I'd join in, but I can't figure out how to log in to do so.
CosmicConservative
You have to be a member of Dean's site to post. He rarely opens up new membership opportunities any more.
Drax
Ah. Good stuff you wrote.
I'm of the following mind, as simply put as I am able.
1) At some point, the unborn human child becomes a human being (and a "person" within the meaning of the 14th Amendment);
2) It is impossible to tell when that point is;
3) Killing an unborn child when you don't know if it's a human being results in two possible errors;
4) The first error is killing something which you believe to be human when it is, in fact, human;
5) The second error is allowing the child to be born even though when it could have been killed, it wasn't a human being;
6) Of these two errors, only one is morally acceptable.
Drax
#4 should read: "The first error is killing something which you believe not to be human when it is, in fact, human;"
CosmicConservative
I concur Drax.
However, I break ranks with most anti-abortion people when I say that i am willing to make some compromise if I can save some portion of the human slaughter. I don't see the moral imperative of letting an entire shipload of people drown just because I can't save a few lifeboats worth.
Drax
I agree.
What gets me is the failure of pro-life advocates to frame the argument much the way I have. After all, it isn't a settled matter whether the unborn child is a "human being" (We can argue what defines "humanness" at some other time...)
Framed as such, I have convinced several pro-abortion people to change their minds.
Saying abortion "is" murder does nothing but force those who refuse to accept that as fact to, at the least, say "prove it" and, more likely, to simply say: "Is not."
This gets us off the essential question of "what defines humanness?" a question which (other than DNA, perhaps) simply can't be answered.
It is the inability to answer that essential question which should be the fundamental underpinnings of any debate opposing abortion.
CosmicConservative
Drax, that's the issue I mostly concentrated on in the Dean's World "debate."
However, one MUST accept the possibility that it is not currently POSSIBLE (and may NEVER be possible) to exactly define humanness. The situation today is that the inability to answer that question has NOT stopped abortions, in fact it has done exactly the reverse, it has allowed abortions to occur right up to the moment of birth.
Drax
CC: I understand that. I understand that defining "humanness" may be impossible forever.
But, I don't agree that this inability hasn't stopped abortions, entirely. I'm simply asserting that the failure to frame the debate on this issue allows for arguments which simply aren't pertinent to the debate to be central to the debate.
We've heard them all:
From the pro-abortion side, you get (among others)
1) It's a woman's body, so she should have the right to "choose."
2) Without safe abortions, we'll go back to back-alley abortions threatening the health and safety of women;
3) What about rape, incest, or the life of the mother?
From the pro-life side, you get (among others):
1) Pictures of unborn children, challenging viewers to say they're "not humans;"
2) Calling abortionists "murderers;"
3) Trotting out children or grown people who have survived abortions and saying "See? Had you killed this person in the womb, this person wouldn't have been alive!"
No. We don't have the debate properly focused.
EVERY debate on abortion should BEGIN with the demand that a pro-abortionist PROVE that the unborn child ISN'T human and END with the admonition that, since the pro-abortionist CAN'T disprove the "humanness" of the unborn child, killing what might be a human is a moral evil, while not killing something which might not be a human being is not.
CosmicConservative
Drax:
Well, the debates DON'T begin that way.
It's a sticky wicket to be sure.
I think the only possible way to resolve anything is to have both sides agree on a quantifiable method to demonstrate the "humanity" of the unborn. And right now neither side wants to do that. They want to point fingers and call each other nasty names because it makes them feel superior to do so.
And in the meantime, millions of human beings are quite literally torn limb from limb in their own mother's wombs.
Drax
I agree that the debates don't begin that way.
They do when I'm involved in them.
They should when any abortion foe is involved in them. They should demand the answer to the first question and dismiss out of hand as being disingenuous or intellectually dishonest (or deficient) who doesn't attempt to answer that question.
Abortion opponents should hammer in the inability to answer that question and the moral implications of that inability.
Over and over and over and over.
Don't let them off the hook.
The only abortion advocate I've seen who directly addresses the question is Paglia (?) who ADMITS that abortion is "murder" but is pro-choice anyway.
This admission makes me admire her for her honesty and detest her for her moral stance.
CosmicConservative
I read Paglia a lot. I've seen her position on abortion before. I RESPECT her, but I don't ADMIRE her. She's a bright person and she confronts her own biases and limitations honestly, which we all should do.
As you should have seen on the Dean's World debate, abortion discussions start with the definition of "human being" with me too.
But as you should also have seen from that, only ONE pro-abortion person had the guts to address it, and I doubt if she'll keep responding since I challenged her on the whole "parasitic tissue" thing.
People don't want to discuss this. The "pro-life" agenda is almost completely owned by the religious right who cast it as a theological issue. the "pro-abortion" agenda is to avoid any discussion since they have nothing to gain and everything to lose.
So people like me who oppose abortion on a rational basis don't find much in the way of a podium to discuss things.
Drax
It's true that pro-abortion advocates don't WANT to confront the question of "when does human life begin" question.
It is also true that, on blogs and when they are allowed to evade the issue, they do. They can't confront the issue without confronting the moral deficiency in their position, so they don't -- if they can escape it.
And, that's my point. They're allowed to escape it in venues where they can be forced to either confront it or be made the fool of for their intellectual dishonesty (or deficiency) -- Hannity, Beck, or just about any show where the host controls the discussion -- and the commentary after the discussion.
I do it in one-on-one debates as well. Either the person refuses to address the question and I let them know what I think of that failure, or they do and I have the potential to change their minds.
I'm cool with either one. The argument is planted either way.
And, frankly, unlike the discussion on Dean's, "all sides of the issue" HAVEN'T been discussed. There IS no true discussion of the central issue as evidenced by what happened to your "debate" over there.
(On Paglia...dunno if I misspoke when I said "admire," I just know that I respect people who honestly address the issues without flinching. I just find her position detestable. I mean, come on... she thinks abortion IS murder and not only supports it but is an advocate for it. I really don't know how much more detestable a human being could be.)
Comments (12)