Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NASA "scientist" says Democracy won't deal with Global Warming...

By CosmicConservative
... so he advocates civil disobedience and criminal behavior (again, he's done this before).
Nasa's James Hansen warns 'democratic process isn't working' in climate change fight | Environment | guardian.co.uk Protest and direct action could be the only way to tackle soaring carbon emissions, a leading climate scientist has said. James Hansen, a climate modeller with Nasa, told the Guardian today that corporate lobbying has undermined democratic attempts to curb carbon pollution. "The democratic process doesn't quite seem to be working," he said. Speaking on the eve of joining a protest against the headquarters of power firm E.ON in Coventry, Hansen said: "The first action that people should take is to use the democratic process. What is frustrating people, me included, is that democratic action affects elections but what we get then from political leaders is greenwash.
So, to understand this, we have a man whose salary is paid by the government advocating illegal activities and civil disobedience against the government. And Obama, no doubt, agrees with him so you won't see him fired any time soon. Why Bush didn't fire him months ago is a mystery to me.

Comments (7)

Old Goat
I have no problem with a person being passionate about what they believe, but in this case the call for civil disobedience is troublesome. This is more proof that GW is becoming a religion to some people.
CosmicConservative
Goat: I don't care if he's passionate either, I just don't think it is ethical for a public official to promote civil disobedience and criminal behavior. Quit your job first. Then make your statements. Don't take taxpayer money to promote criminal behavior. Seems pretty simple to me.
Drax
CC: I must have missed something in that article. Everything Hansen said indicated that he believed in "peaceful protest," not "civil disobedience -- certainly nothing which resembled advocating illegal activity (unless the protest itself is deemed to be "illegal?") What am I missing?
CosmicConservative
Drax: In a previous appearance a few years ago Hansen promoted civil disobedience to obstruct the completion of a coal power plant. He may not be openly advocating such obstruction this time, but when he says "Democracy isn't working" he is certainly opening the door.
Drax
Ah. I just read the article without any background on this guy. However... I'm a fan of civil disobedience. Always have been. When Democracy doesn't work, say....when our elected officials decide to use AIG to launder money to French and U.K. banks, when they know that, had it been put to a VOTE (which they would have had to ANSWER for...) it wouldn't have passed...maybe protest...even going so far as a "million pissed off tax-payers march" on Washington, shutting it down (in contravention of law) would seem appropriate. I'm cool with "civil disobedience" so long as it doesn't turn into "uncivil violence." (I think that blacks and women and...well all "minorities" who were forced into "illegal" activities in an attempt to force society into changing its view when "Democracy wasn't working" would/should agree...)
Drax
Oops. That doesn't mean that I'm not in favor of the Government firing one of its employees if that employee doesn't toe the party line/follow Government's rules. It's the price one pays, at times, if one wishes to force change.