Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Anti-Mormon bigotry key factor in Romney's failed bid for White House

By Dadman
...according to a new book by Craig Foster, A Different God?, soon to be released. I happen to agree with the author's thesis. I know many who visit this blog will reject it. I invite them to read the book and let the facts speak for themselves.
SALT LAKE TRIBUNE - New book says anti-LDS bias led to Romney's downfall Foster offers numerous examples of what he sees as religious bigotry, starting with polls, revealing how many Americans would not vote for a Mormon - from 43 percent in November 2006 to 30 percent in May 2007. He describes media bias, noting a Pew Forum report that 35 percent of all religion-related campaign stories between January 2007 and April 2008 focused on Romney; only 4 percent looked at Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee. "It's been nearly half a century since our political journalism has witnessed anything quite as breath-takingly noxious and offensive as the current attempt to discredit the former Massachusetts' governor for his faith," Foster quotes Tim Rutten of The Los Angeles Times as saying.
Foster cites the Religious Right as Romney's key nemesis, a group that enthusiastically supported Huckabee in large numbers. These same folks, evangelical Huckabee supporters, weren't satisfied with denying Romney the GOP nomination for President organizing to ensure he was also passed over for VP based almost exclusively on religious differences. Of course, they'll claim otherwise, but I'm skeptical. I'm quite certain any Mormon running for national office, even one without the baggage of a former governor of Massachusetts who, apparently, was once pro-choice, would inevitably run into the buzzsaw of evangelical bigotry.

Comments (39)

Boyd
Well, I can't speak for anyone else, but I scratched Mitt off my list long before I got around to his religion. For the same reasons, I'm glad he wasn't selected for VP.
CosmicConservative
Dadman, you are right in saying that some on this blog will disagree with the conclusion this book reaches. I'm sure his Mormonism was a factor, but I can't say it was the deciding factor. I have a lot of deeply religious friends and acquaintances, more than a few of them are Mormon. Now I know it's a small set to extrapolate from, but I never heard one of those people complain about Romney's Mormonism. Here is what they DID list as reasons they didn't support him. 1. His flip-flops on abortion. 2. His flip-flops on gay marriage. 3. His insufferable arrogance (I don't really see this, but they sure do). 4. His waffling on gun control. This is a huge issue with many of the people I speak to. 5. His carefully cultivated Hollywood Star image (Again, I don't see this, it's not his fault he's good-looking, and I don't see why he should dress like a frump just to satisfy other people's envy). 6. His lack of actual political experience (again, I don't see this and I suspect most of those on the right who complained about this are mostly ardent supporters of Sarah Palin). None of them raised his Mormonism as an issue. If I had to sum it all up in one short sentence, I would say that the folks I talk to simply think he's a bit of a blowhard and an untrustworthy one at that.
Drax
Yeah. And, everyone who didn't vote for Hillary was a sexist. Everyone who doesn't vote for Obama is a racist. There were/are books about that too. Gotta believe it. Someone wrote a book about it.
Dadman
Anecdotal evidence aside, it remains an INDISPUTABLE FACT that large numbers of evangelical Christians organized against Romney largely (or simply) because of his religious faith. If the same folks had organized to vote against Obama or Hillary based largely on the stereotypes associated with race or gender most reasonable people would call that racism or sexism or bigotry. I'm not sure why my assertion that SOME evangelical Christians are religious bigots and that they MAY HAVE played a role in the outcome of the GOP primaries is so controversial on this blog. Given the GOP primary we all just experienced it seems self-evident to me...at least from my unique perspective. Maybe this book would be worth a read...
JSullins
I'd agree that, anecdotally, there are conservatives who rejected Romney because of his religion. My brother and his family, for instance. I was half-hoping to see the discord on their faces that would result from having to choose between on evil mormon and an evil liberal. Would have been pure entertainment for me! Heh. Maybe next time. As a mormon, though, I never personally liked Romney.
JSullins
Er, that is, I share his religion and yet didn't like him.
Dadman
JSullins: As a Mormon you must be aware of the hostility many evangelicals have toward your faith and the fact that many of those folks voted in the GOP primaries. I like to call their condition EMoDS - Evangelical Mormon Derangement Syndrome. ;)
CosmicConservative
Dadman: Nobody is disputing that there are significant numbers of evangelicals who opposed Romney due to his Mormonism. What I am saying is that I don't think that was the deciding factor in his not being chosen as VP, or in not gaining the nomination himself. Many, if not most, of those same evangelicals organized against John McCain as well, and McCain still managed to snag the top spot. Had the race been close between Romney and the eventual frontrunner, I might agree with this, but it wasn't that close, so if there was organized resistance to his campaign, I just don't think it made the difference. That's all I'm saying. Is there anti-Mormon bigotry in the world? Absolutely. Is there anti-Mormon bigotry in the Christian evangelical movement. No doubt. Is there anti-Mormon bigotry in the press? All you have to do is count the Mormon references and compare positive to negative counts and you will see that anti-Mormon stories outpace pro-Mormon stories in the MSM by probably 3 to 1. But you have to balance that against the fact that the MSM also runs anti-Christian stories by about the same margin, so I tend to think that the press's obvious anti-Mormon bias is really just a specific manifestation of their overt anti-religious bias.
Dadman
Cosmic: I tend to agree with your analysis. I'm not claiming that evangelical bigotry toward Mormons was the DECIDING factor in the GOP primaries, I'm just saying it was a factor and perhaps a significant factor in the some of the early primaries (e.g. Iowa). If the evangelicals had not defeated Romney in Iowa the trajectory of his campaign may have been different. Maybe. The bottom line is I'm just trying to shine the spotlight a bit on cases of EMoDS and the recent publication of this book was germaine to some of our earlier discussions on this blog.
Drax
CC: Define "significant." Percentages would be nice. Of those "significant" numbers...of *GASP* EVANGELICALS (horrors) how many didn't vote for him because of his pro-abortion stance (when it politically suited him) and anti-abortion stance (when it politically suited him) so that it was utterly clear that, to Romney, politics meant more than the unborn? I had no use for Romney. After one look, neither did the people of Mass. Nor, for that matter, did a SINGLE state in the primaries. What a crock.
Dadman
Well, this thread is beginning to take a familiar path. Not inclined to go there this time...
CosmicConservative
Drax: I don't believe anyone has hard numbers so I used a soft term like "significant" purposefully.
Drax
If you can't put a number to it, it's disingeneous to call whatever number it is "significant." And, this path appears to have been paved by the OP... And, yes, the tenor of it (Evangelicals are bigots) is familiar.
CosmicConservative
I reserve the right to be disingenuous when I want to be, but I don't agree that this was disingenuous. Disingenuous implies a deliberate effort to deceive, and I did no such thing.
Drax
When you wrote the word "significant," did you hesitate because you knew that you had no facts to back that CONCLUSION up and chose that word intentionally BECAUSE you didn't have the facts to back that conclusion up? You stated: "I don’t believe anyone has hard numbers so I used a soft term like “significant” purposefully." While I don't think you intended to mislead anyone with your conclusion, the purposeful use of a "soft" term which could be (and would be) construed by the reader as having actual MEANING is misleading. Other potential "soft" words which do NOT have such HARD meaning would include "some" or whatever which is INTENDED to indicate to the reader that: 1) The writer does not KNOW the number at issue; 2) The writer does not ascribe any VALUE to the unknown number. ("Significant" connotes that the number had an EFFECT...otherwise it's NOT "significant." It is, INsignificant.
Dadman
Much is familiar. I didn't write the book I've referenced in this post, I just happen to be sympathetic to its thesis and believe there is at least some truth to it as do many, many others, including non-Mormons. Whether or not you care to acknowledge it, Drax, many (certainly not all) evangelicals are religiously intolerant. I believe at times their intolerance and obnoxious behavior rises to the level of bigotry. Why that FACT bothers you so much is inexplicable to me, but so be it.
Drax
Wow. Some evangelicals are bigots. Dog bites man. Good to know that all the Mormons out there are not afflicted with that nonsense. Wait.... Oh, yeah. It's only remarkable that evangelicals are bigots, not the other way around. What number Dadman? How many of the Evangelicals are bigots? 1% 10%? 5 guys in a bar? How does this number compare to the number of non-evangelicals (including Mormons) who are bigots? Higher? Lower? The same? In other words, WHY IS IT REMARKABLE that "some" evangelicals are "bigots" when we (all of us -- each and every one of us) KNOW that bigotry is an affliction which crosses ALL racial, gender, political, and RELIGIOUS lines? And, unless you can establish that it IS "remarkable" your constant bashing of evangelicals for THEIR bigotry (which you can neither quantify nor prove that it is in ANY way "remarkable") is simply distasteful.
JSullins
All bigotry is distasteful. In the case of Romney, some percent more than 0% and less than 100% of his primary loss was attributable to bigotry. How's that? And P.S. I would have been a better Mormon candidate :)
Dadman
You're attacking the messenger, Drax, and neglecting the context. I'm not the one who first made the case that evangelicals (particularly in Iowa) mobilized to defeat Romney primarily because of his faith. I'm just reporting what others are saying and, yes, I am inclined to believe what others have written and said about this issue. Mormons can, indeed, be bigots too. In fact, they are presently being accused of just that by gay marriage proponents for actively supporting the California protection of marriage amendment. I personally don't think Mormons are being bigoted by defending the institution of marriage, but others do proving, I guess, that bigotry is in the eye of the beholder. What is being examined in the book I referenced is what happened SPECIFICALLY in the GOP primaries. Beyond this context, yes, all people can and often will be guilty of intolerance and bigotry. But, the SPECIFIC question being asked by many is did evangelical intolerance toward Mormons impact the primary outcomes. I think the answer to that question is 'probably'. Others, obviously, think differently. Perhaps it is distasteful to bring attention to this issue. But, if it is true that evangelicals, in some primaries, lined up to vote against Romney simply because of his faith, well, that is even more distasteful by orders of magnitude...in my world at least. I guess we'll just have to stand on opposite sides of this issue and let it be...
CosmicConservative
Dadman makes a fair point. The issue being discussed here isn't one of basic accusations of bigotry, but whether or not the bigotry of one group had a disproportionate impact on the election of one man. It's not necessary in that context to say "Oh and dogs hate cats too". It is obvious that bigotry crosses ethnic, gender, cultural and religious lines, but so far as I've seen, nobody has said that Mormon bigotry had an impact on the Republican primary process. As far as "significant" is concerned, I stand by my statement that it is a word that provides a lack of specificity while still making the case that there is some impact. For example, I would say that people buying smaller cars is having a significant impact on gas consumption in the United States. I have no figures to back that up, it is based entirely on my own anecdotal experience, my common sense, and the reports I've seen about slower sales of big cars and higher sales of small cars. I don't believe it is disingenuous at all to make that statement without statistics to back it up. I think you are misusing the word "disingenuous" disingenuously. ;)
Andy
Dadman: I won't argue with the assertion of the book. As a non-Mormon Christian I don't know personally any Evangelical Christians that didn't support Romney simply because of his Mormon faith...probably because I try to "keep my distance." ;) But I know that there were a significant number that did. And, there were a huge number of Iowans that didn't support the Republican nominee McCain. I don't remember the numbers, but I do remember that McCain was "finished." (ha ha ha ha ha) Romney was my choice for VP. But I've got to say that McCain is smarter than me. A Romney VP nomination would have done little to energize the party, regardless of the fact that he would (if McCain actually allows input from his VP) be the more solid choice. I do believe that being the Governor of MA hurt him in many ways. The gay marriage edict from the MA Supreme Court, the huge gay influence, pro-abortion influence, etc. forced him to (for lack of a better term) "do what he could." You can only get so much juice from a rotten apple. Romney was dealt a bad hand politically. He did his best to win the pot with a pair of deuces. My guy Fred never got out of the blocks (until Tuesday night at the convention). If Fred had the same fire in the belly for himself as he did for McCain...well, I guess we all admire someone else more than we admire ourselves. (Except for Barack) ;)
Drax
CC: If the "bigotry" doesn't make a difference, it isn't "significant;" it is INsignificant. If your assertion is that it DID make a difference (i.e., was "significant,") then some proof of that claim would seem to be in order. Dadman: I'm pleased to be on the "other side" of this argument. Your side is: "Evangelicals are bigots." Mine is "Really? Prove it." I like my side much better.
Dadman
Andy: You're not permitted to use the word 'significant' in this thread without data that defines precisely what 'significant' means. Just a heads up. 'Except for Barack' - LMAO!
JSullins
I'm pretty disinterested in the whole Romney business -- my position could be summed up as, "meh," hehe. Also... I never particularly liked McCain, but I've got to say, the choice of Palin as VP was masterful. Drax: As a bit of admittedly unsolicited advice -- your arguments would be more persuasive if you adjusted your tone. As a disinterested 3rd party (I think) in this discussion, I am detecing some hostility in your comments (not necessarily directed at me, but present nevertheless). As a general tool in making persuasive arguments, I find hostility to be counter-productive.
Dadman
No, Drax, my argument is SOME evangelicals are so intolerant the Mormon faith they refused to vote for one of its adherents. Intolerance is a form of bigotry. I KNOW that evangelical intolerance of the Mormon faith is real because I, and my family, have experienced it firsthand. I've read their blogs, books, sermons, etc. I don't need to prove anything. The only unanswered question is whether or not the evangelical's organized efforts in the GOP primaries to bring down Romney had any 'significant' impact...
Drax
I take the same "tone" when confronting those who smear evangelicals with bigotry towards Mormons as I would against those who smear Mormons with bigotry against evangelicals. Intolerant and charged statements claiming that one religious group is full of bigots against another religious group should not be allowed to stand unchallenged.
Andy
Dadman: Let me use the term "some" then. Truthfully, I don't think it would have made a difference if it was "some," or "significant." The way the political parties' stupid primary/caucus system is set up, a few thousand zealots in IA, (crossovers in)NH, and SC get to set the agenda for the rest of the process...stupid!!!! Like I wrote before, Mitt was dealt a bad political hand. If Sarah Palin had been Gov. of MA, she wouldn't have even been a blip on the Convention radar. Mitt did well with what he had to work with. I would like to see him as Secretary of The Treasury, or Commerce. But I doubt he'll take it. I could be wrong. If he does take a Cabinet post, it will teach me a good bit more about him. I would like to have his economic smarts and experience in the Cabinet meetings for the next 4 years.
Dadman
Believe what you want, Drax. I'm beginning to believe you're a closet evangelical. More power to you! By the way, just to be clear (because you keep ignoring this pertinent fact), I am not throwing all evangelicals under the bus. Just those who are truly intolerant toward other people based solely on their faith (and then went to the polls to prove it!) Admittedly, it is a smaller subset of the larger evangelical population. Some of my favorite people are evangelical Christians, by the way - like Andy and my new son-in-law!
CosmicConservative
Drax: I think you are doing a better job of making my case than I am. I'm going to try to follow that classic debate tactic of letting the opponent dig his own hole.
Drax
"Some of my best friends are (fill in the blank)" has not been viable camoflauge for many decades. CC: What "hole" am I digging? Is there some argument that the purpose of this post was NOT to lambaste evangelicals and smear them with the bigotry mud? Again? I conceded that "some" evangelicals are bigots. So what? "Some" of EVERY religion are "bigots." How many Mormons voted for Huck? Any charges of "bigotry" there? I feel comfortable positing that a greater percentage of Mormons voted for Mitt than evangelicals voted for Huck. OP keeps stirring the pot against evangelicals. I guess the horrid persecution he has been dealt by some evangelicals has made him see conspiracy and bigotry around every corner when I see the exact opposite. I see a country where a Mormon was not only a serious contender for the Presidency, but for Vice President. One where he can be elected Governor of a very liberal state even though he was hardly "liberal." One where he can be in charge of a "significant" event such as the Olympics to be held on American soil. I see a country where an African-American of mixed parentage can be the front-runner for President, just beating out a female for the chance....running against a female for Republican VP. Are there bigots? Sure. There always will be. But, there are MORMON bigots and EVANGELICAL bigots. There are female sexists and black racists. There are bigots, sexists, and racists of every color, gender and religion AGAINST members of every color, gender and religion. But, when you start making claims that the bigotry is SO PERVASIVE as to be remarkable, one religion against the other, and don't even ATTEMPT to provide proof.... And that smear is not only allowed, but is ENCOURAGED.... I can only shake my head in disgust.
Dadman
You're something else, Drax. I cited a book someone else had written about how evangelicals organized against Mitt. Read the book; perhaps there is some proof therein. Do a Google Search and see what pops up. Read some of the things Hugh Hewitt has written about the issue. Walk in my Mormon shoes for just a little while. Mormons did not organize against Huck and are now currently supporting Palin enthusiastically in spite of the fact she is an 'evangelical Christian'. They supported 'evangelical' Bush in large numbers too. You're missing the context again, Drax. I am merely commenting on what OTHER PEOPLE are saying. It's a legitimate socio-political question - to what extent did evangelical intolerance toward Mormons influence the outcome of the GOP primaries? Pack your outrage in ice, Drax, and chill out.
CosmicConservative
Again, I think you miss the point. Dadman was not making any accusation whatsoever that Evangelicals were the only bigots on earth, or that they were more bigoted than other bigots. He was making the point (or relating the point a book was making) that the bigots in the Evangelical movement may have influenced an election. (A point I believe has been exaggerated, but it's a fair point to make.) It is clear that you can't see the distinction. If an Evangelical were running (one was) and there was evidence that Mormon bigots had torpedoed his election (none did), perhaps Dadman would have posted a nearly identical post but with Mormons as the target. It may be true that Dadman is overly sensitive to this issue (I'm not saying he is, I'm acknowledging your belief that he is), but from where I am sitting, you seem to be overly sensitive to Dadman's posts. I don't buy the argument that you are rallying to the support of the oppressed. Frankly, it's starting to sound almost as if it is more personal than ideological.
Drax
I don't like bigots. I don't care what they are bigoted against, whether it's against Mormons, blacks, or evangelicals. I have no use for them. There is a DIFFERENCE between examining the number of evangelicals who didn't vote for Romney (in an election where an EVANGELICAL ran against him) and coming to the conclusion that their vote might have affected the election and ascribing to those voters BASE MOTIVATION based on...what? One can look at the same data and conclude that, if Romney hadn't been in the running (not winning anything) then HUCK might have won since ROMNEY SPLIT THE EVANGELICAL VOTE. (Sure, Huck didn't get anywhere NEAR the number of evangelical votes as Mitt did the Mormon vote...but, again, no one is claiming that Mormons are bigots...) OP has a consistent pattern of bashing evangelicals, claiming that they are bigots. (Of course, there are "some" who are not... but the consistent bashing and the nebulous "some," "many," a "significant number" of them are -- smearing all with the mud at the same time.) I'm not an evangelical. I'm not a Mormon. I have no dog in this hunt. OP does. Maybe you read his "Evangelicals are bigots" posts and only see his "but not all of them are" parts without seeing his "but enough of them are" parts. I don't. The very notion that Evangelicals are "more bigotted" than members of other "subsets" of religions is distasteful in the extreme. The fact that people write books in an attempt to make the argument that Evangelical Christians are bigots (or more bigoted than others) is distasteful in the extreme. Pointing them out with the following: "Foster cites the Religious Right as Romney’s key nemesis, a group that enthusiastically supported Huckabee in large numbers. These same folks, evangelical Huckabee supporters, weren’t satisfied with denying Romney the GOP nomination for President organizing to ensure he was also passed over for VP based almost exclusively on religious differences. Of course, they’ll claim otherwise, but I’m skeptical. I’m quite certain any Mormon running for national office, even one without the baggage of a former governor of Massachusetts who, apparently, was once pro-choice, would inevitably run into the buzzsaw of evangelical bigotry. " merely highlights that the OP not only endorses the view but encourages it.
Dadman
You don't like bigots, yet you defend them with more zeal than I've seen you defend anything else. No dog in this hunt? I'm not so sure. I am citing what others are saying, not pulling accusations out of the thin blue air. It's been a topic of discussion, Huey, in forums way beyond this blog. I guess you've missed those discussions. I continue to be perplexed by your refusal to even acknowledge what most objective political analysts have documented and noted - that many evangelicals organized for the sole purpose of defeating Mormon Mitt in the GOP primaries. I am sick and tired of your personal attacks and insinuations, e.g. “Some of my best friends are (fill in the blank)” has not been viable camoflauge for many decades. Camoflauge for what, Huey? Why don't you just drop all the pretense and come right out and say it. I'm sure it will be entertaining. Oh, my name is not OP.
Drax
Have I been unclear in my thoughts that you have exhibited bigoted views against Evangelicals? I'm sorry. I tried to make that clear. Have I been unclear that I think that you have a New York sized chip on your shoulder as it relates to Mormon issues which not only colors your thinking but causes you to see the world in a skewed light? Again. My apologies. I tried to make that clear. Is it unclear that I believe that you not only believe that Evangelicals ("many" "some" a "significant number") are bigots but that you encourage others to don your blinders and take up your cause -- attacking any who believe otherwise? My sincere apologies. I will try to be more clear in the future.
Dadman
You know, Huey, you have become so condescending, sarcastic, and unhinged that it has become an utter waste of time having any interaction with you. So, I'm the bigot for citing references that propound the thesis that some evangelicals voted against Romney simply and only because he's a Mormon. I shine some light on some intolerant behavior and that makes me the bigot? Stunning logic. That's roughly equivalent to calling Elie Wiesel and Nazi for pointing out Holocaust atrocities (extreme example I know). Does it really surprise you or anyone that I, as a Mormon, would be just a little more dialed into this and other 'Mormon' issues than...you...for instance? Being forced to restate my position over and over again because I am dealing with someone who chooses not to listen does not mean I have a chip on my shoulder or a flawed perspective of the world. Over and over again you have deliberately missed the context of this thread which is simply that the case is being made by individuals other than myself that evangelical intolerance toward Mormons may have negatively impacted Romney's campaign. For bringing that information to this blog, and being inclined to believe it (along with countless others), I am accused of being a bigot. Your audacity is stunning...
Dadman
Here's just one additional reference, out of hundreds, I could cite... http://www.politico.com/blogs/jonathanmartin/1207/As_The_Speech_looms.html
Dadman
Here's an interesting quote from this article in the Washington Monthly penned three years ago. I encourage you to read the whole article. With hindsight it is very interesting... "The first time I ever heard about Mormons was in fifth grade, sitting in a basement classroom of my Baptist church, watching a filmstrip about cults. Our Sunday school class was covering a special month-long unit on false religions; in the mail-order curriculum, Mormonism came somewhere between devil worshippers and Jim Jones. Although most of the particulars are lost to me now, one of the images remains in my mind: a cartoon of human figures floating in outer space (an apparent reference to the Mormon doctrine of "eternal progression") that appeared on the screen next to our pull-down map of Israel. Even at age 10, the take-away message was clear. Mormons were not like us, they were not Christian. Evangelical opinions about the LDS Church haven't changed so much since I watched that filmstrip more than 20 years ago. In 2004, Mormons were specifically excluded from participation in the National Day of Prayer organized by Shirley Dobson (wife of James Dobson, leader of the conservative Christian organization Focus on the Family) because their theology was found to be incompatible with Christian beliefs". Regrettably, this kind of 'false religion' instruction is still happening in thousands of Baptist and other 'evangelical' churches all over the country every Sunday. Actually, all over the world. Such instruction and indoctrination breeds individuals who are utterly intolerant of faiths other than their own. On a certain level it reminds me of what Wahhabi Islamists do in their madrasas with respect to Jews and the West. I'm done...
Dadman
I said I'm done, but... Some additional evidence of evangelical intolerance toward Mormons. http://www.ksl.com/?nid=148&sid=4237036