Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Has this blog been getting too polarized?

By CosmicConservative
Because of a question "Jack" asked me on the Starbucks post from yesterday, I've had to do some soul-searching about the tone of Cosmic Conservative lately. My goal in having this blog was not to add to the overall rancor and polarization of "new media." It was to give a voice to what I call "rational conservatism" which is a brand of conservatism that is steeped in intellectual analysis of reality, history and common sense. But because of Jack's question I did go back and read through the past few weeks of posts and I have to say there has been a good bit of liberal-bashing going on lately. Much of it from me. And that's not really what I want this blog to be. I suppose it was inevitable that the heat of a critical Presidential election would tend to squeeze out the partisanship, but that election is over now and I need to get back to the daily business of providing a calm, rational voice for conservative principles. So look for less partisanship from me in the future. It's time to move on and get back to rationality and civility. So thanks for the reality check Jack. I like to think that liberals can come to this blog at least and not feel insulted, degraded or condescended to. And there's been a bit too much of that going on lately.

Comments (20)

Dadman
I like Jack based on my limited knowledge of him gleaned through his posts. He reminds me of Pace. Since I am the only other significant poster on this blog I guess I need to ask myself if I've been too partisan. I don't think I have in total, but maybe lately. It's virtually impossible not be polarized and partisan in the midst of a political campaign. And since the country has just elected what may be the most left-leaning President in our nation's history, bipartisanship (or less partisanship) may prove to be difficult going forward. But I will certainly try even if the other side won't. ;)
CosmicConservative
Yeah, I like Pace and Jack too, and if they are feeling like this is an uncomfortable place, then we need to think about doing some housecleaning or rearranging the furniture or something. Dialogue is really what this nation needs, not just another bleating partisan voice...
Dadman
Did you take a wrong turn on the way to work this morning and end up on the high road? I agree with you, but this tone is just the opposite of the hardball politics you've advocated on many occasions before. Anyway, I don't disagree, the world needs more civility and less snark, I just don't think we are going to see it anytime soon in the national debate...except perhaps on this blog from now on. Perhaps you should rename the blog ZenConservatism...or something like that. ;)
CosmicConservative
"Zen and the Art of Conservatism..." Sounds like a winning book title... No, I still advocate hardball politics, but I am a bit embarrassed by my own partisanship when it comes to the actual debate. It's hard to draw that line, I need to work harder on it.
Andy
I don't know, Cosmic. A "rational" presentation of conservative ideals will always likely become polarizing. I don't really see a way around it. When history, common sense, and intellectual analysis is laid out, most (I said "most") liberals just recoil to the old saws. Conservatism is "rational." Even right-wing evangelicals, like me, for the most part (I said, "for the most part") came to our conservatism by observing history, and using our common sense. Jeff, Pace, and many others that lean left of center seem to be very fine men. They don't drop the F bomb, and present their side in a civil manner. But I've noticed that even nice liberals' arguments almost always end with a question. I know this is probably polarizing, but "facts" rarely (I said "rarely") enter into liberal arguments. You can show them the facts about global warming, national security, the damaging effects of welfare, the economic boost from tax cuts, the decline of education under liberal leadership, the crappy results of socialized medicine, etc. It just doesn't matter. There is almost always an emotional, irrational answer that ends with a question. Where do you find common ground? I admire libs with conservative friends, and vice-versa. But it is hard for a rational person to find much in common with someone that won't accept truth...even when it is so evident. I concluded a long time ago that people that deny what is "obviously" true (I exclude people that deny what I believe to be true, but not obvious) don't have anything to add to my life, and really don't want me to add anything to theirs. There is nothing wrong with partisanship. With the facts, history, and common sense on your side, you've got no reason to be embarrassed. There might be some subjects that you have "opinions" on that are truly up for debate (like Starbucks, C.W. McCall, Angie Dickinson) ;) but if you continue to lay out truth...undeniable truth...polarization is inevitable.
Old Goat
There is a difference between being civil and laying down. Look at the political divide we have in this country. Every single move the Republicans did was bemoaned as not being "bi-partisan". When the Democrats took over the Senate and House, even though the differences are still there, they tote that what they do is bi-partisan, yet the votes on these actions follow pretty much along party lines. There are a number of push button issues that are hard to overcome. These are fundamental issues to the conservative viewpoint and the liberal viewpoint. It is far different to have friends who are liberal and have discussions about certain issues involving politics. Rational discourse doesn't always lend itself to the various issues of today. There is a growing rift between the two viewpoints because they are vastly different with core principles.
CosmicConservative
Andy: What is interesting to me is that virtually everything you just said bout conservatives being fact-based and liberals being irrational is exactly what I hear and read on the Lefty blogs I visit but with the roles directly reversed. Most global warming advocates are firmly convinced that it is THEY who are reacting to facts and data and "deniers" like me are the irrational ones. I really think that liberals and conservatives live in different worlds. So different that I sometimes question what color the sky is in their world. When I say that I am an advocate of "rational conservatism" I am not precluding the existence or even the viability of "rational liberalism." In fact I think you can be rational on both sides of that divide. And you can also be irrational on both sides. When Bill Clinton was President I used to get all kinds of abuse from conservatives because I would defend Bill from some of the worst things being said about him. I remember many, many discussions about 'black helicopters', 'chemtrails,' 'murder and drug running', etc. I found much of that to be completely irrational, just as irrational as 'Bush lied and people died', 'Bush is the real terrorist', etc... "Undeniable" truth is a difficult thing to apprehend since so many people are able to deny just about anything. Economics and "progressive" tax policy is a classic example. You and I are firmly convinced that the Laffer curve is real and that history demonstrates its reality. But there are many people who deny those "facts" just as they deny the impact of socializing medicine. It's not because ALL of them aren't rational, its because their reality is different than ours and when they look at the world they see different data than we do. Let's look at one of the most compelling examples of "fact-based" policy. Abortion. To this day I hear people on the pro-abortion side claim that a fetus is not "life." This seems to me to be such a blatant denial of a clearly demonstrable and verifiable "fact" that it just blows my mind to hear it come up in the debate. Yet it does. Does this mean that a pro-abortion position is inherently "irrational?" It can't be, there are too many intelligent, logically trained people who support it for it to be irrational. So I am compelled to conclude that we may be using the same words, but they don't mean the same thing. That's why I try so hard in a debate to define terms unequivocably. It is my belief that a large amount of disagreement can be removed if you can just get people to use words that both agree mean the same thing. That, to me, is the rational approach to the debate, but usually the emotion is so high that jumping in with "wait a minute, exactly what do YOU mean when you say 'life'?" doesn't really have the desired result. In fact it usually just becomes an argument about what "life" is. I don't assume that my opponents in a debate are less rational than I am, or at least I try not to. In the few cases where I've actually been able to sit and rationally discuss global warming, for example, the result has usually been a positive experience, even if no minds are actually changed.
Andy
Cosmic: You wrote, "I really think that liberals and conservatives live in different worlds." And, "I am compelled to conclude that we may be using the same words, but they don’t mean the same thing." Yep! The liberal mind and the conservative mind define terms differently. But "rational" doesn't define any liberal I've ever known. Don't get me wrong, I know some rational Democrats (many in my own family). But I can't assign rationality to any liberal that I've come across. You say that you don't assume that your opponent in a debate is less "rational" than you are. Go ahead and assume it. They aren't. Every lib (not Democrat...lib) that I have ever talked to knows little about that old devil "history." You mentioned in your original post "history" as one reason for your conservative positions. You can not take rational positions if you deny history. The failure of Marxism, the economic woes brought on by high taxes (and govt. regulation), the downfall of societies brought on by decadence...I'll quit beating that poor old dead horse. Liberals just don't see it. They don't see it because they don't want to. I guess that defines me as "polarized" from liberals. Heh! I'll take the North Pole...it's close to Sarah, Santa lives there, and it'll have beachfront resorts pretty soon.
Jack
Wow! I never realized my Starbucks comments and asking CC if he has any liberal friends would spark such lively conversation. Thanks. And I like you guys too. CC, your mention here of thinking that liberals and conservatives live in different worlds reminds me of a thread on Deans World (several months ago) where you made a similar comment but then added something profound. You added, "the truth is probably somewhere in between." It was most likely on a specific topic and not a general statement but I found it profound nonetheless. I've often wondered if brain-wiring determines one's political ideology or principles. That could explain why it's difficult or impossible to change someone's mind when it comes to ideology. A psychiatrist friend of mine once told me that if everyone saw pink elephants or heard voices in their heads, then those that didn't would be the mentally ill ones. Essentially, the majority determines normalcy. He added that everybody is neurotic/psychotic/delusional/etc., etc., but only in small degrees. Hence, we (us) are considered normal/mentally healthy. It's when any diagnosis in a psychiatric or neurological category crosses a threshold that it becomes an illness. That being said, the brain is so complex and even with our self-awareness giving the human brain the ability to turn its attention upon itself for analysis, we still struggle with keeping ourselves from being lost in our own potential misperceptions of reality. And as long as we can function in society, we're normal! :) Maybe, just maybe, there are two major categories (with an infinite number of subcategories) of how one's brain views the world. One we've labeled liberal ideology and one we've labeled conservative ideology. And with very degrees and subcategories and such it can go on and on, but you guys get my drift. And hence, we end up with rational, intelligent people who disagree and just cannot find a common ground. And this brain-wiring most likely would also dictate other aspects of a person's life. I'm a filmmaker and I'm left-leaning. I don't think that's a coincidence or an accident. I think it might be possible that the same brain-wiring that makes one an artist also leads them toward liberalism. And the brain wiring that gravitates one toward being a businessperson also leads them toward conservativism. I'm just talking majority percentages here, guys, nothing firmly in stone. There are plenty of very successful artists that are conservative and successful businesspeople that are liberal. But I do think they're are probably in the minority. Anyways, these are just some thoughts I've had over the years. I may be onto something here or just talking out my backside. :) Great thread! I've thoroughly enjoyed it!
Stevo
Spoon boy: Do not try and bend the spoon. That's impossible. Instead... only try to realize the truth. Neo: What truth? Spoon boy: There is no spoon. Neo: There is no spoon? Spoon boy: Then you'll see, that it is not the spoon that bends, it is only yourself. Kumbaya my lord, kumbaya Kumbaya my lord, kumbaya Kumbaya my lord, kumbaya Oh lord, kumbaya I can feel it right down to my "wingnuts"
Old Goat
One of the things that I have come across in my conversations with friends and acquaintances of the liberal bend is that while they are aware of the pitfalls of socialism (for instance) as it was applied in the Soviet Union or China, they believe because of their knowledge and intelligence the system will work. They believe that they will avoid the problems and foils because of their enlightenment. That is frightening. These are problems that the Romans faced, the Greeks, England, you name it. The problem is that no matter how advanced we become in technology and understanding of our world around us, they believe they can prevent human nature as it has always shown its self, will be different under their rule. Take an issue such as socialized medicine. They may even acknowledge that everywhere that has it tell of horror stories and decreasing services, yet they believe that because it is "us" doing it, we'll do it right. Regardless of history, regardless of the countless lessons where the government has harmed any institution they take over. The ideas are based in Utopia rather than the real world. The conservatives, if you can really call the republicans true conservatives (which is a whole different topic), failed because they moved left. They didn't stay with the values, they grew government control and intervention, they spent money wildly on pork projects. They were trying to buy votes. If asked how any of these programs and pogroms will be paid for, that is always thrust on the wealthy. Which is ignoring the lessons that Rand gave in Atlas Shrugged. Ignoring our own history whenever the wealthiest are taxed heavily they pull back or invest elsewhere. I think that is the biggest difference between the left and right.
Andy
Jack, I hope you win an Oscar. Go for it! The greatest artist I've ever known is my mother. She is as quirky, odd, and as talented as anyone you will ever meet...she "coulda been a contender" in the art world if she didn't have 4 kids to raise...but she made her choices. And, she is further to the right with her politics than I am! I really doubt that you're talking out your backside. Your "percentages" analysis is spot-on. I have always been confounded by multi-millionaire libs. Many just inherited wealth, and don't know what to do with their day...but many of them worked hard, played by the rules and built their own fortunes. Then they decided that the rest of us that hadn't quite "made it" yet should pay for the others that aren't trying to "make it." I guess that when you have more money than you'll ever need, it is pretty easy to hamstring your fellow citizens with a shared burden, regardless of the fact that they don't yet have all that they will ever need.
Old Goat
Andy, the multi-millionaire liberals are either trying to rid themselves of guilt or believe that because they put them in power it will result in more power for themselves. Some of the ultra wealthy didn't earn their wealth entirely, many inherited it.
Jack
Thanks, Andy, we'll see what the future holds for my filmmaking endeavors. And as for your mom, though I'm not a parent, I think there's nothing more nobler and challenging than raising children. And it's never too late for her to pursue other dreams. Dadman, you'll have to check with CC to see what you can or can't do on his blog, but I think it's probably still okay. :)
Old Goat
One other thought to share. I've belonged to a number of different conservative blogs over the years now. Every one of them has been open to liberals posting on them, and they have all ended up closing down due to things getting to nasty. I read a lot of liberal blogs as well. Almost every single one of them end up banning any who post that are of conservative leanings. They remain. I believe in freedom of expressing your viewpoints. I believe in back and forth discussion of ideas and views. The trouble is that the rhetoric seems to escalate when such different views try overly hard to push across their values. The posters you mentioned, pace and Jack don't seem like the closed minded sort that frequently occupy "enemy" ground. ;) There may be some hope for them!
Dadman
I consider the blog to be about 25% mine and with that in mind let me just say Al Gore is a gas bag. :) BTW, I am very right-brained dominant, very visually oriented, and a half way decent artist/illustrator and I lean way right. Of course, in my younger years I once voted for Dukakis. I thought his eyebrows were cool...
CosmicConservative
OK Dadman, you can do every fourth Wordpress upgrade then..... ;)
CosmicConservative
One is due, I've been neglectful of my blog responsibilities.... Probly this weekend. I'm still bummed about the upgrade that lost all my previous categories, that blew away about 18 months of post categorization and I've never had the energy to go and re-categorize them....