Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Fast food ad bans on the way

By CosmicConservative
The nanny state thrives on these kinds of studies. Don't be surprised if someone in Congress proposes a bill for this.
Study: Banning fast-food TV ads could dent obesity A little less "I'm Lovin' It" could put a significant dent in the problem of childhood obesity, suggests a new study that attempts to measure the effect of TV fast-food ads. A ban on such commercials would reduce the number of obese young children by 18 percent, and the number of obese older kids by 14 percent, researchers found.
Now I actually agree with the result here, if advertising didn't work, people wouldn't pay billions of dollars a year to do it. So I have no doubt that an ad ban on fast food would reduce the amount of fast food people buy and eat. In some cases that likely would reduce the number of "obese" kids overall. But isn't the question here about free speech, free markets and personal responsibility? Maybe not so much.

Comments (7)

Dadman
I'm willing to make a judgement call on this: fast food has saturated our culture and is a significant contributor to growing rates of obesity. While I don't support taxing fast food at higher rates, or limiting its consumption by government mandate, I wouldn't necessarily have an issue with reducing, and perhaps even banning, fast food advertising - at least on TV. As things stand now every other commercial on TV is hawking the latest Triple Stack Cheese Whooper Bacon Burger, or some such invention. Now, I love cheeseburgers as much as any burger-lovin' dude, but I believe fast food consumption, driven by incessant advertising, has become a daily norm for far too many people in this country when it used to be the exception...
CosmicConservative
I agree that fast food as a normal diet is not good, neither economically, nor from a health standpoint. But is the "cure" worse than the "disease?" Once you ban ads, don't you next ban the food?
Dadman
I know, I know, it's slippery slope. I just believe there is too much fast food in our culture. It's convenient, it's cheap, it's everywhere you look. People are snarfing it down like starving puppies. Advertising does work, as you say, and it's driving people to consume more of the stuff which in turn contributes to a society that is largely dysfunctional when it comes to dietary habits. At some point the fast food gluttony needs to be moderated and reducing ads might be one way to go...
Andy
I finally found something to disagree with Cosmic and Dadman about! There is no way in our culture that banning fast food ads will slow the consumption of fast food. Cosmic points out that if ads didn't work, companies wouldn't spend the money, and Dadman agrees. Guys, they are not advertising to lure people away from a tuna sandwich and an apple for lunch, or from a healthy family dinner to a greasy pizza. They are advertising to get the already hooked consumer to choose their crap over the other guy's crap. Health conscious (or money conscious) people already bring their own lunch, or make arrangements early on to have a decent dinner for their families after work. But the huge consumer base that really doesn't care that much is going to choose convenience over good sense. McD's, BK, Wendys, Taco Bell, Dominos, Pizza Hut, etc. are advertising to the "decided" crowd. They're just trying to get them to decide on their junk for today. Sure, there might be some attempt to tempt a 4-year-old that wants a "Happy Meal" to scream his way into one. But I think that is pretty minimal. The truth is, fast-food parents are fast-food parents...and they don't really care what the kid eats, as long as they don't have to cook it and force it down his throat. I have known too many parents like that to be convinced otherwise. And fast food adults (with no kids) are fast food adults. They don't want to take the time (or just don't care about it enough) to eat healthy. Those ad dollars are aimed at them. In my "humble expert opinion" ;) the problem isn't the ads...it's that the kids are glued to the TV watching the ads. Heck, almost any kid can eat almost anything, and if they're active enough they'll burn it off. They're kids for heaven sake! Kids will burn it off if they move around enough. The whole idea of banning fast food ads to reduce obesity (especially among kids) is just plain ridiculous. Fast food parents are going to feed their kids fast food regardless. If these do-gooders want want to reduce childhood obesity, they should make every school kid run (or walk) a mile or two every day, limit them to a couple of hours of TV watching in the evening, 30 minutes of video game playing, and 30 minutes on the internet. Heh! I might try that myself...my jeans are shrinking up on me a bit lately.
CosmicConservative
Andy: Don't be surprised if Obama takes on your next to last paragraph...
Andy
Yep Cosmic! I wouldn't be surprised. Even though it was tongue-in-cheek, I can imagine that a guy like Obama might try to make it mandatory.
Dadman
Well, for whatever reason fast food is ubiquitous in our socieity and I believe the billions spent on fast food advertising has create legions of new customers over the past 30 years or so. Andy, your theory just doesn't hold any condiments. ;)