Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Good riddance to bad rubbish

By CosmicConservative
Statement from Senator Arlen Specter:
I have been a Republican since 1966. I have been working extremely hard for the party, for its candidates and for the ideals of a Republican Party whose tent is big enough to welcome diverse points of view. While I have been comfortable being a Republican, my party has not defined who I am. I have taken each issue one at a time and have exercised independent judgment to do what I thought was best for Pennsylvania and the nation. Since my election in 1980, as part of the Reagan Big Tent, the Republican Party has moved far to the right. Last year, more than 200,000 Republicans in Pennsylvania changed their registration to become Democrats. I now find my political philosophy more in line with Democrats than Republicans.
Don't let the door hit you on the way out. Take a few more with ya why don't you?

Comments (22)

reggie
So much for party loyalty, oh wait he had none. One can only hope his "good friend" McCain, and the rest of his fellow travelers will go as well. A RINO is just a Democrat in disguise.
Andy
Poor old Arlen has no choice but to let the door hit him on the way out. Dinosaurs move slowly...
Andy
Oh Cosmic...I just got a heads-up from The National Enquirer. It seems that Specter has the hots for Barbara Mikulski, and wants to "caucus" with her before he croaks.
Old Goat
Spector was never a real republican. This doesn't change much of anything in terms of what he did. It really makes you wonder "what was he thinking" when you look back at the support that Bush gave him. I think the polls will start to show that he has just as a poor a chance at re-election when he is running under his true colors. Then again, you never know, he might have the powerful Acorn backing him now.
CosmicConservative
I openly rooted against Arlen Specter both in his primary and in the general election. I would have prefered to have a Democrat in his chair. And now I've GOT one. Yay. I don't put McCain in the same category as Specter. Specter is an east coast liberal who only ran as a Republican because that was how to win back then. He has voted consistently with the Democrats on major issues since I've been tracking him. In fact I am quite certain that he would not have voted with Republicans on ANY filibuster, so Obama had a filibuster proof majority all along.
Dadman
Specter voted with the Republicans about 40% of the time. Whether or not he continues to do so is the big question...
esox67
1 Rino down, 2-3 more to go. Personally I am tired of people telling me they are conservative, but continue to spend my daughters future job earnings like it was water from the ocean. The first solution is term limits, 2 terms and you are OUT, and you cannot run while you are in office. Now that will bring some change I can believe in.
Boyd
I'm not familiar with Specter's record, so I couldn't really comment, but I observed a discussion between a Democrat and a Republican, and the Dem asked a question the Rep couldn't answer: "Besides the economic stimulus bill and abortion, what's the Republican beef with Specter? He has still voted with the Republicans a majority of the time." I didn't have the knowledge chops to dispute it (although I have the debate chops where I could have still torn the Dem apart without actually knowing anything...he left himself wide open numerous times), so I didn't join in, but I'm curious: did Specter really vote against the Republicans most of the time, Dadman? And further, what specifically are the Republicans' biggest beefs with Specter?
Drax
Gotta love it. R's are down 1 vote; D's are up one vote and, with Franken, fillibuster proof majority. And, some of you are CELEBRATING. Sheesh. I'm sure that the "liberal" Democrat that Specter defeated would have voted to confirm Thomas. Yah. Just dang sure of it. I'm fairly certain that I'd rather have a RINO than a liberal democrat. But, who knows. Maybe it's just better to have someone in that seat who is even MORE liberal than Specter. Yah. That's the ticket. Keep cheering, guys. Your celebration is echoing in the increasingly empty halls of the RNC.
CosmicConservative
Drax: There's actually method to my madness, and we'll see how it pans out. My theory is that the more power the Democrats have, the more they will dig their own grave and lead to a conservative (TRUE conservative) revolt and return to power of conservatism. (As opposed to Republicanism). Specter did nothing but give Republican cover to Obama's agenda. Now he's lost that cover. I think that's a good thing. Remember, he voted for the bailout.
CosmicConservative
Another thing Drax... There are no doubt a billion ways to spin this thing. One way is that this switch has put the Pennsylvania Senate election in 2010 in a situation where the worst case for Republicans is that Specter, who will be a moderate Democrat, will remain in power. The best case is that a conservative Republican will unseat him. I personally think Specter is handily beatable in 2010, and this makes him MORE vulnerable, not less. Yes, for 20 months we have a worse situation, but the prospects for the NEXT six years are looking up.
esox67
Spector has been one of the key cross over votes on a few major bills for the current admin. If the republican party just keeps acting like democrats, why should people elect them? I guess every 30 years or so people need to be reminded of the Carter admin. The republicans need to stand for something other than spending my money with no thought to paying it back. There are already plenty of people in DC with that mindset. It might be bad in the short run, but in the long run I think it benefits conservatives like me who do not think government is not the answer to every single problem.
Andy
I read this comment elsewhere: "I read that Specter was switching parties. I was disappointed to learn that he's still a Democrat." :)
Drax
Let there be NO mistake: Specter voted with the Republicans as a result of Republican pressure rather than as a result of his beliefs. Specter will vote with the Democrats as a result of Democratic pressure rather than as a result of his beliefs. That's HOW IT WORKS. Except for matters of great principle, almost every single "representative" represents the PARTY rather than his constituients (or his own conscience) or suffers the wrath of the PARTY. In fact, it is often reported by those few Democrats who cross over that they are astonished at how light-handed the Republican leadership is in applying that "pressure" as opposed to the often heavy-handed methods used by Democratic leadership. Accordingly, I fully expect Specter's votes to be even MORE liberal. How will he NOW vote on "card check?" His former sources for campaign funds are dry. He will need the support of the PARTY to get funds to fight off his Democratic primary foe...and subsequent general election foe. We know that he will do MUCH to protect his political future. How many votes...CRITICAL votes are now going to go the other way as Specter scrambles (and "compromises") in an effort to save his political skin because of this ABSURD notion that "it's better to have an ENEMY than a lukewarm friend?" I agree that he is beatable. I don't think he'll BE the democratic nominee in the general election. But, I'm WAY less concerned about what happens in 2010 than I am about what happens BETWEEN now and then.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I hear you. However I can't help but point out that in every critical vote that I can recall in the past several years, Specter crossed the line and voted with Democrats anyway. And it's those key, critical votes I care about. We were getting damn few of those from Specter already.
Old Goat
The larger problem with RINO's is that their votes are used as weapons against the Republicans. In Spector's case, he rarely stood for the Republican causes, and each of those times it was hailed as the lack of unity within the GOP. Spector is and has always shown that he is for himself, not the people he was elected to represent. His changing parties won't help save his political job. He stands for nothing... other than making noise about Spygate. This isn't a case where you kick out luke warm "friends", in this case, you remove a consistent threat of being stabbed in the back by one of your "own". That is how Spector operated. It somewhat how McCain operates.
Drax
CC: I mostly agree. Specter was, at best, a liberal Republican, a RINO. In fact, there are Democrats who are more "conservative" than he is. The problem is not only with Specter. It's with all Republicans who run in areas where the voters tend "blue." In those areas, either you get a "liberal Republican" or you get a more liberal Democrat. This is due to the oft-repeated principle that it is the 30% of the voters who don't vote "R" or "D" in a knee-jerk fashion. Both candidates have to appeal to that 30%. In "blue" areas, that 30% is more left-leaning, so the "R" has to be WAY more "left-leaning" since his base is smaller and he has to capture more of that 30% than his opponent who has a larger base. And once elected, the representative must vote so not to tick off that 30%, relying on his ability to use the perks of office (name recognition, face-time, earmarks, "bringing home the bacon," party money, PAC money, national fund raising, etc.) to win the next primary. Specter simply has done what the realities of the two-party system dictates. Absent the economic melt-down, he would continue as the "Republican" senator until he retired, died, or some OTHER event occurred which ticked off his base sufficiently that they voted for a more conservative candidate in the primary. So, even though most political wonks KNOW this, what do they do? They attack him. They make it clear that his days are numbered. They FORCE him to move even FURTHER left if he wishes to survive. He CAN'T move further right if he wants to survive -- he'll get beat by the Democrats in the next general election. Is this how Republicans want to treat those "Republicans" who somehow manage to get elected in "blue states?" Berate them? Punish them for not being "Republican enough?" Withhold party support/money? IF A "CONSERVATIVE" COULD BE ELECTED IN THOSE STATES....ONE WOULD BE. It's not as if there a lack of conservative choices in the primaries; they just ain't getting the votes. In this environment, it is likely that a "conservative" will win not just this nomination but several others, ousting incumbents. The question is whether enough of that "30%" will vote for them (or enough new voters vote for them -- or enough of the "base" of the democrats DON'T vote for their nominee...etc.) Until then, however, it is NOT in the interests of the Republicans (or the nation) for the PARTY MACHINERY to insult those RINOs we still have because it's likely that they, like Specter, may just take their ball and go to the other team where they have a chance to win their next election.
Drax
Old Goat: I'm confused. Are you implying that Specter's loyalty was to the Republican party rather than to the voters of the State of Pennsylvania? It is THOSE VOTERS who put him in the seat....FIVE TIMES. Had those voters WANTED a more "conservative" Senator...they have had FIVE OPPORTUNITIES to vote one in.
CosmicConservative
I hear ya Drax. You might want to read my John Galt post. There's some of that going on here. With me anyway.
Andy
Drax has a point. Look what happened to Santorum. He got completely creamed in PA. PA doesn't want a conservative Senator at this point. Things could change by 2010...but it's uphill for sure.
Old Goat
The problem with Spector is that he talked one way, and acted another. Too many voters just vote in the incumbent unless it is shown to them how he or she didn't act in their interests. Spector has always shown himself to live by the principle that his constituents wouldn't remember what he did, and he was right. In being elected in a party system, you have to support the party on the major platform issues. Otherwise there is no party.
Drax
Old Goat: I agree with the premise that, if a member of a party, one should -- at least in the main -- accept party principles. This, of course, would require that a person's affiliation be defined by the PARTY rather than self-defined. And, we're not really a "party system," we're a "TWO PARTY system," one in which, if you're not a member of one of the two main parties, you simply don't have a chance of being elected -- REGARDLESS of your actual beliefs or those you tell potential voters. 70% (or better) of the voters simply vote "R" or "D" and leave it to chance that the "R" or "D" actually reflects their values.