Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Jay Cutler to be traded...

By CosmicConservative
Apparently primarily for behaving like a selfish two-year old.
Breaking News - Newsradio 850 KOA The Jay Cutler era in Denver appears to be over. Tuesday, the Broncos said they will entertain trade offers from other teams in an effort to move Cutler, who remains upset with the organziation and new head coach Josh McDaniels, who tried to acquire quarterback Josh McDaniels [sic - the actual QB was Matt Cassel] shortly after free agency began in late February. In a statement released Tuesday, Broncos President and CEO Pat Bowlen said it has become clear Cutler wants out of Denver. “Numerous attempts to contact Jay Cutler in the last 10 days, both by Head Coach Josh McDaniels and myself, have been unsuccessful," Bowlen said. "A conversation with his agent earlier today clearly communicated and confirmed to us that Jay no longer has any desire to play for the Denver Broncos. We will begin discussions with other teams in an effort to accommodate his request to be traded," Bowlen added. McDaniels acknowledged to Cutler that the team did try to acquire Cassell but when the deal fell through, McDaniels communicated to Cutler they wanted him as its quarterback.
Based on Jay Cutler's whining, crying, petulance and undeserved high opinion of himself, I don't think too many other teams are salivating at the prospect of having Jay in their locker rooms. I predicted this would end this way. Perhaps Jay will blossom somewhere else, but frankly, if he doesn't grow up a whole bunch, real fast, he's going to be the next big NFL quarterback bust story.

Comments (29)

Drax
I'm one of those who sides with the players...almost all of the time. Jay/Denver have a contract which Jay must honor -- but which the owners don't have to honor. They can just cut him. It's a "contract" in name only. Jay says that he was promised that the offensive coaching team would remain with the change in management. That didn't happen. He says that he was told that he was "the guy." Then Denver went after Cassel. Jay sees that he isn't wanted. How long before he's BENCHED in favor of someone else? Or TRADED to a team that he doesn't want to go to? (And why would the ownership trade him to a team which is a "contender" if they have a choice? No. If they can do so, any trade will be one which HURTS Jay's chances of being on a Playoff team -- because putting him on a team which is a contender now but needs a good QB hurts DENVER's chances of a SB run....) Every single thing about the "business" of the NFL is stacked in ownership's favor. Jay sees the writing on the wall. He wants out ON HIS TERMS to the extent that is possible -- to be traded when HE wants to be traded -- when the teams interested might be ones which have a chance of WINNING -- not the Raiders or some such. No. There are teams out there who want him. Badly. Salivating at the prospect of getting him. Vikings. Bears. Bucs. Lions (use that 1st pick on an OL...). Jets. Panthers. Rams. Salivating.
Old Goat
From what I hear, there are some teams that are looking very likely to go after him. There is a need for decent QBs and even someone who has not come off looking great from this will be given a shot. I really don't understand how the players union could agree to this type of contract structure. None of the contracts seem to go to the end of the deal. Either the player looks to get more, (good on them) or they get cut and are looking for work and none of the money has to be paid. This is in part due to the salary cap issue. When you place constraints like that, it leads to non-binding contracts. It also leads to owners putting far more in their pockets for the most part. While caps may be helpful in creating a sort of parity, it goes against capitalism and therefore is going to lead to a failure.
Drax
Jay was a pro-bowl QB last year. In his career with the Defense deprived Broncos, when that sorry, sorry defense allowed 21 points or less, Jay was 13-1. Half the teams in the NFL NEED him. All but a handful of teams would be significantly better with him. (What great QB's are out there? Manning (the first), Brees, Brady, McNabb, Big Ben -- a couple of others? (And, I have never been convinced of Brady's "greatness." Still ain't. Cassel will be a mediocre QB on another team. It's the TEAM, man....) As to the union...the NFL's player's union is WEAK, always has been. As to salary caps -- I like them. NFL teams aren't in competition with each other in the ordinary sense of the term -- it's a monopoly with different members of the same team struggling for pieces of the same pie. It's all about the BRAND (the "NFL") not individual teams. They want MORE teams...MORE games...MORE "competition" between teams... It ain't like it's WalMart trying to put K-Mart out of business. The success of EACH team enhances the success of EVERY team.
CosmicConservative
I had a long response, but got an error when I tried to post it and don't feel like recreating the whole thing. Probably best anyway. Drax, you are a Cutler fan. I am not. I will only say that right now the only NFL front office who actually KNOWS and has EXPERIENCE with Jay Cutler agrees with me, not you. I guess this will force the issue. Assuming Jay gets traded (and you might recall I predicted he would) we will be able to see how he performs with another team. It is interesting you listed how many games Jay has won when opposing teams scored less than 21 points and you blamed that on the defense. Now, I agree that Denver's defense has been suspect at best, but did you factor in how many of those games the opposing team scored more than 21 points, Jay had turned the ball over in the red zone, leading to scores for the other team? I love statistics like that. Why don't you look at Tony Romo's statistics for games when the Cowboys defense allows 21 points or less? Or Marc Bulger? Or Rex Grossman? How about ALL NFL GAMES IN TOTAL? What is the record of ALL NFL TEAMS when they hold their opponents to less than 21 points? I bet that the result is something like 80% of those games are won by the team that held the other team to 21 points or less. So color me unimpressed by that statistic. I liken that to the "[Team A] has a 21 - 3 record when [Running back 1] runs for 100 or more yards." Um... Duh. Here is my prediction for Jay Cutler's future if he does get traded. He will perform much as he has at Denver, showing moments of brilliance and an awesome arm that make everyone rave about his "potential". He will continue to lose big games by throwing or fumbling the ball away in critical game situations. His stats will be great, but his win-loss result will be mediocre. He will be traded again in three years or less. UNLESS he grows up and learns how to MANAGE a football game. But at this point I see little hope of that.
CosmicConservative
Oh on the "there are teams that NEED him" subject. A short mathematical analysis of the NFL and the QB position shows me that roughly HALF of the NFL teams could either improve or remain the same level by trading for ANY mediocre QB. That does not say much about the QB, it only staes the obvious statistical fact that HALF the teams in the NFL have an average or lower rated QB BY DEFINITION. Remember, half of all brain surgeons graduated in the bottom half of their class. So to say that Detroit is "salivating" at the prospect of upgrading from "crap" to "mediocre" is faint praise at best.
Drax
CC: You say that Jay is mediocre. He was Pro-Bowl last year on a mediocre team. He is one of the top tier QB's in the game. (You know how I can tell? He was PRO-BOWL LAST YEAR.) Of course, 1/2 the teams are worse than 1/2 the other teams and 1/2 the QB's are worse than the other 1/2. I really don't know how you can't like this guy. And, you're really relying on the new head coach and GM (both around Jay's age for cripe's sake) for authority that they "know Jay best" and that it's a GOOD DECISION to trade last year's Pro-Bowl QB? Denver doesn't WANT to trade Jay. They TRIED to "trade up" (in the opinion of McDaniels) by getting Cassel. They SCREWED UP in how they handled it. Now, they have a franchise QB who is ticked off at them and feels that he can't trust them. Because of their INCOMPETENCE, they are in the position of possibly not having a top-tier QB next year when they don't have ANY OTHER ASPECT OF THEIR TEAM in the "top tier." Good going rookies. Of course Cutler makes some bad decisions. Who was the last QB who didn't? (Crickets...) Of course he throws interceptions. Which QB doesn't? (Crickets...) But, if he goes to a team with actual WEAPONS and something which RESEMBLES a defense, he'll be bound to go deep into the playoffs. That's MY prediction.
CosmicConservative
Drax: As I said, you are a Cutler fan. I am not. I think Jay's actual statistics demonstrate UNEQUIVOCABLY that he is a mediocre quarterback. Pro bowl selections are no evidence of quality, ESPECIALLY if Jay Cutler went there instead of several quarterbacks who are DEMONSTRABLY better, including Tony Romo (who went to the Pro Bowl BEFORE Jay Cutler did, just as I predicted when Jay and Tony took over their respective teams in 2006.) In fact I think that my predictions have, so far, been quite accurate. We'll see how my latest one turns out. We can check back in ten years. You say Jay has Hall of Fame potential. I say he's going to be remembered at best as a "might have been" and at worst as a bust. This is testable. We'll see how it turns out.
Drax
When did I say "hall of fame potential?" I said he's one of the "top tier" QB's in today's game. He is a PRO BOWL QB currently. You think ROMO was Pro-Bowl material last year? There's a reason Romo was undrafted. He can have Hall of Fame Wide Receivers, Line Backers, Offensive Line-Backers -- a GREAT running game, a Pro-Bowl calibre tight end, a Hall of Fame Coach...and sits at home in December. Every year. Talk about a "choker" or someone who can't stand up under the pressure and you may as well draw a picture of NOMO ROMO. He might accidently lead Dallas into the playoffs (much like Switzer did after inheriting Johnson's team....), but it will be because he's got a new coach (not Phillips) who can wield the weapons Romo has access to. And, I'm not a "Cutler fan." I could care less about the guy. The only two QB's I'm a fan of are Manning (the first) and Favre....so I'm down to one. (Well...Warner...but who can resist being a "fan" of that guy?) But, you can't dismiss his ability. (Well, I can't...and every GM in the league who DOESN'T have a Manning on his squad can't...)
Old Goat
Drax, I wouldn't keep making so much out about the Pro Bowl stuff, it really doesn't mean that much as to many of the players they don't even want to go to it. Just like the Gold Glove in baseball doesn't mean all that much, some "honors" don't have a lot of integrity backing it up. Pro Bowl is one such honorific. Yes, they have to have "something" to be a Pro Bowl player, but it isn't something that carries much weight.
Drax
Old Goat: I don't agree with that one bit. Not even a whit. Players may not want to PLAY in the Pro-Bowl because it's a meaningless game in which their career might be ended, but it is certainly an honor to be SELECTED since fully two-thirds of the selection is based on the votes of PLAYERS and COACHES and not simply FANS (as in Basketball and Baseball). One can't be selected a Pro-Bowl player simply based on whether one is popular with the fans. The COACHES and the PLAYERS have to think that you're (that year) deserving of the award and it's a HIGHLY RESPECTED award by all players and coaches. The Gold Glove is highly respected as well. Really. Ask Brooks Robinson or Greg Maddux or Bill Mazeroski (the first player voted into the HOF based SOLELY on his defensive ability...) IT is voted on by the coaches and managers with NO fan (or popularity) involvement. It is HIGHLY respected.
CosmicConservative
Hmm.... so the "Nomo Romo" guy you just dissed was voted overwhelmingly to the Pro Bowl in 2007, you know the year he DIDN'T break his finger in the middle of the season... This is testable. I've said that before about other predictions of mine on this subject. So far I have been quite accurate in predicting for both Romo and Cutler. Drax, you have to see that you use one argument to support Cutler and then turn around and completely ignore that SAME argument as it applies to Romo. Here's the deal with Romo and Cutler. Both have been to the pro bowl. Both took over a team in the middle of a current season. Both took over a team that has been great historically, but were coming off of a very mediocre year the year before and poor performance the year they took over. Both have had to deal with on field and off field distractions and controversy. Both have put up amazing numbers in at least one year. Neither has won a playoff game. Along with all that similarity between the two players, there are THREE glaring differences. Romo has a much higher overall win-loss percentage than Cutler has. Romo has a much higher overall QB rating for those three years. And Romo has PLAYED IN two playoff games, while Cutler has appeared in zero. (Do you really think Dallas would have missed the playoffs if Romo had not broken his finger?) Yet you diss Romo while supporting Cutler. Frankly I just don't get that.
CosmicConservative
By the way Drax, exactly how did Cutler perform in his Pro Bowl debut? My recollection is that he performed much like he does in Denver. Great yards, and a boneheaded interception near the end of the game.
Drax
CC: I used to be a "fan" of Romo. He had some pretty good games. But, he has consistently wimped out down the stretch. (Well, the team he "leads" has...) He has done this with an infinitely better overall team and infinitely better weapons at his disposal than Cutler. I just think that Cutler has better TOOLS than does Romo. I think that they have about the same football brains at this point...neither of whom are anything special in that regard. Neither of them "lead" their team as yet and neither have shown any great tendencies towards leadership. I think that, since (in my opinion) Cutler has better QB tools and an equivilent mind to Romo, if he has decent weapons and a decent coach, he'll out-perform Romo who hasn't excelled with OUTSTANDING weapons. I called him "NOMO ROMO" because of his wilting down the stretch. Dallas should have been in the playoffs last year. If Denver had made it, it would have surprised me (at year's beginning...they just don't have ANYTHING except a jail-bound receiver and Cutler) just as it surprised me that they didn't make the playoffs with three games to go. (Just as did the Jets' failure to make the playoffs...but that's why they play the games...) Romo is a drop-back passer who throws at awkward angles. That's a recipe for disaster. He has limited escapability. He just isn't built nor does he throw like a drop-back passer. Cutler does. I don't expect great things of Romo even on a team FILLED with great/HOF players. I DO expect great things of Cutler IF he can get on a decent team. There are only a few QB's who can be "great" without greatness surrounding them. In fact, I count only one. Favre. Every other "great" QB has had greatness surrounding them...whether it's Rice to throw to...(and Roger Craig and Ronnie Lott...or Rice and Owens...or Stallworth/Harris/Swann/Greene/et al...or Taylor to hand it off to or WHATEVER) It's no accident that Elway was "great" but didn't win the SB. His weapons (Smith especially) were borderline HOF's and he had no other really greatness surrounding him. When he got T.D., that changed. Now he had Smith AND T.D. He had WEAPONS. It's amazing how much better a team is when it has great weapons, isn't it? Romo HAD "great weapons." He couldn't do anythign with them. Cutler hasn't had ANYONE who RESEMBLED a "great weapon" let alone two...let alone SEVERAL at one time on both sides of the ball who are future HOFers. Romo had, in his pro-bowl year: Owens (pro bowl)/Glenn/Crayton/Whitten (pro-bowl) to throw it to; Marion Barber (Pro Bowl) and Julius Jones to hand it off to; Leonard Davis (pro bowl) Andre Gurode (pro bowl), Flozell Adams (pro bowl) to protect him. On the other side of the ball, he had Roy Williams, Terrence Newman, Ken Hamlin, DeMarcus Ware, and Greg Ellis (ALL pro bowlers) to keep the score in reach. When Cutler made the Pro Bowl in 2008 the sum total of his "great" teammates is Brandon Marshall.... That's IT. ONE player other than Cutler on EITHER side of the ball made the Pro Bowl, and it's the guy he threw it to. I guess that's my whole point. Culter is good DESPITE his team. Romo is good (thus far) ONLY when surrounded by greatness.
CosmicConservative
Drax: We'll just have to agree to disagree on this. And as I say, the result is testable. I'm sure this isn't the end of our debate on this, and I'm not saying Romo is GREAT, only that he has been BETTER (statistically speaking) than Cutler has been. I think you overstate Dallas as a team and understate Denver. Both have strengths and weaknesses,and Denver's Orange Crush team of the late 70s early 80s had some great talent on it too. They didn't get to the Super Bowl on the strength of Elway's arm alone, although you could argue that they lost TWO of those games directly due to Elway's limitations. As far as Dallas representation in the Pro Bowl in 2007, I have to agree with many Dallas detractors when they say that Dallas (and other big-city teams like New York and San Francisco) get preferential treatment in both the pro bowl and the hall of fame. Marion Barber is not that good in my opinion, and Terrell Owens had one great year in Dallas, and otherwise has been somewhat ordinary. Time will tell. I've made my predictions, you've made yours. We'll see whose turn out to be mroe accurate. As I said, for the past three years I've been making predictions about Romo and Cutler (and Favre and Brady and etc...) and so far I am quite happy with how accurate I've been, especially with Romo and Cutler who have performed virtually EXACTLY as I have predicted. Of the predictions I've made about players, the biggest mistake I made was Eli Manning, who I had pegged very much like Cutler, but had to revise that opinion when Eli actually started acting like he knew how to manage a football game instead of try to be a clone of his older brother. Since then he has been a very good quarterback. Before then he was a whiny, self-indulgent prima donna. So there's hope for Cutler, if he follows the Eli model. So far, as I said, he shows no indication of doing so. So far it all seems to be about him. I think Romo makes better decisions by and large than Cutler does, and I think Romo's skills are better than you describe them. I've seen him make all the necessary throws, and I've seen him scramble quite effectively. Cutler MAY have better skills, but to this point in his career, it is MY opinion that Romo has done more with his skills than Cutler has done with his. By the way, the odds of Cutler going to a team that is better than Denver are quite low in my opinion. So if your contention is correct, that Cutler's middling stats are due to his teammates, this bodes ill for his future.
Drax
I don't know why you think that I underrate Denver. Not one pro-bowler in 2008. Two in 2009. I think that it's demonstrable that leaguewide/player wide/coach wide/fan wide -- everyone just about everywhere who knows anything about football says Denver SUCKS. The opposite is true of Dallas. Everyone thinks that Dallas is underperforming and is the MOST talented team in the NFL. Sorry stats for Cutler: 1st full season: 3500 yards, 20 TD's/14 Ints, 64% Completion rate...2nd full season: 4500 yards, 25/18, 62% Completion rate. Pure suckage. Romo: 1st full season: (after 2 years watching and a 10 game season....): 4200 yards, 36/19, 64% Completion rate...2nd full season: (missing 3 games): 3500 yards, 26/14, 61% Completion rate. Romo's stats are better -- somewhat, but they SHOULD be better -- he actually has someone to THROW IT TO and has an OL which can actually protect him and (regardless of your opinion -- with Barber averaging 4.3 yards per carry and for the past 2 years 45+ receptions per year) had people who can actually run the ball. I get a kick out of the argument that a starting professional NFL QB, who, by default, is one of the best 32 Quarterbacks on the face of the planet, can "make all the throws." Subject to the limitations of arm strength, they ALL can "make all the throws." Romo's good. Cutler's good. Unless and until they swap teams and play with the same players and same coaches, one can't actually compare them. As of now, they EACH are but a wart on the behind of ... Trent Dilfer.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I actually concur with your Trent Dilfer comment. But you are making my argument here. I have always said that my big issue with Cutler is that he is no better than a NUMBER of other "young quarterbacks" many of whom have superior stats, and yet Cutler continues to be the "potential superstar" as Romo throws more touchdowns and fewer interceptions, Roethlesberger wins two super bowls, Philip Rivers gets to two championship games, Eli Manning wins a Super Bowl, etc. etc. etc... I use Romo in most of my arguments because I pay more attention to the Cowboys and so can do much more of a direct comparison between performances that I actually SAW. I could just as easily use Eli Manning or Philip Rivers, etc. It's just more convenient for me to use Romo. I personally think that Cutler is a "good" quarterback, but as you say EVERY NFL quarterback is "good." In my personal opinion, comparing what I can FACTUALLY COMPARE about the different quarterbacks, I would put Jay Cutler about fourth or fifth in ACTUAL PERFORMANCE when compared to his "young" peers. And I'd put several veteran quarterbacks (Drew Brees, Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Kurt Warner, Carson Palmer) above him as well. When you add them up, that puts Jay Cutler somewhere around #13 or 14 on my list. Romo I'd put somewhere around #5. Based PURELY ON ACTUAL STATISTICAL PERFORMANCE. There is a reason the QB rating system exists. There is a reason it is reported on. And according to QB rankings, guess where Romo and Cutler fall over the past three years? Yep, Romo is consistently in the top 5, Cutler is consistently hovering below tenth. We've beaten this dead horse enough. Next year we'll no doubt see the "Cutler's breakout year" stories, and more about "Romo's disappointing Decembers". But by the end of 2009 I will be very surprised if Romo is not in the top five and Cutler isn't still mucking around #12 or so. We'll see.
CosmicConservative
Oh, and here's why I think you overrate Dallas and underrate Denver. In 2008 Dallas went 9 - 7 and missed the playoffs by one game (I contend that they would have won that one game had Romo not broken his pinky finger). In 2008 Denver went 8 - 8 and missed the playoffs by one game. Neither team is a powerhouse. Both teams have strengths and weaknesses. I think Dallas has a tougher schedule, but everyone thinks their favorite team has tougher schedules. If we want to look at crunch time performance, Romo has blown it in two playoff games. But I think it is entirely fair to compare that to Denver's 2008 run when they had to win only ONE of their final three games to make the playoffs, and lost all three. Two of those losses I pin directly on poor decision making and game-changing critical turnovers made by one Jay Cutler. So even in the "clutch performance" category, I think Romo and Cutler are quite similar.
Drax
When Cutler plays on a team with 4 or more Pro Bowlers on BOTH sides of the ball AND one on special teams instead of essentially NONE, then, I'll start considering a comparison of stats rather than a comparison of talent. I agree that Cutler isn't a Rivers nor a Big Ben...but, to be SURE...Denver isn't comparable to either SD's offense/defense OR Pitt's offense/defense. Come on...LT versus ?. Hines Ward versus jailbird? Willie Parker vs. ? Pitt's defense vs....??????? Rivers needs someone to catch the ball. If he gets that, SD is superbowl bound. But, as you say...we'll see.
CosmicConservative
Well, since I have this unfortunate tendency to compare based on measurable factors, and the measurable factors I have show Cutler to be mediocre and well below a dozen or so other QBs. I'm gonna have to go with that until the stats change. Particularly the stat called "win/loss".
Drax
Give me a break! "Stats have meaning." Sheesh. Of course they have meaning. And, the more individual the sport, the more "meaning" they have. That's elementary. Simplicity itself. A no-brainer. On the other hand, the more the sport is team based, the less significance individual stats have. Again. A simple deduction. (Ask Dilfer. Ask Big Ben. Ask Bradshaw.) Two equal QB's. One has a good offensive line, one does not. Gee. Who do you think might have "better stats?" One has a HOF receiver, a Pro-Bowl Running Back, a pro-bowl tight end. The other has...none of those things. Gee. Who do you think might have "better stats?" One has a defense which gives up points in the range of a basketball game. The other has 4 or 5 pro bowl defensive backs and is stingy with giving up points. Gee. Who do you think might have "better stats?" For a "rational" person, you sure seem to be equating things which simply aren't equal. They may be SIMILAR, but they sure ain't "equal." I can, from the "stats," argue that Cutler is SIGNIFICANTLY "better" than Romo. He has about the same completion rate, is in his THIRD year (rather than his FIFTH), shows IMPROVEMENT from one year to the next rather than moving backwards and does it with next to nothing while Romo's stats aren't that much better and he has help in every aspect of the game. Meh. Teams win games, not QB's.
CosmicConservative
As I said, we disagree. Let's see how Cutler does learning a new offense, and dealing with a new team who looks at him and wonders "is he going to be a baby here too?" Also, this business of how great he'd be on a better team completely ignores the reality of his own red zone suckiness. I KNOW Jay Cutler himself cost the Broncos three games they should have won this year alone with bizarre throws that I can't imagine any other quarterback (but Favre) ever trying. So to argue that Jay is somehow the single bright point on an otherwise horrible team completely ignores the demonstrable fact that SOMETIMES at least JAY MAKES THE TEAM WORSE, not better.
Drax
I simply am saying that he would be BETTER on a better team. He'll still make mistakes in the red zone (ask Warner). He'll still throw it where no one on his team could catch it if they were on a motorcycle (ask Manning the First). Just ask Romo if a QB's stats are better when he's on a better team. Ask him what happens when he loses the Julius Jones/Marion Barber 1/2 punch and goes with Marion Barber solo. Ask him what happens when his primary receiver doesn't perform. Ask him what happens when he loses pro bowlers and former pro bowlers don't perform up to previous levels. Never mind. I'll just look at the stats. 36 TDs/19 Int. vs. 26 TDs/14 Ints. 2nd in scoring vs. 18th. 13th in points allowed vs. 20th. 13-3 vs. 9-7 Just for comparison...Denver rated 28th and 30th in points allowed. They got better in points scored, 21st to 16th. But, overall, the team sucked in 2007 and sucked in 2008 while Cutler's numbers got significantly better in 2008.
CosmicConservative
Of course all quarterbacks make mistakes in the red zone. So do running backs, wide receivers, offensive linemen and placekickers. My contention is that Jay Cutler's mistakes are significantly more often and more damaging than MOST quarterbacks, PARTICULARLY the "elite" quarterbacks that everyone keeps trying to put Cutler in the company of. FWIW, sentiment in Denver is running 70% "Good riddance to bad rubbish" in this Cutler situation. And the most common complaint about Cutler by those who are happy to see him go is "He's a locker room liability who makes bad critical decisions in game-changing situations." I think that's a fairly accurate assessment of the guy.
Drax
It's hard to determine how much of that media created "he's a whiner" story line is reflective of how his teammates feel. I don't recall hearing any of that before the blow-up caused by his coach and GM attempting to replace him after assurances that they would not. I think that Cutler handled it badly. He's in the NFL and knows that he's just a commodity. But, by the same token, he know's that he's in the NFL and that, as a commodity, he has some value, a value which has a limited window of worth and which can be diminished by not having any control over where he plays. Accordingly, I don't begrudge him his "whining" in an attempt to get out off of a team which is bad (and ain't getting better) AND one in which the coach and GM don't want him. Right now, Washington is looking at him HARD. They're talking about TWO first round picks for him (maybe MORE). That's a HIGH, HIGH price for a "mediocre" QB, I would think, heh. Methinks that the coaches in the NFL have a significantly higher opinion of Cutler's abilities than you...
Drax
Salivating... Jets? Looking hard, but maybe don't have enough draft picks to outbid Washington. Bears? Looking hard, but again...maybe not enough to outbid Washington. Lions? Ah... Salivating. Towel-wiping, people ducking, river forming Salivating.....#1 Pick? But, does Denver want the #1 pick (and the costs associated with it)? Bucs? Let's see... Griese or Cutler...Griese or Cutler.... Two first rounders? Paid that much for Keyshawn... Looks like there are only around 6 teams or so who DON'T want him. Whatever happens, Denver will be better off (if their rookie GM can deliver in his picks) and the team getting him will be better.
CosmicConservative
Drax: Of course the proof is in the pudding, as they say. If Washington is willing to give up two draft picks to get Cutler, I'd call that a too-high price to pay, and like Minnesota's ill-fated winning of the "bidding war" for Herschel Walker, I suspect they will regret such profligate behavior. Using the attention of GMs to a potential trade as a measure of the rational, fact-based analysis of the situation is quite funny to me. These are the same GMs for the most part who bidded up the Herschel Walker deal, who draft high-priced QBs who never play a down in the NFL and who trade away players like Randy Moss for a song. Since you have been highly critical of those same GMs for exactly that sort of behavior, spare me your appreciation of their sudden brilliance to support your own point of view in this case. Just so you know, here in Denver the Jay Cutler "locker room poison" meme has been around since he took on the job. In fact local reporters have asked John Elway if he can "coach" Cutler on how to relate to his teammates and behave both on and off the field. John, for his part, has offered Jay some public suggestions, some of which have been in the "be a better team player" vein. I think Jay Cutler can be a great quarterback in the NFL, but it is my personal opinion that his potential will never be realized so long as he thinks the world revolves around him. That's just my opinion, and I acknowledge it could be wrong. But that's how I see it.
Drax
Heh. I was simply using the GM's that YOU seem to have such high regard for (since they "know him best," although I think you meant the Denver coach and GM who haven't been on the same team as Jay for a SINGLE DOWN...and haven't been either a head coach or a GM for a single season). I never look at a GM's ability to evaluate talent -- except when there is a long pattern one way or another -- rookies are simply too unpredictable, although a higher draft pick GENERALLY has a better chance of suceeding in the NFL than does a lower draft pick -- again -- depending on where that player goes...(ask Elway....Ask Young...Ask Brees...Ask Favre...etc. etc.) A non-drafted player (Romo, Warner) can suceed; a 6th rounder can suceed (T.D., Brady) A 1st pick can be a boon or a bust (Leaf/Manning). It's just too dang hard to tell -- especially in the QB position. Trading for talent is not QUITE so hit/miss as drafting. The talent has a track record of playing in the NFL, so he can be evaluated at THAT level -- not WHETHER he can play at that level. However, the player must be able to mesh with the SCHEME in the offense/defense he's going to. Sometimes they can; sometimes they can't. Sometimes a "mediocre" talent does exceptionally well in a different system. (Ask Pennington...) The STARTING PRICE (set by Denver) is two first round picks. (Apparently Denver has an idea of what it's giving up.... or hopes no one will be willing to pay it...) It will be higher than that, for sure. (Jason Campbell's "stats" for last year aren't that much worse than Cutler's, but Snider's willing to mortgage his future on this guy....) If he goes there, he'll have a pro-bowl running back (2 time) to hand it off to (Thanks to Denver!), one great and one good WR as well as a very good tight end to throw to, a sterling defense, a promising head coach, and an owner willing to pay whatever is needed in an attempt to win. We'll see if he goes there. If so, that 8-8 team will be at least 11-5 and in the playoffs next year in a MUCH harder division than Denver.
Old Goat
So Cutler is going to Da Bears?!? For two first round picks.
Drax
Da Bears. Two first rounders and their starting QB... Should be a good fit. A potential pro-bowler RB. So-So in receiving corps, excellent defense so he won't be playing from behind so much or feel the need to make things happen because he knows his defense can't stop the other team. Ought to be interesting!