Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Energy Problem

By CosmicConservative
One of the themes in Bush's State of the Union speech tonight was the need to break our "addiction to oil." He mentioned clean coal power plants, wind energy and nuclear energy as three of the ways to do that. Nuclear energy is the only one that has any real shot at generating the amount of energy needed for this nation's rapacious appetite for energy. Coal has its own limitations, and wind energy is Sierra Club fantasy stuff. He did not mention fusion, something I considered to be a significant omission. He hinted that we were on the verge of breakthroughs, but the areas he mentioned, other than nuclear, were all quite conventional. I just don't see how ethanol is going to solve our fuel problems. I have not dug very far into the latest progress in fusion research, it's probably a good time to do that again. In many ways I have come to believe that the future of the human race depends heavily on our ability to harness fusion energy. For most of my life we have been "30 years away" from fusion. Sooner or later that number should drop to at least "29."

Comments (3)

James Aach
I can't tell you much about fusion, but I can give you an insider perspective on currently operating nuclear plants, in the form of a techno-thriller novel. It's available free to readers - who seem to like it, judging from the comments at the website. See http://RadDecision.blogspot.com. (If you like what you see, please pass the word.)
JSullins
I agree that fusion would be wonderful, but I've also always had hope for ethanol. Farmers growing our fuel? What could be better? No more reliance on foreign oil, and a new source of income for the dwindilng family farmers. I'd like to hear what your thoughts are on why this doesn't appear to be viable. Obviously there are issues, because we aren't really using it. I always just assumed it was economics -- oil is still cheaper.
CosmicConservative
JSullins: The problem with ethanol is that there is a tremendous amount of energy that is invested in growing the plants that you then harvest to create ethanol. Ethanol itself is fine, but when you factor in all the cost of creating the fertilizers that are needed to grow it, the water that is pumped for irrigation, the harvesting and processing, the actual energy return on investment is cut back quite a bit. It's not like you can just find a field full of corn in the middle of nowhere and chop it all down to create ethanol. Although one of Bush's suggestions is to find other sources of ethanol than corn, and one of those sources that has shown promise in England and Australia is processing a naturally occurring weed into ethanol. That MAY have a higher return than growing corn, but the studies have not shown an overwhelming advantage to that approach. Also, everything that we grow and convert into ethanol is something that will not be eaten directly by humans, or converted into feed for animals that will be consumed by humans, so it is inevitable that if we try to convert to an ethanol based economy, we will have a collision of self-interest when available land for growing plants runs out. Then we'll have to decide whether to put ethanol in our cars, or food in our bellies. I think I know which one of those wins.