Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Remember the Dixie Chicks?

By CosmicConservative
Remember when conservative Americans voiced their outrage at the comments the Dixie Chicks made about how much they hated Bush and were embarrassed by the US Government and didn't even want to admit they were from Texas? Remember how the Hollywood elite went on virtually every talk show on earth and whined incessantly about how they were being silenced because some people on talk shows were talking about not buying Dixie Chick albums? How much do you want to bet we won't see those same people talking about the worldwide explosion of violence and death threats due to cartoons about Mohammed? Do you think you'll see Barbra Streisand on CNN viciously attacking the Muslims for their repression of the right to Free Speech? Do you think you'll see Ed Asner talking about how this reaction to these cartoons is an example of the "agenda" of the Muslim right in shutting off all free speech? One thing the elitist left in this country has in common with extreme Islamists is a bizarre tendency to react very selectively to things, depending on who is saying them.

Comments (3)

Brian
Careful there - it's bizarre from your point of view. Not theirs. Wait .. hold on. I'm not engaging in a bit of moral equivilency. Nor am I in any way saying that burning an embassy or calling for a boycott is any sort of reasonable response to a freaking set of cartoons. But this behaivor is non-bizarre to the people who are doing it. It is, in their world, a perfectly rational and reasonable thing to do. Looking at it from the streets of Aman .. we're the ones who are acting weird and alien and contrary to what decent people 'should' do. Something to keep in mind as we drag them kicking and screaming into the 21st century.
CosmicConservative
Brian: My point is that this behavior is bizarre to everyone's point of view except theirs. And because that is true, I am willing call the behavior bizarre objectively meaning that it is actually bizarre, not simply bizarre from some other perspective. But then again, I am not a partaker of moral equivalency or cultural relativism. I don't think it is "okay" to behave however your current culture says it is OK. When Nazis ran Germany and killed millions of Jews it was wrong, period. Burning down embassies and threatening jihad over cartoons would also fit that category of being bizarre, period. Now, there is of course the issue of fundamentalism in religion. Your argument is basically, "Hey, they are doing what their religion tells them to do, so it is understandable." If I were a true atheist I might say "Well, you just pretty well described what is wrong with religion." But I'm not a true atheist. As an agnostic I am willing to suppose that a Deity exists. But I am not willing to accept that any diety worthy of worship would tolerate this sort of behavior, much less expect it.
Brian
Your argument is basically, "Hey, they are doing what their religion tells them to do, so it is understandable." I must have gotten lost somewhere between thought and expression of thought. That wasn't where I was going. Analogy; when you train a dog you will generally fail if you persist in thinking the dog is really just a person and you can be best friends. Dogs are dogs - pack animals with a clear top/bottom relationship. They don't want to be your buddy - they either want to dominate you and be the alpha, or be subsurvient. Likewise as we deal (or do battle) with these jokers in the future we need to keep their true nature in mind, and not fall into a trap where we think their actions are outside the norm in their culture. Which isn't what I think you are doing, i just felt it needed to be said.