Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

News reports Scooter Libby claims White House 'Superiors' Authorized Leaks

By CosmicConservative
FOXNews.com - Politics News - Libby: White House 'Superiors' Authorized Leaks The money quote:
The NIE is a report prepared by the head of the nation's intelligence operations for high-level government officials, up to and including the president. Portions of NIEs are sometimes declassified and made public. It is unclear whether that happened in this instance.
This is a really poorly written headline and story. The headline and the first part of the story give the definite impression that Libby was authorized to leak the name of Valerie Plame which is, of course, what the Grand Jury is supposedly investigating. But as the quote above makes clear is that the supposed "leak" is not clearly a leak at all. Libby provided some information from the NIE report. And why is this relevant? Because this particular NIE report is the one that showed that all of the nation's varied intelligence agencies unanimously agreed that Iraq had WMD before the Iraq invasion. Now, is it within the power of the administration to declassify information? Of course it is. So if Libby's "superiors" were Cheney or Bush, even if this story is true, there is no reason to believe it was a violation of any law, or even of any tradition. Presidents and Vice Presidents have routinely made classified information public in the past. So why is this story even being reported? That's a good question. Shame on you Fox, for playing the same game as CNN and the other MSM outlets. At least you could have written a headline that did not mislead, and could have focused the story on the actual contents that were made public. Gee, didn't the NY Times just make a huge case for the importance of leaking critical information that is within the public's "right to know?" Doesn't it seem reasonable that on the eve of going to war the US Public deserved to know that every agency in the world believed that Iraq was a threat and had WMD? The double standards in the media are getting unbelievable.

Comments (6)

Tank
On this topic it would be reasonable for you to acknowledge that when you are talking about consensus among the world's intelligence agencies on WMD evidence as it effects the Plame affair that they all agreed with the Wilson assessment that the Nigerian Yellowcake story was bullshit based on VERY poorly faked documents. At the end of the day WMD evidence as it relates to the Plame/Wilson was entirely fabricated. You might want to ask for a different talking point.
CosmicConservative
Tank: I think I am completely reasonable, as I am sure you think you are. The yellow cake uranium story was challenged in the White House during the CIA presentation and was considered to be less than credible, but it was not nearly the only intelligence leading every nation on earth to believe Iraq had WMD. You need to be reasonable and admit that the great majority of intelligence on WMD which was presented and agreed to by the UN itself in multiple resolutions included evidence (including Saddam's previous use of) literally tons of chemical and biological weapons. Your focus on this tiny and virtually irrelavent story about the credibility of yellow cake uranium as somehow being critical to the decision to invade Iraq or not is either disingenuous, or else it is overlooking the highly credible accounts of other types of WMD.
Tank
Rather than calling it disingenuous perhaps you'd be good enough to explain what WMD evidence other than the Niger uranium has to do with the topic of the Vice President's office leaking the name of Plame while criticising the Wilson findings. Or are you being just as disingenuous in not acknowledging the threat of Chinese ballistic missile development when referring to the Plame affair ?
CosmicConservative
First of all, there is no charge against Libby or the Vice President of "leaking the name of Plame" in the first place, so you are simply asserting something that is not proven. Secondly, there have been multiple investigations into the White House use of intelligence and so far every one of them has vindicated the White House. Thirdly even if the White House did put Valerie Plame's name out there (which is not proven, nor even charged at this time) it is not even remotely clear that she was "covert" at the time. In fact according to the statute that covers covert agents, she was not covert at the time. Which is actually a major reason why Fitzgerald has brought no charges at this time. I won't even go into the inanity of charging a person for obstruction of justice when no crime is alleged to have been committed. What's he covering up Tank? On Joe Wilson himself. If you can't see that the whole Niger yellow cake uranium deal was a set up from the start, you're not looking hard. The real story of the Wilson Niger trip is how the CIA attempted a covert coup against this President because they felt that Bush had put the blame for 9/11 on failures of the CIA. And you should go back and read the actual notes of Wilson's "investigation." They actually imply that the uranium sale was credible, not the reverse. But back to the reason the Niger stuff is irrelevent to this story. The whole point of this story is to somehow imply that the White House approved leaking of classified information in the Plame case, and that has not been proven, nor has it even been alleged. The document in question here is actually one that has been declassified for years, and it isn't even clear from the news story if the declassification happened before or after Libby supposedly shared the information. There is a lot more to this Plame story than has come out in my opinion. Maybe it never will come out. I don't know. But it has convinced me that there is a serious effort within the CIA to undercut the Bush administration's goals in the War on Terror. Why? My guess is that it is ideological and that the rabid symptoms of Bush Derangement Syndrome exist even within the CIA itself.
Tank
Let me get this straight... You've posted the story about the Vice President's office authorising the leak of Plame's ID. However if I refer to the topic then I'm making unsubstantiated claims. Meanwhile the WMD evidence directly involved and central in this affair is irrelevant while all the other WMD evidence not involved in this affair is apparently being overlooked if not addressed and you are disingenuous if you don't incorporate it into your understanding of something it doesn't relate to. Clearly you have your own ideas of where you'd like the goalposts and will at some point settle on something that both your comments and original blog post can agree on. I wish both of you the best of luck with it.
CosmicConservative
Tank: You are completely misunderstanding me. I posted the story and pointed out that the NEWS REPORTS are playing it up to make it appear to be related to the Plame leak, when it is not. That was my point. I'm sorry I didn't make it better. My only point on the Niger uranium story is that it was one tiny part of a much larger WMD concern and the focus on the Niger story is way out of proportion to the actual impact it had on the decision to go into Iraq. The biological and chemical WMD were the primary WMD concerns.