Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Is Palin's star fading?

By Dadman
Or is this AP article just another discordant note in the symphony of negativity directed at Sarah Palin by the MSM? The article feels like another hit piece to me, but I'm concerned there may be some truth to it. There is little doubt Palin has energized the conservative base, including myself, but what are moderate swing voters thinking? Will the growing perception she may not be ready to be POTUS become a significant liability to McCain when all those essential independent voters pull the lever on November 4th? We'll see. I can tell you I'll be watching the VP debate closely this Thursday...
ASSOCIATED PRESS - Palin losing luster with party WASHINGTON -- Has Sarah Palin become a liability for Republican vice presidential candidate John McCain? Since joining his ticket, the overnight political celebrity has seen the shine come off her poll standings and doubts surface among some conservatives once excited about her vice presidential candidacy. The Alaska governor still draws huge crowds and energizes McCain's drive for the White House. Yet in a whirlwind month after he made her his running mate, Palin is starting to seem very, very vulnerable.

Comments (13)

CosmicConservative
I thought I had posted something very similar a few days ago, but maybe I forgot to post it. I am concerned that McCain's team has cocooned Palin. I wasn't impressed with her two interviews, but then again, I wasn't too upset with them either. She did at least as well publicly as Joe Biden has, if not much better. Imagine if Sarah Palin had said that FDR had addressed the nation on television after the 1929 market crash. OMG! But the continued lack of visibility of Palin has made me wonder if McCain's inner circle really does view her as a liability. I hope not, and I guess we'll find out one way or the other on Thursday. Maybe the McCain camp just wants to set expectations as low as possible so that Palin gets the biggest boost possible out of a solid performance in the debate. I guess we'll just have to see. I think I've said all along that I didn't think Palin could save this election for the Republicans. My big hope was that she could be a Maggie Thatcher type rising star so that we had something to look forward to after four years of malaise, foreign policy disasters and likely surrender in the war on terror. Hopefully on Thursday I'll be back to that.
Boyd
My wishful thinking is that they've been hiding Governor Palin in order to set up Bumbling Joe Biden in the VP debate for the spanking he so richly deserves. I'm still taken aback by some of her responses in the CBS interview, so I'll admit that all I've got right now is wishful thinking.
Andy
I'm a rube I know, but who watches CBS News anyway? Old people. I'll confess that I haven't even seen any clips from it. My Great Aunt (85-year-old Democrat) watches CBS News. As far as I know, she's never voted Republican in her life. But she's not voting for Obama. I think Sarah could have come out and said that the Holocaust didn't really happen, and she'd vote for McCain. My Democrat Mom and Dad watch CBS News. If Sarah had come out and done a strip-tease, they would still vote McCain. Mrs. Andy's liberal Aunt in California that has never voted Republican watches CBS News. She's voting for McCain. It's all anecdotal, for sure. But, at the end of the day people vote for President...not for Vice President. Hmmm....that could be good for Obama/Biden.
Dadman
For those torn between McCain and Obama (can't imagine why anyone would be torn at this stage of the game) it might come down to which VP they perceive to be most ready to step in to become POTUS... Andy, I hope your prediction of a McCain victory is accurate, but you were wrong about Mitt and you were wrong about Colorado last year in the World Series. Please quit making predictions. ;)
Andy
The Andy curse is now on BYU!!! Dadman...you should have headed me off at the pass.
Andy
Dadman: If I thought that revising my prediction would do any good now I would. Look, tell all the BYU fans that I'm sorry...sorry...sorry! Don't take any of the blame yourself for not stopping me. Lay it all on me...I'll take one for the team. :) Actually, I'm kinda becoming a BYU fan myself. Those guys are good! If they don't have a bad week it could happen. (there I go again)
annie1958
Normally, I would agree that the choice of VP is low on a voter's totem pole, however, I think the the "Sarah Palin Phenomenon" can be categorized a little differently. Not so much as an indicator of McCain's decision making capability, but because she exploded on the political stage like she did. Whether that explosion was a good thing or a bad thing for the Republican ticket may yet to be determined, but I will say that it got many of the liberals here in Bucks County, PA looking more closely at the GOP. I know it is purely anecdotal. therefore unreliable as an indicator, but it is still heartening to see some folks take their blinders off long enough to learn and accept that perhaps conservatives are not the cruel, heartless, big business loving, god-raptured morons so many on the left see. As a believer in "overexposure can kill", I'm actually glad that things have died down a bit. I was worried when it started to look as though the entire campaign was hanging on her blouse. Lots of pressure and very little room to breathe can make for some fateful mistakes. My 2 copper, for what it's worth. Annie
Anti-Liberalism
this is what i think: Palin appears to be fizzling, heres why: McCain isn't letting Palin be Palin just after the RNC, we saw someone who was energized, rallying the troops to the poll, racing around, and attacking the opponents, now as of late shes become a talking parrot for McCain. If we Free Palin, she will re-energize the population, and make Obama wet his pants again.
CosmicConservative
Anti: That's my optimistic and generous take on the situation too. On the other hand, if Palin really is the self-reliant, principled, Reaganesque figure she seemed to be on that first night, she won't let McCain dictate to her much longer. And if she does? Well, then she's not what I hoped for by definition. So the next week or so will really tell the tale on Sarah Palin, at least in my opinion.
pace
Boyd: I am rather surprised that more conservatives aren't just a little 'taken aback' by Palin's responses in these interviews. But I find it difficult to believe that the McCain camp wouldn't let her formulate her own responses to the questions being posed, if she were able to credibly do so. The babysitting and scripting of her appearances indicates to me that the McCain people know that she is a liability any time she has to ad-lib on policy. Inexperience aside, she simply appears to be alarmingly uninformed on a wide range of current affairs - stuff that is important to these coveted 'swing voters'. It is not that I disagree with her opinions, but that she is barely able to articulate opinion when the topic moves from provincial Alaskan concerns. The folksy shtick may work for many conservatives, but I don't believe it has a broader appeal.
CosmicConservative
Pace: I would say that is a remarkably ungenerous statement about Palin when the Democrat VP candidate has dropped a gaffe a day including such mind-numbing examples as the FDR on TV thing. If you feel Palin has demonstrated an incapacity to be VP, what do you think of Biden?
pace
There seems to be just a little hypocrisy in the Right's ridicule of the culture of worship evident in the Obama movement, when you look objectively at the ascension of Palin. Your comment above: "..if Palin really is the self-reliant, principled, Reaganesque figure she seemed to be on that first night" One speech. She gave one speech, and you guys know everything that matters about her? A few soundbites about cutting pork and eliminating wasteful spending, and she's the future of the Republican party? As for my ungenerous statements, I think I've been extremely moderate in my comments and tone on the subject of Palin. But ok, I'll bite.. Which of her interview responses seemed especially informed and insightful to you?