Today, the Bilsons' family life is a lot calmer and quieter. That's because Marissa and her parents, John and Mary, are following the rules that were made during a five-day intervention. The intervention was provided to them free by the group Autism Partnership, or AP. Usually this type of treatment costs about $20,000 a week, and it's not covered by insurance, but because CNN was allowed to videotape the entire process, AP waived the fee for the Bilsons. The intensive, one-on-one, in-home therapy was meted out by behavioral therapist Rick Schroeder, who used a technique of behavior modification known as "applied behavior analysis" or ABA. ABA essentially breaks down behavior patterns in order to reward good behavior and not reward bad behavior. Essentially, it's all about laying down the rules and sticking to them in a way that Marissa can understand.I have a few comments on this, some good, some bad, all far more personal than I usually get on this blog. So this is a bit of a departure for me. First I need to say that I completely sympathize with and understand the Bilson's situation. Before the intervention in interveiws with Mary Bilson the sheer exhaustion and resignation in her words as she recounts how the family feels like a prisoner in her own home, unable to do basic normal "family" activities such as going shopping or eating out for dinner, those words are poignant and reflect the life impact that thousands of families go through every day. This inability to function as a "normal family" is one of the most difficult aspects of dealing with autism. The sheer exhaustion of making the effort to have some semblence of a normal life is enough to drive many families to the brink of destruction. I know. We've been there. Second, I also need to say that every person tends to view their own situation as intolerable when they are struggling, whether that person is a homeless man on the street, or Lindsey Lohan temporarily unable to fly first class. We all tend to magnify our problems as we confront them. In reading through the Bilson's account I am filled with sympathy not only because of the similarity to our situation, but by my unexpected realization that our situation seems to actually be far better than theirs. And that is an absolute revelation since I tend to view our troubles as being nearly intolerable. Yes we have had to deal with great difficulties and crushing embarrassment in public. There is very little I have endured that is as devastatingly humiliating as trying to stop your son from banging his head on a brick wall at a movie theater because an unexpected snowfall forced us to change our plans and not go to Wal-mart as he wanted. But as horrifying and humiliating as those episodes have been, in comparison to the Bilson's situation I have come to realize that we have managed to deal with those well enough that we have been able to go out to eat, watch movies, go shopping, and in general the results have been frequently frustrating, but only rarely mortifying. We have not had to become prisoners in our own home the way the Bilson's seem to have. So as with many things I need to learn to appreciate what we have instead of pointlessly wishing for things that other people have. Families who don't have to deal with autism somehow still manage to fall apart in spite of what appears to me to be a life that should be full of joy and appreciation of their unrecognized good fortune. Third, in spite of the "transcendant" tone of the stories, and the glowing reports of the parents after the intervention, I hope CNN follows up with this family in six months and a year to see how long this "sticks." I am frankly deeply suspicious of this sort of "big bang" approach to such deeply ingrained problems. Living with autism is difficult to describe to people, not that I'm much inclined to do so anyway. My personal experience with family, friends, relations and coworkers has made it clear that no matter how much sympathy such people express, they really aren't interested in sharing the difficulties of the situation with the family who has the autistic member. It's simply too strange and uncomfortable for the vast majority of people to care to deal with, and as a result there isn't a lot of support to lean on for the family. This is a large part of the reason the Bilson's described their lives as "prisoners in their own home." You won't have much of a social life if people come over and experience a couple of autistic meltdowns. I've yet to meet anyone who doesn't secretly say to themselves "I'd never put up with that!" This judgment of the family leads to a steady reduction in social interaction until such interaction tends to cease entirely. My concern is that the Bilsons are literally in a post-intervention glow in part because they simply have had an experience where they have gone from virtually no social interaction to an intensive interaction with a group of people who not only express great interest in their lives, but who do not judge them overtly or covertly. This is powerful stuff. I frankly don't think I can describe to people who aren't in a similar situation how powerful that can be. And because of that I am concerned about the likelihood that the Bilsons will be able to maintain their enthusiasm and resolve to stick to the behavior modification program. I sincerely hope that in six months they are not right back where they were before, and feeling even more guilty and remorseful for their "backsliding." The biggest challenge for them to overcome in the long term is going to be living with the discipline required to maintain the behavior modification. Having taken that same approach ourselves, I know how hard it is to follow that discipline day after day, week after week, month after month, year after year... That creates a situation where coming home from a hard day at work does not necessarily mean a chance to relax and recharge, instead it means a need to focus and apply that discipline rigorously for every waking hour. It's hard folks. It's the hardest thing I've ever attempted. And I know how far short of that goal I have come. Bottom line though is that these stories have given me a greater appreciation of how lucky we are that our son is not totally out of control in the way that the Bilson's daughter was. Such an intervention might be very helpful to us, and I am looking into it, but $20,000 is nothing to sneeze at even in flush times, much less as we are heading into potentially the deepest global recession of my adult life. Still, I encourage you to read and watch the clips of the story if you have any desire at all to understand the lives of a family with an autistic child. If you have no desire, that's fine too of course.
Living with Autism
By CosmicConservativeCNN has been running a series of stories on a family living with an autistic teenage daughter. The series has been following an "intervention" by a group which offers intensive behavioral modification therapy. The therapy generally costs about $20,000 for the five day intervention, none of which is covered by insurance.
As some of you know, the Cosmic son is autistic, so I have been reading the stories with some interest. Here's a short excerpt from the story.
Comments (1)