten up the slow parts, beef up the conflict and keep the narrative on a clear and comprehensible path. The only question is whether to use a scalpel or an axe. Right this moment there are whole chapters I am thinking should just be ripped out entirely. There are some characters that probably also need to simply disappear. But if I tear it up too much, there is a real risk that I will be so discouraged by the result that I may never finish the book at all. Arg... I suppose one school of thought is "just finish it so you have at least a complete story before you start ripping it apart." But on the other hand, I find my enthusiasm for writing new material waning as I contemplate the need to rewrite the original foundational chapters that lead up the the new material. I'm not really looking for advice, just venting is all...

Comments (5)

Drax
The only "advice" I could give is: "If it was easy, everyone could do it." Keep plugging...
Andy
What Drax said!...some of the best advice Daddy ever gave me.
Dadman
The best advice my dad gave me: 'Son, don't eat live flies'. He also said: 'Listen to your teachers and quit drawing those stupid cartoons in class.' I pretty much ignored the advice...except the live fly advice; that seemed prudent. With respect to your writing...I have to go with what Drax said...and Andy.
CosmicConservative
So, I guess that explains your preference for dead flies on your salad. Got it.
Dadman
Well, we are talking about LIVE flies. The dead ones, I found, make excellent croutons...