Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Is ethanol the answer?

By CosmicConservative
How should we deal with our energy needs? In the State of the Union speech Tuesday, President Bush talked about alternative fuel sources such as ethanol. Yesterday I voiced skepticism about using ethanol as a replacement for gasoline. I have not changed my mind, but I was pointed to this article which provides a relatively vigorous rebuttal of my position, so I thought it was only fair to post a link to it. Perhaps I am being too quick to discount ethanol (and methanol) as options. You can make up your own mind.

Comments (1)

JSullins
Interesting article. I found your previous comments on ethanol compelling, and admittedly I had never given the specifics of the technology much thought. I still think economics are the primary forces to be reckoned with with any alternative energy solution. If gasoline became expensive enough, we'd have alternatives available suprisingly soon. Supply / demand -- it's the American way, or at least I think it once was. In fact I think OPEC knows this -- if they colluded to raise the price of oil high enough the west would finally invest the effort to switch to an alternative. As long as oil is the cheapest solution we'll still be addicted to oil. I suppose I border on blasphemy when I say that I hope oil prices do continue to rise, finally forcing even the apathetic among us to get serious about other options. If gas stations could make more money planting/distilling corn than selling oil, wouldn't the need for profit finally prevail and bring about such a change? By the way, it's not because I share the sentiments of some on the "green" left that oil companies are evil or that fossil fuels are immoral that I have these opinions. Rather, I want an alternative so that there are fewer AK47's pointed at us in the Middle East. By the way, skepticism is always good in my opinion. If all ideas were scrutinized before acceptance the world would be a better place ;)