Of Myth and Message...
By CosmicConservativeSo... I've been contemplating writing again. I haven't attempted to write anything for almost two years now, in fact since my father passed away. But lately I've been thinking more often about getting back to the keyboard and putting words to paper.
As such I've been looking back over the craft part of writing, and reading up on successful techniques and the styles and practices of great writers, particularly of great fantasy or sci-fi writers.
This sort of thing inevitably leads to Joseph Campbell and his thoughts and teachings on the power of myth, the use of archetypes, and the human attraction to a particular epic story arc.
From memory the Campbellian epic myth arc goes something like this:
1. The protagonist of the story begins as a reluctant participant in their own story.
2. The protagonist carries some seed of prophetic greatness (usually genetic, but not always).
3. The antagonist (usually a demigod or even god) knows about the existence of the protagonist, but not specific enough to immediately locate them, and so seeks out the protagonist through minions or some supernatural (or technological) power.
4. The protagonist is identified and attacked, usually through his family, and barely escapes alive.
5. The protagonist is effectively forced through custom, anger or loyalty into pledging battle against the antagonist.
6. The protagonist joins forces with an aging, once-powerful source of wisdom and training who both warns the protagonist of his travails ahead, and provides wisdom and training to unlock the protagonist's prophesied abilities.
7. The protagonist joins forces with a small group of unusual, usually widely diverse allies whose abilities are not nearly as powerful as the protagonist, but whose activities serve to provide the stimulus in unlocking the protagonist's prophesied powers.
8. The protagonist meets a series of ever-more-challenging obstacles and eventually succeeds in unleashing his inner power, frequently in the process of saving one of his allies.
9. The protagonist almost succeeds in defeating the antagonist, but at the last second is betrayed by one of his supposed allies.
10. The protagonist is forced to escape, regroup and eventually engage in a final, climactic confrontation with the antagonist where the protagonist wins an overwhelming victory.
11. The protagonist is heaped with praise, adulation and acknowledgment of his fulfillment of prophesy.
Now, this particular formula has clearly been used very successfully for thousands of years. And for the most part I think Campbell gets this right. Done properly this story arc is probably the most compelling and universally engaging story arc that humans react to in a positive manner. Here is a short list of stories that follow this arc almost to the letter:
1. Gilgamesh
2. Beowulf
3. The Iliad
4. The Odyssey
5. The Lord of the Rings
6. Star Wars
7. Shane
8. The Chronicles of Narnia
9. Harry Potter
etc. etc...
And of course I love all of those stories. But there is something about that formula that has always sort of bugged me. I think I've finally sort of worked it out. The whole business of the elite superman who is born to rule, or born to excel is not very egalitarian.
I mean Harry Potter did not achieve his powers through study and practice, he was born to them. As was Luke Skywalker. Of all the stories above, probably the one that diverges most from the fundamental story arc is actually The Lord of the Rings, since Frodo and Sam represent the "everyman" and are the true heroes of the book. In most of the stories the only role the "everyman" has in the story is to serve as cannon fodder or comic relief. The stories are presented as battles between the opposing wills of the superman protagonist and the demigod antagonist. Entire villages, cities or planets can be wiped out and the reader is not led to care about their lives except as markers to prove how evil the antagonist is. In some cases even the hero lays about with abandon, creating his own mountain of innocent corpses (particularly Achilles). In fact the reader is usually presented with a choice between the personal dictates of the antagonist against that of the protagonist. There's not a lot of room for, say, democratic self-rule, involved in these stories.
So I'm wondering what that says about humans in general. Does it mean that humans truly yearn for the rule of a benevolent dictator who rules by right of divine decree?
George Lucas actually said that. One of the acknowledged themes of his Star Wars movies is that the best form of rule is a benevolent dictatorship of elites with divine powers. George actually is proud of that. I guess he doesn't care much for all the messy nonsense that surrounds a democratic society.
So now I'm trying to decide if I really should follow that story arc if I want to write a story. It's a fairly well-proven formula to attempt, and I don't deny that one of my main motivations to EVENTUALLY write a successful novel is to MAKE SOME MONEY.
But as I said, the more I think about that formula, the more I think it is a bit too elitist for my taste...
What do you think?
Comments (14)