Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

WoW Ulduar report

By CosmicConservative
OK, I know I have been spelling it "Ulduaar" up until now. That's not right. It's "Ulduar". We took a ten person group in tonight and managed to take down the first boss without a single party wipe (although we lost a couple of raid members in the fight). That's pretty good, and boosted our confidence for the rest of the instance. But that ended up being the only boss we took down. We tried three other bosses and wiped every time on them. There is no doubt that Ulduar is much harder than Naxx. I do have a few thoughts after the run though. Consider it a review of the first four bosses in Ulduar (there are a lot more bosses than these four). The instance is not merely challenging, it is challenging in fun and engaging ways. You have to learn new things as you go, much more so than Naxx or other instances I've played in WoW. Since we had no experience on these fights, and only sketchy information from internet posts from people who had completed the fights in beta only, or just the day before, there was a lot of unknown to the fights. Usually in the raids I've been in the raid members are quite knowledgeable about the fight even if they've never done it before because of the wealth of info on the fights on the web. This time it was a whole new experience, and we had to work out strategy as we went. That was really cool. I probably enjoyed tonight's raid more than any raid in a long time. Even though we got waxed pretty good. On the "negative" side, the raid seems to drop a lot less loot than most raids I've been in. A typical Naxx boss drops from four to six items at a time. The one boss we did manage to take down dropped two items, neither of which were useful to a rogue. The "trash" mobs that you fight between bosses also dropped very little loot, in fact the first massive army of mobs you had to fight dropped no loot at all. The two items the boss dropped were all we got from about 40 minutes of fighting. I think Blizzard is trying to rebuild a sense of accomplishment and elitism in the game. From what I saw tonight I don't think there are going to be armies of Ulduar-savvy players running around looking for pickup groups. Between the difficulty of the fights, and the much less likelihood of getting good loot, I suspect a lot of players are going to stick to Naxx and the other raids and venture into Ulduar much less frequently. I suspect that Ulduar raids are going to be much more likely to be full guild raids than the other epic raids are. But I may be wrong. It's all new, and maybe once the strategies are published, tested and copied by everyone with an epic toon, maybe it won't be a big deal to do Ulduar. But right now I suspect a lot of WoW players are feeling like they have bitten off more than they can chew. More to come as we work our way through. And remember, ten man, which we did tonight, is generally MUCH less difficult than 25 man. That will be a whole new level of play.

Comments (1)

Boyd
10-man also drops much less loot than 25-man. As you experienced last night in Ulduar, 10-man Naxx bosses typically only drop two items aside from currency items (emblems and shards) and other common drops.