Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

What good is a high school education?

By CosmicConservative
For that matter, what good is a college degree? I recently found myself in an online conversation about high school learning with several young adults, some of whom are still in high school, but most of whom are now in college. The conversation began when one young adult bemoaned the time they needed to spend studying in order to pass their courses. Another older participant attempted to encourage the first commenter by saying how valuable a high school degree had been in his own life. To which the first commenter said something along the lines of "yeah, but school is so much harder now than it was when you were in high school." This got my attention, and I could not help but get engaged in the discussion. I pointed out that I had a child in college and a child in high school and that I was still fairly intimately involved in both of their educations, reviewing papers, helping with math or other "hard sciences" etc. As such I felt that I had a pretty good idea of how "tough" modern high school and undergraduate college is, at least in the schools they attend (both of which are considered above average in test scores for nationwide high schools or colleges). So I said that my personal opinion was that school was certainly no harder today than it was 30 years ago. This ignited a firestorm of mostly polite discussion about the difference between high schools of today and of 30 years ago. To the assertion that high school kids today had harder coursework, I put that to the test by posing what I thought were some pretty basic questions to the youngsters, including the following: 1. Which of the Bill of Rights describes the right of Due Process? 2. Which branch of the US Government has the constitutional power to declare war? 3. Which branch of the US Government has the responsibiltiy to ratify international treaties? 4. What is the purpose of the electoral college? 5. How many of you have learned to solve a first order differential equation? 6. Which of the following was the country the US first initiated armed combat with in WWII (Italy, Germany, Japan)? 7. In what country was the "potato famine" of the nineteenth century? 8. Who was the first person to lead a round-the-world navigation? In general the answers to the above were invariably wrong by the youngsters, who were then quickly corrected by the oldsters. (Surprisingly to me, the one all the kids got right was the electoral college one. I suppose we can thank Bush vs. Gore for that.) Now I believe I learned all those things in High School. It was clear that today's kids are not taught any of this. Some of this I learned well before high school. In spite of their dismal performance in my on-the-spot quiz, the young adults insisted that their course work was harder than mine was 30+ years ago. I conceded that some of the specific stuff about WWII might be potentially dated (although I don't agree that it is), and I agreed that teaching first-order differential equations in high school should really only be done for advanced college prep students (which it may have been even at good ol' BHS... I think we covered that in the HS physics class taught by the avuncular Mr. Tully). But the rest I considered to be basic stuff that is as important today as it has been since 1789, when our current constitution was ratified and became the law of the land. So anyway, I'm wondering what other people think. My personal opinion is that schools today do a horrible job of teaching basic civics, math, history and english skills. Certainly I use words that I consider to be commonplace and am frequently asked to explain what they mean. So what are your thoughts? Are we raising a generation of ignoramuses? Or is it just generational differences and what kids are taught today is just as relevant and just as difficult as what we learned in the caveman days?

Comments (15)

Lisa
My son is in the 10th grade. A couple of months into the school year, I got an email from his "Writing Essentials" teacher bragging about what a marvelous student he was -- creative, expressive, blah blah blah. She asked me if I'd seen his "Most Admired Person" essay and that if I hadn't I really needed to. She said she held it up to the class as an example of "how to do it right." Well. I asked my son that night if I could read his paper, and he showed it to me. I was appalled. Not that he'd written it about Ghandi (hee), but that the grammar and punctuation was ATROCIOUS and had not been graded. AT. ALL. I was tempted to edit it and send it back to her, but was afraid it would look like I'd opened a vein over it. I asked a friend who is an English teacher at the same high school if that was normal, and she sighed and said yes. Apparently, it's more important that they "get their ideas down on paper" than it is that they, you know, SPELL and PUNCTUATE. I pointed out that maybe they should worry that no one can freaking understand "their ideas," when it's practically unreadable. She agreed, but shrugged. That's the way it is today. I feel sorry for us in 10-15 years. No one will be able to communicate.
CosmicConservative
I have had similar experiences with my childrens' teachers. In fact some of the biggest arguments I've had with my daughter over her homework was that I had higher standards than her teacher. I tried to tell her that what was important was what HER standards were, not her teacher's. I think I finally got through to her, she now wants to be a writer and writes pretty darn well.
CosmicConservative
I think the thing that bothered me most about how they teach in school now is how much kids rely on calculators to do simple math. Isaac Asimov wrote a short story half a century ago about computers becoming so dominant in human civilization that humans literally lost the skill to add and subtract. I hope that remains pure fiction. But I dunno...
Foobarista
I certainly didn't learn the math to know what a differential equation in HS, as I went to a crappy gang-banger high school where math ended at Algebra II. I did learn all the others between dodging gang wars and local drug dealers. I wish I could have jumped from the tenth grade or so right to junior college, where I finally found decent math and science teachers. The English and history instruction was decent.
pace
One explanation for what you encountered in those young individuals is the fact that their brains are simply exposed to a massive amount more stimuli and information than we ever had available. Consequently, I believe they forget seemingly useless facts (from the perspective of a 14 year old) as quickly as they learn them. I experience this myself - finding that I possess snippets of information on an incresingly broad range of topics, while becoming less and less knowledgable on any singular subject as I get older. There's no doubt that schools have placed less focus on grammar, spelling, and elementary mathematics and sciences in favor of creative thinking, but they are not entirely to blame for the apparent loss of knowledge. Parents share a good deal of the responsibility, when they'd rather let their kids play video games all day instead of actually engaging them in learning exercises. Incidentally, I studied Advanced (A-Level) Math in the UK. But I very much doubt I could solve anything other than the most rudimentary differential equation now.
Andy
Cosmic: You and I roamed the same high school halls. And I can tell you for certain that I could not have answered the question about a "first order differential equation." I may have been able to solve the problem if presented, but the terminology stumped me. I never was very good at math. ;) As you know, I've ushered three children (so far) through the same high school. It is interesting. None of my three sons really learned much about history, civics, or economics apart from what we taught them here at home. Don't get me wrong now. There were some basics taught to them in high school. But it was very shallow stuff. Fortunately, they are all "born readers," and I was able to throw real history books, and good historic videos in front of them to chew on. As to writing skills...man, they really suck. It drives me nuts that I had to teach all of them about Introduction, Points, and Conclusion. And as poorly as I write and spell while commenting here...I do know how to do it. It doesn't seem to be important to the teachers any longer, so it certainly won't be important to the students. I'm puzzled about this myself Cosmic. Maybe the fuchur won't rekwire sumbody to have well Anglish Skils to suckseed. I don't know. Good food for thought Cosmic.
CosmicConservative
Pace... "massive amount more stimuli and information than we ever had available...." I hear this a lot, and on the surface it would seem to be self-evident, but I think this sort of thinking ignores the incredible filtering powers of the brain. When I was in high school we had a lot of things flooding into our brains too, and I suspect the poor stone age hunter-gatherer wandering through the woods looking for a squirrel to eat also had a flood of information assaulting his brain...
CosmicConservative
Andy: I think the calculus was only in the Physics class. But the rest of my questions were in the general coursework at BHS. And the good Lord knows that I never considered BHS to be a top-notch school....
Andy
No...it wasn't a top-notch school...but it wasn't a waste of time either. I mean, look at how successful I became! ;)
Foobarista
You guys must have had a kick-butt physics teacher. One problem we had in my HS was all the decent math and science teachers would get hired away from the school by local companies that tripled their pay. I went to HS in Silicon Valley during an early tech boom and companies were hiring anyone with a pulse and a sci/tech degree, especially if they were local. My favorite HS math teacher was Mrs. Garcia, a Mexican woman with a doctorate in Math who clearly knew her stuff. The semester after I took her class, she got hired away by IBM.
CosmicConservative
Actually our physics teacher was a too-nice, avuncular, roly-poly guy who loved physics and loved to teach, but unfortunatly in my case at least, had a class full of cut-ups and reprobates who made many of the classes a frustrating exercise in rebellion to authority. Still, he presented the material, answered questions and assigned coursework all of which those in the class who cared to learn (a minority of that class I'm sure) were able to figure out during the periods when the lunatics were not running the asylum. On the other hand Mr. Anderson, our Chemistry teacher was one of the best teachers I ever had, and Mr. Williams, our Biology teacher was probably the teacher who most inspired me to pursue a hard-science degree in college. I really felt bad for Mr. Tully, he probably should have been teaching at a Jr. College or something, a situation where his students actually cared about learning. He was simply overwhelmed by a class full of cut-ups and goof-offs.
Dadman
So, what exactly were you doing online that led you into a conversation with teenagers...and are any of them now your BFF? Just wondering... ;) As I recall our nickname for Mr. Williams was 'Mr. Bill' and I loved his Biology class too.
Foobarista
For my part, I didn't really discover "love for learning" until I was in junior college (or "community college" as they're called here in Cali), after being convinced by a summer job moving furniture that I'd better get off my butt and get a college degree. The JC teachers were excellent teachers and quite dedicated to their students. The student body at my JC was about 80% Vietnamese, most of whom worked hard to get good grades and transfer to university. Frankly, my profs at UC Berkeley were mostly a disappointment after my JC experience, at least as far as teaching went. One huge exception was my math prof, who convinced me to get my degree in appl. math with a specialization in abstract machines and algorithms. (An aside: I first learned about Noam Chomsky in my languages and computer grammars class, where we studied the "Chomsky Hierarchy of Abstract Languages". I only learned he was a complete moonbat later on...)
Andy
Dadman: Nyuk, Nyuk, Nyuk... I remember Mr. Williams. That guy had the curliest hair this side of Shirley Temple. I had him for Biology II, which was an experimental "team teaching" class at the time. Mr. Williams, Big Ears Tully, and Lem Grigsby took turns on us. It was fun...