Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Game Review: WoW - Wrath of the Lich King

By CosmicConservative
OK, I've played WOTLK enough now that I've leveled up from 70 to 71, so that's a pretty good bit of game play. Here are my thoughts. The new content is superb. The landscapes are beautiful. The new area is a northern continent near Azeroth's north pole (Northrend) so it is a landscape modeled after Sweden, Finland, Alaska and Greenland. There are great fjords, majestic mountains, island-sized icebergs and mile after mile of tundra. The land is populated with what seems to be a Pleistocene zoology, dominated by huge, hairy beasts and the predators which thrive on them. Woolly Mammoths, rhinoceros and giant elk-like beasts roam the area. A nice touch is watching the bull elk-like monsters duel with each other as their ranging around overlaps and they butt up against each other. Because the new areas are all intended for what used to be called "epic level" characters, the land is populated with animals and monsters that are a serious challenge, including storm giants and dragons. Dragons in particular seem to play a large role in Northrend. There are many cities and towns in the new continent, most of which are modeled after ice-age Viking culture and mythology. There are lots of heavy fur wearing people with horned helmets, most of whom carry axes or (less common) swords. And all of whom are at least level 68, and most of whom are level 70+. The continent itself is larger than it looks on the map at first. I've roamed around a good bit and I've still only covered about a quarter of the total area, and most of that has been on the major roads, so even the areas I've mapped still have a lot left to discover. The questing and level grinding is all too familar though. One of the things about MMORPGs that has always frustrated me is how little the actual game play varies as you get to higher and higher levels. At level 1 you might be killing young pigs to gain experience to level up, while at level 70 you are killing giant woolly mammoths, but there really isn't that much difference between the two in terms of game mechanics and game appreciation. Each new "monster" provides a short-term appreciation of the details of that individual creature (as with the rutting elk) but soon enough it just becomes a process of hacking and slashing your way through dozens of them to gather meat, gain XP or fulfill a quest (e.g. gather a dozen woolly mammoth tusks for the king's artist to carve). Of course there is a a valule to this repetitive genocide because you do have to learn how to use all your character's skills and items properly, but even so it can become boring when you are working on your 25th elk waiting for that last bit of pristine elk meat to drop... But that's how these games are, and it seems a bit naive to whine too much about it. Still I do like to think that if I were a game designer at Blizzard, I'd come up with more original and clever ideas than just another, bigger, badder, more dangerous monster to have to go kill and loot. And to be fair, they do try. They have a quest in the new expansion where you ride in a blimp and drop bombs on raiding pirates for example, and that's at least somewhat new and different. Right now the challenge is in completing the quests with the wild mobs of players all desperately trying to be the first on their server, guild or play group to hit level 80. (Interesting note, the first official character to hit level 80 happened on Thursday night in Europe. That means someone advanced from level 70 to level 80 in about 48 hours. At least one person in our guild played for 36 hours straight, but only managed to get to level 74 before crashing.) Still, I do really enjoy the work done on the landscapes and the cities and towns in Northrend. Very quality work, beautiful and imaginative, with just enough reality blended in to keep the game playable. So far I've only found one magic item that was better than my previous gear, and that actually replaced my weakest magic item, so I've not really gained much in terms of power since the expansion came out, but that will come in time. I also have not yet done any of the "dungeons" (which is a WoW term meaning a dedicated computer generated "instance" where your group goes in and does not have to compete with other groups trying to do the same thing). Dungeons are really the most important part of the game at high levels since that's where you have to cooperate to complete them successfully and that's where the really good loot drops, so I need to work on getting into some dungeons soon. There is only one new addtion to the character development part of the game, and that is the introduction of a class called the "Death Knight." A Death Knight is supposedly a powerful hero who died and was brought back to undeath (unlife?) by the Lich King himself to help him conquer the world. Death Knights begin play as level 55 characters and come equipped with standard gear that is robust enough to compete with other level 55 chars. I created one just to see what it was like but I haven't played him enough yet to really have an opinion on playablilty. I do, however, have an opinion on the concept of the Death Knight, and I have to say I find the concept appalling. Basically you are evil incarnate and you are encouraged to slay the innocent, pillage, murder, steal etc... When you are murdering innocent (and frequently unarmed) villagers, they say things like "Please don't kill me, I'm all my grandmother has left") and stand there defenseless as you cut them down. I can't say I find that sort of thing very appealing, and I was frankly a little disturbed by the in-game comments other players were posting about how much fun it was to go on a murderous rampage where people pleaded vainly for their lives. So I don't think I'll be playing my Death Knight much... Also, I'm not sure I like the idea of new players being able to create characters that are already level 55. I had to work pretty hard to get to level 55 and the idea that a new player can come along, and within a few hours have a horse, have tons of magic gear, and can hit some of the most fun and rewarding dungeons in the game is a bit irritating to me. It feels like they are catering to the whole "I WANNA DO IT" mentality instead of the "I want to earn it" mentality that these games usually appeal to. (Note: WoW itself is usually considered to be the easiest of these sorts of games to level up and is for that reason already considered to be lame in comparison to, say, Everquest where you have to spend ten times as much effort for the same reward you get in WoW...) Anyway, I'm not thrilled with the whole Death Knight thing. We'll see where it goes. Overall I think the new expansion is clearly worth the $39 I paid for it. It's energizing to have your character climbing up the level tree again. Based on the fact that for the first time since I started playing WoW I now frequently find myself in line to get a login on the game server, clearly the WoW community is pleased with the release. I'll let you all know when Rhlyssa reaches level 80. I guess it will likely take me until about Christmas to get there.

Comments (4)

Boyd
Once your Death Knight completes the quest chains, he has turned against the Lich King and joins the forces of good. Or something like that. I found it amusing when I took my DK in the Beta to Stormwind, and all the guards tossed rotten fruits and vegetables at me. Not in Ironforge, only in Stormwind. I never bothered to figure out why, or how to improve my reputation so they would leave me alone. And regarding the DK starting point of 55, remember that for anyone to create one, they must have a character on the same realm at level 55. So they've already gone through all the leveling at least once.
CosmicConservative
I still think that starting any character at level 55 fundamentally violates one of the key unspoken "contracts" that Blizzard has with its customers, and that is the concept that everyone had to work like heck to get into the upper tier with their character. Now if I'm a new player who finally reaches level 55 and want to create an alt, it's pretty unlikely that I'll do anything BUT create a Shadow Knight, which means it may not be long before we see more SKs than any other class. I have other concerns about the class. In reading the text about the class's abilities, one of the main (if not THE main) ability that was singled out was the ability to raise from the dead those the SK defeated in combat to fight for him. This is just an example of how my brain works (if how my brain functions can actually be described as "working"). Death Knights can raise from the dead as minions to fight for him those that he has killed himself. OK, this can't really be used in a PvP environment because if I die in PvP I come back ready to fight anew. If Blizzard changes that so that if I am killed by a Death Knight, I come back as a minion of the Death Knight, then it's going to take me about ten minutes to decide to download that "Warhammer" demo. So it seems that ability can't be used in PvP. If not, then if the DK is balanced for PvP, then it must by definition be overpowered for PvE. And if it is balanced for PvE, then by losing that fundamental ability in PvP, it must be underpowered in PvP. Since the whole Death Knight concept seems clearly to be aimed at power gamers, it seems obvious that Blizzard would optimize it for PvP, meaning that it will be overpowered in PvE. There may be ways around this conundrum, perhaps when I am killed by a DK in PvP, I come back to life as myself as I always have, but some simulacrum of myself comes to life as a minion of the DK. I don't know if they did something like that or not, but even then I would have some problems with this (fighting an undead clone of myself? No thanks.) One of the reasons I started a death knight was to see if some of my concerns were realistic, and I have to say that so far my death knight seems to be more powerful at level 55 than my rogue was. I am able to dispatch level 54 and 55 NPCs outside of the "birth area" of the DK with ease, and that is with zero extra equipment and very little understanding of how to actually play the DK. I am very concerned about the DK as a class. I have a feeling that Blizzard is going to regret this introduction.
Boyd
Having watched their work on this for the past two and a half years (and having played several of their other earlier titles), I have faith that Blizzard will get the balancing right, or very close thereto. They continually tweak the details of every class in order to get things right. One significant difference between us appears to be that I'm more "practical," viewing the game as a tool, or a puzzle, where you tend to pay more attention to the lore aspect of things. For me, I only find that part of the game mildly and passingly interesting, and wouldn't think twice about fighting a Death Knight's minion that's a simulacrum of myself. It's just another mob to kill. Oh, and maybe it's because I already have at least one toon of every class, but I disagree that new players will only foll DK alts, especially since it's so much easier to level up to 70 these days. There might be more emphasis on the DK since you save 54 levels, but there are many more factors that go into the decision beyond just "how many levels am I going to have to take this guy through?"
CosmicConservative
Boyd, I always like discussions where the outcome will be definitively visible to the participants. I predict that Death Knights will dominate the level 60 - 80 brackets within six months. That prediction is based on my belief that power gamers will see the potential to skip 54 classes as a no-brainer ESPECIALLY when the class is a power-gamer wet dream, which I think the DK is. I think it is badly overpowered right out of the box and will probably only get worse, not better. I think I'm a pretty critical gamer myself, and I think I have a pretty good reputation for being a highly analytical person. And here is my analysis of the classes as they exist right now: 1. The Paladin is badly overpowered in PvP. This is because Blizzard has caved to pressure to make the Paladin a DPS AND a Tank. Well, they've succeeded so much that they had to do 24 "adjustments" (nerfs) to the Paladin in the last month and it is STILL badly overpowered. 2. The Warlock is also badly overpowered, but not nearly as much as the Paladin. Still the warlock in demon form is nearly as indestructable as the Paladin. Paladins are now dominating arena play. Ret paladins especially. On our server a ret-pally/ret-pally 2v2 PvP team's rating went from 1200 to 2500 in a weekend after the last release. In other words, I simply don't buy any argument that Blizzard is careful to balance their classes. Prior to the 3.0 patches people complained bitterly about the Rogue being overbalanced. Well, they seem to have taken care of that. In the BGs I play now it is common for a paladin to lead damage output, killing blows AND healing all at the same time. That's just insane. My guess is that if the Death Knight is balanced at all, it's going to be balanced against the Paladin, and as such classes like Rogue, Mage or Druid are going to become bit part players in groups dominated by Warlocks, Paladins and Death Knights. Priests will still be needed but only because 90% of paladins are going to be ret spec and will need a healer since the power gamer running the paladin is going to want to rock on DPS. I may be wrong. But that's my prediction.