Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Systemic failures...

By CosmicConservative
There is a reason that hard-left liberals are giddy about the "demise" of "capitalism". Here is a short list of our current economic catastrophes:
  1. Global Banking bailouts required to keep the world economy solvent.
  2. Government buyouts/bailouts of major industries such as auto manufacturing.
  3. Social Security effectively insolvent
  4. Medicaire effectively insolvent
  5. Massive economic bailouts pumping artificial money into our economy as "stimulus".
  6. Unprecedented government debt which presents future generations with crushing financial burdens.
  7. Insolvency looming in virtually every government run pension fund.
  8. Entire states on the verge of bankruptcy
  9. Loss of trillions of dollars of real value in the stock market crash.
I could go on. We can argue until we are blue in the face whether these failures are due individually or en masse to pure capitalism, pure socialism, or some pansy-ass combination of the two. It doesn't really matter. Our system is broke. And I mean that in both senses of the word "broke". Whatever the cause, whether it is because we have too much socialism in a capitalist system, or too much capitalism in a socialist system, or just because we can't make up our mind if we are capitalist or socialist only matters in an intellectual sort of way. In the purest, most distilled sense of things, the bottom line is that our system is broken and needs to be fixed. And the fixes will need to be profound. It is unlikely to me that any fix which actually DOES fix things will be an ideologically pure solution. It is easy to construct thought-experiments which "prove" that pure capitalism and pure socialism are both pure failures as economic engines. And attempting to combine the two also seems to be a failure because our leadership is too gutless to hold the line on spending and too brainless to understand the fundamental rule of unintended consequences. We need a better economic model. Most likely we need a drastically different economic model. Any ideas out there?

Comments (13)

mtnlurker
If I cannot keep a major portion of what I earn for a living then why should I work? I understand there is a need for government and some social funding. I like my police, army, roads, etc. This argument leads towards a more capitalistic system. This link has many different systems. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_system The models seem to be group according to hands-on and hands-off models. I prefer a more hands-off category. I don't trust the government very far so I don't want them in my economic model. There are a lot more systems than I imagined. Why are capitalism and socialism the dominant ones? I doubt it is by chance.
Drax
So long as an ignorant and/or selfish voter can, by pressing a lever, garner a bigger share of the "pie," exchanging his vote for the promised slice without regard and/or knowledge of the consequences of his act, this will continue until such time that it can't.
CosmicConservative
Drax... I'm pretty sure we've just about reached that time.
Drax
Oh, we have a ways yet. Quite some, to be sure. What interests me more (from an intellectual and survival perspective...) is what "can't" means. HOPEFULLY, it will mean that informed voters will so outnumber the ignorant/selfish that the course will be reversed. Approximately forty percent of the voting age population didn't vote last election. I suppose it's possible that, when they have to bring a wheelbarrow to the grocery store just to carry their cash, they might start to vote...
CosmicConservative
Well, when they do carry that wheelbarrow to the grocery store, they newsrags in the racks will tell them it is all the fault of evil capitalists and their only salvation is more socialism.
Drax
That will depend on whether the newspapers are an OFFICIAL arm of the state at that time (as in "owned by the state via bailouts") or they are non-existent, the two most probable results of the newspapers' status as a TACIT arm of the state.
Drax
(I guess I should have said "arm of the progressives/liberals/leftists who currently are in control of the state" rather than "state.")
Cullen
I'm certainly not ready to give up on capitalism. However, my faith in our system was shaken due to our current situation. I have always felt that the greed-based system would self-perpetuate capital to support everything else. And it did work for some time. I, like Alan Greenspan, was kind of dismayed when creditors began going after more short-term gains and ignored long-term issues. I cannot see any way of avoiding something like this again without regulation. I cannot, I do not believe that the government needs to "own" these creditors or banks, but the FCC certainly needs more power over what kind of credit is given or the rules that govern lines of credit. The bigger problem, though, isn't one of government but one of society. We've become so addicted to instant gratification; buying now, paying later; and being given whatever we want, when we want that our financial failure was only a matter of time. If we want to fix capitalism, we also need to re-socially engineer people's perspectives about fiscal responsibility.
CosmicConservative
Cullen: I agree with your analysis. We have developed a culture of instant gratification and self-absorbtion. Personally I blame Dr. Spock.
Drax
I disagree. Years ago, most of the "toxic assets" which are the impetus for the financial meltdown wouldn't have existed. Banks wouldn't have loaned the money...no matter the terms. This is for two very simple reasons. 1) They didn't believe that those to whom the money would be lended could or would pay it back. Banks are in the money business...not the real estate business. 2) There was no way to unload any of these "assets" as no one would buy this kind of bad paper no matter the terms...for the same reason that the banks wouldn't have lended it in the first place. So, the need for "instant gratification" which the potential CONSUMER may feel is unimportant as it, at that time, couldn't be satisfied. That changed through REGULATION. Congress FORCED banks to loan money to those who, without said regulation, they wouldn't have loaned it. THIS allowed consumers to attempt to satisfy their need for "instant gratification." The DANGER such lenders found themselves in, danger of COLLAPSE due to inability to recoup their BAD investments (forced by Congress), caused financial institutions to be CREATIVE and find a way to shuffle the bad paper off the books into the hands of someone ELSE. Fortunately (at the time), Congress helped. Fannie Mae and Freddy Mac began to buy these "toxic assets" up...FUELED by "bonuses" to the management BASED largely upon the number of these assets they obtained. Fannie and Freddie, of course, moved these "toxic assets" further into the financial markets. Buyers of them did so for the simple reason that they were assured that they were backed by the government. (As indeed it appears that they were.) Over the decades, this paradigm fed itself. People who couldn't afford to buy homes were sought out by companies who gave them terms that they couldn't pass up. Those companies made the paper and passed it on...moving on to the next customer. The customer knew that the property would go up in value and "flipping" properties became common. More paper was created. More companies got involved in lending. And Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were at the center of this. And these companies were in bed with those who were supposed to oversee them (Congress.) Well, in bed figuratively anyway...except in the case of Barney Frank who was LITERALLY in bed with them. So, it wasn't underregulation which caused this problem, it was OVER regulation...it was POLITICAL regulation, selling promises (housing for everyone...a chicken in every pot) to their voters in exchange for their votes which ALLOWED voters to satisfy their desire for "instant gratification." It has nothing to do with the DESIRE itself. We have ALWAYS had that desire. Until the past 50 years or so, however, that DESIRE was kept in check by ABILITY TO SATISFY that desire. (If you have any doubt about the desire of "instant gratification" in a financial sense...do some research on the tulip bulb. Informative at the least...)
Drax
"lended" Sigh. Substitute "loaned" or "lent" as you see fit...
Cullen
I agree Drax, and my assessment was an oversimplified one, but I don't take back what I said. As for instant gratification, I both agree and disagree with your assessment. Sure, the desire to own and consume has been there. And sure, it has always been mitigated by manufacturing/service provider ability. But it is indeed that ability that has perverted desire. I'm not saying that we should take things away from people, but I am saying that when it's so easy for someone to get something now and pay for it later, it skews their perspective about responsible consumption. Further, I'm not saying that you, CC, or myself are raising our kids without some common fiscal sense, but I am saying that a lot of families are doing that very thing. This is as much (if not more) a social problem as it is an economic/governmental one. On Government regulation: Yes, I understand the issues with the housing market. I also understand that companies are going to make the best of a bad situation. Yet I remain unconvinced that deregulation of lending, especially for housing, means that this won't happen again. And I say that because lending institutions only make money on homes when homes are being sold. Homes can only be sold when lenders can lend. It seems that, in the short term, the banks are going to lend only to people who can afford it, but there will come a point when the market hits a plateau. Banks will be forced to offer incentives to get new home buyers (who would otherwise be unable to afford loan rates) into loans. Of course, this is a much slower process than the one forced through regulation, but it will happen. I don't see what the problem would be if all lending institutions had to follow guidelines similar to those set forth in VA loans. You know, I don't like the government all up in my shit either, but that doesn't mean that all regulation is bad.
Drax
Cullen: There are so many "regulations" on lending that it would be impossible to read them all in a week's sitting if you did nothing other than sleep and read. If you add the regulations which affect banks, you may as well prop up your feet for a month or more. If you're going to look into all regulations which affect lending, banks, and all other financial institutions, be prepared to give up a year of your life. If you add to that all laws, regulations, and policies which affect any institution which trades in common stock...well, just forget a having any meaningful life. The IRS Code, the case law which interprets it, the regulations of the Internal Revenue Service, and policy statements (both individual and general) are but puppies to the junk-yard dawgs of financial regulation. And, in the end, it doesn't MATTER how regulated the financial system is. As a rule, we only regulate what we KNOW...known excess, known abuse. Sometimes, a very perceptive legislator (there are a few) might be able to identify a problem before it becomes a disaster and introduce legislation to prevent it. Assuming that he is able to overcome the inertia of the lap dogs of special interests we call "Congressmen," and actually effect change, he will only be affecting -- again -- something "known." It is the "unknown," the unforeseeable effects of a market which kills us. Sometimes it's the known effect but the unknowable timing which kills us. (The "greatest fool" paradigm which, in my opinion, caused the latest housing bust.) But, it's almost always something which simply can't be foreseen or prevented. So, I'm for as little regulation as possible so to allow the market to have its cycles and to CORRECT itself as quickly as possible. Once we've identified the problem (as here) it's too late to do anything about it. All we can do is regulate it so it doesn't happen again. (And, if someone can tell me how to regulate the desires of people to make a quick buck, I'd thank them....) Instead, we are trying to treat the effects, and, of course, those who are attempting to treat the effects have no more clue how to do that than they did to prevent the cause. Here, we're pumping trillions of dollars into an economy in an attempt to "prime the pump." The problem is that there are already hundreds of billions of dollars out there sitting in bank vaults (literally and as digits in a computer somewhere) which they aren't lending. The BANKS aren't any more convinced that we've hit bottom yet than the CONSUMERS are. Currently, they have the billions. They ain't going under -- Obama won't let them. What cause to prematurely loan money into an uncertain economy when they can hold onto it until the economy recovers and loan it THEN? And, Obama knows, every economist knows, pumping these trillions into the already cash-flooded markets can have but one result -- INFLATION. That's why China doesn't want to buy our debt. THEY know that they'll get repaid with devalued dollars. Everyone knows this. If there is one area where just about every economist agrees...it's that we're going to get hit with inflation. At some point. But, we're doing it anyway. And, because we know inflation is going to hit us....the same brain trust who got us here in the first place because they don't understand the beast called a "marketplace" any better than ANYONE ELSE, are trying to twiddle with laws, regulations, "investments," outlays...whatever...in an effort to diminish or forestall the certain inflation. Good luck with that. All that we can be UTTERLY CERTAIN of is the law of unintended consequences. And, when we're talking about tinkering with the basics of the American economy in the scale that Obama is...those unintended consequences could be mighty indeed.