Her responses to Gibson's cross-examining seemed canned and rehearsed, a little like the answers you might give in a tough college interview. But that may be a result of the ham-fisted editing - which seemed to cut her off mid-thought on many answers. ABC should release the entire, unedited interview, so that Americans can judge her more fairly.UPDATE: On the cringe-inducing exchange between Gibson and Palin on the "Bush Doctrine" I have seen a few serious defenses of Sarah Palin, even from the Left. Their point (which I did refer to myself) is that there actually IS no such thing as the "Bush Doctrine" and what "Bush Doctrine" means to the speaker seems to depend on context and timing. ORIGINALLY it meant that we would pursue terrorists wherever they went, and we would hold states who harbor terrorists accountable for that. (The invasion of Afghanistan is probably the most clear and compelling example of the Bush Doctrine in action). However, with the famous "Axis of Evil" speech the "Bush Doctrine" morphed into a more general willingness to pursue military action against perceived future threats to the country, even if that meant invading a sovereign country. It was THIS version of the "Bush Doctrine" that led to the invasion of Iraq. Since then the "Bush Doctrine" label has been applied to everything from sending special forces into Pakistan without Pakistani approval to using water-boarding on suspected terrorist masterminds (although the left more commonly uses the word "torture" in its place). So it is plausible that Palin's apparent cautiousness in asking Gibson to better define what HE meant by "Bush Doctrine" could have been because Sarah was not sure which incarnation of the term Gibson was using. Of course my approach to that situation would have been to say "Here is what I believe the 'Bush Doctrine' to be, and here is where I stand on that...." So even with this charitable interpretation of Palin's performance, I think it was still her worst moment.
"Cringe-worthy" Interview?
By CosmicConservativePace, a regular commenter here, posted a comment in another thread saying that the interview between Sarah Palin and Charlie Gibson was "cringe-worthy." Not having seen the interview and relying on transcripts I read of it (which is a standard policy with me, btw, I hate watching these things on TV) I disagreed with him and pointed out that the interview was badly misrepresented by ABC and the rest of the media, which had to rapidly backtrack in their headlines all day long. The first headline I saw on CNN was something like "Palin advocates war with Russia." By the end of the day, as the editors apparently WATCHED or READ the actual interview, that had become "Palin leaves sanctions on table in Russia/Georgia dispute." In actual fact the response Palin gave to that question was EXACTLY the stated McCain position on the issue (and isn't far off Obama's for that matter).
Here is a link to a New York Post article reviewing the interview. It matches most of the other reviews I've seen, including CNN's. In every case the single most damaging part of the interview was the portion on the Bush Doctrine. But without exception, everything I've seen so far has been as critical of ABC and Charlie Gibson for their obvious ham-handed approach to this. Gibson should be ashamed of misrepresenting Palin's position on a couple of issues, and it isn't really fair to hold Sarah Palin accountable for being caught off guard when a supposedly professional interviewer essentially throws unfounded rumors at her and asks her to defend them.
So, what do you all think? Did Sarah strike out? Or did she hit another home run?
My take on this is that she hit a sacrifice fly that advanced the runner, but did not score a run.
Heh, love those sports analogies....
Here's a short excerpt from the NY Post interview, which more or less captures the tone of the whole thing:
Comments (14)