Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Christmas movies (or other themed productions...)

By CosmicConservative
It's getting to be the time of year for Christmas movies to dominate the television schedule... Everyone has their favorites I guess. I'm not really a big fan of the genre myself, but there are definitely some I like more than others. The reason I am posting this is because I went and read several reviews of "Four Christmases" on the Rotten Tomatoes website just to see what the general opinion was of the movie. Frankly, from the previews, I can't say I have any desire whatsoever to see this movie. The older I get the less I like "comedy" based on bodily functions, over the top slapstick, ridiculous caricatures and cringeworthy dialogue. All of which was prominently on display in the previews of "Four Christmases." But that's not what prompted me to make this post. What prompted me to do so is the references in the reviews to other Christmas movies. I guess I never really considered "Christmas movie" to be an actual genre itself, but that appears to be the case. Many of the reviews were laced with references and/or comparisons to other "Christmas movies" of the past. FWIW the "best" review of "Four Christmases" that I read was that it was short enough to forgive its most glaring flaws. That's an odd way to look at a movie's quality... So what other Christmas movies did they compare it to? Here's a list: Miracle on 34th Street. It's a Wonderful Life The Santa Claus(e) (and its sequels) Elf National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation A movie conspicuously absent from the reviews' comparisons was "A Christmas Story". What surprised me was the near-unanimous disdain shown by the reviewers for "The Santa Claus(e)", a movie that the Cosmic family actually likes. I went back and read reviews from the time for "The Santa Claus(e)" and discovered that disdain was pretty widespread at the time of the movie's release, and that the reviewers actually greatly preferred the now nearly forgotten remake of "A Miracle on 34th Street" which came out a bit later that year. This reminded me that the movie "It's a Wonderful Life" was nearly universally panned when it first came out and in fact it did very poorly at the box office. The movie really only became a "Christmas classic" when it went into heavy syndication on cable TV stations in the 70s and 80s. Now it is referred to with glowing admiration in the reviews I read. I suspect "The Santa Claus(e)" may have a similar fate. So, I'm wondering what your favorite Christmas movies are. I'm not going to provide a list because there are too many I'd miss. But if you need a reminder, here's a link to a list of a lot of Christmas movies. My favorite Christmas movie by far is "A Christmas Story." That movie is one of the most hilarious movies ever made and would be on my list of all-time favorite comedy movies outside of any particular seasonal or topical consideration. I don't care much for "It's a Wonderful Life." So what's your favorite?

Comments (5)

pace
"A Christmas Story", and "The Grinch" (starring Jim Carey) are hands down the two favorites of the Pace family. We've watched The Grinch about 5 times already in the past month, and will probably start our Christmas Story marathon pretty soon. "Christmas Vacation" ranks pretty high for me, too.
Dadman
Christmas movies are definitely a genre unto themselves and they seem to be getting more cynical every year... Some of my favorites (off the top of my head): "A Charlie Brown Christmas" "Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer" "How the Grinch Stole Christmas (animated)" "The Grinch" (Jim Carrey version) "The Santa Claus" (our fam likes it too) "Holiday Inn" "White Christmas" "The Homecoming" (launched The Waltons series) "Scrooge" (musical version with Albert Finney) "Elf" (Will Ferrell) I'm sure there are more, but I can't think of them at the moment. I'll review the list to jog my memory...
CosmicConservative
Dadman... to be accurate many of those you listed aren't movies but TV shows, which is really a different genre. Is there really a movie called "White Christmas?" I thought the song came from "The Bells of St. Mary's" and it's not really a Christmas movie, although Christmas plays a prominent part in the movie. The rest of the Cosmic family likes "Elf" but I find Will Farrell to be unfunny most of the time, and "Elf" is no exception. I LOOOVVVVEEE the animated "Grinch Who Stole Christmas," but the movie didn't do much for me. I mostly am nostalgic about "A Charlie Brown Christmas" and "Rudolph the Red Nosed Raindeer." I actually only have vague memories of "The Homecoming" but then I was never a "Little House on the Prairie" fan either... I'm such a cynical curmudgeon.... it's sad.
Dadman
True. The first three I listed are classic TV shows and "The Homecoming" is a made for TV movie. Let's call them Christmas themed productions for both TV and the silver screen. Will Ferrell is funny once or twice, but his act is quite hackneyed now. I did like him in Elf though. Good grief, yes, "White Christmas" is a movie. What planet are you from? It stars Bing Crosby, Danny Kaye, Rosemary Clooney with the music of Irving Berlin including the incomparable tune White Christmas It's a classic...
CosmicConservative
Yah... I was confused because "White Christmas" actually was recorded earlier in the film "Holiday Inn" for which it won an Oscar for "Best Original Song". It was reprised in "White Christmas" according to Wiki.... I guess I better check White Christmas out, the Cosmic Wife loves Danny Kaye.