Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Lessons in abject rationalization

By CosmicConservative
It has been my opinion for some decades now that there is no greater power on earth than the power people have to rationalize their beliefs. How they accomplish that rationalization is usually a private matter, but when they reveal their process, it is frequently stunning how illogical and ignorant that approach is, and yet the power of rationalization is so overwhelming, that they feel no desire to do anything but defend their final position, even if they dig deeper and deeper logical and epistemological holes for themselves. Case in point, Nancy Pelosi's attempt to reconcile her alleged Catholic upbringing with her belief that it is perfectly OK to murder innocent babies inside and outside the womb.
Pelosi gets unwanted lesson in Catholic theology Politics can be treacherous. But House Speaker Nancy Pelosi walked on even riskier ground in a recent TV interview when she attempted a theological defense of her support for abortion rights. Roman Catholic bishops consider her arguments on St. Augustine and free will so far out of line with church teaching that they have issued a steady stream of statements to correct her.
Read the article, but Nancy misrepresents Church teachings, misstates Biblical scripture and reveals gaps of logic that you could drive a galaxy through. But in her (alleged) mind, it all makes perfect sense, and she can't understand how other people don't see it the same way. This is the power of self-deception. Beware its impact in your own life.

Comments (4)

Andy
Cosmic: You wrote, "This is the power of self-deception. Beware its impact in your own life." My friend, you have never written two truer, or more profound sentences in your life.
Drax
As I have stated many times, those who do not accept the teachings of their religion are not worthy of being called adherents to that religion. This is the first time of which I'm aware that such a public (although unremarked upon by the MSM to my knowledge) reminder of this truth has been made by so many in high church office to those in high public office, i.e., "You're not worthy of communion if you are pro-abortion." With the Catholic vote so central in this election, this could be a point or two...
CosmicConservative
... and as I have rebutted, it is a matter of degrees, it is not realistically possible to adhere 100% to the teachings of any religion. If churches excommunicated everyone who had some minor issue with a point of dogma, there would be no religions. Something like supporting abortion would, I believe, pretty much disqualify you from being called a Catholic. But using a condom for birth control? I think not. Although technically it violates Catholic dogma.
Drax
I agree as the "matter of degree." But, when you're talking "matters of degree," the question of where the line is drawn becomes problematic. I think, as I've stated, to be an adherent to a religion, one accepts and attempts to adhere (thus "adherent") to the tenents of that religion. We'll see how much legs this has. I think it has some. How about that McCain? Female? May be a huge choice! I got a KICK out of the press release by Obama which questioned her "experience" with her only being a "heartbeat" away from the Presidency. That would be my next ad. It's amazing to watch these people. McCain is just running CIRCLES around them. As I stated earlier, I was never impressed with Obama's campaigning. He simply got a pass throughout from the MSM and, until the end, one from Hillary. This choice was BRILLIANT.