Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Proposed: Green Lantern is not a "superhero" but James Bond is

By CosmicConservative
Dean's World has been having a fun discussion of the definition of "superhero", and that leads me to propose that "normal" humans who only have "powers" due to technology cannot be properly called "superheroes" while humans who have even nominal "super" powers, such as James Bond, ARE superheroes. To elucidate: There are a number of "superheroes" whose only "super" power is that they were in the right place at the right time when someone was handing out super suits. (To be fair, some created their own). Examples of this would be Green Lantern, Iron Man, Nova, The Atom, and even Venom. On the other hand there are a number of literary figures not normally associated with "superheroes" whose physical or mental abilities are clearly beyond any actual human being's. James Bond is an example of a "normal" human who may never do anything that is actually "super" (such as flying or using x-ray vision) but whose ability to function at 100% human physical or mental capacity as long as he needs to is a super power all its own. Other examples would be Sherlock Holmes (super deductive reasoning), Cyrano De Bergerac (super swordplay), Rambo (super toughness) etc... My proposal is that it is actually more accurate to call James Bond a "superhero" than to call Iron Man one.

Comments (6)

CosmicConservative
See, this is one of the times I miss Drax, he certainly would have had some thoughts on this post...
CosmicConservative
Argg...... the subtle dynamics of a nusery school recess..... arg
Dadman
Not sure what you mean, Cosmic. Given the fact that it was just after a contentious exchange with me that he quit posting on this blog I can only speculate I might have something to do with his continued absence. Perhaps it is 'nursery school' as you put it, but not on my part. I'm still here and more than willing to share ideas and opinions with Drax...
CosmicConservative
I'm just grumbling Dadman... I like things to be civil and I like to think that open debate can be done without rancor.... Although I've been in my share of online flame wars myself... Don't worry, I compare pretty much every human endeavor to nursery school recess dynamics. I don't think we ever really outgrow that. Any of us.
Dadman
All I can say is I'm still here...and Drax thinks I'm a bigot. ;)