Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: Quantum of Solace

By CosmicConservative
I haven't read any other reviews of this movie so I don't know what the "buzz" is or isn't, so this is pretty much an untainted review. I am in general a fan of the spy thriller genre. I like the intrigue, the drama, the gadgetry, the exotic locales, etc. I think a good spy thriller is among the best kind of movie to watch for pure entertainment. As a young fellow I was a big fan of James Bond. I loved "Thunderball," "Dr. No" and "Goldfinger" for example. I was not a big fan of the Roger Moore versions of James Bond. I considered them to be primarily spy-thriller as farce and I like my spy thrillers gritty, not glitzy. And for that reason I have really liked the first two Daniel Craig Bond movies. I like the dark edge to his character. I like the fact that his own team sometimes wonders if he is over the edge. I like the internal conflict and the contrasting motivations that force the viewer to choose whether to root for Bond or against him. I like his bias for action and his willingness to take a risk. The fundamental core of James Bond is that he is a human being whose physical and mental abilities are nearly super-human due to training, temperament and those wonderful gadgets. But beyond that, James Bond has to navigate whatever situation he is in with aplomb. Case in point: In "Quantum of Solace" James has just avoided capture by dispatching four armed men in an elevator while his own hands were bound. Leaving the elevator he has to walk through a high-class hotel without attracting attention. In doing so he encounters his boss, M, who has sent her own agents to collect him, and who is aware of a major CIA activity to bring Bond back in, so CIA agents are swarming the hotel looking for Bond. Bond walkes past M and carries on a critical conversation in just a few sentences, and then casually steps over a railing onto a thin ledge where he then walks down that ledge on the outside of a hallway while the CIA agents rush around the corner where Bond had been a split second before. As the CIA agents dash past M looking for Bond, he casually steps back across the railing behind the agents and strolls on out of the hotel. That's Bond. Craig pulls that sort of thing off wonderfully, perhaps even as well as Sean Connery did. Roger Moore never convinced me when he tried those sorts of things, and his smug self-satisfied appearance also never worked for me either. Bond is never smug about these things because Bond never thinks about them as things to be smug about, they are just what he does, much like I might feel about flipping a coin, or chewing gum while walking. What's to be smug about? To be smug would be to acknowledge that something unusual or remarkable had just happened. When compared to previous Bonds there are two major differences in the Craig portrayal. The first is that Craig's Bond makes spare use of gadgets. For a while a James Bond movie became a gadget-fest where much of the movie was centered around what sort of cool new toy James would get, and when and how would he use it to save his behind. Craig's Bond will use a gadget, but in general he relies on his wits, his fists and his gun. The second major difference is the pure, raw physical impact of Craig's Bond. In both of Craig's movies he is repeatedly physically punished and he deals a great deal of physical punishment himself. His fights are raw, bloody choreographed celebrations of pure physical punishment. Noses break, knives slash, bullets penetrate and bones break with sickening, yet somehow satisfying, crunchiness. The Craig Bond is a bloody Bond, and much of the blood on his tuxedo is his own. Obviously I like the way these last two movies have portrayed Bond. So what did I NOT like about the movies? First, the opening song for this movie truly sucked. It was difficult to sit through it was so bad. It was not only poorly written and poorly performed, but the actual quality of the recording sounded tinny and unprofessional. To top it all off, it was blatantly derivative of previous Bond songs, but in a bad way. I suppose the attempt was to somehow acknowledge classic Bond songs, but instead it just came off as a lame attempt to copy certain riffs and phrases. Some of the graphic work during the song was decent, but overall I was thoroughly disappointed with what is generally a major bonus to a Bond movie. Second, the directing was choppy and the sound editing sometimes made the dialogue difficult to follow. The result was that parts of the movie felt frantic and confusing. Some fight scenes were difficult to follow while in some action sequences (particularly the car chases) it was impossible for me to tell sometimes if I was watching James' car or his pursuers' car, and as such I didn't know whether to root for or against that car. This also translated into the plot development. Perhaps I have been too coddled by other directors, but I did have trouble following the plot in this movie sometimes. Especially when the plot wove the death of Vespa into the current events, which was fairly frequent. Perhaps this will all be wrapped up in the third movie, but I frankly have not yet put together the pieces that demonstrate how Vespa's death ties into the overall picture. Part of that may be just that my memory is so poor that I don't remember enough of the last movie to tie things together. So, to wrap this up, I will have to say that although I loved the portrayal of Bond, the grittiness and the realism of most of the movie, I really wish they had slowed it down a bit so that I could feel more comfortable that I was following the action properly. But that may just be a sign of advancing age. I did enjoy it and give it four disintegrating gooney birds out of five. Cosmic says check it out.

Comments (4)

Old Goat
Sean was the original Bond, and no one can really match up to it. Craig plays it a bit too dark to match with the Bond novels. I am from a similar introduction to the spy movie. Thunderball was a thrill and remains a favorite mainly because of the impact it made when I was young. I will eventually see the newest Bond flick, but Craig just doesn't quite cut it for me as Bond. I don't know why, but I feel like I am watching an imposture. I think Bond getting the crap kicked out him makes it less realistic, in that he would not be able to do what he does after such beatings. I enjoyed the gadgets stuff of the old movies, though some of it got a bit much. A number of them only were shown during the demo from Q. Some were pretty funny, though. Just remember, Bond isn't supposed to get his brass ones dented, as Craig's were. ;)
Old Goat
Got to see the movie tonight. First, while this is called a James Bond movie, I never really felt that I was watching a true Bond movie except for when Strawberry Fields (name only revealed in credits) was in bed with Craig. No real gadgets. Car was ordinary even if the driving was spectacular. M was a wimp of the first order. How the heck did "Bond" have the same tie on after all he had gone through? No one buys multiples of the same tie, yet his was pristine. This reminded me more of the movie Craig was in prior to becoming this faux Bond. I think it was Layercake or something like that. The intro was not up to par. Plenty of action, good boat scenes, blow up scenes, car chase scenes, but it seemed they were in there to cover for the lack of story and plot. I really think Bond would be better played as a period piece. Set in the 60's, much more in line with what Bond was, a cold war warrior. Craig just doesn't make me think Bond. None of the normal quips, none of the "Bond, James Bond" lines, nor any other that were trademark. Gritty, yes, yet why push it off as a Bond film when it is far from it?
CosmicConservative
It's funny, it seems that what most people see as the "Bond trademarks" are what I always viewed as the "Bond gimmicks." I always greatly preferred the straight action and raw physical courage of Bond. The more gimmicky and promiscuous it got, the less it appealed to me. In fact I sort of lost track of Bond during the Roger Moore days. Pierce Brosnan didn't really pull me back in either, although I prefered Brosnan to Moore. As I said above, I prefer to think of Bond as surviving due to his wits and his fists, not his fancy toys and his keen fashion sense. Moore and, to a lesser extent, Brosnan, came across to me more as runway models than as secret agents. Connery nailed it, his magnetisim was truly animal. His sex appeal was in his feral grace and raw physical presence, not in his wardrobe or his dashboard. I like the new Bond. If it's not the same as the old Bond, I'm more than fine with that. Bring back "Thunderball" and "Goldfinger," I've seen enough "Octopussy" to last a lifetime. In fact I'd seen more than enough of it before it even came out.
Old Goat
Cosmic, I see where you are coming from. I thought Moore's Bond movies pushed toward parody rather than like Niven's Bond. Brosnan was too metro-sexual, though it was better than Moore. Not too hard to do. Lazenby was not given much of a chance, but then he was a poor Bond. Dalton was one who was an improvement over Moore and better than Brosnan, in my opinion. The gadgets that were shown in the various movies were just an extension of creativity of the mind, wits if you will. Many of them never got use in the movies, but were shown as features. Octopussy was a low point in Bond movies. As was Moonraker. Jaws was just plain silly. Even though Oddjob was over the top a bit, his deadly derby was something that I thought was pretty cool for something so commonplace. The other thing with Bond is that he was of Scottish decent, as envisioned by Ian Flemming. I agree that the wits and cunning help make Bond. Craig's version, though, makes it seem more like Jason Bourne from England. I was a bit put off by this movie making him rouge rather than just pushing the envelope. This version was too Americanized in the portrayal for it to be Bond. It was a good movie, but you could have named Craig anything other than Bond and you would barely recognize that it was a Bond movie. Back to the gimmicks, most of the things that were shown in the early Bond movies were take offs on things that were around or being developed. It wasn't till the later movies that they pushed it with the inventions. Thunderball, Goldfinger, You Only Live Twice, are great movies. I think you could still make Bond period pieces from the 60's or so, and have it work really well. So much of what we have today in technology removes so much of what made for the ultimate spy. I agree that Connery nailed the part. The clothes and the gimmicks enhanced his wit. He was a real man. Craig is fit, but just doesn't quite pull it off for me. Connery had the rugged good looks, Craig has a face that looks abused. I guess I had just hoped that over all it was going to return to more along the line of Connery's version of Bond. His shaken not stirred was straight up, not confused.