Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

A smelly government report

By CosmicConservative
From the U.K....
A government report that found old-fashioned reusable nappies damage the environment more than disposables has been hushed up because ministers are embarrassed by its findings. The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) has instructed civil servants not to publicise the conclusions of the £50,000 nappy research project and to adopt a “defensive” stance towards its conclusions. The report found that using washable nappies, hailed by councils throughout Britain as a key way of saving the planet, have a higher carbon footprint than their disposable equivalents unless parents adopt an extreme approach to laundering them.
This whole debate of disposable vs. reusable diapers is nothing new. I actually looked into this myself back when the Cosmic Daughter was born twenty years ago. After looking at the environmental impact of disposable vs. cloth diapers I concluded on my own that cloth diapers likely had a slightly higher impact on the environment than disposable ones. And since the health benefits of disposable ones were measurable and well-documented, I went with disposable and have never regretted it. At that time I did have many arguements with well-meaning, but ill-informed "environmentalists" (is that redundant?) who were shocked that I would choose to use disposable diapers which, they assured me, were clogging up landfills and would soon cover all the world. I tried to explain to them that simple mathematics could be used to determine the actual landfill impact, and that disposable diapers were a TINY, TINY fraction of the impact of, say, junk mail or newspapers (which at that time were still pretty common) and as such didn't really factor into the overall environmental "damage" disposable diapers caused. It's nice to see someone did an actual scientific analysis and they reached the same conclusion I did. Of course that makes them right. The other thing that demonstrates how "right" they are is how quickly the Leftists who comissioned the study to "prove" how much better cloth diapers are turned around and tried to kill it when it proved the opposite. So typical....

Comments (7)

annie1958
Keep the results of a study from the taxpayers who funded it. sheesh.
CosmicConservative
Annie, but it doesn't fit the NARRATIVE....
Boyd
As a young man about 35 years ago, my (then-)wife and I were caring for some friends' infant daughter one evening, and disposable diapers weren't yet widely available (if at all...I wasn't keeping up on them at the time). That experience right there solidified my position some 10 years later when my (next) wife and I were blessed with our first-born: cloth diapers are to be used solely as burp cloths and shoeshine rags, and the decision had nothing to do with the damn environment.
Andy
We used nappies on the first 3 sons (born 1980, 1983, and 1989). We really couldn't afford the disposables, and didn't give a flip about the environment, so it was really a matter of having a flusher to dump the bad stuff, a diaper pail to soak them in, and a washer and dryer to finish them off. (Side note...those diaper pins hurt when you poke yourself in the middle of the night) When #4 son came along in 1996 we were in better financial shape...amazing how things change! Love those Huggies! But you're right Cosmic. It is typical. Hide the facts...spin them when they surface.
CosmicConservative
We used (and did for years afterward) cloth diapers in that manner. They are actually great utility cloths. But I admit that in the halcyon liberal days of my youth, I DID factor in the environment, and did a careful study of both before deciding to use disposable. I have done similar analysis of paper vs. plastic vs. cloth grocery bags (cloth is best, paper and plastic are too close to call), and other things (bottled water vs. filtered water, you'd be surprised how environmentally unfriendly water filters can be). In these things I try to come at them as objectively as possible, and yes, I DO factor in my own personal convenience. That is NOT a negligable part of the calculation, but it isn't the only part. That is why we use cloth grocery bags, it's a tad less convenient for us (you have to keep them in the car and carry them in when you shop) but it's enough better for the environment to make up for it.
annie1958
I carry my cloth bags and use them for picking up things, but not for the bi-weekly major run. I actually love the cloth bags as they don't rip, tear when wet, or drop my eggs on the driveway. I did an experiment about three weeks ago. I did my major (overloaded cart) shopping, and put everything back in a cart sans bags, and hence into my trunk (a Dodge Neon). When I got home, I took several loads into the house on a wheeled cart and put things away. You know what? I found it much more efficient than I expected. While I may have had to move my arms more, I spent less time looking and sorting. Things were put where I wanted them. Nothing got crushed or mangled by being jammed into a bag and then mashed on top of another bag. Kind of like shopping at BJ's (gotta love that name!), just with smaller stuff. I think I will keep doing it.