Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The coming evangelical collapse

By CosmicConservative
From the Christian Science Monitor...
The coming evangelical collapse | csmonitor.com Oneida, Ky. - We are on the verge – within 10 years – of a major collapse of evangelical Christianity. This breakdown will follow the deterioration of the mainline Protestant world and it will fundamentally alter the religious and cultural environment in the West. Within two generations, evangelicalism will be a house deserted of half its occupants. (Between 25 and 35 percent of Americans today are Evangelicals.) In the "Protestant" 20th century, Evangelicals flourished. But they will soon be living in a very secular and religiously antagonistic 21st century.
Read the whole thing. For the most part I concur with the sentiments expressed, although I'm not quite convinced of the scope or the timeline expressed. The "culture wars" discussed here did not start in 1960, and they won't end by 2020.

Comments (29)

Dadman
Heh. This guy has a serious case of evangelical tunnel-vision and is seemingly oblivious to other faith traditions that are presently thriving and growing. But he's right that the secular world, and secular pressure, will continue to make it more and more difficult to be an openly devout Christian. The blacklists and boycotts that sprung up in the wake of Prop 8 in California give us only a small taste of what is to come for those who oppose the secular agenda - they will be marginalized and eventually silenced 'for the good of society'.
BS1959
The pendulum swings and will always do so. Evangelical Christians (and I fall in this group)tend to spend so much time trying to be right that they become dangerously exclusive and I believe that is the impetus for some of the growth of other faith traditions. If our numbers are following, perhaps we should look inward to try to figure out why.
Drax
There are so many forces at work here that it's impossible to forecast the near-term future. 1) As a civilization, we (and the greatest part of Western Civilization) have been free of any significant threat to our survival and, indeed, have been living free of even the hint of any significant threat to our privation, that there has been no external need to turn to an outside source for solace. 2) As the need to turn to an outside force for solace has diminished, the indoctrination of our youth has likewise diminished. Without our children being indoctrinated at an early age, it is correspondingly less likely that they will be true adherents to any religion, or to religion in any recognizable form. 3) As we turn from religion, especially organized religion, we, being a people who have an internal need for there being a "meaning" to the universe and our place in it, turn to "fad religions" and new wave "spirituality" rather than the religions of our parents/forefathers. 4) Our society, due to distractions such as television, the internet, and computer games have become more insular, not knowing our closest neighbors, let alone those in our neighborhood. Finding our interation with others via the internet or eschewing it altogether for distractions, this insular nature has reduced the attraction of "church" as a place to get together with our neighbors and friends as a method of social interaction or "fellowship". 5) As a result of our free time and exposure to all the different religions and spiritual expressions, it is difficult for a critical thinker to say, "This religion/teaching contains the answer to life, the universe, and everything," when each purports to. Since all can't be right, it is more likely that all are wrong. All things being equal and this equality measured in degrees of "wrongness," coupled with the lack of early-age indoctrination, results in many just foregoing religion altogether. 6) Television and the internet expose our religious leaders to scrutiny they would not have been exposed to in earlier days. Fallen leaders (Swaggert, Baker, the Catholic Church in toto, etc.) make it difficult for anyone to believe that those who preach a thing actually believe a thing, and, if they (the leaders) don't believe and practice what they preach, what force religion? 7) Religions, in an effort to stem the loss of members, have bent and bowed to social pressures rather than requiring that their adherents actually adhere to the tenents of their religions. Indeed, it seems that most major religions have difficulty requiring that their priesthood actually preach teachings in line with the teachings of the Church they purport to follow. What value a religion which does not require that its members and its priests adhere to its teachings? 8) Society teaches us that, not only do those who fail to adhere to the tenents of their professed religion not be punished ("karma") but are rewarded. (Clinton, Bonds, Rodriguez, etc.) Further, the simple act of watching television shows us that homosexuality is not only "okay," but is an attractive life-style; that prostitution is acceptable (Reno); gambling is an acceptable diversion (pick your closest gambling location), that killing the unborn is not only acceptable but is expected in many situations, that out-of-wedlock sex is the norm, that out-of-wedlock children is not only acceptable but is worthy of admiration....etc. etc. What we see on television, on billboards, in our downtowns is directly in contravention of the core tenents of every established religion. 9) The need of a "Church" to help the helpless or needy is diminished by the role of Big Government. Turning to a Church for help is an "extra benefit" of being a member rather than following from the fellowship of the members. All of these things and many more are driving people from organized and traditional religions in droves. This will happen to ALL major religions, regardless of how "on the rise" they may be at this particular point in time. For, although it is impossible to predict what will happen in the short-term, it is certain that, in the long-term, as members of our society are indoctrinated at an early age from society at large in secularism, as the need for "Church" is diminished in its role as a "meeting place," as the fundamental underpinnings of any religion as a true source of knowledge of "life, the universe, and everything" further erodes into an equality of equal wrongness -- and new wave "spirituality" is given equal credence as the oldest of religious teachings, no "religion" can long survive. This is what gets me more than anything else about our war with fundamental fanatical Islamics. THEY understand these fundamental facts. THEY understand that, to maintain a religious monopoly, you must indoctrinate your young; you must keep temptations which are contrary to your religion's teachings from your adherents; you must require that your adherents actually adhere to the tenents of the religion and punish those who don't; you must clearly state that your religion is the one, true religion and that all others are false. When we understand that the "evil doers" hate us as a society because we, in their eyes, are an evil society and one which attempts to force our evil ways (see above...homosexuality, promiscuity, etc.) on them (whether actively or passively) -- and they see this as a direct attack on the very existence of their religion, we might have a chance at combatting them. But, regardless. Assuming that we survive the next 50 years or so, even those insular, child-indoctrinating, "my way or the "I'll cut your head off" highway" religions will suffer the same fate as they will be no more able to withstand the growth of secularism than our society has been.
CosmicConservative
Drax: You make some excellent points, but there is one area at least that I think your assertions can be challenged. Radical Islam absolutely believes as you assert above that a religion must do all the things you describe above. The history of religion is dotted with religious purges, inquisitions, crusades, etc. all of which more or less support your contention. But religious history is also dotted with religious efforts which are rational and peaceful as well. Two examples I can think of are Buddhists and Mormons, each of which has been able to maintain a steady or growing population of true believers without resorting to the techniques you describe above. So while I generally agree with most of your post, I would challenge the assertion that religion must be fanatical to survive. Although I do agree that some fanatics believe that.
Drax
It is true that the Buddhist religion thrived over populations of tens of millions. I simply would argue that those societies were insular, and really didn't have any competition either from the secular front or the religion front. Of course, as time wore/wears on, not only is the Buddhist religion on the wane as it is assailed by both secular and religious forces, disintegrating from within with schisms and various offshoots of the core tenents of the ages old beliefs. Of course, I would argue that Buddhism isn't a "religion" in any Western meaning of the word, but more a way of living one's life in search of enlightment to escape the never-ending cycle of suffering that is life. Nevertheless, all of what I stated remains true to this and any other insular way of life. (And, religion is typically insular, passed down from father to son.) Just as true, "my way of the highway" or "punishment" can come in forms other than cutting one's head off, i.e., the compelling need to be "one of the tribe/family," or outright ostracism in this life and the afterlife. Mormonism? It suffers from the same deficiencies as do all other mainstream religions, i.e., it has bent and bowed to societial norms, allowing itself to become dilluted in its message in an effort, initially, to survive, now to grow. Mormonism, however, is more "on message" and is more willing to expel members who do not adhere to the tenents of the religion than, say, the Catholic heirachy is willing to do. (Although, the message concerning abortion in the near past towards some prominent politicans who support abortion -- even from the Pope -- seem to support a new-found willingness to require that Catholics actually practice what the Church teaches. However, the unwillingness of the Pope to excommunicate our Speaker for her support of abortion sends the message that I stated above -- what value this religion if those who teach it don't require that those who follow it actually follow those teachings?) What is at the core of the birth and ultimate destruction of any religion (compare to Buddhism) is the same thing -- someone announces that he/she has discovered the truth and that this one truth is the only means to eternal salvation. What good is it otherwise? If the "new" religion (whether advocated by Jesus, Smith, Mohammed, Moon, Moses, Buddah, or whomever) doesn't offer a different path to salvation (or an end to eternal suffering) what purpose does it serve someone to begin believing it rather than the one that preceeded it? The "new" religion must state that all other religions are false. Again, if it doesn't, what purpose does it have? If all religions can lead to the same result (eternal salvation/end to never-ending suffering), then why the existence of the "new" religion? This is the core of all religions, i.e, it is the one and only truth; it is the sole path to "salvation;" all other religions are false. Two religions which have different paths and beliefs to salvation cannot live side-by-side for long so long as those who adhere to those religions actually believe what they profess to believe. They must believe that all those who do not adhere to their religion are damned to eternal suffering if not actively seeking to persuade them to join them in that venture since all religions have the command to "witness" and to convert the unbelievers. But, in Western Civilization, we must suffer these other religions to exist. That has a price. We cannot engage in conversations about religion where the ultimate conclusion (on all sides) is that "You and your family are going to Hell because you are (fill in the blank) instead of (fill in the blank.)" That is unacceptable behavior. The collary of this is that acceptable behavior is the equivocation of one religion to the next. You will never hear the Pope say "All Jews are going to Hell." It just ain't Kosher. You will hear the leadership of all major religions give credence to the beliefs of all other major religions, stating such bon mots as "It is simply a different path to salvation." Thus the seed of destruction is contained in the very thing which creates the religion; the very uniqueness of the religion, its only purpose, bringing souls to salvation through the teachings of that religion and no other becomes a teaching of equivocation where all religions are equal and there's no purpose of being a member of one rather than another. So, Catholics raise Catholics; Protestants raise Protestants, and once they come of age and are able to engage in untutored critical thinking...they realize that there's really no difference between religions or, for that matter, between being a Catholic and believing in crystals. After all, it's their leadership who preach this equivocation.
Old Goat
Another point is that the extent to which the fanatical factions extended. It didn't extend to every member of the particular faith, it was lead by small factions that got a lot of "press" if you will. Most is regional where extreme views take hold and root. I do believe that a large number of leaving churches and denominations due to changing views within their church bodies. Gay ministers, gay marriages, preaching on what the bible actually says as compared to bending the word to fit the world views around us are all contributing to this. The Word is being compromised and more concern is over not offending someone than on what is the true teachings of the scriptures. The 60's is when the pervading views starting coming out of the closet and into mainstream. Global Warming and other such faith based science is replacing religion for a large number of people. The Revelation points toward a one world secular church, a religion that embraces all and consequently nothing.
Andy
Cosmic: Thanks for posting this. I enjoyed reading what this guy has to say. Much of what he, you, Drax, Dadman, and Old Goat wrote ring true in my noggin. I have many thoughts on the comments...which I will keep to myself. I'm a quiet, non-confrontational suck up... :) Many of the points that the author of the article makes are very familiar to me as a Christian. Many millions of us who profess Jesus Christ as our Savior have abandoned the Evangelical Churches. I think the dude makes a good observation that in the future Christianity may well return to it's primitive roots. I don't believe that Roman Catholicism will see a big influx...but I can see the "house church" deal that he mentions. And I do believe that true Christianity flourishes in times of "unpopularity." You could call it persecution, or whatever...but when Christians are under real pressure to either live the faith, or walk the way of the world...that is when one's faith is either raised exponentially, or exposed to be fraudulent. I don't know if that makes sense or not... The guy makes a good point that young people in what most of us know as the Evangelical Church really don't know "why" they are there...or why their parents are there for that matter. The mega-church deal has truly divorced young people from "doctrine." It really is more about the event, and the experience than it is the solid understanding of Jesus, and how He'll get you through the struggles of life. Just one thing about this old boy's article that really raised a red flag with me. And it's probably just "me." Near the end, he wrote, "I'm no prophet..." In my experience, (take this with a grain of salt, seeing as I am almost always wrong) someone who writes, or says, "I'm no prophet," really thinks that they are. Interesting stuff Cosmic.
Old Goat
Andy, I agree with you on the point of where the Christian faith will probably go back to its roots, so to speak. Organized churches that have broken away from the Catholic church are varied in how they reach out to membership. One thing that seems to be a growing trend with a lot of them is secularism that is pushing them to be accepting of things that are contradicted in the Bible. It is this very contradiction that is the root cause of driving people away from the faith in the organization because it is pretty much saying that despite the Word of God is what gives authority to their faith, certain things can be excluded. Once you do that it calls everything into question. I disagree with Drax about the religions being the same. While all faiths have basic tenants which drive those of their followers, there are fundamental principles which are core values that are in opposition. There are components of faith that are not able to be explained and believed. It has to be felt to be understood. Andy, the Bible warns of false prophets, but it also talks in the Revelation that young men will have visions and old men will dream dreams. Increasingly we are hearing of such visions and dreams. It is difficult to know which of the warnings we are to follow with these. I guess its a matter of faith. ;) BTW, many of the prophets of old didn't think they were prophets either.
Drax
Old Goat: You misunderstand what I said (not what I meant...but what I said). I said: "What is at the core of the birth and ultimate destruction of any religion (compare to Buddhism) is the same thing — someone announces that he/she has discovered the truth and that this one truth is the only means to eternal salvation." This is a clear statement that, not only are all religions fundamentally different in their core tenents, but their core tenents are mutually exclusive, i.e., one can not believe all the tenents of one religion while believing all those of another. I said: "Thus the seed of destruction is contained in the very thing which creates the religion; the very uniqueness of the religion, its only purpose, bringing souls to salvation through the teachings of that religion and no other becomes a teaching of equivocation where all religions are equal and there’s no purpose of being a member of one rather than another." This section clearly states that, while the religions themselves are unique the teachers of those religions equivocate so that the adherents can't discern any difference, i.e., the leaders of each major religion state, in one way or another, that all the other major religions have credence and are simply a different path to the same destination. Of course, I except the leaders of fundamental, fanatical Islamicism from this paradigm. I agree that today's "watered down" version of Christianity leaves its adherents with a befuddled mind, wondering why on earth they belong to a church which doesn't have a clear cut set of values (tenents) which it preaches and requires its members (including its leadership) to actualy adhere to.
CosmicConservative
Andy, Well, I'm no prophet, but I think this is a subject that deserves some serious debate and (pun fully intended) soul-searching.
Old Goat
Drax, while it seems on the surface that it is the same destination, descriptions of that destination are vastly different. I do get what you are driving at. Something that has me puzzled lately is the Bible talks about other gods. We tend to rationalize this as being material type things that drive us, such as wealth and distractions of false items that are set up to worship. Seeing the variety of different faiths around the world and thinking also about the native american's having multiple gods makes me wonder if the meaning of it as stated in the Bible are meant literally. That there are other powerful beings that have at different times been worshiped. Satan could be viewed as such and is widely accepted in church doctrine as a being rather than just a means to embody evil. He is talked about being a fallen angel that once had a close relationship with God. Islam has roots in worshiping the moon god. It has morphed into having ties with the Bible and yet it also criticizes the Bible as having been adulterated and changed. Anyway, that is going WAY off topic, but in a convoluted manner may be the reason we do have many different religions. This new one springing up with Global Warming is just an extension of worship of the Earth Mother.
Drax
What I'm saying is rather simple: Religion without enforced instruction becomes a club. Church, rather than a place to receive instruction (to be later assidiously followed) becomes a place of socialization only -- to receive "fellowship." Once a religion loses its force as the revealed word of the godhead, the divine word of which its leaders instruct and to which it adherents adhere -- it just ain't much of a religion anymore.
CosmicConservative
Goat: Yeah, I once asked a minister at my church who the "other gods" mentioned in the Bible were. I also asked him if God is the only true god, who turned the Pharoah's clerics' staves into snakes to be eaten by Moses' superior staff-snake? Similarly who were the other people living in the "Land of Nod" from whom Adam and Eve's descendents found mates? Where are the dragons that would live in the benighted lands that god smote "forever?" Etc. etc... I frequently tell people that my problems with the Bible come from actually having READ the dang book. There is definitely a strong connection between the Global Warming religion and Gaia worship. No doubt about it.
Andy
Cosmic: Good pun! Yep...if there ever was a time for "soul searching" in our day, this is it. Hmmm...I wonder who one "BS1959" might be...I've got my suspicions. ;) Old Goat: I know that this is nit-picky and not relevant to the thrust of this thread. But... you wrote that "many prophets of old didn't think they were prophets either." Now, I'm no Biblical scholar, but my memory of the Old Testament is that the prophets normally started with something like (paraphrased) "The word of the LORD came to me and said, 'Stand up and prophesy to Israel. I'm gonna remove their herbs & give them extra double misery & subject them to another catastrophe, a bad king, and the pox if they don't straighten up and fly right!' " There may have been prophets of old that didn't really think they were...and I'm sure that there were many that battled the task before relenting. And I'm sure that there are many roaming the Earth today that don't really think they are. But, when I read the writer of the article stating, "I'm not a prophet," it brings to mind TOO MANY that I've come across. They use that phrase, and then begin to tell you what's gonna happen. I have known personally many people that I perceive to be prophets of God. And they are not afraid to take the mantle. They just "own it." It's like, "Hey, God told me to say this." I can deal with that. Like I said...not relevant to the thread...it was just on my mind. Sorry for rambling so long. And oh yeah, my goat-brother...if Christians were as committed to their "faith" as the global warming adherents are...well...
Dadman
Andy: BS1959 ain't me...in case that is what you were suspecting. I've learned to stay far, far away from religious-based threads. In fact, I'm way too close to it now... ;)
CosmicConservative
Andy, based on the polls I've seen, the faith of the Goracle followers has been tested lately, and many have been found lacking. When they see the 25% surcharge on their electric bills for "cap and trade" fees, their faith will be tested even more.
Andy
Dadman: I didn't suspect that BS1959 was you. I was thinking of a female... That definitely ain't you! You're probably wise to back off. I probably shouldn't have clogged up the blog with my own stuff. But heh, I'm pathetic. BTW, I have been reading more and more about your boy Flake on Al's internet. The boy is making a stir out there. Got all 12 fingers crossed for guys like him. Cosmic, funny! Yep, as Springtime flowers get killed by ice and snow in Gore's Warm New World, and Coloradans dig out in June, and "if" cap and trade fees start hitting all those poor old folks when the light bill comes... I just "Hope" it can be "Changed" before it's too late. There is an upside though to the coming global cooling...Dadman will only have to roast at 107 degrees in February, instead of the normal 119.
Dadman
Heh. My wife and I actually had dinner with Jeff a couple weeks ago. Well, to be completely fair it was a large event with many people in attendance. He was a couple tables over. :)
Dadman
Oh...I know who BS1959 is!(insert lightbulb going off here)
Andy
Yeah Dadman...I knew you and Jeff were tight. Seriously, from what I can tell he's the kind of guy that could step up from the shadows and go yard. There is a lot of chatter on the Gore-net about him for real. So many good guys like him are lost "through attrition." They never get enough steam in their Party...and finally lose heart and fade away. That's why I've got my fingers crossed for the boy. I would pray for him, but my prayers are guaranteed to bring destruction (GUARANTEED!!!), so I'll just HOPE!
Dadman
Okay, here's the deal with me and Jeff Flake. We both graduated from BYU in 1986 with a B.A. in International Relations. Our paths crossed in class and on campus on occasion. After going in different directions for a few years we both ended up in the same community (Ahwatukee) here in AZ in the early/mid 90s. My daughter was in a singing group organized and conducted by his wife. He also attended my nephew's wedding. And the other night we shared a lovely dinner together at an event organized by United Families International. I just can't shake the guy! But were not 'tight' by any means.
Dadman
BTW, given that Flake is a deluded cult member doing Satan's bidding (TIC), he will have to endure the same nonsense Romney did in a national political campaign. Might be tough for him to go yard...
CosmicConservative
Well, maybe he can hide behind Romney long enough that people get bored with attacking Mormons. I don't know enough about him to have an opinion on his national appeal. I hear Newt is contemplating a run for President in 2012. If so it's going to be hard for anyone to beat him.
Drax
CC: Do you mean it will be hard for anyone to beat Newt for the Republican nomination or for the Presidency? I can almost see him winning the nomination, but really can't see him winning the Presidency.
CosmicConservative
Yes, that's what I mean, I mean Newt will be tough to beat in a Republican primary.
Old Goat
Newt mentioned he would run if he felt there was the need. I got the feeling that he wouldn't be running if there were a viable candidate. Romney's religion played a bit of a role in his candidacy, but I don't think it was as big a role as some of his views. He is perceived as liberal in a number of ways, which hurt him with some of the conservative base. I think Newt would be like Fred Thompson. Jumping in too late and not really having the desire and heart for it.
Drax
Old Goat: I disagree. I think that there is nothing in the entire world that Newt would rather be than President. I think that he wants it so much that if he thought he had a shot at it, he would jump at it and give it everything he had. Newt, from the earliest age, wanted to be in Politics so that he could effect change, and no one in the Civilizized World can effect more change than can the President, especially one with a vision coupled with the ability to communicate it to the American People. Newt has both. Newt, however, is HATED. Hated in Washington -- hated by the MSM. He was vilified -- pilloried -- as none other than Bush II and Reagan has been. He was "the Grinch." He was mean. He wanted to throw old people into the street. He stepped over the homeless (if he didn't step ON them.) It is POSSIBLE that the increased face-time he would receive as a candidate would diminish this impression of him with the citizenry and he could get his message across. And, depending on just how bad things get under Obama, it's also possible that the voters might actually LISTEN to him -- as they did Reagan while the memory of Carter was still fresh in their minds. (And, I don't think we can diminish the effect of his face-time as a commentator might have as well. Heck, I think that even Karl Rove is no longer thought of as a demon since he came out from "behind the curtain" and began his career as a commentator...)
Old Goat
Any and all true conservatives are hated in Washington and the MSM. Newt had the opportunity to run this time around and didn't. He talked a little about it, but it never went anywhere. I don't disagree that he would love to be President, but I don't know if he wants to go through that whole process. His talk and actions remind me of how Thompson ran. Reluctant and indecisive, which may be the qualities that will win next time if Obama's campaign remains as spectacularly poor as it has been so far. (Obama is still thinking he is campaigning and not actually running things.)
Drax
Old Goat: True conservatives are, in general, thought of as troglodytes by the MSM and the Washington elite. Successful conservatives who are actually able to put into effect their beliefs are hated. The last election was a "lost election." NO ONE of any substance thought that ANY Republican candidate stood a chance in hell of getting elected. (I did -- and stand by that still...) There's no way Newt, a student of politics who is unsurpassed in this regard, would have wasted his one shot at running in that environment. None. Instead he is spending his time on the airways as a commentator, much, much more time doing so than he had in the previous eight years. He is going to gather forces and take a look at it in 2012. If he thinks he has a legitimate shot, I think he'll take it. If he doesn't, he'll just continue his work in opposition through the airways and behind the scenes.