Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Who is John Galt?

By CosmicConservative
So... I haven't talked much about the growing "go John Galt" movement that is making the rounds on the "intellectual" conservative blogs. More and more I am reading posts and comments from serious minded, well spoken (or written) conservatives who state that they are absolutely going John Galt. Many have outlined their current and past activities to do so. I have to say I've been doing a bit of John Galting myself. Not in any big way, but in small ways. Probably the biggest John Galt thing I COULD have done is forego the Cosmic Clan's vacation plans this year, but I guess I'm just not that committed since I just made reservations for the trip last night. I'm not sure everyone knows what "going John Galt" means. "Atlas Shrugged," from which the term is derived, is a difficult read for many people, and the concepts in the book are not simple ones, although the overriding concept is very simple. Ayn Rand originally intended to use the title "The Strike" instead of "Atlas Shrugged." That would have made things more explicit for sure, but I'm glad she went with the title she picked. It's a great title. Anytime you get a Greek Titan in your title, that's a good thing. One of these days I'm going to write a book called "Prometheus' Gamble" or something like that. ;) The fundamental concept of Atlas Shrugged is that society truly has "givers" and "takers." The "Givers" are those who produce wealth. The "Takers" are those who absorb wealth. In "Atlas Shrugged" business leaders, innovators and industrialists are the Givers. Politicians, Labor and Entitlement recipients are the "Takers." In the book a "tipping point" is reached where the Takers have voted themselves so much of the productive output of the Givers that the Givers, led by the mysterious figure "John Galt" begin to systematically stop providing their leadership, effectively going on strike. The result is a rapid disintegration of society's infrastructure and economy as the "Takers" find there isn't enough of anything to go around anymore. As the Takers legislate more and more draconian means to appropriate the productive results of the Givers, more and more Givers join John Galt, leaving less and less for the Takers to take. The end result is a total collapse of the world economy and a return to near stone-age culture everywhere except the enclave (in Colorado, no less) John Galt has set up for the Givers to plant the seed for the new renaissance where Givers are no longer made slaves of the Takers. Going John Galt can be dramatic or subtle. The dramatic approach is obvious. Cash in all your stock, close all your business dealings, live off the interest on your assets and simply watch from the sidelines as society crumbles around you. Of course to do this you would need to have resources such that you could live off the interest on your current assets. Most of us can't do that, so the subtle approaches are more likely. Examples of subtle "John Galting" would be:
  • Pull all your money out of any nationalized bank.
  • Refuse to purchase any product that is created by a nationalized business. For example, buy no GM cars.
  • Forego any purchases beyond what is needed to maintain your lifestyle. That 60" HDTV? Do you really NEED it? If not, live with your 47" TV for now.
  • Apply for any government hand out that you can conceivably qualify for. Grants, food stamps, whatever. Put as much strain on the spending side of things as you legally can.
  • Aggressively pursue every possible tax loophole. Defer as much of your income as you can possibly manage. Put as much strain on the tax collection as you legally can.
  • Take advantage of any "incentive" program which forces the government to spend money. Need new windows? Make sure you get government subsidized windows. Spend a premium on your electricity bill to use "green" energy to force the government to spend more money subsidizing wind or solar energy. Use ethanol as much as possible. If you buy a car, buy one that gives you tax breaks or has a government subsidy or both. Preferably buy these from non-state owned car companies.
  • When nationalized health care is instituted, push it to its limit. Visit the doctor for any conceivable allowable reason. Got a sniffle? Get a flu regimen. Got a splinter? Get some anti-biotics.
Of course the result of going John Galt is the complete and utter destruction of the economy and infrastructure. So maybe you don't really want to do that. The hope of most who are going John Galt is not that they will precipitate an economic acopalypse, they hope that doing so will demonstrate the failure of the socialist state, and return the nation to a capitalist foundation. In some ways it is a dangerous game. If enough people pursue this stuff, it could very well push things to a tipping point where things could spiral out of control. However things turn out, I predict that this "John Galt" thing is going to gain a LOT of traction this year. This is just the beginning.

Comments (30)

Drax
I read "Atlas Shrugged" many years ago. I mostly thought it a badly written science fiction novel. The "givers" in any society are "givers" simply because they are built that way. They are driven to be good at what they do, no matter what they do. The results of their efforts are frequently accidental. These kind of people don't simply STOP being themselves. They can't HELP THEMSELVES. They live to compete...to achieve...and, it doesn't matter whether they're working their way up the ladder at the local McDonald's or at GM...circumstance, choices made, genetics, geography, whatever.... places them in the arena they find themselves in, but WHATEVER arena they find themselves in...they will strive for excellence. It's how they're built. Accordingly, there can no more be an "enclave" of these types of people than there can be a society WITHOUT them, a society of people satisfied with mediocrity. So, I pretty much dismissed that book as being nothing more than badly written SF. But, we will see a MIGRATION of those "givers" to environments which aren't so punitive to them. This is already occurring and has been occurring for some time. The ever-increasing ability to do just about anything from just about anywhere will simply accellerate this migration. It is no accident that states such as Texas aren't hit as badly by this economic crisis as are states such as Michigan -- as states such as Texas more reward "givers" and states such as Michigan more reward "takers." The more important question is which COUNTRIES will attract the "givers," as it is certain that they will come out of this crisis with a greater core of "givers" than they had going in. I'd REALLY like that to be reflective of U.S. thinking. But, then, Franken wins. Sigh.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I'm not really inclined to debate the critical merits of the book "Atlas Shrugged" with you. I read it as a philosophical treatise, and as such I think it is very well written. Yeah it's "bad" fiction, but it is GREAT philosophy. Read "Critique of Pure Reason" to get an idea what I mean. To make one point, the central theme of the book is EXACTLY what you describe here. Howard Roarke Harry Reardon, the protagonist, is a GIVER who is DRIVEN to produce, and the story is essentially the story of his efforts to CONTINUE to give in spite of all opposition to his efforts, and the steadily ramped up apropriation of his money, his industry and his good will by a government driven by the Takers. The climax of the book is when Howard Roarke Harry Reardon himself decides that he has no choice left but to join John Galt. So I consider your fundamental criticism above to be odd since it is essentially accusing the book of ignoring what is the actual central plot of the book. Sometimes I think we are in a race between the growing entitlement state and the upcoming singularity where technology finally reaches a threshold that it actually transforms human society at the most fundamental levels. I'm afraid as I get older that I consider a lot of this partisan debate to be completely irrelevent to the future of human society. What we will see in a hundred years will be SO FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT from what we have today that concepts like "liberal" and "conservative" will simply be interesting historical anecdotes as we grapple with concepts like immortality and transcendent artificial intelligences. I suffer a lot of cognitivie dissonance on this political stuff these days. In many ways it feels like the crew of the titanic rearranging the deck chairs. That iceberg is right up ahead folks.
Drax
As I said, it's been many years since I've read the book. I just don't see a "giver" opting out. He may change HOW or WHERE he does what he's driven to do...but he just ain't gonna STOP. Of course, the argument could be made that, by "opting out," a "giver" could be attempting to DO something, i.e., force a change in society, but I can't believe that such a person could completely STOP "giving." He'd just do it in a different way. Maybe go into politics himself. Maybe become a painter. Write a book. Whatever....he just ain't gonna stop DOING.
Old Goat
Drax, that is the whole point of the book's characters. Those who "go on strike", don't really stop producing, they produce elsewhere. It is recognized that they will be producers of things, they set up the economy of their haven from the "takers" to be of a barter system. The stoppage is where they stop giving their efforts to a failing economic system. The book was written in extremes to drive home the points it was working to make. The Fountainhead was a much more subtle attempt at framing out the ideas of how Ayn Rand thought society was heading and where it should be. In all the givers worked when they were in the country at large, but they stopped being producers of wealth. We already see that with a lot of businesses that have stopped expansion since Obama was elected because they knew it would lead to greater taxes. I've read the book a number of times, my understanding of the overall messages it was trying to convey changed quite a bit as I got older, and hopefully, wiser to the intrusiveness of the government in our lives. Putting some of the book into the historical landscape of what was happening in the world when it was written also helps increase the understanding of the philosophy behind it. Maybe you should give it another reading. I think you might see it isn't that far from what you are stating.
Drax
Old Goat: Based on what you and CC have said, I think that I clearly need to re-read the book before I comment on its message, rather than rely on today's interpretation of what "going Galt" means.
Old Goat
In the book, one of the things that was an undercurrent was that the "givers", when out in the normal workplace, were the extraordinary workers. Doing the mundane, but excelling at it. The point in that was that they still did the job well, but wouldn't allow themselves to move to higher positions. They left and started anew elsewhere, in a place where they could keep what they earned. The last time I read it, I noticed a number of parallels to the direction we are seeing going.
CosmicConservative
Sigh... I conflated "Atlas Shrugged" and "The Fountainhead". Howard Roarke is the architect who is the protagonist in "The Fountainhead." The protagonist in "Atlas Shrugged" is Harry Reardon. My mistake. I hate that.
CosmicConservative
As far as comparisons between "Atlas Shrugged" and "The Fountainhead" are concerned, it should be noted that neither book was written to be a literary masterpiece. Rand was after bigger fish than literary recognition. "Atlas Shrugged" was intended to warn the world about the looming threat of worldwide socialism after having seen that system destroy her family in Russia. "The Fountainhead" is a more subtle book, and is a much more pleasant read, but it still operates in absolutes, which leads to a lot of criticism of the characters, particularly the character of Howard Roarke himself. Most critics scoff at the Roarke character as a one-dimensional caricature. But that's the point. Rand was presenting Howard Roarke not as a "normal human being" but as an ARCHETYPE of the IDEAL MAN. Roarke was not intended to be a believable literary character. Roarke was intended to be a personification of the ideals of "Objectivism" the philosophy Rand espoused. Criticizing either book based on literary merit is fine and dandy, but even if you do that, you should also understand that the books were not written to please critics, nor to appeal to literary palates. They were written first to warn about the evils of socialism and second to provide an example of how a "perfect man" should act. In my mind Rand achieved her goal. Read from the perspective she intended them to be read, "Atlas Shrugged" is absolutely chilling in its parallels to what is happening in this country today, and "The Fountainhead" can be inspiring for those who feel the philosophy resonates with them. FWIW, Objectivism does not fully resonate with me. It's more hard-core than I am willing to live.
Old Goat
CC, I know that Rand 100% believed in what she wrote, but her writing has engaged and helped to shape and define viewpoints of some of us on the "right". I have a number of problems with the absolutes that she had set down as her views, but I still think there is tremendous value to her work that resonates today. Some of it is a little dated, and obviously pushed to extremes, but I think that was to move the works along and to drive home the points she was making. They aren't terrible to read, but some parts tend to bog down and drag and get redundant.
Dadman
I ran into John Galt this evening in Safeway buying Diet Pepsi and Twinkies with food stamps...
bob
Better not buy any cars from any COUNTRIES that do bad things like nationalize the companies or health care plans. That means no Japanese goods, no Chinese goods... You guys wouldn't give up your luxuries if they were pried out of your hands. You're not "going Galt". Objectivism is all about "the self". And NONE of you are going to go without your comforts, as you tell everyone else to do so in the name of some belief you won't even follow yourself.
eman
It appears as if your advice is for "givers" to become "takers" rather than go on strike.
CosmicConservative
Bob: The issue at hand is not how do we change the Chinese or Japanese governments, it is how do we restore the principles of capitalism to THIS country. Besides I would say there are profound differences in the level of capitalism between Japan and China. If you were a regular reader of this blog you'd know that I traded in my 4x4 SUV for a sub-compact fuel efficient car. We also purchased a water filter to stop buying bottled water. We've cut back our entertainment and eating out budgets significantly. We've foregone purchasing a replacement car for our aging Subaru. We've scrimped and saved to pay off all of our cars and credit cards... I think that's a pretty good start. What have you done? It's interesting how you immediately make stereotypical assumptions about what we are willing to give up simply because this is a conservative blog. I'd be more than willing to compare my sacrifices in the past year to yours. Look again at the list above. Besides, if you even read my post you'd have understood that I specifically said that I DON'T follow objectivism. eman: That's a fair point. In Atlas Shrugged the "givers" really didn't become "takers" they just took entry level or menial jobs to deprive socieity of their wealth-creating potential. However, if the goal of "the strike" is to force the issue of societal economic and infrastructure collapse, it's a simple logical step to go from standing on the sidelines to actively exacerbating that collapse. It facilitates the ultimate goal, and Objectivists, if nothing else, are all about efficiency and goal fulfillment. So I think it's consistent with the overall message of "Atlas Shrugged" whether Rand took it that far or not.
Kevin in WI
Cosmic, One action I would add for going John Galt is: If you plan on buying a "big three" car, buy a Ford. They are going to recover through selling their assets and taking on private debt, and will be run by producers. Government Motors and Chrysler will be owned by the federal govt and the UAW - after they shaft the private owners of their bonds out of over $35 billion dollars. In the Obama administration managed bankruptcy of GM, the federal government is getting 87 cents on each dollar invested, the UAW 76 cents, and bondholders less than 10%. They are literally stealing the company from it's main creditors. If you believe in private enterprise or the rule of law and precedent (particularly in regards to bankruptcy), don't buy a Chrysler or GM car as long as they are owned by those two thieving institutions. Better hope some fund in your 401k or your pension plan doesn't own any GM or Chrysler bonds.
Kevin in WI
The other reason you should buy a Ford: They're going to need the help. Now that the government and the union will own their two biggest competitors, how long do you think it will be before Ford runs into labor or regulatory troubles?
TheBaffler
Do you still believe that a philosophy that divides society into two categories - people who always give and people who always take - is "great?"
CosmicConservative
Baffler, you continue to demonstrate significant difficulty getting beyond your biases and preconceived notions to actualy comprehend what people you believe you disagree with are saying. I said the book is a "great philosophy book" not that I thought Objectivism is a "great philosophy." In fact I specifically said that Objectivism is "too hard core for me." If you want to have a conversation with me, first at least demonstrate that you are capable of comprehending what I am saying. You have yet to accomplish that.
TheBaffler
Which philosophy was the book about if not Objectivism?
CosmicConservative
I'm beginning to think your lack of comprehension is pathological Baffler. Let's say I thought a book was a "great crochet book". Would that mean to you that I thought crochet was great? As a book that was written to explore and demonstrate a philosophical concept, "Atlas Shrugged" does a great job. Ergo, it's a great philosophy book. That is not the same as saying it is a book about a great philosophy. Understand yet?
TheBaffler
Probably better than you did the difference between Atlas Shrugged and The Fountainhead. "I have to say I’ve been doing a bit of John Galting myself. Not in any big way, but in small ways. Probably the biggest John Galt thing I COULD have done is forego the Cosmic Clan’s vacation plans this year, but I guess I’m just not that committed..." "FWIW, Objectivism does not fully resonate with me. It’s more hard-core than I am willing to live." "Rand was after bigger fish than literary recognition. “Atlas Shrugged” was intended to warn the world about the looming threat of worldwide socialism...“Atlas Shrugged” is absolutely chilling in its parallels to what is happening in this country today..." You sympathize with Objectivism but aren't packing the gear to drop out of society. Oddly, you think that not taking a vacation has some relevance.
CosmicConservative
I give up. Obviously not only is rationality lost on you, so are attempts at subtle humor.
TheBaffler
It seems a bit mendacious and disingenous to claim that statements that you find difficult to defend were misunderstood jokes.
CosmicConservative
I suppose it would to someone who was looking to believe that Baffler. Look, seriously, if you want to have an actual conversation, I'm more than willing. But I hate these disingenuous games people play to try to "win" the internet. If that's your game, fine, you win. I don't care.
TheBaffler
If the internets could be won, I wouldn't want it. In the interest of having an actual conversation, I'll rephrase and expand upon my first question in the hope that you'll answer it. Do you believe that a philosophy that divides people into two categories - those who always "give" and are idealizations, and those who always "take" and deserve death (e.g. the train wreck in Atlas Shrugged) is a great philosophy? Or do you find it more realistic that at various points in our lives all of us are (to put it in simplistic terms) switching between the roles of "givers" and "takers?"
CosmicConservative
Baffler, I am forced to conclude that you are deliberately refusing to accept my repeated statement that I have not ever once stated that Objectivism is a "great philosophy." I am nonplussed and somewhat irritated by your continued insistence that I have done so when I have demonstrated that I have not. If it helps you I will repeat it in more direct terms. I do not consider Objectivism a "great philosophy." In fact I consider it to be harsh enough to qualify in some eyes as "cruel." But having said that, as philosophies go, I consider it far more appealing than philosophies which have led to the outright slaughter of millions of human beings like Marxism. So you have to factor in the alternatives. Just to give you an idea, my favorite philosophers tend to be the pragmatic, intellectual and empirical ones, such as John Stuart Mill or Henri Poincare. Having said that, it is possible to demonstrate mathematically that on balance you actually CAN divide people into two, or at most three categories economically, on balance over the course of their lives. Producers, consumers and possibly those who produce exactly as much as they consume. But that's a pretty poor philosophy if it reduces sentient beings to their economic contributions. I would like to think there is more to life than that. Does that help you at all?
TheBaffler
Yes, but I disagree with your contention that it is possible to mathematically demonstrate whether or not a randomly chosen person is at any given point in their life a net "giver" or net "taker." In fact, I don't think you could even do this for yourself.
CosmicConservative
Baffler, here is how you do it mathematically. Whether measurable or not, individual human beings produce and consume economic value during their lives. While it may be beyond our ability to measure due to the complexity of the system, an individual human being over the course of their lives will have a net economic production greater than, less than or equal to zero. That seems pretty straightforward to me. Now, can you demonstrate that any random person is a net giver or taker? Well, if that random person is, say, Bill Gates, or a person who has never held a job and been on public welfare all their lives, I'd say "yeah, you can." However, there are certainly a lot of people whose net economic value production will be difficult to ascertain. My point above was not about picking a random individual. It was about aggregate groupings. And I also said that any philosophy that reduced sentient beings to their economic contribution is a poor philosophy. So this would be an example in my opinion of you not truly wanting to have a conversation, but instead looking for any potential nit you can pick to try to score a rhetorical point. Which bores me Baffler.
TheBaffler
If you're bored, feel free not to respond. In the event that you do, I look forward to seeing an example of the mathematical proof of an individual's net production to consumption ratio that you mentioned earlier.
CosmicConservative
I'm done baffler. Feel free to continue to try to win the internet.
TheBaffler
Come on, man. I don't even want to win your blog. I'm just giving you a bit more of a challenge than your sycophants do.