Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Georgia on the brink...

By CosmicConservative
Remind me again which U.N. Security Council Resolutions Georgia violated? How many arms inspectors had the U.N. sent in just to have them ejected in defiance of U.N. Resolutions and treaties? How many Russian planes were shot at by Georgian anti-aircraft missiles? How many neighboring countries had Georgia invaded? How many public votes did Russia's parliament hold on the potential need to invade Georgia? Oh yeah. Zero. In all cases. In case you were wondering what the difference was between Russia invading Georgia and the U.S. and its allies invading Iraq. Because the press, you see, will make it all sound the same...
My Way News - Georgia claims Russians have cut country in half GORI, Georgia (AP) - Russian forces seized several towns and a military base deep in western Georgia on Monday, opening a second front in the fighting. Georgia's president said his country had been effectively cut in half with the capture of the main east-west highway near Gori. Fighting also raged Monday around Tskhinvali, the capital of the separatist province of South Ossetia. Russian warplanes launched new air raids across Georgia, with at least one sending screaming civilians running for cover.
I will say that Russia seems to be running a classic divide and conquer operation here. Sun Tzu would approve.

Comments (18)

Andy
"All warfare is deception, so when strong, feign weakness and when weak, feign strength. If your target is nearby, make it appear to be distant. Only thus will you achieve your objectives." -Sun Tzu, The Art of War So if Sun Tzu would be proud, Russia is very weak...as they are throwing much of what they have at hapless Georgia...feigning strength. We saw how weak they were when the Soviet Union broke up...all the while they were feigning strength to the world. We know for sure that the UN feigns strength, and is even weaker than it appears...useless!!! I don't know Cosmic...this one is a real "head scratcher" for me. My ever-expanding gut tells me that Russia is the 90-pound weakling picking on the kid in the wheel chair. I know for sure that if the US decided to end this militarily, it would be "ended." But we don't proceed that way now. I often wonder why we have worried about building up the most powerful, well equipped military in the history of the world. When it comes time to use it we handcuff it, and then prosecute our guys that really know what "needs to be done." I'm not spoiling for war. But I do know that President Bush needs to get some stones on this one. This needs to stop now! He needs to pull a Reagan and scare the hell out of his commie buddy Putin...
CosmicConservative
Andy: Here is my analysis. Russia is weak. Weak in comparison to it's previous Cold War might, and weak in comparison to the United States or China. Being weak does not mean that nothing is weaker than you, and picking a weaker target to appear strong is exactly what Sun Tzu was talking about. What is Russia's real goal in this conflict? It is not, as they claim, to ensure peace in a breakaway province of Georgia. It is to smash the Georgian government and gain control of critical energy resources so they can gain leverage with Europe. As much as I agree that a strong military is only valuable so long as it is used appropriately, I am not spoiling for a fight with the second-most powerful nuclear stockpile on earth.
Jack
Actually, Georgia invaded South Ossetia which has close ties to Russia. I'm sure Russia views themselves as protecting their own interests.
CosmicConservative
Jack: Are you suggesting that South Ossetia is Russian territory or Georgian? Would you make the same statement about an Iranian move into Iraq based on religious and cultural solidarity? How about a Mexican move into San Diego using the same logic?
Dadman
Heh. I guess we'll just have to look the other way if Canada decides to invade Vermont ...in Jack's world, at least.
Jack
Sean, Oh brother. I'm not suggesting anything. I'm just stating fact. And how Russia probably sees it. Nothing in my statement above suggests in any way, shape or form that I agree with Russia's actions. Jeez, so much for open discourse here. I see if one steps out of lockstep, they get a personal attack. How sad and pathetic.
CosmicConservative
Jack: You can draw your own conclusions about things, but to suggest that this blog has any sort of "groupthink" going on is pretty ludicrous considering the long and frequent (mostly amicable) disagreements among the primary participants. The reason your comment received the reaction it did (from me, anyway) is that your comment was written in an argumentative manner. (I mean "argumentative" in the formal sense of the word, which is to say that your statement was presented in a manner that challenged the authenticity of my own blog entry). You said "Actually, Georgia invaded South Ossetia..." which is symantically contradicting my comment about Russia invading Georgia. But the problem with your statement is that it is technically impossible for a country to invade itself. South Ossetia is a province of Georgia. Sending troops into a province of your own country is not by any reasonable definition an "invasion". HOWEVER, sending your troops into ANOTHER country, no matter what the reason, IS technically an "invasion." So my comment was technically and common sensically accurate, where yours was not only technically inaccurate, but completely beside the point. Your comment seems to suggest that any country can invade any other country any time they feel that there is some sort of cultural solidarity with some segment of the other country's population. Thus my comments about Iran and Mexico, and Dadman's comments about Canada. So the reason you got the reaction you got is not that you disagree with our groupthink, as you seem to think, but because your base assertion is fundamentally wrong, was presented in an argumentative, accusatory manner, and demonstrated what Dadman and I took to be a bizarre notion that would have supported, for example, the notion that the Union forces had no right to "invade" the Confederate states in the U.S. Civil War. So if you are going to make judgments of the regular participants of this blog, at least make accurate ones. The right judgment to make of us is not that we are "lockstep" thinkers, but that we thought your comment was rather silly and irrelevant.
Jack
Sean, I was not being argumentative. I thought my second sentence explaining a possible motivation for the invasion would've made that clear but I guess it did not. In your original post, you list the things that Georgia didn't do which might warrant an invasion. But you didn't mention South Ossetia at all, not even as a side comment. I thought maybe you were unaware of the conflict since the news was so fresh when you made your post. "Invasion" or "civil war" as a description of the conflict between Georgia and South Ossetia aside, I was just trying to explain what may have motivated Russia to act. You refer to my comment as irrelevant. Well, it's clearly not irrelevant to Russia. I know a few people from South Ossetia that would clearly say Georgia invaded but that's neither here nor there because it is indeed a UN recognized province of Georgia. I've been told that South Ossetia is an absolute political mess and could lead to a conflict between Russia and Georgia. And that was told to me a long time ago so it really didn't surprise me when it happened. It seemed to me that in your original post you had no idea why Russia would invade Georgia. And right or wrong, justified or not, I was only trying to explain a possible motivation for the invasion. That was all. I found your response odd and Dadman's response to be an unmotivated personal attack. I think you and Dadman didn't understand what I was saying which led me to misunderstand your responses.
CosmicConservative
Jack: OK, that makes sense. If we jumped on you due to a misapprehension of your comment, I apologize. I can't claim that I have nearly the historical background knowledge that you have about Georgia or South Ossetia, and I don't claim that I was providing a "fair and balanced" portrayal of the tensions there or the leadup that led Russia to actually invade. But that's because I was comparing and contrasting the Russian invasion of Georgia and the U.S. invasion of Iraq from a geopolitical perspective, not a cultural one. What I was attempting to point out is that Russia more or less did exactly what the Left typically (and unfairly) accuses George W. Bush of doing, which is to have mounted an invasion of a sovereign country in violation of international law and social convention. The difference between the two could not be more stark, but the Left will pretend that they are one and the same and will morally equate the two. They have already started to.
Jack
Sean, No apology necessary. I should have been more clear. I wrote two quick, poorly worded sentences before I dashed out the door. And I made assumptions that I shouldn't have. I'm not in any way a historian and you clearly seem to be far more knowledgeable in that area than I. I just know a few people from that region and they've given me an occasional ear full. And I factor in that they will spin it a certain way because that's part of the human condition. We all do it, especially when we get emotional about it. Just in case you were wondering: I'm the same "Jack" that's over at Dean's World. I'm a screenwriter and film director and though I'm not far left, I am, without a doubt left-leaning. Please don't hate me. See. You can tell I'm left-leaning because I'm neurotic. LOL. Take care now. :)
CosmicConservative
Heh, we don't "hate" here, do we? Well, we try not to. I haven't been very active on Dean's World lately, maybe it's my timing, but ever since his conversion to Catholicism, his blog seems to have become a religious blog, and I don't read too many of those.
Dadman
Jack: So, what movies/film/documentaries have you written or directed that I might be familiar with? And, BTW, my comment was an attempt at humor, not an 'unmotivated personal attack'. I'm surprised you took it that way. Perhaps another symptom of your self-admitted neurotic tendencies? ;)
Jack
Sean: No, I don't think you guys hate liberals. (At least I hope you don't). You do use a few colorful descriptors for liberals like "moonbats" and harsher words in some of your posts. I do realize you're passionate about your convictions (which is great!) but using such words might make a reader hesitate to present an opposing view if they think they might be attacked or dismissed. I'm just respectfully presenting how you come across to me at times. I generally don't post political commentary on someone's blog because I see politics as an impossibly large Rubex Cube that in the end is unsolvable. Maybe I just don't have the mind for it. Sigh. Dadman: After years of making short films and one ultra-low-budget horror film, I recently made my first "real" film. It's a feature-length 35mm supernatural thriller that I co-wrote and directed. It's titled "Ghost Image", and stars Elisabeth Rohm (Law & Order, Miss Congeniality 2), Stacey Dash (Clueless, The Cosby Show), Waylon Payne (played Jerry Lee Lewis in Walk The Line), Roma Maffia (Nip/Tuck, Disclosure, Nick of Time, and a ton of other movies and TV shows), and Matthew Del Negro (The Sopranos, The West Wing). Here is the IMDb listing: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0861772/ You can watch the trailer by going to our distributor's website at www.artistviewent.com Go to the New Releases and find Ghost Image and you can view the trailer there. The film will be on a major cable network by either December or January. When I know the day and time, I'll follow up with a post here to let all of you know. This year I've written two screenplays (for pay! Woo Hoo!) for some producers. I've also written a screenplay for my next film which my producer hopes to raise the funding for by next Spring or Summer. I'm 48 years old and have been plugging away at this for years and now, finally, things are looking up for me. :)
Jack
Sean: No, I don't think you guys hate liberals. (At least I hope you don't). You do use a few colorful descriptors for liberals like "moonbats" and harsher words in some of your posts. I do realize you're passionate about your convictions (which is great!) but using such words might make a reader hesitate to present an opposing view if they think they might be attacked or dismissed. I'm just respectfully presenting how you come across to me at times. I generally don't post political commentary on someone's blog because I see politics as an impossibly large Rubex Cube that in the end is unsolvable. Maybe I just don't have the mind for it. Sigh. Dadman: After years of making short films and one ultra-low-budget horror film, I recently made my first "real" film. It's a feature-length 35mm supernatural thriller that I co-wrote and directed. It's titled "Ghost Image", and stars Elisabeth Rohm (Law & Order, Miss Congeniality 2), Stacey Dash (Clueless, The Cosby Show), Waylon Payne (played Jerry Lee Lewis in Walk The Line), Roma Maffia (Nip/Tuck, Disclosure, Nick of Time, and a ton of other movies and TV shows), and Matthew Del Negro (The Sopranos, The West Wing). Here is the IMDb listing: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0861772/ You can watch the trailer by going to our distributor's website at www.artistviewent.com Go to the New Releases and find Ghost Image and you can view the trailer there. The film will be on a major cable network by either December or January. When I know the day and time, I'll follow up with a post here to let all of you know. This year I've written two screenplays (for pay! Woo Hoo!) for some producers. I've also written a screenplay for my next film which my producer hopes to raise the funding for by next Spring or Summer. I'm 48 years old and have been plugging away at this for years and now, finally, things are looking up for me. :)
Jack
Dadman, After years of making short films and one ultra-low-budget horror film, I recently made my first "real" film. It's a feature-length 35mm supernatural thriller that I co-wrote and directed. It's titled "Ghost Image", and stars Elisabeth Rohm (Law & Order, Miss Congeniality 2), Stacey Dash (Clueless, The Cosby Show), Waylon Payne (played Jerry Lee Lewis in Walk The Line), Roma Maffia (Nip/Tuck, Disclosure, Nick of Time, and a ton of other movies and TV shows), and Matthew Del Negro (The Sopranos, The West Wing). Here is the IMDb listing: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0861772/ You can watch the trailer by going to our distributor's website at www.artistviewent.com Go to the New Releases and find Ghost Image and you can view the trailer there. The film will be on a major cable network by either December or January. When I know the day and time, I'll follow up with a post here to let all of you know. This year I've written two screenplays (for pay! Woo Hoo!) for some producers. I've also written a screenplay for my next film which my producer hopes to raise the funding for by next Spring or Summer. I'm 48 years old and have been plugging away at this for years and now, finally, things are looking up for me. :)
CosmicConservative
Jack: Just so we are clear, I don't use "moonbat" and "liberal" interchangably. I use "moonbat" to refer to a particular sort of individual whose head is so filled with wishful thinking nonsense that they are not rational about anything. I know there are versions of the same thing on the right (the Left calls them "wingnuts") and I recognize that both sides probably have equal measure of fringe nutcases. But since this is a blog with a right-center tilt, I'm going to rail against moonbats and mostly leave the wingnuts alone. I feel no compulsion to provide a "fair and balanced" view. I disproportionately attack Leftist wackos because I disproportionately dislike and disrespect leftist wackos.
Jack
Sean, I've made a mess of your blog! I've tried posting the above comment several times on a few of your threads and kept getting a screen that said "Word Press Error". Now it looks like everywhere I tried to post it, it has now appeared! You mentioned in another thread that it may be caused by my putting links in the message and I'm thinking you're right. Anyways, I do understand what you're saying. From someone like myself who visits many blogs, I was just relating how you sometimes (not always) come across to me.
Dadman
Jack: Thanks for the information. As a huge fan of movies I'm insanely jealous. Best of luck to you in the future. I hope you win an Oscar!