Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On Magic, verisimilitude and suspension of disbelief...

By CosmicConservative
The novel I put down almost two years ago is a fantasy story which involves extensive use of magic as part of the plot. This is true of most fantasy novels. But it is usually the way that magic is described and used in a story that I find to be the weakest part of any fantasy story. In most fantasy stories magic is simply so arbitrary and situational that it is indistinguishable from divine intervention. Harry Potter is probably the worst example of this. I like the Harry Potter books but every time Harry gets in a tight spot, I know that Rowlings will get him out of it with some new, yet-undiscovered magical ability that just happens to be exactly what he needs at exactly the right moment to keep the story going. There's no reason or rationale whatsoever behind it. If he needs to be able to cast a stronger, faster spell than the acknowledged most powerful wizard of all time, then that's what Harry does. If the spell needs to come from out of nowhere and do something no spell has ever done before, then that is what the spell does. By the way, Star Wars is a fantasy story, set in a sci-fi universe. The "Force" is just magic. Jedis are just warlocks. In other fantasy stories the author goes to great lengths to explain the rules behind the magic system and shows how the "wizards" have to study and learn to utilize the magic. Eregon is like that. The "magic" is all in the "true language" words that hold all the power in the universe. Usually those books try to keep some sense of limitation to what magic can do, but usually the author finds ways around their own built-in limitations to advance the story line. Again the Eregon series is a classic example of this with the reader first being told that magic is limited to the physical power that a person can generate from their own body, but as the story develops and more and more powerful magical spells are needed to advance the story and enhance the crises, suddenly tools, techniques and artifacts appear which get around this limitation, and we are back to magic having arbitrary limits and capabilities as needed for the author to get their hero out of a jam. I hate that. The Lord of the Rings had a unique perspective on magic, and a unique means of describing the use of magic to the reader. We are told that Gandalf is a wizard early on, and he demonstrates his wizardness at first through the use of fireworks, a specialty of Gandalf's. The fireworks show at the long awaited party is very skillfully done for a modern reader because the fireworks are just magical enough to tantalize, but described as recognizable chemical-powered rockets and devices. The reader is left to wonder how much "magic" is actually in play with Gandalf's wizardry. In fact in the entire book Gandalf's first-hand descriptions of magic are quite rare, and when done, are quite subtle. Gandalf uses his staff and a burst of his magic to start a fire in a snow-sodden pile of wood. And as he does so he complains "There, I have said 'Gandalf is here!' to anyone who cares to see." This was wonderfully done because it was a life-saving use of magic beyond the ability of any mortal present, yet was nothing more than lighting a fire in the cold, and yet the use of it was fraught with danger because of the recognizable signature his magic carried with it. This conflict betwen Gandalf's well-known magical powers and the danger inherent in their use is almost unique in literature. His most blatant uses of his power are described only as remote events at the time, as in the unusual flashes of light on Weathertop, or as after-the-fact descriptions of the results, again as on Weathertop where Aragorn and the hobbits find the hill scorched and burned from the terrible energies weilded between Gandalf and the Nazgul king. Now we have EVIDENCE of Gandalf's power, but we still don't SEE it. It's left almost entirely to the imagination. Perhaps the most overt use of magic in the entire book was when Gandalf went to save Farimer from the Orcs at Osgiliath and we see then that he raised his HAND to direct white bolts of energy at the Nazgul. But even then Gandalf was only able to fend them off, his bolts did not reduce the Nazgul to cinders upon contact. One of the reasons I love the Lord of the Rings books is precisely because Tolkien managed to deal with magic in such a way that the reader is left with the IMPRESSION that Gandalf is a supremely powerful magician, but virtually all of Gandalf's magic is hidden, subtle, or of a seemingly minor nature when compared to other wizards in literature. But Gandalf's magic was BELIEVABLE. I never had any problem suspending my disbelief with Gandalf. I was convinced of his power, and awed by his self-control. Magic was something to be used responsibly and sparingly precisely BECAUSE of its power. There are subcurrents that Saruman's fall was, at least in part, due to his pride in using his own magical abilities, and a major sub-theme of the book was the temptation to abuse power, especially magical power. OK, so I probably went on too long about Gandalf and his use of magic.... The point is that in the novel I was writing, I wanted magic to be more like LOTR magic than most fantasy novels. I wanted it to be powerful, subtle and mostly hidden, but lurking like a tiger in the weeds, ready to pounce on the unwary. So as I started working on the book, I tried to create a set of rules for magic that I felt would allow me to create such an experience for the reader. And you know what? It's hard. And what I found is that it's even harder to stick to it once you get the story going. In fact, in rereading it, I find the magic system to be annoying to me now. I don't like it at all. So now I'm figuring I'll have to rewrite all the parts where the protagonist or anyone else in the story is using magic. And I know that the desire to rewrite a story is one of the great threats to completion of a novel... But still, even I don't "believe" the magic in my story. It must be fixed.... So back to the drawing board.

Comments (8)

Cullen
Cosmic, knowing that you play RPGs, have you ever played any of the White Wolf games, particularly Mage? The White Wolf magic system is pretty cool. They pull a lot of their lore from many different sources. Basically, magicians are able to tap into "ley lines." Magic isn't necessarily something mysitcal, but rather is imposing someone's belief on the physical world (also kind of a Green Lantern thingy there). The great thing about this is the "equal and opposite reaction" for the use of magic. There is, for lack of a better term, a "physics police" that makes sure reality works the way reality is supposed to and if a magician breaks the rules too much or in too obvious a way, he can cause all kinds of nasty things to happen both to himself and the physical world around him. They call is paradox. In game play, every time a magician uses magic, they also earn paradox. It's a pretty clever game system. The Wikipedia entry is pretty good.
Cullen
Yikes. I really need to preview my comments before posting when I'm doing too many things at the same time.
CosmicConservative
Cullen: The only RPGs I have played are: Everquest (MMORPG) Everqest II (MMORPG) World of Warcraft (MMORPG) Baldur's Gate (RPG) Oblivion (RPG) Might and Magic (RPG) Neverwinter Nights (RPG) I haven't played "Mage" but that sounds like an intriguing system. It's sort of interesting to compare RPG and MMORPG magic to the literary variety. In RPGs, particularly table-top RPGs, magic is a very utilitarian thing, it isn't simply about doing damage to an enemy. In MMORPGs that's about the extent of the value of magic. Oh, you can make food and transport folks around a bit, but the vast, vast majority of magic use is directed at hammering down an opponent's health or hit points. I think that's a great weakness of MMORPGs. I think that's one reason they get a bad rap from some people. The same is true of non-magic characters, my rogue is non-magical but other than picking locks and picking pockets, pretty much all of her rogue abilities are just about getting more damage out of her weapons. I think the next big MMORPG is going to take elements from systems like "Second Life" and try to create a far more social experience where fighting is only one way to advance in the game. Believe me, I get tired of visiting genocide on poor overmatched denizens of WoW, even when it is advancing my character's skills or goals.
Jack
CC, Do you have any science fiction ideas you're working on? Since you have a Bachelor's degree in physics, Hard SF might be right up your alley. Your background and your blog writing reminds me a bit of Larry Niven. He was my favorite author of Hard SF from the mid-seventies to the early nineties. He still is but I don't read as much SF as I used to. I'm not much of a fantasy novel reader, but whatever book you write, I'll buy a copy!
CosmicConservative
I wrote a couple of sci-fi short stories. The first one I wrote, back when I was still in high school, was about an artificial intelligence that achieved self-awareness. This led to all sorts of difficulties and when he and his creators applied for citizenship, resulting in a massive worldwide protest, a group of religious fundamentalists bombed the research center, destroying the mainframe computers he "lived" on. However, just before that, unknown to any but a select few, "Frankie" had been downloaded onto what would now be called a "mini computer" and loaded on a truck and driven away. I thought it was a great story. The editor who rejected it called it "derivative". Oh well. Another was a story about an orbiting "skyhook" which was like a giant rotating wheel without a rim orbiting the earth at the equator. That was a couple of years later, when I was in physics and could actually work out the math. The spokes of the satellite counter-rotated at just the right speed so that they had zero linear velocity in relation to the earth. They dropped down to about 35,000 feet in the air, where flying spacecraft latched onto them, and were then carried into orbit and flung into a higher orbit by the angular momentum of the skyhook. To balance it out, for each ship that was carried into space, a huge chunk of metal refined from an orbiting asteroid was brought down to earth, keeping the overall energy balanced so that the cost of sending ships into high earth orbit was practically zero. The editor who rejected it called it "too far-fetched" in spite of my appendix where I had all the math proving the concept was feasible, IF you could find a material with the tensile strength necessary for the spokes. Carbon fiber, by the way, has enough tensile strength. The story was about a group of luddite flat-earther terrorists who tried to destroy the skyhook with nuclear bombs. And I wrote about half of a lame story about mining on the moon, but even I thought it was turning into "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress" and I gave up on it....
Jack
Like I said, you strike me as very Niven-like. And don't let the rejections get you down. You're in very good company. Here are some famous writers and their history with rejections: Ray Bradbury has had about a thousand rejections over his 30 year career according to a B&N interview, and says he is still getting rejected. Stephen King got the following rejection for his bestselling novel, Carrie: "We are not interested in science fiction which deals with negative utopias. They do not sell." Excerpt and paraphrased rejection letter to Ursula K. Le Guin: "The book is endlessly complicated...unreadable...dry and airless...lacking in pace...whatever drama and excitement the novel might have had is entirely dissipated... The manuscript of The Left Hand of Darkness is returned herewith." (The novel went on to win both the Hugo Award and the Nebula Award.) Madeleine L'Engle's A Wrinkle In Time was rejected by 26 publishers before being accepted. It ended up winning the John Newbery Medal as the best children's book of 1963 and is now in its 69th printing. Meg Cabot said that her Princess Diaries got rejected seventeen times before it was finally bought. "After spending six years writing the first instalment of her "Harry Potter" novels, J.K. Rowling was rejected by 9 publishers before London's Bloomsbury Publishing signed her on." The Dr. Seuss books got rejected more than 15 times before the author finally found an editor who accepted his work. Margaret Mitchell's Gone With The Wind was rejected 38 times. Richard Hooker's book, M*A*S*H was rejected 17 times. Jonathan Livingston Seagull by Richard Bach was rejected 140 times before it was eventually published. Watership Down by Richard Adams: 26 rejections. Frank Herbert's Dune was rejected nearly 20 times before being published. My own story -- Seventeen years ago: A movie distributor watched my (albeit bad) first feature film. That distributor said, and I quote, "You can't write, produce, direct or edit. You have no business being in this business. I'M in this business, so I would know!" That hurt. It hurt bad! Today: My new film, Ghost Image, is airing 11 times this month on the premium cable channels and 18 times next month! Cosmic, keep swinging that bat! You'll get a strike or hit a foul ball now and again, but in time you'll get a solid connect. You might only get a base hit to begin with. But you keep swinging, you'll keep connecting, and eventually put one out of the park. It might take 5 swings. It might take 100 swings. But you'll do it.
CosmicConservative
Well, the best advice I ever saw on writing was just two words: "Writers write." I used to do that, I used to write, write, write. Even when I knew it was never going anywhere. Then I admit I got married, had kids, built a career and frankly got discouraged about the rejections (which I used to keep in a sort of self-flagellation file) and let my writing atrophy. That was one reason I started this blog, I wanted to create a compelling reason just to keep writing so my fundamental writing skills (such as they are) did not degrade too much. Then I got what I thought was a great idea for a fantasy novel, started working on it and was really burning out page after page (I think I have about 250 pages complete) when my dad's cancer hit, and I put it down and just haven't been able to pick it back up. I think a lot of it is habit, like many things in life. When I was churning out the pages I had developed the habit of working at least an hour a day on the book. Usually that turned into two or three. But now I've got different habits. I need to get back to that "one hour per day" habit.
Jack
Before John Grisham became a full-time writer, he was a practicing attorney. He started each day with one hour of writing with the goal of doing at least one page per day. He figured that way he would have the first draft of a novel in a year. Not a bad way to start; one hour a day.