Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Autistic child causes plane to return to terminal

By CosmicConservative
Here's a story I can really relate to.
An American Eagle flight taxiing to an RDU runway was turned around Monday, but not because of a terrorist threat. The crew was kicking an autistic Cary toddler and his mother off the plane. As the American Eagle flight headed down the taxiway, 2-and a half-year-old Jarett Farrell wasn't a happy traveler. His mother says she was doing all she could to calm the autistic boy, but got no sympathy from the flight crew. "If they just would have been a little more understanding I think that none of this would have been a problem," Mother, Janice Farrell said. But it became a big problem for everyone on the plane. Farrell says that's because the flight attendant was indignant. "She kept coming over and tugging his seatbelt to make it tighter, 'This has to stay tight'. And then he was wiggling around and trying to get out of his seatbelt. And she kept coming over and reprimanding him and yelling at him," Farrell said. One of the pilots came back to the cabin with a stern warning and Farrell says the frustration level escalated. She says Jarrett picked up on that and things only got worse. "He just melted down. He saw me getting upset. He was upset. He was on the floor rolling around," she said.
As the parent of an autistic child, let me tell you that I know exactly what this mother is talking about. On our first trip to Disneyworld we discovered that our son had extreme sensitivity to air pressure changes, which caused a lot of difficulty on the trip TO Florida. But to make matters worse, on the way back he did not want to get on the airplane because of the discomfort he suffered the flight out, so it was difficult enough just to get him onto the plane. Then the flight was delayed multiple times and we ended up sitting in the airplane on the tarmac for a couple of hours while he got more and more agitated and concerned about the upcoming flight, the smells in the airplane, the looks of the people around us and the general confined space of the airplane. In our case, when we were sent back to the terminal on one occasion, a flight attendant allowed me to take him off the plane into the gangway so he could calm down a bit. But to this day that experience was one of the most stressful situations we have ever been in, and let me tell you, other than that kind flight attendant, by the time we finally got into the air and got him calmed down, I was quite convinced that there was not a sympathetic thought towards us from anyone on that flight. People who don't experience this sort of thing really have no idea what it is like, and in my experience, have little to no tolerance for the child or the family when a meltdown like this happens. As I said, I sympathize with this lady.

Comments (20)

Dadman
We live in an increasingly uncivil society. People who geniunely care for and empathize with other people (even when it is part of their job description to do so) seem to be a rare breed these days...
Andy
Cosmic: Yep...though not in as severe a situation as you, I can empathize...I've got long stories, but pretty lame compared to others. The unfamiliar smells, the loud sounds, the sudden change in schedule, and adults that don't understand what is going on making it worse, etc. Yep...
Drax
Dadman: What amazes me is that on the surface, what with all the political correctness and the "live and let live" philosophy taught from every source, you're correct. This is an uncivil society and getting increasingly so every day.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I have a theory about that. My theory is that people more and more believe that expressing a DESIRE for tolerance, absolves them from actually PRACTICING tolerance. I call this the "bumper sticker syndrome." In other words, putting a bumper sticker on your car expressing "green solidarity" completely absolves the driver from spewing pollutants and sucking down fossil fuels, because their HEART is in the right place. So now they are free to drive like lunatics, flip off other drivers and more or less act like wild animals. This is especially funny here in Colorado where you see green bumper stickers quite literally on Ford Excursions and Hummmer H1s.
Andy
Dadman: Drax beat me to the punch. I thought about your comment later, and just "amen" Drax. I see it all of the time. Not to open up a can of worms, but I have noted that people are much more civil to minorities, openly gays, young kids with fourteen tattoos and twelve piercings than they are to regular old white folks (like me). It's just an observation. I went through the San Diego Airport a few years ago headed back home from TJ. I was dragged aside for a near strip search (as usual), and at the same time a 60-something year-old businessman (well dressed, gray haired...obviously a terrorist) was pulled out, wanded and patted down...his laptop almost torn to pieces, etc. While that was going on, I watched with amazement as every foreign-looking, or circus performer looking person just breezed through security...aaaaahhhhh political correctness! I finally was released from TSA hell...made an O.J. 400-yard dash, and caught the plane just before the door slammed shut. Drax is right! One would think that with as much sensitivity training that every employee, or student receives, autistic kids would at least receive as much grace... I wonder...and this might sound ugly...I wonder if this was a white kid. I don't know anything about the race of the child. But my gut tells me that if this was a minority child the airline employee would have handled it differently.
CosmicConservative
The child was caucasion, or at least the photo sure looked caucasion.
Andy
Cosmic: Yea, I figured as much. The problem we have as parents of either severely, or mildly autistic children (my son is in the "mild" category) is that we don't want to "brand" them before the public. If there was a way to let everyone know that our child is autistic before they made snap-judgments, it would solve a lot of social difficulties for autistic kids. But, I don't want my 12-year-old walking around with the Scarlet Letter "A" on his chest. If there was such a "brand" it would make my life easier in public right now. At the same time, it might make him less likely to be able to deal with problems on down the road (when I'm too old, or dead, and unable to clean up the messes). It's a real balancing act for sure. I can empathize.
CosmicConservative
Andy, boy did you hit it. My son is very high-functioning. And in some ways that makes things worse when we are out in public, because he has very few visual clues to his situation, and when he does have a melt-down, it just looks like a temper tantrum, and 95% of the public doesn't know how to tell the difference between and autistic melt-down and a temper-tantrum (the other 5% have autistic family members themselves). In my experience, this gets worse as he gets older and expectations increase for him based on his size and age.
Andy
Cosmic: Yea, I know... I am one of the parents whose child gets better and better as time passes. We are very fortunate. Things do explode from time to time, but it has become more and more rare. I feel for you and CosmicWife...every child is different. I have learned to recognize "autistic" behavior as not just "spoiled brat" behavior. But most of the public hasn't. I can't blame the public. From what you have written, I know that you don't either. You have to experience it yourself to pick up the signals. My 12-year-old whipped me 11-5, 10-11, and 11-2 in foosball this afternoon. Thanks for the blog post...helps more than you know...
Foobarista
Frankly, I wouldn't be able to tell myself. And I do see way too many kids having temper meltdowns and parents who try to pretend it isn't happening or indulge the kid. If you're in a plane, you're already wondering whether that crying baby will be fussy all the way across the Pacific, or whether you'll catch that guy's flu, or whether the pilot just lost his pension :) Bonus points if the guy next to you weighs 300 pounds with bad breath and body odor. When kids melt down, I try to ignore them so as to not embarrass the parents or incite the kid further, but I'll admit that seeing a kid randomly blow up on a plane is not something I really handle well, and probably wouldn't smile kindly, especially if the blow-up is bad enough that it delays the flight and causes me to wonder if I'll miss my connection or airport ride.
CosmicConservative
Foo: Just so you know "melt down" actually has a very specific meaning when it comes to autistic people (and I specifically mean "people" because it applies to adults as well as children). Based on research that has been done on autistic individuals, when an autistic person has a "melt-down" it's a physical thing, not an emotional one. Usually. The problem is that the brain essentially gets overwhelmed with stimuli. Non-autistic people, or people who do not live with autistic people have very little awareness of one of the key aspects of autism, which is that the autistic person's brain is hyper-sensitive to stimuli, that's part of the pathology of autism. In other words, it seems to be a physical thing in the brain, not a behavioral problem. Think of how you would react if you were thrust into a room with overwhelming smells, lights so bright they hurt your eyes, sounds like fingernails on a blackboard and the feeling of dry, raspy burlap across your skin. That's sort of what happens when an autistic individual's senses overload, the stimuli become so great that the brain simply can't deal with it. And the reaction ranges from classic autism retreating and auto-stimulus (such as rocking back and forth vigorously in a corner) to violent physical reactions (spinning around and flailing with arms, or screaming and pounding on the floor). The reaction is a defense mechanism to overcome the external uncontrollable stimuli by providing internal controllable ones. Once the melt-down starts, it is very, very, very difficult to overcome (and I don't string three "very's" together lightly.) Even as the parent of an autistic child who suffers from melt-downs it is frustrating and emotionally draining, and I frankly don't deal with them well. To an outside observer who has no idea what is going on, it is easy to understand why they would react negatively to the autistic individual. But the conclusion they reach is usually completely wrong, but that does nothing to help the people dealing with the situation. I don't blog about this much, it's way too personal and way too self-indulgent. I'll just leave it with the observation that autism is no picnic.
Andy
Foobarista: I understand totally. My 3 oldest sons were perfect gentlemen in public as young boys. I always wondered why all those "lousy parents" wouldn't control their kids... Then along came #4. We did nothing different as far as discipline, etc. But it became apparent pretty early on that something was just really "different" with #4. I don't blame anybody for not being able to know what's happening, because I've been on both sides of the fence. But be careful what you write! I might have been that 300 lb. guy with the bad breath next to you... :)
Andy
Cosmic: Yep, the physical melt-down is pretty tough...the spinning, flailing, jumping from high places, banging on the floor, etc. (and that was just me). I know that's not funny, but it's true. This post is personal, but it's not just self-indulgent. It helped me...more than you know.
Foobarista
CC - thanks for your remarks. I'll try to be less harsh in my thoughts if I see stuff like this in the future. Not judging is hard for us INTJ's...
Dadman
Gotta love obscure references to Myers-Briggs. I happen to be an INTJ too, but I don't put much stock in standardized personality assessments. They're equivalent to palm readings in my humble opinion...
CosmicConservative
INTJ is, I think, supposedly the rarest personality type. My own evaluation comes out as INTJ or INTP depending on my mood (I think the other one is "P") So I'm pretty borderline. In fact it's sort of weird, if I take it at work, I almost always come out INTJ, but if I take it at home or in a non-work environment, I go the other way.
Dadman
I actually misremembered. I came out as an INTP not an INTJ when I completed the assessment years ago. INTP characteristics are actually eerily similar to my 'real' personality, but I still consider the whole exercise to be little more than psycho-babble voodoo...
JSullins
I also test as an INTJ. Hmmm..... Maybe you should make the change to INTJ blog ;)
AutismTreatment
Anecdotal reports support newer forms of play based behavioural therapies and alternative methods involving vitamins and dietary restrictions, although many autism treatment experts vigorously disagree over whether these offer benefit.