Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

"Cringe-worthy" Interview?

By CosmicConservative
Pace, a regular commenter here, posted a comment in another thread saying that the interview between Sarah Palin and Charlie Gibson was "cringe-worthy." Not having seen the interview and relying on transcripts I read of it (which is a standard policy with me, btw, I hate watching these things on TV) I disagreed with him and pointed out that the interview was badly misrepresented by ABC and the rest of the media, which had to rapidly backtrack in their headlines all day long. The first headline I saw on CNN was something like "Palin advocates war with Russia." By the end of the day, as the editors apparently WATCHED or READ the actual interview, that had become "Palin leaves sanctions on table in Russia/Georgia dispute." In actual fact the response Palin gave to that question was EXACTLY the stated McCain position on the issue (and isn't far off Obama's for that matter). Here is a link to a New York Post article reviewing the interview. It matches most of the other reviews I've seen, including CNN's. In every case the single most damaging part of the interview was the portion on the Bush Doctrine. But without exception, everything I've seen so far has been as critical of ABC and Charlie Gibson for their obvious ham-handed approach to this. Gibson should be ashamed of misrepresenting Palin's position on a couple of issues, and it isn't really fair to hold Sarah Palin accountable for being caught off guard when a supposedly professional interviewer essentially throws unfounded rumors at her and asks her to defend them. So, what do you all think? Did Sarah strike out? Or did she hit another home run? My take on this is that she hit a sacrifice fly that advanced the runner, but did not score a run. Heh, love those sports analogies.... Here's a short excerpt from the NY Post interview, which more or less captures the tone of the whole thing:
Her responses to Gibson's cross-examining seemed canned and rehearsed, a little like the answers you might give in a tough college interview. But that may be a result of the ham-fisted editing - which seemed to cut her off mid-thought on many answers. ABC should release the entire, unedited interview, so that Americans can judge her more fairly.
UPDATE: On the cringe-inducing exchange between Gibson and Palin on the "Bush Doctrine" I have seen a few serious defenses of Sarah Palin, even from the Left. Their point (which I did refer to myself) is that there actually IS no such thing as the "Bush Doctrine" and what "Bush Doctrine" means to the speaker seems to depend on context and timing. ORIGINALLY it meant that we would pursue terrorists wherever they went, and we would hold states who harbor terrorists accountable for that. (The invasion of Afghanistan is probably the most clear and compelling example of the Bush Doctrine in action). However, with the famous "Axis of Evil" speech the "Bush Doctrine" morphed into a more general willingness to pursue military action against perceived future threats to the country, even if that meant invading a sovereign country. It was THIS version of the "Bush Doctrine" that led to the invasion of Iraq. Since then the "Bush Doctrine" label has been applied to everything from sending special forces into Pakistan without Pakistani approval to using water-boarding on suspected terrorist masterminds (although the left more commonly uses the word "torture" in its place). So it is plausible that Palin's apparent cautiousness in asking Gibson to better define what HE meant by "Bush Doctrine" could have been because Sarah was not sure which incarnation of the term Gibson was using. Of course my approach to that situation would have been to say "Here is what I believe the 'Bush Doctrine' to be, and here is where I stand on that...." So even with this charitable interpretation of Palin's performance, I think it was still her worst moment.

Comments (14)

CosmicConservative
Hmmm... I just get a blank page. Perhaps the corporate firewalls are blocking the content...
CosmicConservative
Well, I went and looked for some other takes on that subject, and updated the post. Let me know if that is close to what the link you posted was saying.
Boyd
Oh, Bill can go on and on (God love him!), so he pretty much beat that subject into the ground. He went through all (or almost all) the permutations of the Bush Doctrine with glossies with circles and arrows...well, you get the picture. I haven't had the opportunity to view the interview myself yet, so I can't give my own reaction based on seeing it first-hand. I'm also almost as much of a Palin fanboi as Bill is, so I'll admit I'm not especially objective on the subject of the Governor of Alaska. But I will say that Gibson was setting a trap, and even if she had responded as you would have, Gibson could still have looked down his nose and effectively said, "Poor little empty-headed woman doesn't even know that the Bush Doctrine is..." whatever he wants it to be. If everything I'm reading about the interview is accurate, including the editing, the tone and certainly the content, it sounds like it's mostly a hit job by Gibson and his producer (and anyone else at ABC that got to lend a hand). But that's okay. All the crap they've pulled over the past couple of weeks has blown up in their faces, and they still haven't figured out how to avoid that.
Dadman
I haven't viewed or read a full transcript of the interview either, but I'm certain I wouldn't have found it to be 'cringe-worthy'. This begs the question why people perceive things so differently, especially when politics is the context. On occasion I'll listen to our local liberal talk radio station to hear them condemn the things I would praise and praise the things I would likely condemn. The libs think the MSM is biased against THEM. Palin is a lightweight while Obama somehow has gravitas. Franken is a serious candidate to them. I think he's a joke. Ultimately, it's all about perceived values. If a candidate seems to share our personal values we will have a natural affinity for them and overlook their flaws. The converse, of course, is also true. How Palin's 'performance' in the interview is judged or perceived has everything to do with politics and very little else...
Andy
I didn't watch the interview, but have seen some clips today, and heard some commentary while out and about today. I think the hand has been dealt. The question about the "Bush Doctrine" probably stumped everyone in the US except for Gibson (an arrogant guy for sure). I imagine that anyone watching didn't care much. Palin might gaff occasionally...but she's running for VP. Remember when President Bush got blindsided with the question about the "name of Pakistan's president?" He got elected, and got to know his name pretty quickly thereafter, huh? This whole election has been settled. It is McCain v. Obama. Nobody votes for Vice President. The only exception that I can imagine (and it's purely hypothetical) is if the idiot Obama had taken Hillary as his VP nominee...that might have gained him some votes. I have said before, and I'll say again that this is going to be a landslide for McCain. Well, gotta go batten down the hatches. We are getting the outside bands of Hurricane Ike this afternoon. Wind early, and heavy rain this afternoon. Man, this rascal is big. It hasn't even hit Houston yet and we are getting big-time rain already way up here.
Dadman
Well, I saw part of Gibson's interview last night on 20/20. It was cringe-worthy afterall. Charlie Gibson made me cringe (and scream at my TV) with his condescension, rudeness, effete elitism, and clear attempts to trip up Palin. This wasn't so much an interview as it was an interrogation the likes of which Obama and Biden have yet to receive. I hope they do, but won't be holding my breath...
pace
I apologize for not follow-up sooner - my ISP changed our static IP address block without informing me, and I was without Internet access for most of the weekend. So I have watched the interview several times now, and have to say that while Gibson's tone was condescending, the questions were far from hardball. I know that the left are playing up the 'war with Russia' comments, but I did not find Palin's response to the question of "what if Georgia joined NATO" to be particularly objectionable or inappropriate. I thought it was a fair response, at least the way the question was worded. But... Gibson: Do you have the experience and ability to be Vice-President, and perhaps President? (paraphrased) Palin: I do. ... I'm ready. She offered no further qualification of how or why she is ready and able, nor did Gibson ask for it. Gibson then asked if, for a moment, she considered answering 'no' to McCain's request to run with him. A more appropriate question would have been, to what degree of consideration did she give to the proposal. In any case, she answered that she did not blink, and then started waffling about being 'committed to the mission', 'the mission of reform... and victory in the war'. And clearly she thinks blinking is overrated. She evades the question relating to McCain's statements on her security credentials, instead attempting to (wisely) steer the conversation toward her supposed role in energy independence. Gibson does not pursue this further nor press the point. She makes a valid point on energy independence being critical to national security, but does not explore it any further or offer anything not being said by either McCain or Obama. The questions about her experience/travel abroad were a little below the belt (no doubt Gibson already knew the answer), but were not unexpected or out of left field. The question certainly seemed to make her uncomfortable as she once again digressed into her waffling, folksy, they-didn't-coach-me-for-this-one mode. Her response to whether she had ever met a foreign head of state was a good answer, albeit not delivered with the best composure. It rattled her. And then... Gibson: What insight into Russian actions - particularly in the last couple of weeks - does the proximity of the state give you? Palin: They're our next door neighbors. And you can actually see Russia from land, here in Alaska. I can't tell if that was an intentional joke. But if so, she could certainly teach this Englishman a thing or two about dry delivery. But seriously... that was just a dumb response. On the topic of nuclear weapons and Iran, all she offered was that we have to keep them out of the hands of the terrorists and put pressure on Iran. Well, duh. I could go on, but what's the point. If Biden had delivered these responses (and I certainly hope that Gibson will level the same questions at him), you guys would be laughing him off the stage. Now, I am sensible of the fact that this is a conservative blog and I am obviously not a conservative. My perception of an interview such as this will invariably differ from the occupants of this site. But in turn, many of the views expressed here may not be especially representative of mainstream electorate opinion. I posted my original brief observation of the Palin interview on a website that I moderate on; an auto-enthusiast forum of some 5,000 members. I put it in an area accessible only to other moderators. Their demographic is that of late-twenty and early thirty-somethings, who occupy the full political spectrum. Here are the comments of those who responded after watching the interview: 'M', a liberal: "Her answers were obviously told to her ahead of time by someone in the campaign. "Remember these names. Say them so you sound smart. You are not allowed to talk about this, this, or this. Ignore any questions about them. You are not to commit to any action. Your opinions are...." 'B', a Mormon and Republican from Utah: "So I disagree philosophically with Obama on 60% of his ideas for change. He made the non-obvious, brave, and right choice for VP to govern, not to win an election. McCain made the obvious choice for VP to win, and not to govern. That's a slippery slope. What other tactics are you wiling to employ to win, you know, for the greater good? [Obama] has got my vote." 'A', a moderate: "What exactly is McCain's economic policy? Not trying to be a asshole here, but I have never heard him say anything about the economy or his plan for it. A quick peruse of his website the only thing I really found of substance is that he wants to lower corporate taxes." 'MM', a moderate: "I will say that I am very surprised that she didn't even know what the Bush Doctrine is." Food for thought. Maybe. I did not yet watch the second interview, but the accounts I've read suggest she fared a little better.
CosmicConservative
Pace: All good points, but I don't think we would have laughed Biden off the stage. Certainly Obama has had his moments of looking stupid on foreign policy, his statements about Pakistan being one very startling example. And I don't recall the folks on this blog making a big to-do about it and calling him stupid for it. And last I checked HE was running for President, not Vice President.
Dadman
A Mormon Republican voting for Obama? Why, he oughta be excommunicated! ;) In spite of the anecdotal evidence you've collected on the blog you moderate, the polls are telling a significantly different story. I'll second Cosmic's reminder that Obama has committed similar or worse gaffes and he is running for President. I've noted in a previous post that the Palin selection for VP was a purely political move designed to shake up the dynamics of this election. I believe I even called it cynical. But, I recognize the fact that VP selections are almost ALWAYS motivated by rank politics. Biden was selected primarily to shore up Obama's image as a light weight with little significant governing experience. I personally believe Biden would be an disaster as President. I like Palin. She shares my values. She has enormous potential where experience may be lacking. And besides, it's been 35 years since a sitting VP became the POTUS. A vote for McCain-Palin puts McCain in the White House. A vote for Obama-Biden puts a well-spoken, far-left empty suit in the White House. I'm voting for McCain...
Andy
Pace, trust me. If Biden gave the same answers as Palin I certainly wouldn't have laughed him off the stage. In truth, Biden might give the same answers on many questions. I thought that she was thoughtful, and careful to ask Gibson to nail down his question about the Bush Doctrine. I would have...or like to think that I would have. At the risk of projecting my thoughts on you, I would imagine that you would also...you seem like a thoughtful, careful fellow. And I'm also in solid agreement with Dadman. A Mormon Republican voting for Obama should be ex-ed. ;) But I don't get a vote on that one...
pace
Regarding the polls: The post-convention-Palin-bombshell bounce seems to have subsided. Barry is still significantly ahead in projected electoral votes, and Florida, Ohio, and Wisconsin are ostensibly a dead-heat right now. The polls I've seen indicated that the Palin selection primarily effected a solidification/motivation of the existing base, rather than generating significant new votes from independents. Regarding the Mormon comments: I'll be sure to pass them along to Brandon. But I have to ask you; does McCain exhibit Mormon principles that Obama does not? Let's be honest, the guy is as 'left' as a Republican can be without being subject to party ex-communication himself. So I am curious why a vote for Obama would be anathema to a born and bred member of the LDS where a vote for McCain would be so profoundly different.
Dadman
Pace: Notice the emoticon...I was kidding about excommunication. It was a joke. In truth, there is a great deal of political diversity among the LDS faithful, hence you see Harry Reid on the moonbat end of the political spectrum and Mitt Romney or Jeff Flake (congressman from AZ) on the more conservative end. I think it's fair to say, however, that most Mormons are conservative, particularly on social issues, and, for my part, the abortion issue alone is enough to make me part ways with most Democrat candidates. One of the most significant reasons I will vote for McCain is the appointments I hope he will make to the Supreme Court. So, a vote for Obama is not inherently anathema to being LDS, but it does appear to anathema to being smart. Heh. ;)