Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Living in the moment...

By CosmicConservative
So, my last post about Facebook got me thinking. And that's not always a good thing, my thoughts frequently take me places that most other people seem to not want to go. I think that a hundred years from now my generation will be looked upon as the last pre-computer generation. Which doesn't just mean "internet", it means all of the things that are associated with computer technology. Here's what I mean: I learned to type on a manual typewriter. I still have my manual typewriter on which I wrote virtually every significant research paper in high school and college. I used that typewriter to write two books and to create the rulebooks for two games. I never purchased an electric typewriter because I eventually moved directly to computer word processing instead. I used to write letters. I have a box full of old letters I received in my closet. Letters from friends, family, girfriends, etc. I used to write a lot of letters. Most of the letters I wrote were hand-written, not typewritten, as are most of the letters I received. My first "calculator" was a slide rule. I still love slide rules. In fact I love writing by hand, and I love manual typewriters too, even though I rarely do any of those things any longer, and when I do, it's mostly simply for nostalgic reasons. But habits linger. Writing by hand, and using a typewriter force the writer to think about what they are saying. There is no "delete" key on a manual typewriter. You can use whiteout to correct a letter or two, but if you have written an entire paragraph and decide that isn't what you really meant to write, your only realistic option is to put in a new blank sheet of paper and retype everything. The major habit this situation reinforces is the habit of self-editing. It teaches you to organize your thoughts before you type, either by writing them down, or else by working through what you want to say and how you want to say it in your mind. It also teaches you to learn to spell, because retyping a page because of spelling errors is no fun at all. Similarly, it reinforces learning grammar and organization. In general I would either have a hand-written first draft, or at least a hand-written outline that I worked from when I began typing. I used to hear all the time about how important it is to "live in the moment". "Living in the moment" was considered to be more "authentic," more "organic" and more "real." Well, in the internet age it seems that "living in the moment" is all we do anymore. We've raised a couple of generations of people who have never had to self-edit a thought in their lives. They think it, and they say it. Internet chat rooms, email, message boards, blogs... all of those things allow people to have a thought and publish that thought seconds later. The result, in my mind, has been a dramatic coarsening of our culture. Misspelled words are so common now that it is considered rude to ask people to learn to spell before they publish their thoughts. Spelling is not important. Grammar is archaic. An entire culture has grown around the deliberate mangling of the English language with "L33T SP33K". Bad spelling and grammar went well beyond "acceptable" and became "cool". But worse than that is that a similar approach has overcome the CONTENT of our messages. All you have to do is visit a prominent blog and read the comments to see how little thought people give to whether their thoughts SHOULD be published. Living in the moment has come to mean that the moment someone THINKS something, they have no problem PUBLISHING it. Our culture has become a culture of stimulus-response, with very little governance of the responses. Back in the days when I had to physically write a thought on paper, the fundamental question that was always the first to ask was "is this worth writing down or typing out?" That fundamental governance of our interactions has disappeared, so it should be no surprise that "is it spelled right?" is rarely even considered at all. I'm sure I'm just an old fogey, but I feel that the world has lost something when it lost this sort of self-governance. We need to get back to "stimulus-THINK-response." I see this on Facebook a lot. I've even participated in it. Why in the world would I think it is a thought worth publishing that I have decided to take my dog for a walk? Or that I am microwaving a burger?

Comments (6)

Dadman
I probably think Facebook is as silly as you do, but it is not without value. It's social networking (as you know). It's a medium through which real friends and family can stay connected. And I think to derive the most value from tools like Facebook your friends list should be limited to only those people who truly are friends (which I haven't done by the way on my own Facebook account) and might actually be interested in some of the mundane things you do or ponder throughout the day. Of course, there is no rule dictating that only trivial, mundane activities be documented on your FB wall, albeit that is what most people seem to do. I agree with you that there is a decided lack of self-governance in all aspects of our modern lives, however, I think you've confused this fact with the idea of 'living in the moment'. Living in the moment is not synonymous with being impetuous or lacking self-constraint. I think it is more about deriving as much joy and pleasure from the moment in which we presently find ourselves rather than spending our 'now moment' regretting the past or worrying about the future...as so many of us are inclinded to do. In my mind, living in the moment is simply a means to enjoying life a little more...
CosmicConservative
I hear you Dadman. And I agree that I have, at least, conflated the "spiritual" concept of "living in the moment" with the "secular" one. Maybe I should have titled this "The Spontaneous Society" instead. Back to the Facebook thing. Here's my problem with it. When I first got on, I saw that "what are you doing?" status thing and thought "Hmm.. that might be cool." Since it asked me to put what I was doing/thinking about out there, I did. So I said "Contemplating the history of metallurgy" or something like that. And soon I got a "thumbs up" from a friend, along with a contextually appropriate question. But that was it. A few days later I posted "Contemplating the origin of language" or something like that and the responses I got were "lol, I just wanna have a beer" or stuff like that. The impression I got was "wow, this guy is pretentious!" But you know, that IS what I was thinking about. Those are the sorts of questions I ponder on a regular basis. I suppose it might be pretentious, but that's me. But it seemed crystal clear to me that posting such thoughts would just have the same results on Facebook as my relationships in real life have, which is to say that I wouldn't expect to be invited to many Facebook parties. So for a couple of days I said "OK, I'll do the silly stuff" instead. And those just disappeared into the background noise of people watching their favorite TV shows, or walking their dog, or taking their kids to a movie, or whatever. So I stopped. Last night I posted "Thinking about Iran" because that's what I was thinking about. But I have to be honest and say that I am finding it less and less fulfilling to even get onto Facebook. I know this is a horrible personal failing of mine, but I can't honestly say that I enjoy gossip, chatting or small talk. I really don't. I'm not good at it. I suppose in part it is because I really don't care to share personal details of my life with other people. My life isn't one of those "I'm so happy today" kinds of lives. And I'm afraid I'm not very good at pretending such things. And if I posted relevant details of my actual life, I'm sure I would initially get a lot of "hang in there buddy" sorts of responses, but it wouldn't be long before I saw my "friends" list shrinking fast. So I'm not really much inclined to post much on Facebook at the moment. Nobody else is interested in what I'm really interested in, and I'm not much inclined to share my daily life details since my life is not really one that needs to be shared, and finally I don't care to pretend that things are different than they really are by posting happy smiley faces when that's now how my life is. So I suppose I'll continue to mostly just respond to other folks when I feel something is worthy of response, but I doubt I'll be initiating much on Facebook.
Dadman
FB is what it is - frivolous, trivial, silly, and intermittently amusing. Sometimes it can be fun when ancient photos are dusted off, digitized and posted for the everyone to see. A good chuckle is nice on occasion. FB is rarely profound and is certainly NOT the medium through which to have deep, philosophical discussions. FB is superficial, by design it would seem. But even regular, superficial contact with old friends is better than no contact at all. Honestly, I'm bored with FB myself. I'm not inclined to share (or impose?) my mundane activities or random thoughts on either family or friends. Believe it or not, small talk is not a strength of mine either, but I love my friends and family so I'm more than happy to do what is necessary to keep in touch.
CosmicConservative
Yeah, you're right Dadman. As usual. I'll keep checking it out, and I do think it's a good way to keep in touch. But the "keeping in touch" is so superficial that I wonder sometimes whether it's mostly illusory.
Dadman
I think a lot of it is illusory which is why I think the best FB approach to limit your 'friends' to only those people who are actually friends. I've already blown that plan and now face the prospect of de-friending some people that are current job colleagues. I'm concerned how that might be received. I considered inviting you to join the FB 'party' a few months ago, but I knew how you'd respond to it - basically a more intense version of my response to it which is FB is STUPID and full of women who like to yak, yak, yak about the most inane things. ;) For self-amusement you might consider posting controversial comments on occasion and see what kind of response you get. But don't expect anything too deep or profound. Profundity seems to be anathema to what FB is all about...