Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Is the Cosmological Principle wrong?

By CosmicConservative
Some scientists are questioning one of the most fundamental scientific assumptions, an assumption that has been essential to the creation of the scientific method and which underlies everything we know about physics from the ubiquity of gravity to the theory of relativity. The Cosmological Principle, also known as the Copernican Principle, is one of the most powerful tools in science. Stated as simply as possible it states "There is nothing special about earth's place in the cosmos." It is also sometimes stated as "No matter what direction you look, or how far you look, the universe looks pretty much the same." Copernicus was the first scientist known to voice this principle directly by saying "There is no reason to suppose the earth is at the center of the universe." It was that core belief which allowed Copernicus to create the Copernican theory of the solar system, which put the sun at the center of the solar system instead of the earth. It is hard to overstate the importance of this assumption in science. This is the same thing that led Newton to conclude that gravity was a universal force when he realized that the same thing that caused an apple to fall from the tree is what kept the moon in orbit around the earth. Einstein used this same principle as the foundation of his theory of relativity. Effectively he said that not only is the Cosmological Principle true AT REST, but it is also true NO MATTER HOW FAST YOU TRAVEL. That realization led directly to his pursuit of the theory of Relativity and beyond that, to his search for a "Theory of Everything." This principle is a core assumption in the creation of things like the Large Hadron Collider because it says that physical laws are location independent. That means that if we recreate conditions on earth that we would find in the center of an exploding star, we can assume that the forces and interactions of particles are the same. This is the only reason it makes sense to construct multi-billion dollar machines designed to explore exotic conditions like particle accelerators do. But some scientists are starting to question that assumption.
Earth may be trapped in an abnormal bubble of space-time that is particularly devoid of matter. Scientists say this condition could account for the apparent acceleration of the universe's expansion, for which dark energy currently is the leading explanation.
It's an intriguing hypothesis. If true it is hard to overstate the impact on modern cosmology. It could mean that most of what we think we know about the size, age and composition of the universe could be flawed, just because we happen to be in a low-mass bubble in the universe and because we've assumed that there is nothing special about where the earth is. I love this sort of thing.

Comments (10)

Foobarista
A good SF variant on this idea is the "zones" from Verner Vinge's universe, that he discusses in "A Fire upon the Deep". Basically, he further from the galactic core one is, the more efficient things like faster-than-light drives and such can work. Also, animal and machine intelligence are affected by the Zones - the further out, the "smarter" things can be. At the edges of galaxies, "transcendence" is possible and a species can essentially become gods. I always thought this was a particularly cool idea, and figured that it was far more likely than the idea that "space is basically the same everywhere".
CosmicConservative
Oh, don't you love the breathless science "reporting" going on here? The earth is not merely "located" in a low mass bubble, no it is TRAPPED in such a bubble. Desperately struggling to escape! Likely to gnaw it's own south pole off in order to get out! Tune in next week for another exciting episode of EARTH TRAPPED IN GIANT COSMIC BUBBLE!!! Of course any reasonable critical thinking would lead one to wonder if the earth WOULD NOT EXIST if not for the bubble it is in. Perhaps in higher mass places in the universe, stellar and planetary formation is different enough that no "earth" could be possible. I really hate it when I read such emotional verbage in a "science" story. I always think that the reporter and/or editor originally said "located" but then read it and said "it needs more PUNCH." Morons.
CosmicConservative
Foo: I agree that such a universe is more dramatic, but I frankly don't find it more plausible than the one we seem to live in. There was a sci-fi short story I read a long, long time ago which explored the possibility that the solar system has been moving through a neural suppression cloud, and as the earth emerged from it, human intelligence increased exponentially... It was a pretty cool story.
Ed Minchau
Cosmic: the story you are thinking of is Brain Wave by Poul Anderson.
annie1958
Okay, this would be the time for me to NOT "open my mouth and remove all doubt". However, the concepts are fascinating if a bit over my head.
CosmicConservative
Poul Anderson! I loved him! He wrote "Tau Zero" one of the greatest sci fi stories based entirely on relativity principles. Fantastic story...
Andy
This is really interesting Cosmic. What if Earth really is in some unique "bubble" in the vast expanse of the universe? Hmmmm...
Dadman
Andy: If that is true that technically would make us 'bubble boys'. I've always wanted to be a 'bubble boy'... ;)
CosmicConservative
By the way, nothing in the data, nor in the analysis of it would suggest that even if we ARE in such a "bubble" that the bubble would be "unique." In fact, my immediate supposition would be that such bubbles are common throughout the universe.