Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Sotomayor a disaster in the making?

By CosmicConservative
Besides her now famous racist rant about how a latino woman would automatically be a better justice than a white male, Obama's nominee for the Supreme Court has been overturned by the existing Supreme Court in roughly 60% of her rulings which have made it to the Supreme Court. But then there's this:
Sotomayor Ruled in "D-Bag Case" | NBC Connecticut President Barack Obama’s nominee to fill a Supreme Court vacancy has yet another tie to Connecticut. She sided against a student in the infamous “douche bag” case, and that has upset some free-speech advocates.
My concern is that this is another Ginsberg in the making folks. During the election (and in previous elections) I maintained that one of the main reasons for voting against Obama (as opposed to voting FOR McCain) was that Obama's SCOTUS nominees would be radical empathy-based "feel good" justices as opposed to actual legal experts who understood and followed the actual Constitutional processes the court is supposed to follow. But the ruling cited above gives me pause. I disagree with the ruling, but it seems that an empathy-based justice who ignored legal precedent would not have ruled the way Sotomayor did in this case. In fact this ruling seems to be one that follows the letter of the law TOO closely in one regard, while ignoring the larger constitutional free speech issues. So I'm not sure what to make of this.

Comments (1)

Drax
Anyone who actually paid attention to what Obama SAID about his vision of what the Supreme Court should do (even well before his Presidential run) could predict that he would nominate liberals who viewed the Constitution as a document writ in water. The thing about this choice that really gets to me is the underlying assumption from just about everyone -- all sides of the political spectrum -- that "diversity on the Bench" is, in itself, a "good idea." The fundamental underpinning of justice in America is that it is blind. Nothing less. Blind to race, nationality, economic status, gender, and any other factor. Justice is BLIND. The fundamental underpinning of diversity being a "good idea" is that Justice ISN'T blind, that, in order to receive justice, those before the court must have someone on the court who "looks like them." This conclusion has, as its corelative, the belief that anyone who is before a court who DOESN'T "look like them" will NOT receive "justice," else the conclusion itself is FALSE and diversity is unnecessary in order to receive Justice. When we have Senators, Presidents, and just about every elected official advocating for "diversity," we have those who are charged with getting us Judges/Justices advocating the principle outlined above, i.e., that the Justice System itself is racist AND sexist (or pick your personal "...ist" or whatever other factor which requires "diversity.") Our Senators and Presidents TELL AMERICA in their advocacy of "diversity" that a Latina Female CAN'T receive "Justice" from a White Male. Else, again, there's no need for "diversity" at least from the substantive perspective of dispensing "Justice." The identity politics which drive Presidents and Senators (and voters when they can choose Judges) to advocate for "diversity" has the insidious effect of undermining the most fundamental principle of the American Justice System, that Justice is blind.