Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Math Wars!!!

By CosmicConservative
A long time ago, in a world far, far away..... People used to actually do long division...
They call it the Math Wars: The debate, at times acrimonious, over which way is best to teach kids math. In its most black-and-white form, it pits schools hoping to prepare kids for a new world against reluctant parents, who feel the traditional way is best and their kids are being shortchanged. But there are lots of parents who fall into a grayer area: They're willing to accept that their kids are learning things differently. They just want to be able to help them with their homework. And very often, they can't. "Sometimes I'll meet up with another parent, and we'll say, 'What WAS that homework last night?" says Birgitta Stone, whose daughter, Gillian, is entering third grade in Ridgefield, Connecticut, next month. "Sometimes I can't even understand the instructions." Funny, perhaps, but also a little sad. "It's frustrating," says Stone. "You want to help them. And sometimes I can't help her at all."
I've experienced some of this. And as a person with a Physics degree, I actually think I can see and understand both sides of this issue. (Well, to be fair I USUALLY think I can see both sides of an issue. It's a curse of mine...) On the one side you have educators who want kids to learn the CONCEPTS of what they are learning. On the other side you have parents who want their kids to learn HOW to do something. The two approaches are not only philosophically different, they are frequently directly at odds with each other. Now here's my position on this. I think the educators are flat wrong about this. Teaching kids HOW to do math is far more important than teaching kids the CONCEPTS of math. And that's because of the simple, if somewhat sobering, reality that 95% of the kids who take math in high school and college will never have any need or interest in the concepts behind math!! But those same people will have to balance their checkbooks!!! There are some kids who need to learn the concepts. And for the most part in the history of humanity, those are the same kids who pursue the concepts and become mathematicians, engineers and physicists. For the rest of the mass of humanity, there is very little to gain from trying to focus on concepts, and very much to lose if the result is kids who can't add, subtract or multiply, and have long ago lost any interest in the conceptual views and so have lost that as well. Teach 'em to balance a checkbook, calculate gas mileage and do the sort of geometry that allows them to build bookcases in their garages. That's what the vast majority of people actually do with their math skills. Even a "physicist" like me. Those who want to pursue a career in the field will learn the concepts as they need them. They don't teach cooks biochemistry, they teach them how to cook. And that's what they SHOULD teach them.

Comments (7)

Andy
"95% of the kids who take math in high school and college will never have any need or interest in the concepts behind math!! But those same people will have to balance their checkbooks!!!" Amen, and amen! Maybe more than 95% will ever have need to understand the concepts behind math. I have an uncle with a degree in math. He made about a gozillion bucks in the oil business. He once told me that his degree in math didn't really help him that much in the oil biz...but it got him his first job. A young man that lived with us for a while is now teaching, and working on his PhD at Texas Tech in math. He loses me really quickly when he gets going... He has the brain power, and interest in the subject to "get it," even though he was just taught practical mathematics at BHS in the mid-90's. You are right.
CosmicConservative
This is what happens when people who live in ivory towers and only discuss their interests with other people of the same interest make public policy.
CosmicConservative
I will say that I was one of those kids who seemed to need to know the concepts behind math, and that I always felt I didn't "understand" the subject until I understood the concept behind it. The "why" always gave me a better understanding of the "how." But I also tutored math in college and I have tried to teach it to my own kids, and I have to tell you, I have met maybe two or three other people in my life who have any interest in "why" 1+1 = 2. As much as I wish that learning concepts was more important than learning mechanics, my life history has convinced me of the exact opposite. Learning HOW to do it is preferable to learning WHY to do it. The main reason is because more people will LEARN how to do it than will learn WHY to do it. And for those of us like myself who seemed to need to understand why... I presume they'll continue to go and learn it themselves. The ill-advised conceit of the "educators" who push the "concept" approach is that doing so will open up more minds to the concepts and that will create more kids interested in math careers. But if you think that is working, you have not been looking at what college students are majoring in these days. Here's a hint.... It ain't math.
Dadman
Math was never my strength although I did reasonably well in my college math courses when I applied myself. Acing Trig at La. Tech after flunking it at BHS is still one of my most significant experiences of personal redemption. ;) For my part, I needed to understand math conceptually to maximize my ability to apply mathematical principles and formulas in problem solving. When I aced math courses it was always because I made the effort to conceptually process the 'language' of whatever discipline of math I was studying at the time - algebra, trig, calculus, geometry et al. So, I'd like to throw out the possibility that some kids might 'get' (and even enjoy) math more if they were taught concepts behind it. That's how it always worked for me...
Andy
Dadman: Can't argue. Every kid is different for sure. Mrs. Archambeau gave me a D in Algebra I instead of the F I deserved, because she didn't want me back in her class again. I aced Geometry...didn't even have to study. The thought of me taking trig at BHS or at Tech...ha ha ha. When I took Algebra classes at Tech, I made respectable B's (I had good teachers, but struggled for them). You are right. I guess the challenge is to figure out which kids respond better to practical, rather than conceptual math. I don't know how we would ever get down to that kind of specifics in our public education system...most of it is too occupied with trivial crap. But Cosmic made a good point. Almost all of us will never really need to know the concepts of mathematics to be able to balance a checkbook, make change, or figure out that two guys didn't show up for work. Interesting subject...haven't thought about this kind of stuff in a good while.
CosmicConservative
Dadman, I used to think that too, and I don't have a problem with teachers introducing and "teaching" the concept. I have a problem with them choosing to do so AT THE EXPENSE OF THE MECHANICS. If they can do BOTH then great, but if they can only do ONE, then they should do the one that benefits the most kids the most in their lives. And that "one" ain't math "concepts."
Foobarista
I use math concepts all the time in my work, although I learned them in my junior and senior years at college as a math major, not high school. That said, I always figured that math is a language, with its own vocabulary, syntax, and grammar. And this stuff has to be drilled and memorized, just like you can't "intuit" French verb conjugation or the construction of Chinese characters. Over time, you may develop intuition for mathematical concepts, but the drilling comes first, not last - and can't be avoided.